Monday, January 2, 2012

Traditional Families Are No Longer the Norm

This photo shows my father, the baker,
Ichabod (another baker), LI, and Mrs. Ichabod.
Our grandson looks very much like LI in this photo.


rlschultz has left a new comment on your post "Fertility rate plummets in Brazil - The Washington...":

It seems that in this present time, many of the younger folks do not want to do what was so easy one or two generations ago. Getting married and being blessed with children seemed so normal and most aspired to do so. The responsibility of raising a family was a natural outgrowth of proper upbringing. Marriage rates are much lower today. The live-in partner almost seems to be the new norm. The commitment in marriage is what God has ordained for us. But, we have been told by experts that every family is dysfunctional. But, there is no drop-in replacement for a so-called traditional family.

***

GJ - Bruce Church has published a lot of good information on this. Pastors have seen the reality, and many of them were pioneers in the new morality. Virtually all couples who marry today have been living together for years, often with an illegitimate child or two, sometimes three.

Natural law means - God commands what is good for us. He created the institution of marriage. To live in sin, as we geezers used to say, is to defy the Word of God. But living in faith with a spouse and children glorifies God and generates the fruits of the Spirit.

Marriage protects men, women, and children. When children grow up with both of their parents under the same roof, they learn to model behavior after their fathers and mothers. They look for a spouse who is similar to the opposite sex parent.

My high school class celebrated our 45th reunion this year. A small group of us (out of 730 graduates) noted our 40+ marriage anniversaries and laughed about all the antics of our grandchildren. We have a lot of achievers - from the Medal of Honor to a distinguished law career.

Some classmates spoke about their travels, but I could say, "I am on vacation 12 months a year. I live 10 minutes from our son's family." In the last 28 months we have raked leaves, fed geese, watched movies, gone to church, grilled chicken, laughed about funny YouTube productions,  played Uno, and celebrated Christmas three times."

I have attended over 25 of the famous Walmart Saturday Morning Meetings, which are required for their executives. The CEO of Walmart, Mike Duke, probably knows my face better than any other visitor's. Best of all, I know as much about our son's work as he knows about mine. When we come back from the meeting, he fills in Mrs. I. about his work.

What is more enjoyable - having a laugh with our grandson, enjoying a delicious meal from our daughter-in-law, sharing an old joke with Danielle, or buying a Bible in Mandarin for Josie? We heard she squealed with happiness.

I warn my students that they will never say, "That was a great meeting 20 years ago!" but they will go over all their pleasant memories of their families growing up. That is God's plan, natural law, as Jesus said, "That your joy may be complete."

Epistler Plays Whac-a-Mole.
No Scandal Too Big To Finesse



The Epistler has left a new comment on your post "Anonymous Mind-Reader Is Not Happy with Posts and ...":

While the child porn scandal at the WELS headquarters is tragic and disturbing at so many levels, I have no clue as to how it is relevant in this case. Unless, of course, it's just a way to shoulder the failings of one man onto a group of people.

You say that it took the FBI to shut it down. I'm not surprised. That's their job. It is so, so, so easy to hide illicit activity in everyday internet traffic. Is it fair to paint the tech support and administration at the WELS headquarters as incompetent or in denial? Maybe a simpler reason exists. He wasn't caught because, well, he simply wasn't caught. By your arguement, the wife of every cheating husband is stupid or in denial.

My guess is, it doesn't matter to you that the decisions of one man devestated a number of lives. It's just a very convenient way to deface your enemies in one fell stroke.

---

G-NoMoney has left a new comment on your post "Wisconsin Synod Facing Another Lawsuit":

I was raised in a WELS church/school - St John's, Tosa. When I was eight, I told my third-grade teacher that my daddy came in my bed with no pajamas. The teacher, (who was the pastor's mom), slapped me across the face. Then she started shaking me while screaming, "You Horrible, Horrible girl. How dare you say such a filthy thing. You are going to Hell!" --- I never told anyone again. I was assaulted, then raped for another six years before quitting the ninth grade and running away from home. WELS is an unsafe environment for many children. I am just one example.

***

GJ - I believe the report by G-NoMoney is genuine. I can add another from a different denomination. A man raped a young girl. The girl and her mother went to their pastor. He said, "If you go to the police, you will go to Hell." The girl is grown, but still suffers from the trauma. She is no longer a Christian. The pastor of that church knew all about the previous minister being an adulterer. In fact, the members knew about the pastor's mistress, because she was a member of the parish.

Within WELS there are many examples of church workers preying upon children and being caught. However, Holy Mother Synod never admits to these crimes, so most people remain innocent and gullible when the spin-doctors go to work. They tend to repeat the crime, as several workers have shown.

The anonymous critic is overlooking a previous crime in the Hochmuth scandal. According to the Criminal Report, Hochmuth was caught before and went into counseling with his wife. Supposedly she caught him. That means the counselor did not report the crime, which is required by law. The others who knew did not report the crime. I know the facts were never communicated to the authorities because Hochmuth has never been charged with any crime. Not even charged! Yet he was the main representative for WELS to the world at large, even when denouncing ELCA for its homosexual advocacy.

Although I have probed, I have not learned whether the WELS agency was involved in this counseling. Others have asked as well. Silence. I take that as an admission, but that is because I assume the worst when dealing with pathological liars.

The Wisconsin Sect was eager to make a known adulterer and false teacher into one of their own. I said then, as I repeat now, that these sins are piling up for the Day of Judgment. Public relations, Hochmuth's strong suit, will not be enough to fool God.

All the leaders have a responsibility to send the predators to prisons, instead of providing a cover story for them, as they did with DP Ed Werner.

DP Ed Werner was born forgiven,
but the state sent him to the Big House for his crimes against
minor girls in his congregation.
Pastors knew but never talked - GA works.


The feigned compassion of the anonymous critic is meaningless as long as the predators run loose, knowing with smug certainty that many will jump up to assail anyone who points out the truth.

Missouri and the Little Sect on the Prairie are no better.

---

The Epistler has left a new comment on your post "Epistler Plays Whac-a-Mole. No Scandal Too Big To ...":

I believe that you mistake my intentions. I have no interest in trying to defend the WELS. Why should I? I left the church long ago. Today I'm agnostic. But religion came so close to utterly destroying my life and that of my family that I feel obligated to try to limit the damage that the faithful perpetrate, even if it's simply by calling people out on the potential destructiveness their words carry.

I carry no sympathy for Mr. Hochmuth. As far as I am concerned, there is no forgiveness for someone like him, and he should be punished to the fullest extent of the law. How anyone can stand beside him is beyond me. But the callous way in which the responsibility has been spread by Ichabod to include multiple people and to suggest that they are also responsible for the exploitation of children is a facile and dangerous arguement. There are only two people who know for certain what Hochmuth was doing. His wife - and himself. Just because he claimed he was in counseling does NOT mean that he revealed the full extent of his crimes. Couples go to counseling for porn addiction all the time. There is nothing to suggest that the counselor wasn't lied to. In fact, since no crime was reported, it seems likely. And pouring guilt by association onto the WELS tech staff and administration does just as much damage to people who are (lesser) victims of this scandal. They were betrayed by a trusted employee. Why are you trying to crucify them with the traitor?

The rabid tendencies of religious individuals to place a blanket of blame on victims is near universal. It's ironic that the example of a young woman who was molested and then told she was going to hell is a perfect example of why religion is the primary source of evil in the world today.

One more example. Perhaps you've heard of  [deleted example].

***

GJ - I deleted the example because I have no first-hand knowledge of that situation in an infamous circuit, although one source told me he knew some of the basics.

I wonder how the Epistler can be so ignorant of the secular concept of supervision, not to mention the admonitions of the pastoral epistles. Supervisors (Greek, episcopon, overseer, bishop) are responsible for the people under them. Denominations play innocent, but the justice system comes down hard on religious franchises that tolerate and transfer known child abusers.

Liability is shared by the supervisors and the organization. WELS was so tolerant of abusive church workers that the insurance companies finally began requiring some kind of clearance for each worker. I recall DP Robert Mueller being very unhappy about that requirement. That would have ended Lutheran Parish Resources, one of Mueller's little gifts to Columbus, Ohio.

Paul McCain told me that Missouri began clamping down because "it was costing them so much money."

ELCA lost a $40 million lawsuit from one incident. Fred Adrian's congregation and WELS lost a $400,000 lawsuit, both involving abuse of minors. Good ol' Fred is back in the ministry, thanks to John Seifert. The denominations do not report the annual total of these costs, not to mention the synodical lawyers who work hard at squashing and settling cases on the QT.

I am addressing the human cost of this failure to supervise. I made many different direct attempts to stop what was happening in Columbus. I did not send anonymous comments or make wry little jokes at meetings (the accepted WELS approach). I spoke face-to-face with the Circuit Pastor, the DP, and the First VP - all of them liars. They were stunned that I learned the truth when I pressed them about their responsibility, then began getting even with me.

I also spoke to the future DP, John Seifert, who did the typical WELS flip, jumping to the other side of the issue when it suited him. And SP Naumann's son? He knew all about it, too. So did dozens in the Michigan District, WELS; the future president of the Little Seminary on the Prairie; and Floyd Stolzenburg's future co-worker, Jay Webber.

I told Mueller on the phone, "Every girl that is raped, every woman seduced, I hold you responsible for that."

He was startled and said, "Why?" I responded, "Because you are doing nothing about this now."

In conclusion, the decades of greed, immorality, and corruption are coming home, with a gigantic bill to be paid - not only in dollars, but also in lives destroyed and souls murdered.

http://www.childwelfare.gov/systemwide/laws_policies/statutes/manda.pdf

http://www.ncsl.org/default.aspx?tabid=13460

More Lies - But From ELCA This Time.
The Good News - No Gay ELCA College Videos So Far


The next bishop of the Minneapolis Area:

My prediction is that the Rev. Mary Albing will become bishop.  The Minneapolis Area Synod likes to be innovative and this is their chance to elect a non-celibate member of the GLBT community.  It is my opinion that this will also play into the political scene as Minnesota will vote on a marriage amendment in 2012.  Many in the ELCA synod are eager to enshrine the 2009 CWA decision with a bishop who was not even allowed to be a called pastor in the ELCA a couple years ago because of "who she loved."  It is important to complete the revolution as soon as possible.

So are there any ELCA pastors left in the Minneapolis Synod whose bound conscience will be offended when their bishop has a lifestyle they strongly disagree with?  If there are what will they do?  There is this ongoing idiotic statement that gets made, "Your congregation does not have to call a GLBT pastor."  Well for those congregations who disagree with the 2009 innovation--if there are any left in the Minneapolis Synod--they will be forced to accept a GLBT bishop.

Perhaps my prediction is premature but I will stand by it.  It helps that she is at the top of the list due to her name.  Then again perhaps she is the most qualified of the 18 to be bishop and her election will have nothing to do with her affectional preference.

At the last ELCA congregation I was a member of, I predicted that their next pastor would be a member of the GLBT community several years before the current pastors resigned.  When they retired, the congregation fulfilled my prediction.  The members at the time declared that the new pastor was a perfect fit, the best person that they could find for the job.  Yet given the small number of non-celibate ELCA pastors at the time, the odds were fairly small.    It was obvious to some former members that "affectional preference" did influence the congregation's action.

Brian J. Bergs,
Minneapolis, MN

***

GJ - I second the prediction, which will also apply to the next ELCA Presiding Bishop. The current Episcopal PB is married, but she said her husband would move to her Episcopal palace in NYC when "it made sense." No, I am not saying she is or is not. Given her hyper-aggressive policy, there is no doubt about   her original platform when she ran for office.

The agenda means that they must place their open activists in the highest offices.

More lies - they just buried the most influential woman at LCA and ELCA headquarters - Marple. She ran the important activities for decades and was always in The Lutheran magazine. At least two former PBs preached her into heaven after she died. "She is survived by a sister, Virginia Reynolds and nine nieces. She is also survided by a long time friend, Dr. Lois Leffler."

Normally only family members are listed as survivors. Naming a long time friend with blood relatives is the equivalent of announcing a Boston marriage.

To say that Mary Albing will be the first open LGTB leader is deceiving. The message about Dorothy Marple was there for everyone in the know in the LCA/ELCA, and certainly broadcast in her obituary. Everything is done is stages, so dissenters can be excluded.

That is why I am scornful about pastors who spent 25 years in ELCA and decided there was this shocking gay agenda, so they had to leave with their long-established congregations. But they would leave only if they could keep women's ordination and their money in the ELCA pension fund.

WELS and Missouri follow their ministry partner's previous policy in doing nothing about known homosexual pastors. They move them around a bit, deny knowledge, and most of all say - "I am helpless to do anything."

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Bring-back-the-MLC-version-of-party-in-the-USA/246627466671?sk=wall

---

KC has left a new comment on your post "More Lies - But From ELCA This Time. The Good News...":

How about these videos from Gustavus Adolphus' freshmen orientation, sponsored / required by the college?

http://gustavus.campusreform.org/group/blog/video-inside-freshman-orientation 

***

GJ - Good point, KC, but ELCA is supposed to be ee-vul and pansexual. WELS is supposed to be straighter than the road to heaven. WELS, Missouri, and the Little Sect pretend to be so different from ELCA but work with them and emulate them.

Two-Timing Tyndale:
WELS Ditching Biblical Scholarship for UOJ.
January Diaprax

The Little Sect on the Prairie also likes to turn a
Gospel admonition into law - "Go manufacture disciples!"
rather than "Go, teach all nations."


The New NIV has already been approved by WELS. The franchise is simply waiting a bit to squash all opposition.

The next step is the January exercise in process (diaprax). Victims from all over WELS - two from each district, I believe - will gather at The Sausage Factory for some GA nostalgia.

Hold back the tears of laughter now. This is not a post from The WELS Potato. The participants will have an open discussion of the translations being considered (really only one).

This process will identify the boot-licking and ignorant friends of the NNIV while setting apart those who actually understand Biblical translation. Those who go along with the program will be rewarded while those who resist will be vilified behind their backs and punished in various ways.

Lying is basic to WELS management.
GA is based on lies, and still exists,
but they lie about that too.

The look on Paul Wendland's face during the convention discussion said it all - "How dare they question my authority and the majesty of my office?"

After this farce is over, the Dishonest Presidents will manipulate the upcoming meetings to approve the NNIV. They may even pull a Gurgle and say, "The presses are running at NPH already. We can't stop now!" (Feign a look of alarm and concern, for effect.)

The Gang of Four (Wisconsin plus Minnesota) will deliver roughly 75% of the WELS population to the NNIV. They are not alone in their doctrinal lassitude. If a district comes down against the NNIV, the minority will be condemned as extremists and Ichabodians. Even the ultra-polite Intrepids are dismissed as radicals.

The discussions and votes do not matter, except they serve as justification for the final decision. Only the feminist Shrinkers wanted Northwestern College merged into Dr. Martin Luther College, but amalgamation turned into a fact from all the fake participation and faux-votes. The ultimate vote failed, so amalgamation buddies turned the results around and reported a victory. It pays to have the power to appoint the ballot committee.

The only question is - will anyone fight this battle?


PS - Don't expect Synod President Mark Schroeder to show any leadership. He is utterly silent.

---

Brett Meyer has left a new comment on your post "Two-Timing Tyndale: WELS Ditching Biblical Scholar...":

The attempted steamroll by Committee 19 can be watched here (Note: most of these men have been teaching the (W)ELS called workers - Clergy, teachers etc)

http://vimeo.com/channels/wels#27483517 

---

Brett Meyer has left a new comment on your post "Two-Timing Tyndale: WELS Ditching Biblical Scholar...":

Wendland begins his manipulation of the Convention attendees at 1:30:30

Sunday, January 1, 2012

Every Cow Is Sacred in WELS

WELS Pastor, MariQueen, and
The CORE's No Children Allowed Special.


Brett Meyer has left a new comment on your post "Anonymous Mind-Reader Is Not Happy with Posts and ...":

Epistler, I was being facetious about the (W)ELS ministry directed toward active heterosexual and homosexual porn stars like MariQueen. Ski, having been trained and mentored by Mark Jeske, is part of the (W)ELS New Age Emergent Church advance contingent. He posted the photo of his embrace with MariQueen on his Facebook page. MariQueen is an active porn star. It would have been grossly inappropriate for Ski to have posted a photo of their embrace if he was witnessing the Law to her. This was just another hypocritical action that the false teachers in the Emergent Church are famous for. Yet, as the WELS Church Lady correctly points out not only is Ski still a Pastor in good standing with the Synod, he and Glende are dictating their own rules with the blessing of the District President. This kind of activity will only increase as the impotence (or condonation) of the COP and SP become more evident.

Why bother with the Means of Grace
when manipulation with the Law works so well?
Can these leaders be called Lutheran?
---

Brett Meyer has left a new comment on your post "Every Cow Is Sacred in WELS":

Epistler, I apologize if I gave the impression that some people are undeserving of help. Everyone is undeserving, and everyone needs to hear the Word purely taught. Through that Word, the Means of Grace, God calls, gathers, enlightens the whole Christian Church on earth. Romans 8:30 Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified. Note that it is Ski and the Emergent side of the (W)ELS who used MariQueen as an object to appear relevant. Instead of grasping the magnitude of the danger that she is in through unrepentant sin he, and the rest of (W)ELS who turn a blind eye to the false teachers, false doctrine and false practice in the synod, are simply using the lost to sell their methods.

To a point you made earlier, I do not wish that the (W)ELS be entirely shut down. I would that they return to the one true Gospel and reject the false man made gospel of Universal Objective Justification - which if a person truly clings to separates them from Christ and God's one true way of righteousness. UOJ is their official teaching and it can and has been clearly shown that it is false. Since the pure doctrine of Justification, faith in Christ alone, is essential for one to be a Christian the Lutheran Synods have shown themselves to be unChristian in their official doctrines. The Lord is dealing with them as He ordains. Since the eternal spiritual welfare of men, women and children are being directly influenced by their official teaching of UOJ I would rather (W)ELS be crushed instantaneousely than another soul be taught to cling to righteousness before and without faith and thereby separated from Christ. But that hasn't happened and so I will continue to expose the false teachers in the Lutheran Synods as God gives me the ability. Not everyone in the (W)ELS confesses the false gospel of UOJ - but unfortunately the majority of faithful Lutherans (the minority) in the synod are largely silent and have decided to let the Synod persecute faithful Christians in order to protect themselves. The Lord's will be done.  

Lutherans Read It Here First - Anglicans have U.S. home in Catholic church – USATODAY.com

Episcorat Steenson


Anglicans have U.S. home in Catholic church – USATODAY.com:

VATICAN CITY (AP) – Pope Benedict XVI named a married former Episcopal bishop Sunday to head the first U.S. organizational structure for disaffected Anglicans and Episcopalians who want to join the Roman Catholic Church.



The Rev. Jeffrey Neil Steenson, a father of three and Catholic convert, will lead the Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter, the equivalent of a diocese, that will be based in Houston, Texas, but will operate nationally.
The Vatican created the first such ordinariate in Britain last year. Other ordinariates are being considered in Australia and Canada.
Steenson stepped down in 2007 as the Episcopal Bishop of Rio Grande, in Albuquerque, New Mexico, after theEpiscopal Church elected the first openly gay bishop, V. Gene Robinson of New Hampshire. Steenson had said he was "deeply troubled" about the direction of the U.S. denomination and he described the Catholic Church as the "true home of Anglicanism."
The Episcopal Church is the U.S. Anglican body in the United States.
Benedict in 2009 issued an unprecedented invitation for Anglicans to become Catholic in groups or as parishes, at a time when traditional Anglicans in several countries were increasingly upset by the ordination of women and gay bishops. Formerly, Anglican converts to Catholicism were accepted on a case-by-case basis.
The pope's decision created tensions with Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, the spiritual leader of the world Anglican Communion, who like his predecessors had been in talks with Vatican officials to bring Anglicans and Catholics closer together.
The 77-million-member Anglican fellowship has its roots in the Church of England, which split from the Holy See in 1534 when English King Henry VIII was refused a marriage annulment.
At the time of the pope's announcement, Anglicans were already fracturing over Robinson's election and other issues. Williams had little advance notice of the Vatican announcement. Still, after meeting privately with the pope soon after, the archbishop of Canterbury said he was convinced that there was no "dawn raid" on his church by the Holy See.
Under the pope's plan, Anglicans who become Catholic will be allowed to keep some of their heritage in liturgy and other areas. Married Anglican priests who convert can stay married and be ordained in the Catholic Church, an exception to the Vatican's celibacy rule. Married Anglican bishops, however, cannot retain that position, and will serve the Catholic Church as priests.
More than 100 Anglican clergy have applied to become Catholic priests in the U.S. ordinariate. Church officials said more than 1,400 individuals are seeking to join. The U.S. Episcopal Church has just under 2 million members. Many Anglo-Catholics in the United States had never been part of the Episcopal Church.
Steenson, 59, who has a doctorate from the University of Oxford, has been married since 1974 and has three adult children. His wife also converted to Catholicism. He was ordained as a Catholic priest in 2009 in the Archdiocese of Santa Fe, New Mexico, and helped create the education and training program for Anglican priests seeking to join the Catholic Church.


'via Blog this'

***

GJ - All of you are wondering, "How he know this so early? He even named the new leader."

I have listening posts everywhere, and I pay special attention to the Episcopal Church in the US. I started getting a subscription to their tabloid in the 1970s, due to some friendships with conservative, married priests. The tabloid followed me to each address and I watched the decline gather momentum. I taunted the ELCA about brave Episcopal defections when relatively few left ELCA. Suddenly ELCA calved one large congregation after another, leaving after the 2009 convention.

This ordinariate is quite important, because the Church of Rome has made it shockingly easy for Episcopalian priests, bishops, and congregations to be part of Catholicism while retaining what they value from their own history. I do see the irony, given the 25 years of homosexual scandals in the Roman Catholic Church. Given the indefectible character of the Roman Church (a concept familiar to WELS, Missouri, and the Little Sect - about their own franchises), that Roman scandal is just a blip. Like Tabor, Just, Hochmuth, and the rest of the Lutheran blips.

Dumbing Down America


Charlotte Iserbyt is the consummate whistleblower! Iserbyt served as Senior Policy Advisor in the Office of Educational Research and Improvement (OERI), U.S. Department of Education, during the first Reagan Administration, where she first blew the whistle on a major technology initiative which would control curriculum in America's classrooms. Iserbyt is a former school board director in Camden, Maine and was co-founder and research analyst of Guardians of Education for Maine (GEM) from 1978 to 2000. She has also served in the American Red Cross on Guam and Japan during the Korean War, and in the United States Foreign Service in Belgium and in the Republic of South Africa. Iserbyt is a speaker and writer, best known for her 1985 booklet Back to Basics Reform or OBE: Skinnerian International Curriculum and her 1989 pamphlet Soviets in the Classroom: America's Latest Education Fad which  covered the details of the U.S.-Soviet and Carnegie-Soviet Education Agreements which remain in effect to this day. She is a freelance writer and has had artiles published in Human Events, The Washington Times, The Bangor Daily News, and included in the record of Congressional hearings.

California notes this book event:

Charlotte Iserbyt's latest book has been released, and pre orders are currently being shipped from the printer.  It is already showing up available from secondary sources through amazon.com.   There is a good blurb about the revised and updated new book on the amazon site attached.    It can also be ordered from Charlotte (1-207-737-4730).

The new chapter which  chronicles  events about education since the original book published in 1999 until 2011, contains a bit of my contribution.

----- Forwarded Message ---

Sent: Mon, 02 Jan 2012 00:33:55 -0000 (UTC)
Subject: deliberate dumbing down of america, abridged, updated version at amazon.com

Please forward following Amazon link to your addressees:

http://www.amazon.com/Deliberate-Dumbing-America-Revised-Abridged/dp/0966707117/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1325463741&sr=8-3


Charlotte Thomson Iserbyt
Former Senior Policy Advisor
U.S. Department of Education

http://www.deliberatedumbingdown.com

http://www.americandeception.com

We know! We know!
Stetzer copyrighted a graphic with an obvious spelling mistake in it.
His diciples in WELS should spot it right away.

Fertility rate plummets in Brazil - The Washington Post



Fertility rate plummets in Brazil - The Washington Post:


By Juan Forero, Published: December 29

BATAN, Brazil — Priscila da Silva once asked her grandmother why she had 12 children, and the answer was simple: “Because I wanted to.”

These days, Silva, like many women in Brazil and the rest of Latin America, has other plans. At 24, she thinks about having one child, if that.

186
Comments
Weigh InCorrections?


inShare


(Juan Forero/ The Washington Post ) - At their new restaurant, Saborearte in the Rio de Janeiro suburb of Batan, Priscila da Silva, left, and Jaqueline Ramos, both 24, are focused on making their business a success. If she ever has children, Silva wants one. And Ramos said, for now, she's happy raising her dog.
Graphic

Fertility rates plunging across Latin America

“The situation today is different, and raising a child is difficult,” said Silva, slicing tomatoes at a restaurant that she founded with four other women, only one of whom has planned a family of any size. “This is another time, and it’s not the same.”


'via Blog this'

Anonymous Mind-Reader Is Not Happy with Posts and Comments


The Epistler has left a new comment on your post "TODAY Entertainment - Russell Brand, Katy Perry ar...":

@Brett Meyer. A good friend of mine once posed for pornography. She was also a meth addict. In fact, she had a lot of problems. Her current boyfriend is the one who first took her to a WELS church. She's now a Sunday School teacher there. She credits him and the work of that church for her salvation. Even I can't deny that her current congregation changed and maybe saved her life. So before your post more of your sneering judgement on "the porn-star outreach," balance this. It is no secret that if you and others here had their way, the WELS would be entirely shut down. And one woman would most likely be dead. Is that worth your personal satisfaction? I suspect to you it would be.

@WELS Church Lady. I'm sure Pastor Koelpin has better ways to reach a decision than listening to your rumour (sic)  mongering.

***

GJ - The milk of human kindness has curdled in poor little Epistler's heart. He knows that Brett Meyer wishes a Sunday School teacher dead and all of WELS shut down.

Confidentially, it took the FBI to shut down man-boy child pornography at WELS headquarters.

And it is rumor mongering when an attorney from Glende's congregation and pastors from the district investigated the plagiarism of false doctrine at St. Peter Freedom? The facts have been established and published about the circuit pastor being fired.

But it is a sin to tell the truth about WELS. The clergy turn venomous as soon as anyone dare to mention the facts.

Mark Jeske - A Taxing Issue

Does he pay taxes on his house,
since his school business is tax-reliant?


 bruce-church (http://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "The Sunday after Christmas: Galatians 4:1-7":

With Gov Walker's expansion of School Choice, i.e., lifting the cap on the number students who could enroll, St. Marcus is doubling the size of their school to a 1,000 students. The $12 million school building addition is well underway. I'd say Jeske is more of a public servant than a WELS or LCMS pastor right now, plus he's a public school teacher union buster:

http://www.stmarcus.org/school/

-----------

http://www.politifact.com/wisconsin/promises/walk-o-meter/promise/577/remove-enrollment-caps-for-private-school-choice-p/

In the parental choice program, the 22,500-pupil cap is gone, and students will now be able to attend private schools beyond the city of Milwaukee's borders.

The Sunday after Christmas:
Galatians 4:1-7




The Sunday after Christmas

Pastor Gregory L. Jackson


Bethany Lutheran Church, 10 AM Central Time


The Hymn # 85:1-8 From Heaven Above 4.55
The Confession of Sins
The Absolution
The Introit p. 16
The Gloria Patri
The Kyrie p. 17
The Gloria in Excelsis
The Salutation and Collect p. 19
The Epistle and Gradual       
The Gospel              
Glory be to Thee, O Lord!
Praise be to Thee, O Christ!
The Nicene Creed p. 22
The Sermon Hymn #85:9-15 From Heaven Above 4.55

 Redemption, Atonement, Forgiveness

The Hymn #657            Beautiful Savior                    4.24
The Preface p. 24
The Sanctus p. 26
The Lord's Prayer p. 27
The Words of Institution
The Agnus Dei p. 28
The Nunc Dimittis p. 29
The Benediction p. 31
The Hymn #83     Hark! What Mean Those Holy Voices  4:40

KJV Galatians 4:1 Now I say, That the heir, as long as he is a child, differeth nothing from a servant, though he be lord of all; 2 But is under tutors and governors until the time appointed of the father. 3 Even so we, when we were children, were in bondage under the elements of the world: 4 But when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law, 5 To redeem them that were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of sons. 6 And because ye are sons, God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, Abba, Father. 7 Wherefore thou art no more a servant, but a son; and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ.

KJV Luke 2:33 And Joseph and his mother marvelled at those things which were spoken of him. 34 And Simeon blessed them, and said unto Mary his mother, Behold, this child is set for the fall and rising again of many in Israel; and for a sign which shall be spoken against; 35 (Yea, a sword shall pierce through thy own soul also,) that the thoughts of many hearts may be revealed. 36 And there was one Anna, a prophetess, the daughter of Phanuel, of the tribe of Aser: she was of a great age, and had lived with an husband seven years from her virginity; 37 And she was a widow of about fourscore and four years, which departed not from the temple, but served God with fastings and prayers night and day. 38 And she coming in that instant gave thanks likewise unto the Lord, and spake of him to all them that looked for redemption in Jerusalem. 39 And when they had performed all things according to the law of the Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth. 40 And the child grew, and waxed strong in spirit, filled with wisdom: and the grace of God was upon him.

Sunday After Christmas

O almighty and everlasting God, mercifully direct our ways, that we may walk in Thy law, and be made to abound in good works: through Thy beloved Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, who liveth and reigneth with Thee and the Holy Ghost, one true God, world without end. Amen.

The Meaning of the Gospel


KJV Galatians 4:1 Now I say, That the heir, as long as he is a child, differeth nothing from a servant, though he be lord of all; 2 But is under tutors and governors until the time appointed of the father. 3 Even so we, when we were children, were in bondage under the elements of the world: 4 But when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law, 5 To redeem them that were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of sons. 6 And because ye are sons, God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, Abba, Father. 7 Wherefore thou art no more a servant, but a son; and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ.

This passage is part of a brief but powerful letter where Paul attacked the attitude of salvation through the law, showing that one cannot mix the law with the Gospel and still have the Gospel.

Galatians 4:1 Now I say, That the heir, as long as he is a child, differeth nothing from a servant, though he be lord of all;

This analogy is so clear that everyone should grasp it at once. Nevertheless, one could easily show that much of Christendom remains under the law, seeking comfort and salvation from man-made law rather than from the Gospel. This is not a letter aimed at Jews but at Christians tempted by combining the Gospel and the Law.

One branch of my family fell into this, when they were part of the Seventh Day Adventists in Battle Creek. (Kellogg’s cereal was part of this movement, although he broke with them.) It is tempting to think of Jews as heirs of the Promise, therefore following the Old Testament Law would be the perfect combination of the Law and Gospel.


When that part of the family moved to Iowa to farm, they found that the SDA laws prevented them from making a living, so they changed to an Evangelical congregation. Later, a SDA minister impressed me with how obsessed he was with all Old Testament details. Strangely, the Adventists wanted to duplicate the false view Galatians was written to oppose.

The comparison is clear, because the child of a wealthy lord is still very much a servant as long as he is young, even if he is the heir. The tutor is appointed to direct the child and give him training. So the promise of a title is there, but the reality is not.

2 But is under tutors and governors until the time appointed of the father.

Lenski:
Paul himself states what he has in mind. Just as a slave has his superiors who control him and his affairs, so this young heir. Paul thinks of a large inheritance as befits the great spiritual inheritance which he is illustrating. Hence he names two classes of superiors, tutors and governors, which some regard as identical. But the former are those who are placed in charge of the young heir himself, call them guardians; the latter are those who manage his estates, stewards. The latter were often slaves yet were competent men, one being placed over this, the other over that estate of the owner. In our estimation the “guardians” were those who, among other things, attended to the boy’s education.
Since Paul is writing to Galatians who are not merely Roman citizens, it is doubtful whether he refers to Roman law. This provided for a tutor (or several) until the age of puberty, the fourteenth year, was reached, after that for a curator until majority was attained, which occurred at the age of twenty-five years. The “guardians” of whom Paul speaks do not seem to be the tutor and the curator but those whose duty it was to provide the necessary teachers for the young heir. The point is that the minor heir is under others and that of necessity because he is still a minor.
The other point is the length of time he is under others, which is thus again mentioned, but now more specifically: “until the time set in advance by the father.”
Lenski, R. C. H.: The Interpretation of St. Paul's Epistles to the Galatians, to the Ephesians and to the Philippians. Columbus, O. : Lutheran Book Concern, 1937, S. 193


That is even more true of a young king, who has the title but not the rule. One influential relative or official is the real king as long as the child is too young to be free of adult tutors. Queen Victoria became the most powerful monarch in the world as a teenager, so she depended on adults to guide her in politics.

This is so clear in human government, but people fail to see it at work in the difference between Law and Gospel. The Law says “must” and “ought to” while the Gospel says “want to” and “glad to.”

The exact same thing can be done as a child under the Law or as an adult freed by the Gospel. As children, we always responded to chores with, “Do I have to?”
As long as we were ordered to do it, we did so, but reluctantly.

We can all remember our childhoods enough to recall that we were dependent upon others, chafing against rules but needing them, and wishing we could be grown-ups.

One couple told me about an older teen who complained about being treated as a child. I asked some questions. Does he do his own laundry? No. Cook for himself or you? No. Pay for his housing? I suggested they lay that on him so he could be an adult.
The worst college students are the ones coddled by indulgent parents or special programs where everything is paid. The best are the ones paying their own way and making sure they get their money’s worth.

3 Even so we, when we were children, were in bondage under the elements of the world:

Being under the Law is the same as being children. While it was true that the Jewish people were given the Promise of the Messiah, that was already realized, so there was no reason to go back to the Law, which kept them together as a nation. Neither was there a reason to blend Law and Gospel, to make believers into Jews with ritual law (kosher, circumcision, and traditions).

All the Jewish traditions and worship practices prepared them for Jesus as the Messiah. That is why conversions to Christianity continue to this day. Everything leads up to the Promise being fulfilled because the Old Testament is filled with references to Christ and justification by faith in Him. My catechism students soon learned that everything in the Exodus pre-figured Christ. As one said, “I am not sure if the answer is Jesus, but all the other answers have been.”

The questions involved the innocent lamb slain for the Passover, the manna, the burning bush, the water from the rock, and so forth.

4 But when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law,

This is another example of the Two Natures of Christ being, teaching His humanity (made of a woman, under the law) and His divinity (God sent forth His Son). The skeptics want us to think that Paul never mentioned the Virgin Birth of Jesus, but this verse and the opening of Romans both teach the Two Natures clearly. Jesus, in John’s Gospel, often referred to Himself as sent from the Father. And how was that done, except through the Virgin Birth?

What skeptics choose to ignore is the way arguments are made based upon current issues. Paul was not addressing the Virgin Birth but salvation through the Law. Nevertheless, the basics of the Gospel came through in a very short letter. I challenge anyone to make such powerful statements about the Christian faith in so few words. That by itself is testimony to the Holy Spirit’s inspiration.

At the perfect time, God’s own time, God sent His Son to reveal the complete Gospel, the atoning sacrifice, resurrection, and ascension. Hundreds of eye-witnesses were available to preach the risen Christ at the time of Paul. They saw and heard the risen Christ teach. Before that, many miracles confirmed Jesus as the Messiah, the Son of God.

5 To redeem them that were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of sons.

Lenski:
The whole thought is a refutation of the Judaizers. God’s Son set free all those who were under law; this purpose, being objective, was achieved. Furthermore, it was achieved in order that we Jews should receive the sonship. This was a subjective purpose that was also achieved, but only in the believing Jews, the unbelieving were hardened and cast away (Rom. 11:7). “The sonship” is modified by the context (v. 1–3) and thus signifies the status of sons who have advanced from their minority to their majority, to the status of full-grown sons who are no longer under guardians and stewards. “Adoption” is not the proper word, for it may apply to a babe, a minor son and heir.
This eliminates the question as to whether regeneration as well as justification is included in this “sonship.” In their minority, before Christ came all the heirs were both regenerated and justified although they were still under the guardianship and the stewardship of the Mosaic law (v. 2). When Christ came, when their majority was attained, this involved the end of the guardianship and stewardship of law for them. Ever after that time they were entirely free of it.
Lenski, R. C. H.: The Interpretation of St. Paul's Epistles to the Galatians, to the Ephesians and to the Philippians. Columbus, O. : Lutheran Book Concern, 1937, S. 204

To redeem (and Galatians 3:13) is from the verb to purchase for a price. The other word we translate as redemption is to release, as in releasing from slavery.

The idea of blood sacrifice prepared Jews for the atoning death of the Lamb of God. All those sacrifices for centuries were a foreshadowing of the sacrifice of Christ.

This is where people get confused, when they do not comprehend the Means of Grace. Christ paid for the sins of the world. Redemption and atonement are synonyms. Propitation and expiation are also words used the in the New Testament for the atonement.

Luther anticipated what the Concordists faced after the Book of Concord. The redemption or atonement is the Gospel treasure. No one needs to say, “What can I do to make up for my sins?” The payment has been made.

But that is not the same as saying

LCMS Brief Statement of 1932:
Scripture teaches that God has already declared the whole world to be righteous in Christ, Rom. 5:19; 2 Cor. 5:18-21; Rom. 4:25; that therefore not for the sake of their good works, but without the works of the Law, by grace, for Christ's sake, He justifies, accounts as righteous, all those who that is, believe, accept, and rely on, the fact that for Christ's sake their sins are forgiven. Thus the Holy Ghost testifies through St. Paul: "There is no difference; for all have sinned and come short of the glory of God, being justified freely by His grace, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus," Rom. 3:23, 24. And again: "Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the Law," Rom. 3:28.

All the Scripture examples above are wrong, and some are outrageously in error.

God’s declaration of forgiveness is what we call justification by faith. That is always through the proclamation of the Gospel (the Means of Grace) and faith in Jesus.

6 And because ye are sons, God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, Abba, Father. 7 Wherefore thou art no more a servant, but a son; and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ.

This is a classic passage in the New Testament, often quoted to show us that the Spirit works through the Word to plant faith in our hearts, to move us to say Abba, Father – the Lord’s Prayer.

Because Christ makes us a brother, a member of God’s family, we are able and willing to call upon Him in every time of trial or need. We do not live in bondage to the Law but in freedom through the Gospel.

Ephesians 3:20 Now unto him that is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think, according to the power that worketh in us, 21 Unto him be glory in the church by Christ Jesus throughout all ages, world without end. Amen.

Isaiah 65:21 And they shall build houses, and inhabit them; and they shall plant vineyards, and eat the fruit of them. 22 They shall not build, and another inhabit; they shall not plant, and another eat: for as the days of a tree are the days of my people, and mine elect shall long enjoy the work of their hands. 23 They shall not labour in vain, nor bring forth for trouble; for they are the seed of the blessed of the LORD, and their offspring with them. 24 And it shall come to pass, that before they call, I will answer; and while they are yet speaking, I will hear. 25 The wolf and the lamb shall feed together, and the lion shall eat straw like the bullock: and dust shall be the serpent's meat. They shall not hurt nor destroy in all my holy mountain, saith the LORD.


Hedonists
The hedonists misunderstand this. They imagine they can do whatever they want and use the Gospel as an excuse, saying, “I know I am a sinner, so I know I am forgiven.” Paul disposed of this lame approach in Romans 6, but the idea has great attract for the Old Adam. 

New Law-Givers
Rick Warren and his disciples are good examples of returning to the Law. At first Pietists emphasis the small group, prayer, and Bible study. But because they do not teach the Means of Grace, they think something is lacking. They return to the Law by saying they have to transform society and make the world a better place. Every denomination that embraces Pietism goes from the small group to the new laws – with Moses as the Savior. Soon they see how there are many others who also want to transform society, so they lay aside all differences and join in union efforts to transform society. We are far worse off today than we were before people were transforming society.  

Lenski:
This translation assumes that the sonship of the Galatians is now to be proved, and that the possession of the Spirit is the proof. But the sonship is proved in v. 4, 5, and what is now added is the result of this sonship, the corroboration of it, exactly as is done in Rom. 8:14, 15, which treats the possession of the Spirit as one of the great results of justification. A result may, of course, be used to prove its cause; but here Paul does not reverse matters in this way, he states the cause and then its result. In 3:2 he inquires for the source of the effect and thus does reverse the two.
The moment we note that “sons” means sons who are no longer in their minority but in their full majority, we see how Paul has, indeed, proved the Galatians to be such sons: God’s Son has abolished all minority, no minor heirs now exist, all guardians and stewards over minors are now and forever abolished. It is in this sense that the Galatian believers are “sons” also with the evident result of such mature sonship and freedom from superiors, namely that God commissioned the Spirit of the Son with the cry of sons, “Abba Father.”
Note the close parallel: “God commissioned forth his Son” (v. 4)—“God commissioned forth the Spirit of his Son.” These are the two great historic acts. All the promises of Jesus regarding the sending of the Spirit apply, John 14:16, etc.; 15:26; 16:13, etc.; Acts 1:8. The fulfillment came on Pentecost and remained for all believers of all time. The things to be noted are not the outward miraculous signs which occurred at the time of Pentecost, which are like the angels singing at the time of the nativity; but all the statements of Jesus that the Spirit could not come to the disciples until Jesus had gone to the Father. When redemption was entirely complete, the Spirit came, “commissioned forth” as Jesus had been. Then all the guardians and the stewards were dismissed, the Spirit took their place, for the heirs’ minority was ended, the Galatian believers were “sons” in this full sense.
We need scarcely say that the Spirit wrought in the Old Testament, that the faith of the Old Testament believers was produced by the Spirit. To think that the Old Testament believers were devoid of the Spirit is to imagine an impossibility. Pentecost ushered in a new era, the era when the Spirit is able to glorify Jesus as one having come, to take all that Jesus has achieved, to declare it unto us, John 16:14; this is his world-wide mission. And this means: no longer minor heirs waiting for this era. “You are sons.”
For such “sons” the Spirit of God’s Son is intended. When Paul says that he is in “our” hearts and changes from the second person plural to the first, we must go on to v. 7 where he changes to “thou,” the singular, every individual. These different pronouns are not stressed over against each other; they merely turn the thought in every direction. “Our” hearts thus include Paul and the Galatian believers. Paul himself and the great mass of Jewish believers in the Christian Church had come to faith after the Son brought redemption. This includes the 3,000 who came to faith after the Spirit was poured out at Pentecost. Like the Gentile believers, all of them at once became “sons.” Do not forget that among the 3,000 there were not a few proselytes (Acts 2:10), former Gentiles. All of them were not minors but sons in their majority. There was no further waiting for the testamentary promises to be fulfilled, no further supervision for minor heirs.
Lenski, R. C. H.: The Interpretation of St. Paul's Epistles to the Galatians, to the Ephesians and to the Philippians. Columbus, O. : Lutheran Book Concern, 1937, S. 205.


Friday, December 30, 2011

MLC board OKs senior housing for New Ulm - NUJournal.com | News, Sports, Jobs - The Journal, New Ulm, MN

MLC money-making project.


MLC board OKs senior housing for New Ulm - NUJournal.com | News, Sports, Jobs - The Journal, New Ulm, MN:

'via Blog this'

---

Brett Meyer has left a new comment on your post "MLC board OKs senior housing for New Ulm - NUJourn...":

You will soon be going out penniless and unwillingly. Unfortunately the Lutheran Synodical leaders have swindled the laity into giving Thrivent their money in exchange for doubling the bake sale proceeds. They also gave generously to Lutheran World Relief (LWR) which is an NGO of the United Nations. Both have used your financial support to advance the New Age agenda through ELCA and the United Nations. Not only has this allowed the incessant slaughter of the unborn children of ELCA called workers, it has exported this same slaughter around the world of men, women and children. You see, Thrivent's direct support, amoung other things, for the New Age United Religions Initiative is the direct support for worshipping the earth as God and Mother and condemning humanity as it's worst plague which must be eliminated to sustainable levels while establishing a global governement and religion (headed by the Antichrist) required to enforce such satanic doctrines. This is why the value of your dollar has collapsed to it's current point, represented so perfectly by the current value of gold. Thus the retirement age of 20-25% of Boomers is 80yrs and realistically - never. Now would be a good time to humourously say BAZINGOO! but it is far to terrible to joke about. MLC is just buying time - of which there is very little left. In view of the events depicted in Matt. Chapter 24 Christians pray that Christ would return soon, knowing fully what that entails and ought to know just how much the so-called Lutheran Synods are doing in opposition to Christ and His Church.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/halahtouryalai/2011/12/14/is-80-the-new-retirement-age-many-americans-think-so/

http://www.green-agenda.com/index.html  

---

California wrote:

Reading about WELS' venture into Senior Housing linked to Early Childhood  Learning, is an idea lifted right out of the womb to tomb Big Brother agenda being put in place by government across the nation.   For half a century, WELS has always been playing "catch-up" with the latest socialist utopian scheme to come along, and even the terminology reminded me of one California County's Early Learning Master Plan (2010) which I have in my hand as I write.  It is just one of other clones across the nation for government schools and communities.   In that plan, even the carefully crafted terminogy is explained as  follows:  "By the way: we titled the effort an 'early learning plan' advisedly.   We wanted to convey the message that early learning is not an 'extra' or preamble to 'real school, but rather a vital component of the BIRTH TO ADULT LEARNING CONTINUUM".  (emphasis added by me)

The terminology is subtley changed from Early Childhood Education or Preschool, to " Early Learning" in order to accommodate the idea of institutional oversight from birth to old age.   Elsewhere in the same document, prenatal home visits are programmed into the scheme.

According to the November 2011 publication from MLC in which the planned Early childhood Learning Center and the New Senior Housing Facility are reported  to be linked together for a continuum of generations  with "classrooms for infants and toddlers and well as 3, 4, and 5 year-olds".

No mention at least in the MLC publication of prenatal visits to prospective homes of families by WELS overseers, but can that be far behind as WELS agenda is gravitating to institutionalizing functions for which God provided families?.  

WELS is obviously following models being put in place by government at Federal, State and local levels, with schools to become the centers for the socialist community utopia.  WELS and other church related  entities should instead be encouraging parents to rsist the paradigm, and "parent" their own young children at home in family context, not lending their infants and toddlers to instutional instruction, observation, and assessing, then planning and programming for housing of surrogate grandparents in the "grand" scheme of instituionaling all of society.  

Granted  that participants will be willing or nudged to be participants since the power of the sword is not yet employed to enforce participation,  but it will be interesting to know whether government funding is a factor especially  re: the "Senior Housing" Project.  The Plan fits the Agenda 21 Model regardless of where the funding comes from, but then should anyone be surprised? Way back in the 1970s , this observor complained about DMLC recommending that WELS teachers obtain social studies lessons and material from the UN.

---

California on the Dunning-Kruger Effect:

In a comment re: "Post Dunning-Kruger Effect in the OldenSynodical Conference", rlschultz says,   "So much of CG nonsense creates the illusion of participatory democracy.  As has been pointed out elsewhere here at Ichabod, this is usually done to draw out the dissenters and find the yes-men".

rlshcultz is exactly right in the observation about the system being designed to draw out the dissenters and find the yes-men.   However, it is not to "create the ILLUSION of participatory democracy", for it IS THE ESSENCE OF PARTICIPATORY DEMOCRACY.  "Participatory Democracy" is one of those clever euphemisms created by the antagonists of democratic representative governance. The terms are often confused, but couldn't be more different.

The term, "Participatory Democracy" was coined in the document, "The Port Huron Manifesto" attributed largely to leftist activist, Tom Hayden and published by Students for Democratic Society in 1962 during days of student revolutions.   The text of the Port Huron Manifesto is still posted on internetaccessible with a simple google search. Those who are old enough to remember the national turmoil during the 1960's will recognize the name of Students for Democratic society (SDS), a leftist student revolutionary movement.

It came to my attention during my research and battles with the government schools system's planned, programmed, "unfreezing of the system".

In researching the system we discovered PPBS, Planning Programming, Budgeting System, which was a new form of governance being superimposed on our representative form of governance in education as well as most other governmental agencies starting with the Department of Defense.  That's all documentable.   It was that research and involvement in secular arena which sharpened my antenna as a member of a WELS congregation, when I happened to have access and see a memo from  Norman Berg to pastors, in which he used the term: "Participatory Democracy".   I thought then that surely the origin and real meaning of the term must not have been known or understood. In retrospect, maybe or maybe not.   

My research resulted in activism, some writing and a speech in  1972 re: PPBS in schools.  In the speech I quoted a book, MANAGEMENT OF EDUCATION, by Shelly Umans who said it well:   "If people are involved, then whole new strategies must be developed to 'engineer' people into accepting change. Projects that do not take into account the need to involve the people affected are not likely to succeed......In discussing strategies for affecting change, we are talking about broad plans, the over all plans for gaining acceptance.  How will the person out there be convinced that he wants to adopt the change?"

 "They call it people technology in the same book.  So involving the potential adopter in the development of innovation is the strategy for overcoming resistance both within the academic community and the general public."

Another name for this process is Participatory Democracy,a term by the way, which was coined by SDS in their Port Huron Manifesto, to identify the process for citizen participation in destruction of their own political institutions. Participatory Democracy is not to be confused with participation in representative government."  Speech titled PPBS (1972)

Participatory Democracy is designed to let everyone think they are having a voice in an already predetermined objective, but it is designed to identify resistance in order to either circumvent it or ultimately isolate or eliminate absolute resistance which can't be presented in the controlled
resulting "consensus".   

When I discovered  in the 70's that WELS had adopted PPBS as its modus operandi in the late 60's, I knew the die was cast..

Efforts to explain the toxicity of PPBS and the systems driven term: Participatory Democracy fell on deaf or ears of those who couldn't conceive of Synod leaders allowing anything like I described or on ears already committed to the Process.

Participatory Democracy is such a nice sounding term, but one which is a clever deception in itself, whose meaning is well understood by the perpetrators of destruction of  institutions.