ICHABOD, THE GLORY HAS DEPARTED - explores the Age of Apostasy, predicted in 2 Thessalonians 2:3, to attack Objective Faithless Justification, Church Growth Clowns, and their ringmasters. The antidote to these poisons is trusting the efficacious Word in the Means of Grace. John 16:8. Isaiah 55:8ff. Romans 10. Most readers are WELS, LCMS, ELS, or ELCA. This blog also covers the Roman Catholic Church, Eastern Orthodoxy, and the Left-wing, National Council of Churches denominations.
---
Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Freddy Finkelstein on Building Evangelism":
Freddy Finkelstein, I bet the congregation you were at had their loan request turned down, and that's when they saw the light and reduced expectations. It's funny how the Spirit can supposedly be leading a congregation in one direction, but then reality sets it. Perhaps it was the "spirit" of ambition after all? Or ignorance is bliss?
That reminds me of the WELS missions that had to be curtailed due to this current recession. I could hardly believe my ears when I heard from two different pastors a year ago that those missions and called missionaries were wanted by God at those locations, so the WELS's pulling back a little was only because of sin by WELS members. It's almost as though the WELS was conquering Canaan, and because the WELSians didn't try hard enough, they sinned due to unbelief. The Israelites though saw God and were commanded directly to conquer, but the WELS has no such direct line to God, despite what some pastors think.
Back to the building issue. A similar thing happened at our church. The pastor wanted a $100k addition to the parsonage, even though the houses in the neighborhood around the church sold for $80k, and some were even smaller and sold for less. Talk of this went on for an entire year! Fortunately, someone pointed out that you can't sell even a McMansion for substantially more than the average price of a house on the block where it is located. In other words, if the church closed or moved, we'd never be able to get our money back on a McMansion-parsonage! So a more modest addition to the parsonage was approved.
We woke up to news of church services being canceled all over the region. The snow was not bad, but the roads are steep and curvy. As the Russian proverb says, "The church is near, but the way is slippery. The tavern is far, so I will walk carefully."
We had our regular Sunday worship service, with attendance from across the country, perhaps across the world.
Any church can broadcast free over the Internet, using a fairly new computer, a $75 camera, broadband, and Ustream. Many members have the broadband to watch the service, whether broadcast from the chapel at home or from the church.
---
Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Snow Did Not Cancel Our Service":
Compare this with Freddy’s story “If we build it, they will come.” Almost any congregation can get online and begin sharing the Word. Yet, hardly any do so. Why? Evidently it is not as rewarding to the pastors – the same pastors who keep talking about doing the work of the Lord.
There are a multitude of possible reasons including the following:
1. Monuments & Recognition. Tangible objects like buildings provide monuments to their efforts.
2. Metrics, Peer Pressure & Group Think. Synod places a high value on buildings and judges pastors accordingly.
3. Supporting Membership. A web-based ministry does not increase the headcount – again very important in the synod. You end up giving away the Word and get nothing in return.
4. Outreach. Most pastors will do anything to avoid doing outreach either directly or indirectly.
5. Myth. Pastors subscribe to the false belief that buildings bring in lost souls thereby saving souls and the church.
"O Jesus Christ, Thy Manger Is"
by Paul Gerhardt, 1607-1676
1. O Jesus Christ,
Thy manger is
My paradise at which my soul reclineth.
For there, O Lord,
Doth lie the Word
Made flesh for us; herein Thy grace
forth shineth.
2. He whom the sea
And wind obey
Doth come to serve the sinner in great
meekness.
Thou, God's own Son,
With us art one,
Dost join us and our children in our
weekness.
3. Thy light and grace
Our guilt efface,
Thy heavenly riches all our loss
retrieving.
Immanuel,
Thy birth doth quell
The power of hell and Satan's bold
deceiving.
4. Thou Christian heart,
Whoe'er thou art,
Be of good cheer and let no sorrow move
thee!
For God's own Child,
In mercy mild,
Joins thee to Him;-how greatly God must
love thee!
5. Remember thou
What glory now
The Lord prepared thee for all earthly
sadness.
The angel host
Can never boast
Of greater glory, greater bliss or gladness.
6. The world may hold
Her wealth and gold;
But thou, my heart, keep Christ as thy true
Treasure.
To Him hold fast
Until at last
A crown be thine and honor in full
measure.
The Lutheran Hymnal
Hymn #81
Text: Luke 2: 7
Author: Paul Gerhardt, 1653, cento
Translated by: composite
Titled: O Jesu Christ, dein Kripplein ist
Composer: Johann Crueger, 1653
Tune: O Jesu Christ, dein Kripplein
---
Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "WELS Congregation Promotes ELCA Program, Female Bi...":
Several Wels churches tried the stepping stones program a few years ago, at the time I heard that WLCFS worked with the Faith Inkubators program to change it to be inline with WELS doctrine.
http://www.mlc-wels.edu/home/administration/pastor/evangelismday/evanday2009sched/
Rev. James Mattek: Rev. James Mattek is currently CEO of Wisconsin Lutheran Child and Family Service, Inc. He oversees a nursing home, assisted living facility and an independent retirement facility. He
also oversees a team of WELS counselors, which includes 2 PhD psychologists, as well as Ministry Support Services which serves WELS
clergy with their personal, mental and spiritual issues.
WLCFS is also developing a family ministry program called "Faith Stepping Stones" and a teen program called "Peer Leadership Training". He served Immanuel of Findlay, OH for the first 17 years of his ministry. He then served for
five years as pastor at Trinity, Watertown, WI. He served the WELS as chairman of the Governing Board at Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary and as a member of the Board for inisterial Education. He is married with four children.
WELS also promotes it here:
http://staffministry.net/resources.php?c=7
---
dk has left a new comment on your post "Write A Letter":
I agree that errors in doctrine and practice need to be dealt with swiftly. But I've heard that within the WELS structure it is very difficult to deal with problems swiftly and this leads me to ask:
If the WELS CAN'T take care of problems immediately does it have the right to exist, under its own self-definition? According to the WELS, Synod=Church, correct? We all know that the legitimacy of a church depends on its doctrinal integrity. Maintaining doctrinal integrity means dealing with problems quickly so they don't spread. So if the WELS is 1 church, as they claim, how legitimate are they?
SP Schroeder has a big job, partly because of the WELS structure and partly because these problems have been festering for two decades or more.
The office of WELS synod president is not a dictator--no
WELS synod president has the executive authority to make changes (termination of calls etc.) instantly and based on his judgment alone. There's a well ordered system in place for the purpose of preventing quick changes. One must recognize that this ties the hands of Triglotta Lutherans when error does arise in attempts to guard against liberals who might hold the same office.
SP Schroeder is no exception. I'm under the impression that he has to play "the game" because of the limitation on his authority. While it's a shame that he's hampered, I'd rather have a Conservative as SP than someone like Kelm. God uses faithful men for his purposes in whatever situation they find themselves. I imagine Schroeder has a full plate and he can use our prayers--wishing him swiftness.
Remember though, that if you're WELS you ARE in close fellowship with Ski, Glende, Jeske, Kelm, Hunter, Gunn, and all the rest. YOU belong to the same church and by your testimony you are one in faith with them! At what point should you contest the legitimacy of the WELS based on an absence of church discipline?
Sooner or later something has to happen and people will have to be held accountable.
My new years resolution is to write the District Presidents who have errant pastors under them. CC your emails to president Schroeder so that Schroeder has more to refer to when he talks to the DPs about the problems. I'll just bet that by respectful protest (a flood of emails) the Triglotta Lutherans could really aid in the process of church discipline!
---
rlschultz has left a new comment on your post "This May Explain Why WELS Has So Many Big Building...":
Freddy,
Thank you for sharing your experience with a building program. I have a story also. Many of the details are different form your's. But the attitude is the same. As you have so aptly stated, this is a "build it and they will come" approach.
My story is from my former congregation, which I left about six months ago. They began their scheming about five to six years ago. They waited until the senior (in age) pastor first retired. Looking back now, I can see how they eased the members into the idea of expanding. A lot was done ahead of time to minimize resistance. The list includes steering committees, informational forums, and financial planning.
All of this sounds innocuous enough. We all understand the need for financial responsibility and stewardship. My observation to several members was, "we will get this expansion. But, what will we become?"
As all of this unfolded, I witnessed one of the most craftily planned series of manipulations with the members that was even more subtle than what most cults engage in.
The end result was to create a high profile congregation that was self serving. A nearby congregation closed their LES. The first wave of new members were those who transferred in from that congregation to allow their children to attend the school. The next bunch were those who were also transfers from close by.
The voters' meeting to approve the expansion was like an Oprah Winfrey show. Some long time members gave a tearful plea to claim that one soul was worth it. Next, was the appeal to the women, who allegedly had no voice.
Once approved, the antics really proliferated. Part of the plan was to get members as stakeholders. The number of committees increased. All along, the use of financial commitments was bandied about. There was the constant positive feedback from new members which was printed in the monthly newsletter. Those members who grumbled, mostly did so under their breath.
The final straw for me was when they hired Cornerstone Stewardship Ministries, on a commission basis, to ratchet up the appeals. I contacted the Council President to express my misgivings about Jeff Davis and his connections to Church and Chicanery.
I spent two hours telling my concerns to one of the pastors before I left. I found very few members who were willing to listen. I did not attack anyone or cause any type of a scene in public. I am glad that I did not waste much time and energy fighting all of this. Those who continue to grumble, still murmur under their breath.
When you do not believe in the Efficacy of the Word, you think that building a Tower of Babel will increase your numbers. If all you care about is increasing your numbers, you will use methods to achieve that end. This will come at the expense of serving your members with proper pastoral care.
I read about this type of scenario happen many times. When it happened at a congregation where I spent most of my adult life, I was horrified. I refused to play any of their games. That was the best way to resist it, in my situation.
An informed and discerning laity, strengthened by the Means of Grace, is a powerful tool against all forms of Enthusiasm. We must remember to always be thankful for the Word of God, which is sharper and more powerful than any two-edged. That is our only weapon.