Saturday, May 21, 2011

How To Find Some UOJ Stuff Here



Randall van der Sterren has left a new comment on your post "Ichabod Averages 1500 Page-reads Per Day":

Where can I find primary sources defining and defending UOJ?

In other words, where can I find theologians, scholars and other credentialed people reading Lutheranism to say all men are justified?

***

GJ - Start in the left-hand column. There are many UOJ essays published verbatim, with a collection of the worst sayings. Everything is document. Try to find the equivalent anywhere else.

Ichabod Averages 1500 Page-reads Per Day

Roman Catholic priest, Lutheran pastor, Anabaptist professor - good preparation for WELS work.


It's all about the numbers. People are reading 1500 pages of Ichabod each and every day, year around.

The cost is zero. No ads. A number of people regularly participate in our traditional Lutheran worship services, in: Arkansas, Michigan, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Ohio, and Washington.

I started this to express my outrage over the destruction of the Lutheran Church by its elected and appointed leaders. Nothing has improved, but the laity are alerted about the facts and the clergy are encouraged, knowing they are not alone.

One layman kept asking me about people who publish anonymously or send me information. I usually do not know who they are, but when I do, no one is identified unless that individual has given me explicit written permission.

I do not control the discussions. More than 99% of the comments come through. There are reasons to stop some, but not because I disagree. I would like all the adulterous Shrinkers to post anonymously and defend what they do. That would be far more edifying than attacking me. Precious few even try to do so.

I have heard many positive reports from readers. The efficacious Word does bear fruit, always far more than we can imagine or plan. If only a few take an interest in the Scriptures and Confessions, I am satisfied.

Gerberding - The Preached Word as an Instrument of Grace


"To the Lutheran the sermon, as the preached Word, is a Means of Grace. Through it the Holy Spirit calls, gathers, enlightens, and sanctifies the whole Christian church on earth. It is a constant offer of pardon; a giving of life, as well as a nourishing and strengthening of life. In the Reformed churches the sermon is apt to be more hortatory and ethical. It partakes more of the sacrificial than of the sacramental character. The individuality of the preacher, the subjective choice of a text, the using of it merely for a motto, the discussion of secular subjects, the unrestrained platform style, lack of reverence, lack of dignity, and many other faults are common, and are not regarded as unbecoming the messenger of God in His temple. Where there is a properly trained Lutheran consciousness such things repel, shock, and are not tolerated."
G. H. Gerberding, The Lutheran Pastor, Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1915, p. 278.

The pulpit shown is from the congregation of Pastor John Bachman, Charleston, South Carolina. He served there 56 years.

Although Herman Melville was a free-thinker, his statement about the pulpit is far more impressive than what we hear from putative Lutherans who feel a need to entertain, titillate, and caffeinate their audiences.

Chapter 8 - The Pulpit by Herman Melville, from Moby Dick
I had not been seated very long ere a man of a certain venerable robustness entered; immediately as the storm-pelted door flew back upon admitting him, a quick regardful eyeing of him by all the congregation, sufficiently attested that this fine old man was the chaplain. Yes, it was the famous Father Mapple, so called by the whalemen, among whom he was a very great favorite. He had been a sailor and a harpooneer in his youth, but for many years past had dedicated his life to the ministry. At the time I now write of, Father Mapple was in the hardy winter of a healthy old age; that sort of old age which seems merging into a second flowering youth, for among all the fissures of his wrinkles, there shone certain mild gleams of a newly developing bloom- the spring verdure peeping forth even beneath February's snow. No one having previously heard his history, could for the first time behold Father Mapple without the utmost interest, because there were certain engrafted clerical peculiarities about him, imputable to that adventurous maritime life he had led. When he entered I observed that he carried no umbrella, and certainly had not come in his carriage, for his tarpaulin hat ran down with melting sleet, and his great pilot cloth jacket seemed almost to drag him to the floor with the weight of the water it had absorbed. However, hat and coat and overshoes were one by one removed, and hung up in a little space in an adjacent corner; when, arrayed in a decent suit, he quietly approached the pulpit.

Like most old fashioned pulpits, it was a very lofty one, and since a regular stairs to such a height would, by its long angle with the floor, seriously contract the already small area of the chapel, the architect, it seemed, had acted upon the hint of Father Mapple, and finished the pulpit without a stairs, substituting a perpendicular side ladder, like those used in mounting a ship from a boat at sea. The wife of a whaling captain had provided the chapel with a handsome pair of red worsted man-ropes for this ladder, which, being itself nicely headed, and stained with a mahogany color, the whole contrivance, considering what manner of chapel it was, seemed by no means in bad taste. Halting for an instant at the foot of the ladder, and with both hands grasping the ornamental knobs of the man-ropes, Father Mapple cast a look upwards, and then with a truly sailor-like but still reverential dexterity, hand over hand, mounted the steps as if ascending the main-top of his vessel.

The perpendicular parts of this side ladder, as is usually the case with swinging ones, were of cloth-covered rope, only the rounds were of wood, so that at every step there was a joint. At my first glimpse of the pulpit, it had not escaped me that however convenient for a ship, these joints in the present instance seemed unnecessary. For I was not prepared to see Father Mapple after gaining the height, slowly turn round, and stooping over the pulpit, deliberately drag up the ladder step by step, till the whole was deposited within, leaving him impregnable in his little Quebec.

I pondered some time without fully comprehending the reason for this. Father Mapple enjoyed such a wide reputation for sincerity and sanctity, that I could not suspect him of courting notoriety by any mere tricks of the stage. No, thought I, there must be some sober reason for this thing; furthermore, it must symbolize something unseen. Can it be, then, that by that act of physical isolation, he signifies his spiritual withdrawal for the time, from all outward worldly ties and connexions? Yes, for replenished with the meat and wine of the word, to the faithful man of God, this pulpit, I see, is a self-containing stronghold- a lofty Ehrenbreitstein, with a perennial well of water within the walls.

But the side ladder was not the only strange feature of the place, borrowed from the chaplain's former sea-farings. Between the marble cenotaphs on either hand of the pulpit, the wall which formed its back was adorned with a large painting representing a gallant ship beating against a terrible storm off a lee coast of black rocks and snowy breakers. But high above the flying scud and dark-rolling clouds, there floated a little isle of sunlight, from which beamed forth an angel's face; and this bright face shed a distant spot of radiance upon the ship's tossed deck, something like that silver plate now inserted into Victory's plank where Nelson fell. "Ah, noble ship," the angel seemed to say, "beat on, beat on, thou noble ship, and bear a hardy helm; for lo! the sun is breaking through; the clouds are rolling off- serenest azure is at hand."

Nor was the pulpit itself without a trace of the same sea-taste that had achieved the ladder and the picture. Its panelled front was in the likeness of a ship's bluff bows, and the Holy Bible rested on a projecting piece of scroll work, fashioned after a ship's fiddle-headed beak.

What could be more full of meaning?- for the pulpit is ever this earth's foremost part; all the rest comes in its rear; the pulpit leads the world. From thence it is the storm of God's quick wrath is first descried, and the bow must bear the earliest brunt. From thence it is the God of breezes fair or foul is first invoked for favorable winds. Yes, the world's a ship on its passage out, and not a voyage complete; and the pulpit is its prow.

UOJ Stormtroopers on LQ (sic) Run Shamelessly Away


They act like Nazis, but fight like sissies - the UOJ sorority at LutherQuest (sic).


In the wee hours this morning, waiting anxiously for the end of the world, I looked up LutherQuest (sic), trying to find news about LSTC.

Timothy Blank (CLC - sic) opened a discussion on whether Robert Preus repudiated UOJ in his last book. No one touched the argument I made in two books, with copious citations. No one conceded that Preus made his point with a Calov quotation. I published that Calov quotation separately, in the doctrinal graphics.

I sent this link to several friends, so they could have a look:

http://www.lutherquest.org/cgi-bin/discus40/discus.cgi

I discussed their "arguments" here.

A few hours later, the link stopped working when I tried to find the thread. One justification by faith fan found it again. The site has poor navigation, which is appropriate for blind guides.

All the UOJ Stormtroopers weighed in: Stephanie Kurtzahn, Jay Webber, Tim Blank, Rolf Preus, et al.

They belong to four sects but agree on one thing - everyone is born forgiven, guilt-free.

I have published some doctrinal graphics based on Luther and the readings for the Fourth Sunday after Easter, John 16. They will read them over superficially and harden themselves against the Word.

My Tour of Dow Chemical:
This Connects with Publishing

Gratuitous kitteh photo


A chemist gave us a tour of the labs in Midland. We saw how they found the chemical composition of various puzzles. For instance, some expensive product from Dow failed, and they had to find out why. They ran it through tests and found that cockroaches got into the product at the buyer's factory, so that ruined the performance for some reason.

He condensed the tests (nuclear, gas chromatograph, mass spectometer) this way - "We get the substance excited and see how it responds. The response tells us what the chemical is." For example, when cockroach remains are bombarded, they always respond with certain frequencies, which are charted.

That is also how blogging works for me. I irritate various doctrinal positions and practices and look at the responses. The way people respond--LutherQuest, McCainery, Kilcrease/Brigadoon--reveals what they believe and teach.

Clearly, UOJ Stormtroopers cannot defend their position. Their ranting only serves to awaken the laity, who have been bamboozled by these lying frauds for decades.

The more we learn about UOJ, the worse the leaders look. For instance, there has been a deliberate and prolonged effort to replace justification by faith with UOJ, while pretending UOJ was always the Olde Syn Conference position. Published documents (catechisms) prove otherwise.

UOJ leaders provide terrible pastoral care because they do not know the Gospel and reject the Biblical meaning of the Means of Grace. Like the Pharisees, they make their disciples twice more fit for Hell. Some WELS examples are the hardening and blinding effects upon murderers Tabor and Just, sex-offenders like DP Ed Werner, and the whole staff at The Love Shack.

Missouri and the Little Sect have similar stories. The CLC (sic)? Don't get me started.

The sect they all pretend to loathe but secretly emulate and covet - is ELCA. They believe the same way, with the same results.

Mrs. Ichabod - On the End of the World


The world is supposed to end at 6 PM today, according to a self-promoting sectarian.

Last night, Mrs. Ichabod asked, "What if we wake up on Sunday?"

Today I was having a terrible time publishing on Blogger and also in sending Tweets. I said, "Blogger is really bogged down right now."

My wife said, "Well, it's the last day."

I am wiping the tears from my eyes - from laughing.

Luther - Believers and Unbelievers Distinguished:
Gospel Lesson for the Fourth Sunday after Easter


"Godly and believing persons know their sins; they bear all their punishment patiently, and are resigned to God's judgment without the least murmur; therefore, they are punished only bodily, and here in time, and their pain and suffering have an end. Unbelievers, however, since they are not conscious of their sins and transgressions, cannot bear God's punishment patiently, but they resent it and wish their life and works to go unpunished, yea, uncensured. Hence, their punishment and suffering are in body and soul, here in time, and last forever beyond this life." Sermons of Martin Luther, 8 vols., ed., John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983, III, p. 131. Fourth Sunday after Easter, Second Sermon John 16:5-15.

Luther - Faith Is So Strong and Overpowering:
Gospel Lesson for the Fouth Sunday after Easter

Norma Boeckler designed, decorated, photographed, and Photoshopped our altar at Bethany Lutheran Church.


"However, here the Lord speaks quite differently, and says: 'The Holy Spirit will convict the world in respect of sin, because they believe not on me.' Unbelief only is mentioned here as sin, and faith is praised as suppressing and extinguishing the other sins, even the sins in the saints. Faith is so strong and overpowering that no sin dare put it under any obligation. Although sins are present in pious and believing persons, they are not imputed to them, nor shall their sins condemn them."
Sermons of Martin Luther, 8 vols., ed., John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983, III, p. 127. Fourth Sunday after Easter, Second Sermon John 16:5-15.

Luther - Where Faith Is Wanting:
Fourth Sunday after Easter Gospel Lesson


"Therefore the Holy Spirit rightly and justly convicts, as sinful and condemned, all who have not faith in Christ. For where this is wanting, other sins in abundance must follow: God is despised and hated, and the entire first table is treated with disobedience."
Sermons of Martin Luther, 8 vols., ed., John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983, III, p. 141. Fourth Sunday after Easter, Third Sermon John 16:5-15.

Blind Guides Discuss Justification Without Faith -
Their Hobbyhorse at LutherQuest (sic)

Kurtzahn had major problems with pancakes on Shrove Tuesday, but no problem with Chinatown adultery/incest.



Click here for the thread. You have to look around for an older thread.
The usual blind guides, clowns, and illiterati get a chance to post brief thoughts without being responsible. One pastoral friend called LQ (sic) "a skunk patch." LI wondered if insanity or ignorance had the upper hand on the discussion board.

Timothy Blank opened up the discussion, and Joe Krohn weighed in to make a point.

LQ (sic) is a UOJ union shop. I think most of the contributors have macros, so they can post the same thing repeatedly. Below is an example of a shallow WELS response. Kurtzahn was WELS, CLC, and WELS again. David Menton said he would not remain in the same room with Kurtzahn, as a measure of his disgust with the man.

Kurtzahn:
I suppose by commenting on this my picture will be on Ichabod again...

Jackson basically holds to the old Ohio Synod position on justification. Lenski is his idol. That should tell you everything.

BTW, Jackson didn't really make an issue of justification while he was in the CLC.

***

GJ - Kurtzahn managed to be wrong in three out of three statements. He added another error later on a different topic, the CLC and self-love, making him four for four.

"Jackson basically holds to the old Ohio Synod position on justification."
I agree with St. Paul, Luther, and the Book of Concord about justification by faith. I also agree with Robert Preus' last book, Justification and Rome, which I quoted in Thy Strong Word and emphasized in Luther versus the UOJ Pietists: Justification by Faith.

I am not sure what he means by "the old Ohio Synod position on justification." That is a good example of making an unwarranted claim, with no evidence on either side. But that would require some intellectual effort and study.

"Lenski is his idol. That should tell you everything."
I have not provided any evidence for that claim - just the opposite. I fault Lenski for his monkeying around with the text, following that charlatan Tischendorf and the apostates Wescott and Hort.

I have pointed out more than once that Lenski tried hard to moderate toward the UOJ position. If Kurtzahn actually cracked open his Lenski, he would find passages that would titillate and excite him. In fact, Lenski could be used by the ruffians on LQ (sic) to make their case, if they ignore some of his basic conclusions.

But that is my problem. I read Lenski steadily and know his work fairly well. They do not, because in sneering about Lenski they excuse themselves for never studying the text. No one else has carefully examined and explained the entire text of the New Testament. Those who look down on Lenski only prove what fools they are. Timothy Blank is definitely one of those.

The theologians I admire the most are Luther, Melanchthon, Chemnitz, and Chytraeus. "Idol" is not a term I would use for any writer or leader.

BTW, Jackson didn't really make an issue of justification while he was in the CLC.

I was discussing the justification issue with various people when I was in the corrupt, immoral, legalistic CLC (sic). The topic had been raised in St. Louis, and people from various parts of Lutherdom communicated with me. Kurtzahn was too busy being a lapdog and weathervane to notice.

Kurtzahn error #4 - bonus. He denied there was any teaching of self-love in the CLC (sic). The conflict began with an article in a WELS periodical, arguing that "Love your neighbor as yourself" is a commandment to love ourselves. The Shrinker faction of the sect emulates WELS errors as much as possible, so they were promoting self-love. The convention discussed it. Old Paul Nolting got up and beat the drums for self-love, offering himself as an example.

The UOJ Problem
The Enthusiasts may buzz all day long, but they cannot change some simple facts:
  1. UOJ cannot be found in the Scriptures.
  2. Their position is identical to ELCA's and close to Universalism. The difference with the Universalists is that they are more honest.
  3. The Book of Concord teaches justification by faith, not UOJ. The same is true of Luther, Chemnitz, Melanchthon, Chytraeus, Gerhard, Calov, and Preus in his last book.
  4. Gausewitz, the favorite WELS catechism, had no UOJ in it. Kuske with UOJ replace Gausewitz. With that came Church Growth.
  5. The LCMS still sells a KJV catechism with no mention or teaching of UOJ.
  6. Few laity agree with UOJ because they know the Word of God and have not suffered from the brain-washing of the Lutheran seminaries.

Luther - Satan Is Angry That a Poor Fragile Vessel
Has the Word


"Thus also the devil is angry because God wants to trample him under foot by means of flesh and blood. If a mighty spirit were opposed to him, he would not be so sorely vexed; but it greatly angers him that a poor worm of the dust, a fragile earthen vessel defies him, a weak vessel against a mighty prince. God has placed his treasure, says St. Paul, in a poor, weak vessel; for man is weak, easily aroused to anger, avaricious, arrogant, and weighed down with other imperfections, through which Satan easily shatters the earthen vessel; for if God would permit him, he would soon have utterly destroyed the whole vessel." 
Sermons of Martin Luther, 8 vols., ed., John Nicholaus Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983, V, p. 268. Twenty-first Sunday after Trinity, John 4:46-54; 1 Peter 5:8; Ephesians 6:12.