Monday, January 19, 2009

WELS To Fall Back on Lutheran Doctrine -
A Welcome Change for that Church




From WELS Together:

COP addresses important issues

From the office of President Mark Schroeder

The Conference of Presidents (COP) held its quarterly face-to-face meeting last week. Here's a recap of the most important matters discussed.


Doctrine and practice
One of the most important roles of the COP is to oversee doctrine (what we believe and teach) and practice (what we do in applying our beliefs). When it met, the COP had a lengthy discussion about the importance of retaining our unity in both areas.

Some congregations, in a desire to reach as many people as possible with the gospel, have been considering some new and different approaches and methods, especially in the areas of worship and outreach. Cautions and concerns have been voiced about some of these trends. Expressing the commitment to maintain our synod's faithfulness to the Scriptures and the Lutheran Confessions, the COP concluded that "the underpinnings of 'non-traditional' type of worship cannot be ignored" and that we need to be careful to "walk the 'narrow Lutheran road' between legalism—and ignoring and failing to admonish where practices are contrary to or dangerous to the principles of gospel proclamation and the efficacy of the means of grace."

As a result of this concern, the COP resolved that "an ad hoc committee be convened in consultation with the [COP] doctrine committee that can . . . address this issue and produce a study document that can be shared with circuits and also congregations for study and careful evaluation of practices in worship, sacraments, outreach, organization, music selection, etc."

Convention essays
The theme of the 2009 synod convention will be "Christ's Love, Our Calling." The COP directed that two essays be presented to the convention expanding on this theme. The first essay dealing with Christ's love will focus on the efficacy of the means of grace, in which God conveys his grace to us through Word and sacrament. The second essay, dealing with our calling, will have an emphasis on the many aspects of the Christian's calling, including a focus on the call to faith, the call to proclaim the gospel, the call into the public ministry, and the Christian's vocation. These essays, in keeping with the recommendations of the Ad Hoc Commission, will form the basis for two years of synodwide Bible studies in circuits, conferences, and congregations.

***

GJ - Hey convention essayist guys. You are welcome to hook a few hundred quotations from this blog or from http://www.gljackson.com/books.htm to get links without the pop-up ads.

Yes, I published about this topic in 1991. Wally Oelhafen, Fred Adrian, and Roger Kovaciny went ballistic at the pastors' conference when I gave the Cure chapter from Liberalism: Its Cause and Cure. And yes, there was a concerted effort to boot me from WELS the moment the book came out. For some reason, NPH kept delaying the printing. Backroom brawling? I think not. All the WELS pastors agree about doctrine - that is what John Seifert and John Lawrenz told me.

And I published more in Thy Strong Word, with hundreds and hundreds of quotations. That was 2000 or so. The reception was, shall we say, frigid. Once I had to help a CLC (sic) pastor give a paper on the Means of Grace. He did not learn anything about it at their plywood seminary, where each seminary class of one can graduate summa cum laude.

The WELS essays are significant in turning away from the icky and silly Reformed-Pentecostal themes of the past ("Going, Growing, Glowing").

The Biblical message of the Word alone being effective is long overdue.

WELS has the chance to invite its synodical conference partners back to sound doctrine.

WELS Conference of Pussycats,
Purrfect Harmony



WELS Mascot, Vente Latte


Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Quotations - The Holy Spirit":

This is from an update on the most recent meeting of the WELS COP. These sections fall under the heading "Doctrine Committee" and reads as follows:

5.D.03 Establishment of “non-traditional” (“new style”) congregations (P. 16)

We feel that the underpinnings of this “non-traditional” type of worship cannot be ignored.

We also feel that the issue is extremely complex and will take great care to be careful to walk the “narrow Lutheran road” between legalism and ignoring and failing to admonish where practices are contrary to or a danger to the principles of gospel proclamation and the efficacy of the means of grace.

We move that an ad hoc committee be convened that can study and address this issue and produce a study document that can be shared with circuits and also congregations for study and careful evaluation of practices in worship, sacraments, outreach, organization, music selection, etc. Motion carried.

[Here is a another section, under the same heading]:

5.D.05 C & C and outside speakers (P.14)

We recommend that our Synod President and District President(s) continue to work with the representatives of Church and Change to come to an understanding of our desire for them to withdraw their invitation to the speaker proposed for their next conference.

Some may see positive signs in this. I see only cowardice. I know cowardice well, because I'm too cowardly to use his name here. The COP are cowards like me. They growl and show their teeth to each other when they meet in private. They've had twenty years to condemn these sorts of things and here they are...talking about it...still. They will still be talking about 20 years from now, after their synod has been torn apart by these two issues. Half of it will become Baptist in both name and practice (they already are in practice). The other half will become non-denominational in both name and practice (they already are in practice).

After it happens, the COP will probably pass a resolution to discuss the possibility of maybe condemning them...if they feel like it...finally...some time in the future...maybe.

***

GJ - The comment above is precise and accurate. The Doctrinal Pussycats, Circuit Pussycats, and pastors all have role in shutting down the openly Babtist congregations in WELS. The laity are ignored. If any layman questions the obvious doctrinal errors, he is summarily dropped from any committee work. Discerning pastors face varying degrees of Mennonite-style shunning.

The synod of "you must talk to me privately about my published false doctrine" has a special way of dealing with faithful Lutheran pastors. I have watched many pastors pushed out of their congregations and out of the ministry for one reason only - questioning the Church and Change ideology of false doctrine and cheesy worship.

One was excommunicated by Bruce Becker for teaching the Biblical doctrinal of the efficacy of the Word. The Easy Lutheran Sect (no surprise) upheld the excommunication. The pastor was allowed to worship at an ELS church (such grace, such benevolence) but not allowed to commune. And the ELS has long been known for open communion. There is Open Communion and open communion, I suppose.

The laity and pastors have a chance to reverse the trend. There are some good signs that this is happening. Relying on the Doctrinal Pussycats is not a solution. They are a problem, not a solution.

I have some staggering statistics on grantsmanship coming up. They make the previously published one look like coffee hour donations, to spin a phrase.

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Gerhardt: If God Himself Be For Me, I May a Host Defy (Ist Gott fuer Mich)




"If God Himself Be for Me"
by Paul Gerhardt, 1607-1676

1. If God Himself be for me,
I may a host defy;
For when I pray, before me
My foes, confounded, fly.
If Christ, my Head and Master,
Befriend me from above,
What foe or what disaster
Can drive me from His love?

2. This I believe, yea, rather,
Of this I make my boast,
That God is my dear Father,
The Friend who loves me most,
And that, whate'er betide me,
My Savior is at hand
Through stormy seas to guide me
And bring me safe to land.

3. I build on this foundation,
That Jesus and His blood
Alone are my salvation,
The true, eternal good.
Without Him all that pleases
Is valueless on earth;
The gifts I owe to Jesus
Alone my love are worth.

4. My Jesus is my Splendor,
My Sun, my Light, alone;
Were He not my Defender
Before God's awe-full throne,
I never should find favor
And mercy in His sight,
But be destroyed forever
As darkness by the light.

5. He canceled my offenses,
Delivered me from death;
He is the Lord who cleanses
My soul from sin through faith.
In Him I can be cheerful,
Bold, and undaunted aye;
In Him I am not fearful
Of God's great Judgment Day.

6. Naught, naught, can now condemn me
Nor set my hope aside;
Now hell no more can claim me,
Its fury I deride.
No sentence e'er reproves me,
No ill destroys my peace;
For Christ, my Savior, loves me
And shields me with His grace.

7. His Spirit in me dwelleth,
And o'er my mind He reigns.
All sorrow He dispelleth
And soothes away all pains.
He crowns His work with blessing
And helpeth me to cry,
"My Father!" without ceasing,
To Him who dwells on high.

8. And when my soul is lying
Weak, trembling, and opprest,
He pleads with groans and sighing
That cannot be exprest;
But God's quick eye discerns them,
Although they give no sound,
And into language turns them
E'en in the heart's deep ground.

9. To mine His Spirit speaketh
Sweet word of holy cheer,
How God to him that seeketh
For rest is always near
And how He hath erected
A city fair and new,
Where what our faith expected
We evermore shall view.

10. In yonder home doth flourish
My heritage, my lot;
Though here I die and perish,
My heaven shall fail me not.
Though care my life oft saddens
And causeth tears to flow,
The light of Jesus gladdens
And sweetens every woe.

11. Who clings with resolution
To Him whom Satan hates
Must look for persecution;
For him the burden waits
Of mockery, shame, and losses,
Heaped on his blameless head;
A thousand plagues and crosses
Will be his daily bread.

12. From me this is not hidden,
Yet I am not afraid;
I leave my cares, as bidden,
To whom my vows were paid.
Though life and limb it cost me
And everything I won,
Unshaken shall I trust Thee
And cleave to Thee alone.

13. Though earth be rent asunder,
Thou'rt mine eternally;
Not fire nor sword nor thunder
Shall sever me from Thee;
Not hunger, thirst, nor danger,
Not pain nor poverty
Nor mighty princes' anger
Shall ever hinder me.

14. No angel and no gladness,
No throne, no pomp, no show,
No love, no hate, no sadness,
No pain, no depth of woe,
No scheme of man's contrivance,
However small or great,
Shall draw me from Thy guidance
Nor from Thee separate.

15. My heart for joy is springing
And can no more be sad,
'Tis full of mirth and singing,
Sees naught but sunshine glad.
The Sun that cheers my spirit
Is Jesus Christ, my King;
That which I shall inherit
Makes me rejoice and sing.

Hymn #528
The Lutheran Hymnal
Text: Rom. 8:31-39
Author: Paul Gerhardt
Translated by: based on Richard Massie, 1857
Titled: Ist Gott fuer mich, so trete
Composer: Melckior Teschner, 1613
Tune: Valet will ich dir geben



1. Ist Gott für mich, so trete
Gleich alles wider mich,
Sooft ich ruf' und bete,
Weicht alles hinter sich.
Hab' ich das Haupt zum Freunde
Und bin geliebt bei Gott,
Was kann mir tun der Feinde
Und Widersacher Rott'?
2. Nun weiß und glaub' ich feste,
Ich rühm's auch ohne Scheu,
Daß Gott der Höchst' und Beste,
Mein Freund und Vater sei,
Und daß in allen Fällen
Er mir zur Rechten steh'
Und dämpfe Sturm und Wellen
Und was mir bringet Weh.

3. Der Grund, da ich mich gründe,
Ist Christus und sein Blut,
Das machet, daß ich finde
Das ew'ge wahre Gut.
An mir und meinem Leben
Ist nichts auf dieser Erd';
Was Christus mir gegeben,
Das ist der Liebe wert.

4. Mein Jesus ist mein' Ehre,
Mein Glanz und helles Licht.
Wenn der nicht in mir wäre,
So dürft' und könnt' ich nicht
Vor Gottes Augen stehen
Und vor dem strengen Sitz;
Ich müßte stracks vergehen
Wie Wachs in Feuershitz'.

5. Mein Jesus hat gelöschet,
Was mit sich führt den Tod;
Der ist's, der mich rein wäschet,
Macht schneeweiß, was ist rot.
In ihm kann ich mich freuen,
Hab' einen Heldenmut,
Darf kein Gerichte scheuen,
Wie sonst ein Sünder tut.

6. Nichts, nichts kann mich verdammen.
Nichts nimmet mir mein Herz!
Die Höll' und ihre Flammen,
Die sind mir nur ein Scherz.
Kein Urteil mich erschrecket,
Kein Unheil mich betrübt,
Weil mich mit Flügeln decket
Mein Heiland, der mich liebt.

7. Sein Geist wohnt mir im Herzen,
Regieret meinen Sinn,
Vertreibt mir Sorg' und Schmerzen,
Nimmt allen Kummer hin,
Gibt Segen und Gedeihen
Dem, was er in mir schafft,
Hilft mir das Abba schreien,
Aus aller meiner Kraft.

8. Und wenn an meinem Orte
Sich Furcht und Schwachheit find't,
So seufzt und spricht er Worte,
Die unausprechlich sind
Mir zwar und meinem Munde,
Gott aber wohl bewußt,
Der an des Herzens Grunde
Ersiehet seine Lust.
9. Sein Geist spricht meinem Geiste
Manch süßes Trostwort zu,
Wie Gott dem Hilfe leiste,
Der bei ihm suchet Ruh',
Und wie er hab' erbauet
Ein' edle, neue Stadt,
Da Aug' und Herze schauet,
Was er geglaubet hat.

10. Da ist mein Teil, mein Erbe
Mir prächtig zugericht't;
Wenn ich gleich fall' und sterbe,
Fällt doch mein Himmel nicht.
Muß ich auch gleich hier feuchten
Mit Tränen meine Zeit,
Mein Jesus und sein Leuchten
Durch süßet alles Leid.

11. Wer sich mit dem verbindet,
Den Satan fleucht und haßt,
Der wird verfolgt und findet
Ein' harte, schwere Last
Zu leiden und zu tragen,
Gerät in Hohn und Spott,
Das Kreuz und alle Plagen,
Die sind sein täglich Brot.

12. Das ist mir nicht verborgen,
Doch bin ich unverzagt.
Dich will ich laßen sorgen,
Dem ich mich zugesagt,
Es koste Leib und Leben
Und alles, was ich hab';
An dir will ich fest kleben
Und nimmer laßen ab.

13. Die Welt, die mag zerbrechen,
Du stehst mir ewiglich,
Kein Brennen, Hauen, Stechen
Soll trennen mich und dich,
Kein Hungern und kein Dürsten,
Kein' Armut, keine Pein,
Kein Zorn der großen Fürsten
Soll mir ein' Hindrung sein.

14. Kein Engel, keine Freuden,
Kein Thron, kein' Herrlichkeit,
Kein Lieben und kein Leiden,
Kein' Angst und Herzeleid,
Was man nur kann erdenken,
Es sei klein oder groß,
Der keines soll mich lenken
Aus deinem Arm und Schoß.

15. Mein Herze geht in Sprüngen
Und kann nicht traurig sein,
Ist voller Freud' und Singen,
Sieht lauter Sonnenschein.
Die Sonne, die mir lachet,
Ist mein Herr Jesus Christ;
Das, was mich singen machet,
Ist, was im Himmel ist.

---

GJ - Thank you, Norman Teigen, for finding this great hymn and posting it.

The College of Cardinals, Backed by a Pope




The Arizona Cardinals shocked everyone at the University of Phoenix Stadium by defeating the Eagles. Leonard Pope played an important role in the victory.

The Second Sunday after Epiphany



Adam and Eve sinned, but heard the First Gospel, Genesis 3:15 -
NKJ Genesis 3:15 And I will put enmity Between you and the woman,
And between your seed and her Seed;
He shall bruise your head, And you shall bruise His heel."


The Second Sunday after the Epiphany

Pastor Gregory L. Jackson

http://www.ustream.tv/channel/bethany-lutheran-worship

Bethany Lutheran Worship, 8 AM Phoenix Time

The Second Sunday after the Epiphany

Pastor Gregory L. Jackson

http://www.ustream.tv/channel/bethany-lutheran-worship

Bethany Lutheran Worship, 8 AM Phoenix Time

The Hymn #387 by Luther vss. 1-5 Nun freut euch
The Confession of Sins
The Absolution
The Introit p. 16
The Gloria Patri
The Kyrie p. 17
The Gloria in Excelsis
The Salutation and Collect p. 19
The Epistle and Gradual Romans 12:6-16
The Gospel John 2:1-12
Glory be to Thee, O Lord!
Praise be to Thee, O Christ!
The Nicene Creed p. 22
The Sermon Hymn # 387 by Luther vss. 6-10 Nun freut euch

Justifying Faith

The Hymn #370 Magdalen
The Preface p. 24
The Sanctus p. 26
The Lord's Prayer p. 27
The Words of Institution
The Agnus Dei p. 28
The Nunc Dimittis p. 29
The Benediction p. 31
The Hymn #309 Old Hundreth


KJV Romans 12:6 Having then gifts differing according to the grace that is given to us, whether prophecy, let us prophesy according to the proportion of faith; 7 Or ministry, let us wait on our ministering: or he that teacheth, on teaching; 8 Or he that exhorteth, on exhortation: he that giveth, let him do it with simplicity; he that ruleth, with diligence; he that sheweth mercy, with cheerfulness. 9 Let love be without dissimulation. Abhor that which is evil; cleave to that which is good. 10 Be kindly affectioned one to another with brotherly love; in honour preferring one another; 11 Not slothful in business; fervent in spirit; serving the Lord; 12 Rejoicing in hope; patient in tribulation; continuing instant in prayer; 13 Distributing to the necessity of saints; given to hospitality. 14 Bless them which persecute you: bless, and curse not. 15 Rejoice with them that do rejoice, and weep with them that weep. 16 Be of the same mind one toward another. Mind not high things, but condescend to men of low estate. Be not wise in your own conceits.

KJV John 2:1 And the third day there was a marriage in Cana of Galilee; and the mother of Jesus was there: 2 And both Jesus was called, and his disciples, to the marriage. 3 And when they wanted wine, the mother of Jesus saith unto him, They have no wine. 4 Jesus saith unto her, Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come. 5 His mother saith unto the servants, Whatsoever he saith unto you, do it. 6 And there were set there six waterpots of stone, after the manner of the purifying of the Jews, containing two or three firkins apiece. 7 Jesus saith unto them, Fill the waterpots with water. And they filled them up to the brim. 8 And he saith unto them, Draw out now, and bear unto the governor of the feast. And they bare it. 9 When the ruler of the feast had tasted the water that was made wine, and knew not whence it was: (but the servants which drew the water knew;) the governor of the feast called the bridegroom, 10 And saith unto him, Every man at the beginning doth set forth good wine; and when men have well drunk, then that which is worse: but thou hast kept the good wine until now. 11 This beginning of miracles did Jesus in Cana of Galilee, and manifested forth his glory; and his disciples believed on him.

Second Sunday After Epiphany
Lord God, heavenly Father, we thank Thee, that of Thy grace Thou hast instituted holy matrimony, in which Thou keepest us from unchastity, and other offenses: We beseech Thee to send Thy blessing upon every husband and wife, that they may not provoke each other to anger and strife, but live peaceably together in love and godliness, receive Thy gracious help in all temptations, and rear their children in accordance with Thy will; grant unto us all to walk before Thee, in purity and holiness, to put all our trust in Thee, and lead such lives on earth, that in the world to come we may have everlasting life, through the same, Thy beloved Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, who liveth and reigneth with Thee and the Holy Ghost, one true God, world without end. Amen.

JUSTIFYING FAITH


John’s Gospel should be memorized, as much as possible, by all Christians. The Fourth Gospel has the most apostolic authority (known as the disciple John’s from the beginning) and the most passages about the meaning of Christ and His relationship with the Father and the Holy Spirit. I have been reading The Jewish Trinity by Joel Natan, so John’s emphasis on the Old Testament is especially interesting in these Trinitarian discourses.

John’s Gospel sorts out some historical questions which people have. For instance, John reveals a three-year public ministry of Christ.

Two other instances are the early cleansing of the Temple and water turned into wine. The Temple cleansing taking place early explains the opposition of the Jewish leaders from the start. The miracle at Cana explains how Jesus had a following from the beginning, even if many were only miracle-believers.

I mention these matters because the four Gospels weave together a complete portrait of Christ, one that is astonishing in its harmony.

In this Gospel we have a miracle that is so remarkable that it made the divinity of Christ apparent to everyone. People have always claimed to have the power to heal others. We often hear the claim today. Some fakes use animal parts and pretend to pull them out of their patients through “psychic surgery.” Pentecostal healers carefully select those whose ailments can improve temporarily with a shift in mood. Arthritis and hearing problems are quite variable, so an instant cure seems impressive. One fake name Popof was exposed for using a radio setup with his wife. She sent him messages in his earphone about personal information on the cards of members in the audience. So Rev. Popof could miraculously tell someone that her sister was ill, or that she had a son named Bob. Once he proved his powers, thanks to radio, Popof could fool them about anything. As I said, Popof was exposed a few years ago, disgraced, and now he is back again on television. Televangelists are an inspiration to any politician in trouble.

But with this miracle the claim is very clear. The people knew they were out of wine. The servants knew they were dealing with water. They filled the water pots with water. If they had poured in wine by mistake or through cunning, the aroma would have given them away. The texture of wine is also quite different. I doubt whether the whitest wine could pass for water, especially in a culture where wine was a daily staple.

But, at the Word of Jesus, the water became wine. No one asked for a miracle or looked for a miracle, except Mary. Mary knew her Son had the ability to solve the problem. Most mothers think so, but in this text we can see that she is asking for something beyond His immediate desire to fulfill. His response is at least a mild rebuke.

Here the translators often think they are wiser than the Holy Spirit. They do not like Jesus calling His mother woman, so they add words, such as “Dear woman.”

NIV John 2:4 "Dear woman, why do you involve me?" Jesus replied. "My time has not yet come.

Twice when Jesus addressed His mother directly in the Gospel of John, He called her woman instead of “mother.” This shows us that He was her Lord and not just a son. It also shows how the Church of Rome has distorted the relationship between Mary and the Son of God. One papal announcement in my database even claims that Mary offered up her Son at the crucifixion, in a priestly fashion, making her a Co-Redeemer. The term Co-Redemptrix

[Pope Pius XI used the title Co-Redemptrix in the encyclical, Miserentissimus Redemptor, 1928. As Pius X put it, Mary merits for us de congruo what Christ merited for us de condigno. Ad Diem said that Mary is the "aquaduct" as Bernard taught, "or even the neck by which the Body is joined to the Head, and by which the Head communicates force and power to the Body." [p. 96]
Paul F. Palmer, S.J., Mary in the Documents of the Church, Gerald G. Walsh, S.J., Westminster, Maryland: The Newman Press 1952, p. 97.

"The authors of the Marian chapter purposely avoid the use of the term 'co-redemptrix,' for while it admits of a correct interpretation, it is also susceptible of grave misunderstanding. They also tread lightly on such controversial ground as the famous promise of the proto-gospel (Genesis 3:15) that Adam's seed shall bruise the serpent's head, because of an erroneous translation in the Vulgate ("she shall bruise your head," instead of it--that is, the seed, referring either to man in general or to the Messiah.) The Constitution Ineffabilis Deus of 1854 defining the Immaculate Conception had still taken this as a proof passage referring to Mary's own victory over the serpent."
Titus Cranny, S.A., Is Mary Relevant, A Commentary on Chapter 9 of Lumen Gentium, The Constitution on the Church from Vatican II, New York: Exposition Press 1970, p. 35.

The proper role of Mary is seen in the Scriptures as the mother of Jesus who raised Him in faith. She was a mortal woman, a sinner who died in the same way all must die. She did not fully understand her Son, as shown in the incident in the Temple, but she believed in Him and had a major role in the apostolic church. She is named early in Acts and then never again. (We should marvel that the apostles did not make a cult out of Mary then, for she was there at the beginning and had many years of memories of Him. So we see that the apostles resisted the urge to concentrate on Mary. Instead they preached the Gospel of Christ.)

This miracle raises the issue of justifying faith.

11 This beginning of miracles did Jesus in Cana of Galilee, and manifested forth his glory; and his disciples believed on him.

When we speak about faith, the word faith can have many meanings.

For instance, everyone has faith or trust in something. The atheist Carl Sagen did not believe in God, but he believed in extra-terrestrials. He needed to. Anyone who insists on evolution must have life on other planets, to show that life can generate itself spontaneously and without God.
The epistle of James speaks about dead faith. Lutherans should not be afraid of this letter or fail to study it. The Gospel always brings the fruit of the Spirit. If the fruit is lacking, then it points to a lack of faith. We see that in many church leaders who can speak the right words but keep themselves in power through lies, slander, and protecting false teachers. It is good to remember their faith and avoid falling into the same trap. As James says quite vividly, “The demons believe and their hides bristle.” That is not justifying faith. It is an awareness of the power of the Word: hating and fearing it.
Faith in miracles. Martin Chemnitz writes about this in his Loci, and it should make us think. Many hundreds if not thousands saw the miracles of Jesus. Certainly this happened at the wedding feast, at the grave of Lazarus, and in many other instances. They believed it was a miracle but they did not necessarily follow Jesus or believe in Him as their Savior.
Historical faith. Many scholars and people on the perimeter of Christianity have faith in the basic facts about the Bible. They even believe in the historical truth of the Bible. But it never goes farther than that. Luther said in many ways that it does no good to say that Christ died for the sins of the world if we fail to say, “and for me.” Unless we say, Christ died for my sins, we only have historical faith.
Kohlerglaube. A collier’s faith is based upon an incident where a coal handler was asked he believed. “I believe what the church believes.” And what does the church believe? “The church believes what I believe.” In other words, it is just an attachment to the institution, without knowing much or believing. Although this can bring a whole family or ethnic group to church, it is easy for someone to hear the Word and reject it by saying, “This is the right place. All my friends and relatives are here.”

I am not listing all these variations to become a new scholastic but to show how many ways faith can be something other than justifying faith.

Chemnitz and the authors of the Book of Concord were anxious to show the Church of Rome the proper understanding of faith.

"But when we are speaking of the subject itself, it is certain that the doctrine of gracious reconciliation, of the remission of sins, of righteousness, salvation, and eternal life through faith for the sake of the Mediator is one and the same in the Old and in the New Testament. This is a useful rule which we must retain at all costs: The doctrine, wherever we read it, in either the Old or New Testament, which deals with the gracious reconciliation and the remission of sins through faith for the sake of God's mercy in Christ, is the Gospel."
Martin Chemnitz, Loci Theologici, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1989, II, p. 459.

This is beautifully expressed by Melanchthon, the primary author of the Augsburg Confession:

"Thus when we say that we are justified by faith, we are saying nothing else than that for the sake of the Son of God we receive remission of sins and are accounted as righteous. And because it is necessary that this benefit be taken hold of, this is said to be done 'by faith,' that is, by trust in the mercy promised us for the sake of Christ. Thus we must also understand the correlative expression, 'We are righteous by faith,' that is, through the mercy of God for the sake of His Son we are righteous or accepted."
Melanchthon, Loci Communes, “The Word Faith.” Cited in Martin Chemnitz, Loci Theologici, II, p. p. 489.

I doubt whether the authors of the Book of Concord ever imagined that any Lutheran would speak of righteousness apart from faith, apart from the Word, apart from the Means of Grace. But sadly, that is common now and blabbered about as if it were true.

This miracle also shows how Jesus honored the institution of marriage. His decision to appear at the marriage is very significant, especially since He was there with His disciples. Outside influence made the Medieval Church despise marriage and force non-marriage (but not celibacy) on its priests, monks, and nuns. Worst of all, the Medieval Church portrayed a non-married priest as spiritually above a married man, no matter what kind of priest he was.

Marriage is the institution created by God through the Word (Genesis). This natural law concept is so powerful that the entire world honors it, one way or another. Even the Marxists register people as man and wife, apart from any official acknowledgement of God. They realize marriage is a major building block of society.

Luther’s point about this miracle is that marriage, through faith in God, is like water turned into wine. God honors what the world despises. The unbelieving world says, “You must be happy at all times or you have permission to split.” God says, “Whatever is done in faith honors Me.” So marriage offers children an ideal school for learning about the Christian faith, relationships, forgiveness, and love.

Luther has a funny comment about Adam and Eve being married hundreds of years. “You ate the apple,” countered by “You gave it to me.”

I have around 120 students studying communication at the same time, online. One issue is about the difference between men and women in the way they relate to each other. One woman offered a list of rules, but I countered with this concept – One has to start with forgiveness based on faith in Christ, because we are all weak, fallible sinners. What we do is significant, but the foundation is what we believe and applying the Gospel to our lives.

Where justification by faith flourishes, people enjoy the fruits of the Spirit. Everyone flourishes because God’s plan is to give us life in abundance, that our joy may be complete.

Quotations - The Holy Spirit




"The purest and best part of the human race, the special nursery and flower of God's Church, is tender youth. Youth retains the gift of the Holy Spirit which it received in Baptism; it learns eagerly the true doctrine about God and our Redeemer, Jesus Christ; it calls Him God with a chaste mind and with a simple, pure faith; it thanks Him with a quick and joyful heart for the blessings received from Him; in its studies and the other parts of life, it carries out the duties commanded it; and it obeys God and parents reverently. Particularly God-pleasing, therefore, are the studies of one's earliest age: prayer, obedience and praises which honor God, regardless of how weak and stammering its voice may be."
David Chytraeus, A Summary of the Christian Faith (1568), trans., Richard Dinda, Decatur: Repristination Press, 1994. p. 9.



"Emphatically does Scripture state that the action of the Spirit covers the whole life from first to the last. He is the Spirit of Life for regeneration (John 3:5, 8): the Spirit of Sonship for adoption (Romans 8:15): the Spirit of holiness for sanctification (Romans 8:5): the Spirit of Glory for transfiguration (2 Corinthians 3:18); the Spirit of Promise for the resurrection (Ephesians 1:13). Only through the Holy Spirit are men drawn to the Author and Finisher of their salvation." Arthur H. Drevlow, "God the HS Acts to Build the Church,"
God The Holy Spirit Acts, ed., Eugene P. Kaulfield, Milwaukee: Northwestern Publishing House, 1972, p. 15. John 3: 5,8; Romans 8:5; Romans 8:15; 2 Corinthians 3:18; Ephesians 1:13



"On the contrary, with the Anabaptists and the Reformed Church in general, the Mennonites are Enthusiasts, lay great stress on the immediate working of the Holy Ghost, who is said to 'guide the saints into all truth.' In his Geschichte der Mennonitengemeinden John Horsch, a prominent Mennonite, states that the Holy Spirit is the 'inner word,' who enables Christians to understand the Scriptures. Without the inner word, or the light, the Scripture is a dead letter and a dark lantern."
The. Engelder, W. Arndt, Th. Graebner, F. E. Mayer, Popular Symbolics, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1934, p. 260.



"It is God the Holy Ghost who must work this change in the soul. This He does through His own life-giving Word. It is the office of that Word, as the organ of the Holy Spirit, to bring about a knowledge of sin, to awaken sorrow and contrition, and to make the sinner hate and turn from his sin. That same Word then directs the sinner to Him who came to save him from sin. It takes him to the cross, it enables him to believe that his sins were all atoned for there, and that, therefore, he is not condemned. In other words, the Word of God awakens and constantly deepens true penitence. It also begets and constantly increases true faith. Or, in one word, it converts the sinner."
G. H. Gerberding, The Way of Salvation in the Lutheran Church, Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1887, p. 145f.



"It is indeed a precious truth, that this Word not only tells me what I must do to be saved, but it also enables me to do it. [enables me to do it in italics] It is the vehicle and instrument of the Holy Spirit. Through it the Holy Spirit works repentance and faith. Through it He regenerates, converts, and sanctifies."
G. H. Gerberding, The Way of Salvation in the Lutheran Church, Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1887, p. 132.



[The popular idea about the Word] "He sees that he must repent and believe, but by his own reason and strength he cannot. He learns further, that he needs the Holy Spirit to enable him to repent and believe, but, according to the current opinion, that Spirit is not in the Word, nor effective through it, but operates independently of it."
G. H. Gerberding, The Way of Salvation in the Lutheran Church, Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1887, p. 131.



"The same divine Saviour now works through means. He has founded a Church, ordained a ministry, and instituted the preaching of the Word and the administration of His own sacraments. Christ now works in and through His Church. Through her ministry, preaching the Word, and administering the sacraments, the Holy Spirit is given. (Augsburg Confession, Article 5.)
G. H. Gerberding, The Way of Salvation in the Lutheran Church, Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1887, p. 30.



"To the Lutheran the sermon, as the preached Word, is a means of grace. Through it the Holy Spirit calls, gathers, enlightens, and sanctifies the whole Christian church on earth. It is a constant offer of pardon; a giving of life, as well as a nourishing and strengthening of life. In the Reformed churches the sermon is apt to be more hortatory and ethical. It partakes more of the sacrificial than of the sacramental character. The individuality of the preacher, the subjective choice of a text, the using of it merely for a motto, the discussion of secular subjects, the unrestrained platform style, lack of reverence, lack of dignity, and many other faults are common, and are not regarded as unbecoming the messenger of God in His temple. Where there is a properly trained Lutheran consciousness such things repel, shock, and are not tolerated."
G. H. Gerberding, The Lutheran Pastor, Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1915, p. 278.



"Even though the water which is used for holy Baptism continues to retain its natural essence and natural attributes after Baptism, it is nevertheless not just lowly [plain] water, but it is formulated in God's Word and combined with God's Word. Thus it is a powerful means through which the Holy Trinity works powerfully; the Father takes on the one who is baptized as His dear child; the Son washes him of his sins with His blood; the Holy Spirit regenerates and renews him for everlasting life."
Johann Gerhard, A Comprehensive Explanation of Holy Baptism and the Lord's Supper, 1610, ed. D. Berger, J. Heiser, Malone, Texas: Repristination Press, 2000, p. 56.



"For just as we are born again through the Sacrament of holy Baptism, so also we are nurtured for eternal life through the Sacrament of this holy Supper. Just as we were taken into God's covenant of grace through the former Sacrament, so also through the latter Sacrament we are preserved in the very same covenant of grace. Just as the Holy Spirit awakens faith in us through the former, so also He strengthens and increases it through the latter. Just as circumcision typifies the former, so the Passover [paschal] lamb of the Old Testament typifies the latter."
Johann Gerhard, A Comprehensive Explanation of Holy Baptism and the Lord's Supper, 1610, ed. D. Berger, J. Heiser, Malone, Texas: Repristination Press, 2000, p. 209.



"The efficacy of the Bible is that property by which the Bible has indissolubly united [Romans 1:16; 1 Thessalonians 2:13] with the true and genuine sense [Ephesians 3:3-4; Acts 8:30, 31, 34] expressed in its words the power of the Holy Spirit, [Romans 1:16; 1 Thessalonians 1:5] who has made it for all times the ordinary means by which He operates [Psalm 19:8; Psalm 119:105, 130; 2 Peter 1:19; 2 Timothy 3:16, 17] on and in the hearts and minds of those who properly hear and read it [Revelation 1:3; Ephesians 3:3-4; John 7:17].
A. L. Graebner, Outlines of Doctrinal Theology, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1910, p. 12. Romans 1:16; 1 Thessalonians 2:13; Ephesians 3:3-4; Acts 8:30f; John 7:17.



"The New Testament is the inerrant record of the revelation of Jesus Christ in word and deed, and of the truths and principles proceeding, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, from that revelation. The Old Testament is in like manner an inerrant record, having the express and often repeated testimony and authority of Christ, of the preparatory and partial revelations made concerning Him before His coming. Hebrews 1:1."
Henry Eyster Jacobs, A Summary of the Christian Faith, Philadelphia: General Council Publication House, 1913, p. 3. Hebrews 1:1.



"What testimony is given to the presence of the Holy Spirit in and with the Word? The words of Scripture are repeatedly cited as the words of the Holy Spirit. Acts 1:16, 28:25; Hebrew 3:7; Psalm 10:15."
Henry Eyster Jacobs, A Summary of the Christian Faith, Philadelphia: General Council Publication House, 1913, p. 288f.



"Is it the office of the Word simply to afford directions that are to be followed in order to obtain salvation? It is more than a directory and guide to Christ. It does more than 'give directions how to live.' It brings and communicates the grace concerning which it instructs. It has an inherent and objective efficacy, derived from its divine institution and promise, and explained by the constant presence and activity of the Holy Spirit in and with it. Romans 1:16; John 6:63; 1 Peter 1:23; Matthew 4:4; Ephesians 6:17; Hebrews 4:12; Romans 10:5-10; Isaiah 55:10."
Henry Eyster Jacobs, A Summary of the Christian Faith, Philadelphia: General Council Publication House, 1913, p. 288.



"Thus the Holy Spirit works only through the Word. But the Word of the Gospel comes to man in two different modes."
Henry Eyster Jacobs, Elements of Religion, Philadelphia, Board of Publication, General Council 1919 p. 161.



(1) "He that believes and is baptized Shall see the Lord's salvation; Baptized into the death of Christ, He is a new creation. Through Christ's redemption he shall stand Among the glorious heavenly band Of every tribe and nation. (2) "With one accord, O God, we pray: Grant us Thy Holy Spirit; Look Thou on our infirmity Through Jesus' blood and merit. Grant us to grow in grace each day That by this Sacrament we may Eternal life inherit."
Thomas Kingo, 1689, "He That Believes and Is Baptized" The Lutheran Hymnal, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1941, Hymn #301. Mark 16:16.



"The Holy Spirit works through the Word and the Sacraments, which only, in the proper sense, are means of grace. Both the Word and the Sacraments bring a positive grace, which is offered to all who receive them outwardly, and which is actually imparted to all who have faith to embrace it."
Charles P. Krauth, The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology, Philadelphia: The United Lutheran Publication House, 1871, p. 127.



"This Word works in the Thessalonians what Paul states in 1:3; it came to them with the power of the Holy Spirit and much assurance (1:5); it turned them from the idols to the living God, to Him who raised up Jesus from the dead, the Savior from the wrath to ccome (1: 9, 10). This effect, wrought by the Word, convinces all believers, all who experience this blessed effect, that this is, indeed, God's Word."
R. C. H. Lenski, The Interpretation of Thessalonians, Columbus: The Wartburg Press, 1937, p. 261. 1 Thessalonians 2:13; 1 Thessalonians 1:5, 9, 10

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Welcome to Bailout-istan



The postal service is trying out a new, green,
cost-saving way to deliver mail.


Mark Steyn created the new word for America: Bailout-istan.

Herbert Hoover and FDR both used jobs programs, tax hikes, and government bailouts to end the Great Depression. Both presidents made everything worse through their foolish gestures.

Expect no better this time around.

Foundation Blues



Yesterday's great ideas are no longer so great.


Yale lost 25% of its endowment in 2008, through investment write-downs. Yale was famous for gaining 16% a year for 10 years, tripling the endowment. They did this through alternative investments, like real estate.

That worked well earlier, when real estate jumped and the stock market was flat. All the other big endowments followed Yale.

Every foundation or endowment spends from the total, so a significant loss means a reduction in funds for the future. Since the bi-partisan recession is universal and global, everyone is seeing the same losses.

So what happens with these illiquid (hard to sell) investments? When the funds are short and the bonds are not producing, they will have to sell stock. One expert predicted that some endowments could run out of cash in two years.

That means the foundation-dependent congregations are going to be howling for more funds, but the cash will be greatly reduced or gone.

Risen Savior, Milwaukee: Champeen in Grantmanship, Church and Change Leader



Risen Savior Evangelical Lutheran Church
Milwaukee, WI 53224


Media Transparency Profile

Total Grants to Risen Savior Evangelical Lutheran Church
Total $ Granted: $ 75,000
For Years: 2005 2004
# Grants: 3


Grants to Risen Savior Evangelical Lutheran Church


Date Amount Purpose Funder
7-10-2005 25,000 To support outreach ministries The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
8-10-2004 25,000 To support urban outreach ministries The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
4-13-2004 25,000 To support urban outreach ministries The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.

There are many more grants. The pastor teaches grantsmanship (note the new label) at Church and Change conferences.

THOSE SERVING GOD'S PEOPLE AT RISEN SAVIOR

Rev. Kenneth J. Fisher
Senior Pastor -- pastor@risensavior-luth.org

C and C: "105...... Grant Writing 101–Ken and Kim Fisher."

Prince of Peace, Florida: "Show Me the Money"





Prince of Peace Lutheran Church
Englewood, FL 34223


Media Transparency Profile

Total Grants to Prince of Peace Lutheran Church
Total $ Granted: $ 2,000
For Years: 2005 2004
# Grants: 2


Grants to Prince of Peace Lutheran Church
Click date for grant details.

Date Amount Purpose Funder
1-10-2005 1,000 To support general operations The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
4-20-2004 1,000 To support general operations The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.

St. Marcus and $400,000



And they still cannot spell.



St. Marcus - two grants totally $400,000.

St. Marcus Lutheran School
Milwaukee, WI 53212


Media Transparency Profile

Total Grants to St. Marcus Lutheran School
Total $ Granted: $ 400,000
For Years: 2003 2001
# Grants: 2


Grants to St. Marcus Lutheran School


Date Amount Purpose Funder
12-12-2003 50,000 To support various projects The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
12-13-2001 350,000 To support the capital campaign The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.

WELS - $320,000 in Grants - Community Development


Here is the link.

Total Grants to Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod
Total $ Granted: $ 320,000
For Years: 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001
# Grants: 8


Grants to Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod

Click date for grant details.

Date Amount Purpose Funder
9-20-2005 10,000 To support the Model ESL and First Language Literacy Training Programs The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
9-10-2004 10,000 To support the Model ESL and First Language Literacy Training Programs The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
9-10-2003 50,000 To support neighborhood development The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
4-11-2003 50,000 To support neighborhood development The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
9-10-2002 50,000 To support neighborhood development The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
4-10-2002 50,000 To support neighborhood development The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
9-10-2001 50,000 To support neighborhood development The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.
4-10-2001 50,000 To support neighborhood development The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Inc.

Friday, January 16, 2009

St. Andrews Latte Church versus Freddy Finkelstein



Standing too close to the espresso altar can cause problems
during a power surge.



Is this Luther's Theology of the Cross? I think not.


Freddy Finkelstein said...(Bailing Water comment)
“The approach being used at Waunakee is adiophora (sic).”

Adiaphora – the strawberry bubblegum of the Church Growth movement. They keep a wad in their mouth so that they are always ready to spit it out (yes, I've chewed this bubblegum too -- thank God it's finally lost its flavor). Adiaphora for them is nothing but Green Fields and Blue Sky as far as the eye can see, and everything so designated affords the claimant full creative license to dance in the daisies and chase butterflies, unfettered by pesky 500-year-old Confessional documents. Yes, there is freedom, but it is hardly unfettered. Indeed, if one cares to read the Confessions for oneself and take them seriously, it is apparent that our so-called adiaphora is bounded far more narrowly than the free-birds among us wish it to be known.

What is the proof offered that this congregation operates under the umbrella of Lutheran Confessionalism? Why, listen to the sermons, one is told – it's got Law and Gospel, therefore they're Biblical. Well, such advice misses the point – the entire issue has nothing whatsoever to do with preaching (at least not directly), it has to do with Practice.

So, what evidence is there that this congregation operates outside the umbrella of Lutheran Confessionalism? Look at their Confession and their Practice. What I stated on this blog a few months ago (here) applies in this case as we examine a congregation's practice: “But, while Krauth was addressing doctrine, are we not, in our case, looking at Lutheran practice? Yes and no. We are rightly concerned with practice as it is a reflection of what we Confess, and we see evidence of doctrinal error in the practice of the C&C crowd. When those who confess doctrinal unity with us engage in practice that is confusing or offensive, we have every right to demand of them an explanation, and they have every obligation to render one. Drawing the C&C or CG crowd into explanation of their practice, more and more, it seems, exposes their divergence from us and their disregard for anything more than rhetorical unity. So, while we take our queue from confusing and offensive practices endorsed by the C&C church-growthers, our concern is Confessional integrity.” If this congregation gives one indication in their sermons and confessional statements, and gives another in their Practice, they are guilty of offense. Their practice in this case strikes one as open sectarianism. Too bad the FIC “journalists” were too busy celebrating innovation that they didn't also notice that there might be an issue, and go to pains to give evidence to the contrary.

While it may be groovy jargon, “Keepin' it real” in the Divine Service means keeping it Confessional, means keeping the Marks central, means overt and prominent use of the Means of Grace and overt rejection of statistically derived man-made contrivances designed to coerce and manipulate people through clever use of Natural Law (contrivances held out to us by the heterodox in oh-so-many tempting ways), it means subjecting individuality to unity in confession and practice, and it means so much more that CG Church Changers apparently view as the irrelevant trappings of medieval Christianity. I am not impressed by Lutheran congregations so imbued with creativity and so-called “evangelical concern” that they can't seem to actually do “Church.”

The quote at the head of this blog reads, “Anything that isn’t unbiblical is fair game.” The glaring omission in this statement is reference to the Confessions. It should have read, “Anything that isn’t unbiblical, and isn't non-Confessional, is fair game.” Better yet, “The only fair game is that which is Biblical and Confessional.” Too many Pastors, it appears to me, think they are clever enough to recreate the Confessions directly from Scripture – so that whatever they derive directly from Scripture is automatically Confessional. It's becoming apparent to me now, that Rev. Berg was right when he stated on this blog many months ago: “Missouri, for all its problems, at least has a sizeable confessional movement. While Wisconsin has plenty of conservative pastors I could probably count the confessional pastors on two hands. Most of these men have been marginalized or are lying low.”

Freddy Finkelstein

WELS - Typical Church and Change Guys


Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Sound Advice from Freddy Finkelstein":

Typical Church and Change resentment when given reproof and correction. Unless they get the respect that they think they richly deserve they react with vindictiveness and nastiness.

***

GJ - Yes, there was an interesting event involving the Florida WELS experiment, which became a Roman Catholic parish. They actually built an attractive building, threw all kinds of money at it, and put their most unstable Church Growth pastors in it, all at once. Randy Catter and Mark Freier were involved; neither one is Lutheran now.

At a nearby parish someone made a chance remark during a church council meeting. It was mild and factually true. Well, he had to apologize. And he did. That was not enough. This went on forever. I received a stack of papers in the mail. Otherwise it would not be believable that grown men could wig out and stay wigged out for so long.

I have noticed that WELS DPs want a triple-scoop of apologies, too. I have never known that a DP apologized for wrecking parishes, for ruining the lives and families of pastors, for promoting known adulterers and false teachers.

Presidential Quotations





This link morphs the images. I haven't found the You Tube embed code.

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Deutschlander's New Book: The Theology of the Cross



The Theology of the Cross: Reflections on His Cross and Ours
by Daniel M. Deutschlander

Are you living under the theology of the cross or the theology of glory? This new book looks at Christian doctrine and reminds readers that all biblical doctrine relates to Scripture's central teaching that God sent his Son to save lost sinners. However, it also deals with the seeming paradox between the theology of the cross and the theology of glory. Sinful people tend to overlook the cross and its demands. As a result they take their eyes off Jesus and turn their attention to themselves. It is a rich study of a weighty theological issue and a worthy addition to a professional or personal library.
For further comment on this volume, from Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary Professor James Korthals, click HERE.

Paper cover, 292 pages
CC15N0746, $17.99

***

GJ - I do not have this book yet, but I know Deutschlander is one of the most respected teachers in WELS. Readers may recall that Ski skipped the Deutschlander presentation to WELS pastors in Atlanta in order to worship with the Babtists and John Parlow. Deutschlander, at the late Northwestern College, had no use for the Church Growth Movement.

---

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Deutschlander's New Book: The Theology of the Cro...":

I was able to page through a preview of this book at a bookstore, and it seems quite interesting. I happened upon a section entitled "Lutheran Worship reflects the theology of the cross, not the theology of glory" (or similar). Looks like this will be good reading.

The public school students had to take "remedial" doctrine class at MLC, and Deutschlander taught it. But contrary to the 000-level numbering, the class was likely the most rigorous, focused, and confessional class I have taken while in attendance at any Lutheran college. Many future WELS pastors who "escaped" by attending parochial school audited the class anyway. Hopefully some of it rubbed off on them.

Sound Advice from Freddy Finkelstein



Two hats, one purpose: Bruce Becker,
Church and Chicanery Board Member;
Administrator (top dog) of Parish Services, WELS.



Freddy Finkelstein has left a new comment on your post "Want To See More FIC Articles about St. Andrews La...":

Concerning lay effort addressing the Confessional Crisis that WELS appears to be facing, I wrote the following awhile back as a followup to discussion in a different blog entry. The discussion moved on by the time I completed it, so I didn't post it. I post it here for the benefit of laymen wondering what they can do. Maybe others have additional advice:

---------------------------------------------
So, how should the laity get involved? By shooting off angry letters to Synod Headquarters, or to DPs outside their Districts? Maybe... By feverishly blogging? Maybe... Frankly, I think the most effective way for us to fight these battles is from the ground up, beginning in our own congregations.

First, calmly and dispassionately inform your congregations' Boards of Elders of the issues. Chances are, they don't have a clue. Inform them directly, not through your Pastor. Personally give them the materials and point them to the sources so that they can form their own unfiltered opinions. They are the one's responsible for considering these issues within the congregation, and they are the one's that need to work with the Pastor to address them as they occur among our Brothers outside the congregation.

Second, understand that in the next three years there will be two Synodical Conventions and a District Convention, and these issues may well be on the agenda or otherwise come up in discussion. Encourage your congregations to thoughtfully choose Convention delegates – instead of automatically choose an arbitrary retiree just because he's got the time. Many of us will need to use Vacation time to cover these Conventions. Don't wait to be asked, let it be known ahead of time that you would like to be considered as a delegate and that you are willing to set aside time to do so.

Third, keep the torch lit – that is, continue to engage in discussion with your Pastors and with competent laymen in your congregations regarding these issues. Assume that you won't be the one going to Convention, and that someone else from your congregation will need to understand the gravity of these issues in order to participate effectively at Convention.

Fourth, inform your lay contacts in neighboring congregations and in our Sister synods (like, the ELS, ELFK, LBK, and others – like our very conservative African brothers) that it appears that WELS

...is tolerating “ministerial associations” with the heterodox (Willow Creek Association, and others),

...is celebrating the formation of “emergent-church congregations” in its publications and appears to be eagerly underwriting “rock'n roll churches,” which elevate anthropocentric elements like ambiance and human emotion over the Marks of the Church, mistakenly treat worship as Means of Grace, supplant the Means of Grace with the means of man and of Natural Law, and turn the Divine Service into an outreach event rather than maintain it as the wholesome christocentric setting for Christian worship that it has been for the past two millenia,

...is struggling with outside Church Growth organizations like “Church and Change” that are essentially operating as a parallel church within WELS, mouthing Confessional unity while essentially preaching Pietism and conspicuously divesting themselves of Lutheran identity --- from dropping the term “Lutheran” in their church names to engaging in virtually unrecognizable church practices,

...that our practice of the doctrine concerning the roles of men and women is diverging from our confession as, frequently, our women are taking speaking positions in the Chancel during the Divine Service (as Lectors and "Worship Ministers"), are engaging in ministerial roles authoritatively teaching in mixed-gender settings, and increasingly seem to be taking on roles of positional authority in congregations,

...etcetera...

WELS must address these issues, and at this point, it must do so directly and publicly. Pressure from our congregations and from our Brothers in other synods – i.e., their support – may well produce the action from leadership that is needed.

Finally, don't get “too big for your britches.” That is to say, remember that we are laymen, not pastors, and not theologians. Be respectful and maintain a teachable spirit. That isn't to say, however, that we don't have every right to expect and to insist on satisfactory answers from our Pastors and Theologians, nor to have a firm hand in directing Congregational and Synodical action.

---------------------------------------------

Understand, that the CG Church Changers are probably already preparing to defend themselves and take the offensive. They definitely have the advantage in terms of their internal communication network and seem to be entrenched in key political positions. Do nothing, and Dr. Jackson is right – conservative and confessional Lutherans in WELS will be steamrolled.

Freddy Finkelstein

---

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Sound Advice from Freddy Finkelstein":

The sky is falling...the sky is falling....

***

GJ - Typical Church and Change mockery from Anonymous.

Does anyone remember how WELS pastors clucked their tongues at how Missouri changed while denying it? How Missouri let their prep schools go? How Missouri watered down their pastoral training? Worked with the LCA, ALC and Roman Catholics? And Missouri went from denial to defending to cries of "Legalist"?

I remember.

Marva Dawn - Thou Hast Conquered...WELS




Marva Dawn, mover and shaker for women's ordination in Missouri.
Move over, Marva - WELS is already doing it.


From St. Andrew's Latte:

"As Staff Minister of Worship, Kristen is responsible for planning and implementing all worship opportunities at St. Andrew. She also oversees the large corps of worship volunteers who serve in many and varied capacities each week. Music is the largest part of the worship ministry at St. Andrew, but the worship ministry also includes lay readers, dramatic and visual arts, hospitality ministries and audio/visual tech support. Kristen works closely with Pastor Hunter to study and understand biblical worship principles and practices, evaluate current worship practices at St. Andrew, and define future directions for St. Andrew’s worship ministry."


WLC (womb of Church and Change), Larry Oh!'s Staph Ministry (Martin Luther College), and St. Andrew's Latte Lutheran - a perfect combination for de facto women's ordination. Rev. Kristen Koepsell.


Kristen graduated from Wisconsin Lutheran College in 2003 with a B.A. in Psychology and minors in Communication and Theology. While at WLC she worked for two years in the Campus Ministry Office planning and implementing daily chapel services, organizing various musical groups for worship, and learning from Campus Pastor Nathan Strobel. She is currently pursuing Staff Ministry certification from Martin Luther College.

Kristen grew up in the Pacific Northwest and always intended to return there after college, but God had other plans for her. He has planted her firmly in the family of faith at St. Andrew and for this she is truly and deeply grateful. When she’s not writing services or running rehearsals, Kristen spends her time reading science fiction and classic literature, playing piano, writing music, taking long walks in good weather, staying connected with friends and family, and generally enjoying life.

“The best part of my job is knowing that my work directly impacts the spiritual lives of those who worship here and enables them to connect with God. I say this with a full and complete understanding (and appreciation!) of the fact that the actual work is done by the Holy Spirit through the means of grace – but it is a great privilege and a great joy to be an instrument in ‘administering God’s grace’ in the form of worship gatherings. The second most rewarding aspect of my work is assisting all sorts of members of the congregation in bringing their gifts to God and to each other as joyful offerings. How exciting it is to see brothers and sisters in Christ – of all ages! – learning and working together to serve God and His people. The interpersonal connections made and the spiritual lessons learned through this ministry are invaluable blessings from our gracious God.”

The Minister of Worship can be contacted online.


***

GJ - A pastor is defined as one who "administers the Means of Grace." Perhaps at this point some people will see that my warnings about Church and Chicanery were far too subtle, too mild, and too tentative.

When the Episcopalians instituted women's ordination, they held actual ordination services. WELS goes ahead without bothering with the formalities. Everything is possible when all things are adiaphora.

Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod



One solution: switch to de-caff.


Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Joe Krohn, Rock and Roller--Previously Retired for...":

JW said..."Some insight on me before I elaborate…I’m a PK (Pastor’s Kid) from Mequon but not from the Seminary. That narrows down my identity significantly. I’ve been WELS educated from Kindergarten to Undergrad."

Uhhh, GJ, there is a Pastor Stanley Weinrich in Mequon. I think there is a pretty good chance this is his son. It's not Krohn. You have just discredited yourself and this whole blog by not addressing this. A previous poster brought this to your attention.

***

GJ - I don't think this post proves anything. It is anonymous. It has no blogger ID attached to it. It could be from anyone. If people do not use their real names, I feel free to speculate.

Joe Krohn has posted anonymously or semi-anonymously. He is free to say on his blog whether he is this person or not.

This blog focuses on Lutheran doctrine, not on critics who hide behind "Anonymous."

I understand why genuine Lutherans use another name, because the vindictiveness and spite of the Church and Changers is boundless. Look at how they treat the Office of the Synod President, which they think is their collective doormat.

If you want proper identification, use it in your posts. If not, switch to de-caff.

---


Awww. Not that cowardly Anonymous again!
He doesn't even know how to use sic.


Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod":

What it tells me and others is that you are sloppy in your research and that maybe there are other glaring errors in your 'blog'.(sic)

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod":

I thought you cared about truth and accuracy. I think you just want to make trouble.

---


The hive is swarming today. What made them so angry?


Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod":

Agreed. I'm a faithful reader of Bailing Water and to see you rip from there to post on your own blog is kind of sad. You do this often so I suppose I shouldn’t be too upset.

If you want to give your thoughts on a Bailing Water post use the comment section on Bailing Water.

This is kind of like stealing a sermon from Mark Driscoll, adding your own thoughts, and then preaching it in your church. You would never do that! (I also read this blog very often)

***
GJ - I am endlessly amused by the feigned outrage of anonymous Enthusiasts, perhaps from the same person. Who knows? They love Babtist doctrine so much they dare not speak their name.

Ripping suggests stealing without attribution, a habit among such Church and Chicanery leaders as Paul Kelm, John Parlow, and Matt Doebler. How many WELS pastors admit their model for pastoral work is Mars Hill, North Point Community (really Babtist), and Willow Creek?

I copy from Bailing Water with attribution to give that fine blog greater recognition. The third editor has been unfailingly fair in giving everyone a chance to discuss their ideas. BW is the only blog I quote on a regular basis.

---

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod":

No kidding. It's OK for Ichabod to copy and paste to his hearts (sic) content, but not for anyone else. He reminds me of the spoiled brat that can dish it out but can't take it.

BTW GAGmeister..."free to speculate". I think that pretty much sums up this blog(sic). There is no care in presenting truth as evidenced by this episode concerning Krohn. Clearly you try to stir things up. Paul warns against people like you.

***

GJ - The difference between plagiarism and scholarship is the citation. I try to show what is copied verbatim and exactly where it came from. That courtesy is seldom repaid by the Enthusiasts, but that is what I expect from dishonest bottom-dwellers, clouds without rain, Lutherans in Name Only, Babtist wannabees.

---

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod":

Wow, I haven't heard the term PK (pastor's kid) in a long time.

I am not a pastor's kid, but I sure met a lot of them during my time in elementary and prep school.

Now, first I want to say that there are MANY fine children of pastors and teachers out there...

However, there certainly are enough that go "above and beyond the call of duty" to show how they can break the rules.

Lay members of the congregation are very hesistant (sic) to bring this to the attention of called workers, and problems usually go unaddressed. In prep school where many of the dorming students were PKs (or TKs, teacher kids) special allowances would sometimes be made based on the relative connections of their parentage. Lay kids when caught are usually given the standard punishment with stern admonishments from called workers. The called workers' kids? It usually varies much more...

Is their (sic) nepotism everywhere? Oh, you bet there is.

[GJ - Spell-check confirms this is indeed a product of the WELS educational system.]

---

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Some Poor Feller Lost His Faith in Ichabod":

LOL, I deserved that one!

Mr. "Sic" Anony Mouse

***

GJ - A sense of humor! That's a switch.

Want To See More FIC Articles about St. Andrews Latte WELS?
Do Nothing About It.



Some Evangelicals know how toxic this trend is.
Church and Change loves it, funds it with your offering money,
and promotes it with your offering money.


My initial response to the St. Andrews article, copied below: "This is another hit below the belt from Church and Change operatives at The Love Shack."

If a significant number of WELS/ELS pastors actually committed themselves in writing, to object about the article, it would be the last one like that. The Little Sect on the Prairie is in fellowship with WELS. Silence means agreement, and they have been silent forever and a day.

The laity need to voice their objections, too. One way is through church council resolutions. An article like this makes anyone in the Christian faith look foolish and self-centered. More importantly, St. Andrews Latter diminishes and adulterates the Gospel in the name of making it attractive.

One person alone is going to accomplish nothing. I remember how the closet conservatives would urge me to write about this or that. They never could get themselves to second the motion.

That is why farces like the Stolzenburg-Kuske Pilgrim Community Church are now a mini-denomination within WELS--and the ELS!--today.

Closet conservatives - you bought and paid for this situation with your silence, your cowering before the apostates, and your coveting of a better call.

Comment on St. Andrews Latte Lutheran



Grounds for canceling your subscription to WELS FIC, the vanguard of Church and Change in WELS.


And so John came, baptizing in the desert region and preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. The whole Judean countryside and all the people of Jerusalem went out to him. Confessing their sins, they were baptized by him in the Jordan River. John wore clothing made of camel's hair, with a leather belt around his waist, and he ate locusts and wild honey.

People had to leave their comfort zone (no Starbucks in the Judean desert) and make an effort to hear a counter-cultural character preaching a seeker-challenging message. Similarly, when our Lord began his ministry, his first message was, The kingdom of heaven is near. Repent, and believe the good news. Hunter’s approach, on the other hand, is similar to that of what is frequently called the “emerging church,” or sometimes the “emergent church.” The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel recently published an article about one of these in Milwaukee. The “attendees” (there are no members, of course) who were interviewed clearly expressed the drawing-power of such a church: it’s all about me. It fits my expectations for what I want and how I will feel fulfilled. No need for repentance, for self-sacrifice, or for submitting to one another in love. “I must decrease that he might increase” might be a pious-sounding motto they would place underneath a picture of surfer Jesus, but it would be absolutely meaningless.

Someday someone will ask these people, “What did you go to Waunakee to see? Couches and a coffee pot? If not, what did you go out to see? A projection screen? No, a projection screen is in movie palaces.” What they did see and hear was someone saying, “We’re trying to keep it from becoming the thing that turned a lot of people away from church.” Like what, Randy? The worship of God that millions, perhaps billions of people of every tribe, nation, and language have found edifying for two millennia? Have you thought you might be producing a generation of post-modern proof passage biblicists who will have an excellent grasp of “this is what this passage means to me,” but not a clue about what the passage means? Why do you have an altar at all in this worship facility, when sacrifice seems to play little or no part in your message, and when, I bet, the sacrifice of Christ’s body and blood is never communicated to the faithful from that altar?

Women Teaching Men in WELS



It's just an experiment, like Pilgrim Community (Kuske's) in Columbus.


Q: Is it within scriptural parameters for a woman to teach parenting classes based on Scripture to a church group of both men and women?

---------------------------

A: When it comes to the authoritative teaching of the Word in mixed groups of men and women, the Apostle Paul in 1 Timothy 2:12 clearly points out that God asks spiritually mature men to carry out that kind of teaching of his Word. "I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man." (An even better translation of that verse would read, "I do not permit a woman to teach in such a way as to have authority over a man.") The authoritative teaching of the Word that takes place in a Bible class (including a scriptural parenting class), is not the sharing of opinions. It is teaching with authority what our God has for us to believe and live. Those leading us will be saying to us repeatedly: "This is what the Lord says." I cannot imagine a parenting class in a Lutheran church that did not have at its heart an authoritative sharing of law and gospel as it applies to our calling as Christian fathers and mothers.

However, I have also taught such classes in which, for one of the sessions, I had a female pediatric nurse from the congregation come in to share issues of infant growth and development. I do not believe such sharing of medical expertise violates the principle of head and helper. Everyone in attendance could tell the difference between a session like that, and the typical sessions of that class in which the Word was being studied and shared.

---

And yet, the Staph Minister at Gunga Don Patterson's Church brags:

"Holy Word Lutheran Church has offered the “Becoming a Love & Logic Parent” seminar approximately every 6 months since March of 2004. We have a team of individuals who help to both coordinate and teach each seminar. That team is made up of an elder and his wife (parents of three teen-agers), a member who is married to a man with terminal cancer (parents of two boys – a teen-ager and a son in elementary school), and Cindy and me (parents of three children – 8 yrs, 6 yrs, and 2 yrs). In addition to the seminars we have given at Holy Word, Cindy and I have also taught the class at Cross of Christ in Universal City, TX, at Lord of Life in Friendswood, TX, and at Christ the Rock in Round Rock, TX."


***



GJ - WELS has promoted women teaching men and women usurping authority for over 20 years. At St. Paul in Columbus, Mike Nitz set up the same situation for Sunday mornings. I was blasted at the conference for asking about it. Mike pretended not to know.



For those who have never dredged the Fuller and Willow Creek websites, here is a clue. Most of the WELS leadership has been trained at one or the other beehive, many at both. And there is Trinity in Deerfield, alma mater of Larry Oh! (Our Staph Infection) and many others. At Fuller and Willow Creek, they "deal with" people who have trouble with the ordination of women. At Willow Creek in particular, the men who join have to promise to accept spiritual leadership from women. "Blessed are they who make themselves eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom."



So Willow Creek WELS/LCMS congregations, like St. Mark De Pere, have already pledged this repudiation of the Pastoral Epistles.



Meanwhile, Gunga Don's Holy Word is slipping it in, just as Nitz did decades ago.

Luther: Dear Christians One and All Rejoice




From Martin Luther: Hymns, Ballads, Chants, Truth page 36-38:
"This, Luther's first congregational hymn, appeared in print in 1524. It is almost autobiographical in nature, for the first stanzas reveal the guilt and frustration Luther felt, especially in the monastery. What is true of Luther is true of every human being - all are sinners, as this hymn shows. Yet there is reason to rejoice. God sent His Son, Jesus Christ, to take on our flesh and bone, to live, die, and rise from death for our justification. The exuberant original tune is agile enough to reflect the joy of the redeemed sinner."

Prelude: Dear Christians, One and All Rejoice
Christopher A. Loemker
Publisher: Concordia Publishing House (2003)


"Dear Christians, One and All, Rejoice"
by Martin Luther, 1483-1546


1. Dear Christians, one and all, rejoice,
With exultation springing,
And, with united heart and voice
And holy rapture singing,
Proclaim the wonders God hath done,
How His right arm the victory won;
Right dearly it hath cost Him.

2. Fast bound in Satan's chains I lay,
Death brooded darkly o'er me,
Sin was my torment night and day,
In sin my mother bore me;
Yea, deep and deeper still I fell,
Life had become a living hell,
So firmly sin possessed me.

3. My own good works availed me naught,
No merit they attaining;
Free will against God's judgment fought,
Dead to all good remaining.
My fears increased till sheer despair
Left naught but death to be my share;
The pangs of hell I suffered.

4. But God beheld my wretched state
Before the world's foundation,
And, mindful of His mercies great,
He planned my soul's salvation.
A father's heart He turned to me,
Sought my redemption fervently:
He gave His dearest Treasure.

5. He spoke to His beloved Son:
'Tis time to have compassion.
Then go, bright Jewel of My crown,
And bring to man salvation;
From sin and sorrow set him free,
Slay bitter death for him that he
May live with Thee forever.

6. This Son obeyed His Father's will,
Was born of virgin mother,
And God's good pleasure to fulfill,
He came to be my Brother.
No garb of pomp or power He wore,
A servant's form, like mine, He bore,
To lead the devil captive.

7.To me He spake: Hold fast to Me,
I am thy Rock and Castle;
Thy Ransom I Myself will be,
For thee I strive and wrestle;
For I am with thee, I am thine,
And evermore thou shalt be Mine;
The Foe shall not divide us.

8. The Foe shall shed My precious blood,
Me of My life bereaving.
All this I suffer for thy good;
Be steadfast and believing.
Life shall from death the victory win,
My innocence shall bear thy sin;
So art thou blest forever.

9. Now to My Father I depart,
The Holy Spirit sending
And, heavenly wisdom to impart,
My help to thee extending.
He shall in trouble comfort thee,
Teach thee to know and follow Me,
And in all truth shall guide thee.

10. What I have done and taught, teach thou,
My ways forsake thou never;
So shall My kingdom flourish now
And God be praised forever.
Take heed lest men with base alloy
The heavenly treasure should destroy;
This counsel I bequeath thee.

Hymn 387
The Lutheran Hymnal
Text: Rom. 3: 28
Author: Martin Luther, 1523
Translated by: Richard Massie, 1854, alt.
Titled: "Nun freut euch, liebe Christen g'mein"
Tune: "Nun freut euch"
1st Published in: Etlich' christliche Lieder
Town: Wittenberg, 1524