Monday, October 21, 2019

Coleridge on Luther's Galatians Lectures - He Read It! - Unlike Jay Webber or Jon-Boy Buchholz

 Samuel Taylor Coleridge
 The poet's nephew and author of the quotation - Henry Nelson Coleridge. His son became the first editor of the O.E.D.


In Krauth’s “Literature review” section at the start, we find this quote by Henry Nelson Coleridge. What a gem!:
Coleridge is here answering some of the aspersions cast by High-Church writers on Luther. Referring to one of them, who had called the Commentary on Galatians “silly,” he says:
“Shakspeare has been called silly by Puritans, Milton worse than silly by Prelatists and Papists, Wordsworth was long called silly by Bonaparteans; what will not the odium theologicum or politicum find worthless and silly? To me, perhaps from my silliness, his Commentary appears the very Iliad of justification by faith alone; all the fine and striking things that have been said upon the subject, are taken from it; and if the author preached a novel doctrine, or presented a novel development of Scripture in this work, as Mr. Newman avers, I think he deserves great credit for his originality. The Galatians Commentary of Luther contains, or rather is, a most spirited siege of Babylon, and the friends of Rome like it as well as the French like Wellington and the battle of Waterloo.”
From Biographia Literaria, by S. T. Coleridge, edited by Henry Nelson Coleridge, New York, 1848. quoted in: Krauth, Charles Porterfield. . Philadelphia: The General Council Press. 1871/1899. LutheranLibrary.org. [GJ - I added a few words to make it clear that the opponents found Luther's Galatians Lectures, aka Galatians Commentary, "silly."]