Saturday, February 15, 2020

Like Calvin Ferdinand Wlhelm Walther - They Look for Relief in Calvin's Dogma

If people avoid foundational doctrines, they can outdo Calvin anytime. Ask Walther and his adoring fans.

Article XI, which Chemnitz wrote to prevent future problems, warned against speculation.

What did Walther do? He promoted his own ideas so he could split the Synodical Conference and rule as king over the remnant. That was probably good, because the LCMS became good at producing copies - strutting popinjays shouting down anyone who questioned them.

The OJists, with nowhere to turn, always go back to treating faith as a work of man, not as a gift from God.

They cannot escape their bedrock dogma, that God enthusiastically declared the entire world righteous, free of sin.


Alec Satin Found a Great Luther Quote

John Lenker, graduate of Hamma Divinity School, editor.


22. The Devil Directs His Main Attack Against Faith

Point fifteen: The devil directs his main attack against faith. When that has been overthrown he has won. The Sacrament of Repentance,[*] also, of which mention was made before, is based upon this Sacrament. No others receive forgiveness of sin but those who are baptized, that is, those who have received the promise from God that their sin shall be forgiven. The Sacrament of Repentance points back to the Sacrament of Baptism and confirms it. It would be quite in order for the minister to say when pronouncing absolution: “Behold, God has now forgiven thy sin according to the promise made before in Baptism, a forgiveness which I have been empowered to pronounce by virtue of the office of the keys. Now you are once more in possession of Baptism, its power and life. If you believe, it is true in respect of you. If you do not believe, you perish.” You will find, then, that sin will hinder Baptism in working its appropriate effects: the forgiveness and destruction of sin. Unbelief alone, however, with reference to these effects will render Baptism absolutely destitute of all power. Hence everything depends upon faith.
[*]: Now no longer called and considered a Sacrament among Lutherans.

***
GJ - No one finds Lutheran classics the way Alec Satin does - The Lutheran Librarian.

Luther's Sermon on the Sower and the Seed. Sexagesima



SEXAGESIMA SUNDAY.
   


TEXT:

Luke 8:4-15. And when a great multitude came together, and they of every city resorted unto him, he spake by a parable:

The sower went forth to sow his seed: and as he sowed, some fell by the way side; and it was trodden under foot, and the birds of the heaven devoured it. And other fell amidst the thorns; and the thorns grew with it, and choked it. And other fell into the good ground, and grew, and brought forth fruit a hundredfold. As he said these things, he cried, He that hath ears to hear, let him hear.

And his disciples asked him what this parable might be. And he said, Unto you it is given to know the mysteries of the kingdom of God: but to the rest in parables; that seeing they may not see, and hearing they may not understand. Now the parable is this: The seed is the Word of God. And those by the way side are they that have heard; then cometh the devil, and taketh away the Word from their heart, that they may not believe and be saved. And those on the rock are they who, when they have heard, receive the Word with joy; and these have no root, who for a while believe, and in the time of temptation fall away. And that which fell among the thorns, these are they that have heard, and as they go on their way they are choked with cares and riches and pleasures of this life, and bring no fruit to perfection. And that in the good ground, these are such as in an honest and good heart, having heard the Word, hold it fast, and bring forth fruit with patience.


I. THE NATURE OF THE WORD SPOKEN HERE.

1. This Gospel treats of the disciples and the fruits, which the Word of God develops in the world. It does not speak of the law nor of human institutions; but, as Christ himself says, of the Word of God, which he himself the sower preaches, for the law bears no fruit, just as little as do the institutions of men. Christ however sets forth here four kinds of disciples of the divine Word.

II. THE DISCIPLES OF THIS WORD.

2. The first class of disciples are those who hear the Word but neither understand nor esteem it. And these are not the mean people in the world, but the greatest, wisest and the most saintly, in short they are the greatest part of mankind; for Christ does not speak here of those who persecute the Word nor of those who fail to give their ear to it, but of those who hear it and are students of it, who also wish to be called true Christians and to live in Christian fellowship with Christians and are partakers of baptism and the Lord’s Supper. But they are of a carnal heart, and remain so, failing to appropriate the Word of God to themselves, it goes in one ear and out the other. Just like the seed along the wayside did not fall into the earth, but remained lying on the ground in the wayside, because the road was tramped hard by the feet of man and beast and it could not take root.

3. Therefore Christ says the devil cometh and taketh away the Word from their heart, that they may not believe and be saved. What power of Satan this alone reveals, that hearts, hardened through a worldly mind and life, lose the Word and let it go, so that they never understand or confess it; but instead of the Word of God Satan sends false teachers to tread it under foot by the doctrines of men. For it stands here written both that it was trodden under foot, and the birds of the heaven devoured it. The birds Christ himself interprets as the messengers of the devil, who snatch away the Word and devour it, which is done when he turns and blinds their hearts so that they neither understand nor esteem it, as St. Paul says in 2 Timothy 4:4: “They will turn away their ears from the truth, and turn aside unto fables.” By the treading under foot of men Christ means the teachings of men, that rule in our hearts, as he says in Matthew 5:13 also of the salt that has lost its savor, it is cast out and trodden under foot of men; that is, as St. Paul says in 2 Thessalonians 2:11, they must believe a lie because they have not been obedient to the truth.

4. Thus all heretics, fanatics and sects belong to this number, who understand the Gospel in a carnal way and explain it as they please, to suit their own ideas, all of whom hear the Gospel and yet they bear no fruit, yea, more, they are governed by Satan and are harder oppressed by human institutions than they were before they heard the Word. For it is a dreadful utterance that Christ here gives that the devil taketh away the Word from their hearts, by which he clearly proves that the devil rules mightily in their hearts, notwithstanding they are called Christians and hear the Word.

Likewise it sounds terribly that they are to be trodden under foot, and must be subject unto men and to their ruinous teachings, by which under the appearance and name of the Gospel the devil takes the Word from them, so that they may never believe and be saved, but must be lost forever; as the fanatical spirits of our day do in all lands. For where this Word is not, there is no salvation, and great works or holy lives avail nothing, for with this, that he says: “They shall not be saved,” since they have not the Word, he shows forcibly enough, that not their works but their faith in the Word alone saves, as Paul says to the Romans: “It is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth.” Romans 1:16.

5. The second class of hearers are those who receive the Word with joy, but they do not persevere. These are also a large multitude who understand the Word correctly and lay hold of it in its purity without any spirit of sect, division or fanaticism, they rejoice also in that they know the real truth, and are able to know how they may be saved without works through faith.

They also know that they are free from the bondage of the law, of their conscience and of human teachings; but when it comes to the test that they must suffer harm, disgrace and loss of life or property, then they fall and deny it; for they have not root enough, and are not planted deep enough in the soil. Hence they are like the growth on a rock, which springs forth fresh and green, that it is a pleasure to behold it and it awakens bright hopes. But when the sun shines hot it withers, because it has no soil and moisture, and only rock is there. So these do; in times of persecution they deny or keep silence about the Word, and work, speak and suffer all that their persecutors mention or wish, who formerly went forth and spoke, and confessed with a fresh and joyful spirit the same, while there was still peace and no heat, so that there was hope they would bear much fruit and serve the people. For these fruits are not only the works, but more the confession, preaching and spreading of the Word, so that many others may thereby be converted and the kingdom of God be developed.

6. The third class are those who hear and understand the Word, but still it falls on the other side of the road, among the pleasures and cares of this life, so that they also do nothing with the Word. And there is quite a large multitude of these; for although they do not start heresies, like the first, but always possess the absolutely pure Word, they are also not attacked on the left as the others with opposition and persecution; yet they fall on the right side, and it is their ruin that they enjoy peace and good days. Therefore they do not earnestly give themselves to the Word, but become indifferent and sink in the cares, riches and pleasures of this life, so that they are of no benefit to any one. Therefore they are like the seed that fell among the thorns. Although it is not rocky but good soil; not wayside but deeply plowed soil; yet, the thorns will not let it spring up, they choke it. Thus these have all in the Word that is needed for their salvation, but they do not make any use of it, and they rot in this life in carnal pleasures. To these belong those who hear the Word but do not bring under subjection their flesh. They know their duty but do it not, they teach but do not practice what they teach, and are this year as they were last.

7. The fourth class are those who lay hold of and keep the Word in a good and honest heart, and bring forth fruit with patience, those who hear the Word and steadfastly retain it, meditate upon it and act in harmony with it.

The devil does not snatch it away, nor are they thereby led astray, moreover the heat of persecution does not rob them of it, and the thorns of pleasure and the avarice of the times do not hinder its growth; but they bear fruit by teaching others and by developing the kingdom of God, hence they also do good to their neighbor in love; and therefore Christ adds, “they bring forth fruit with patience.” For these must suffer much on account of the Word, shame and disgrace from fanatics and heretics, hatred and jealousy with injury to body and property from their persecutors, not to mention what the thorns and the temptations of their own flesh do, so that it may well be called the Word of the cross; for he who would keep it must bear the cross and misfortune, and triumph.

8. He says: “In honest and good hearts.” Like a field, that is without a thorn or brush, cleared and spacious, as a beautiful clean place: so a heart is also cleared and clean, broad and spacious, that is without cares and avarice as to temporal needs, so that the Word of God truly finds lodgment there. But the field is good, not only when it lies there cleared and level, but when it is also rich and fruitful, possesses soil and is productive, and not like a stony and gravelly field. Just so is the heart that has good soil and with a full spirit is strong, fertile and good to keep the Word and bring forth fruit with patience.

9. Here we see why it is no wonder there are so few true Christians, for all the seed does not fall into good ground, but only the fourth and small part; and that they are not to be trusted who boast they are Christians and praise the teaching of the Gospel; like Demas, a disciple of St. Paul, who forsook him at last, 2 Timothy 4:10; like the disciples of Jesus, who turned their backs to him. John 6:66. For Christ himself cries out here: “He that hath ears to hear, let him hear,” as if he should say: O, how few true Christians there are; one dare not believe all to be Christians who are called Christians and hear the Gospel, more is required than that.

10. All this is spoken for our instruction, that we may not go astray, since so many misuse the Gospel and few lay hold of it aright. True it is unpleasant to preach to those who treat the Gospel so shamefully and even oppose it. For preaching is to become so universal that the Gospel is to be proclaimed to all creatures, as Christ says in Mark 16:15: “Preach the Gospel to the whole creation;” and Psalm 19:4: “Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world.” What business is it of mine that many do not esteem it? It must be that many are called but few are chosen. For the sake of the good ground that brings forth fruit with patience, the seed must also fall fruitless by the wayside, on the rock and among the thorns; inasmuch as we are assured that the Word of God does not go forth without bearing some fruit, but it always finds also good ground; as Christ says here, some seed of the sower falls also into good ground, and not only by the wayside, among the thorns and on stony ground. For where-ever the Gospel goes you will find Christians. “My word shall not return unto me void.” Isaiah 55:11.

III. THE FRUIT OF THIS WORD.

11. Here observe that Mark 4:8 and Matthew 13:8 say the seed yielded fruit some thirty, some sixty and some a hundredfold, which according to all interpretations is understood of three kinds of chastity, that of virgins, married persons and widows; and virgins are credited with a hundredfold of fruit, wedded persons with thirtyfold, the least of all, and widows with sixtyfold. But this is such coarse and corrupt talk that it is a sin and a shame that this interpretation has continued so long in Christendom and has been advocated by so many noted teachers, and criticized by none of them. In this one perceives how many wide-awake, well-armed and faithful teachers the church has had heretofore, and how one blindly believed another, and how God allowed many noted saints and people to play the fool so completely in these important matters pertaining to the soul that he warned us to believe no teacher, however saintly and great he may be, unless he comes with the pure Word of God.

12. First, it would be doing the Word of God injustice to hold that it brings forth no other fruit than chastity, since St. Paul boasts quite differently in Galatians 5:22. In brief, the Word of God accomplishes all good, it makes us wise, sensible, prudent, cautious, pious, kind, patient, faithful, discreet, chaste, etc. Hence this comment referring only to three kinds of chastity is wholly unchristian. The heathen and wicked people, who neither possess the Gospel nor persecute it, have also virgins, widows and married persons. Doubtless Anna and Caiaphas had been properly married. Thus there were virgins, widows and consorts before the Word of God; for virgins were born, and when the Gospel comes it finds virgins, widows and wives; the Gospel did not first make them virgins, widows or wives.

13. Secondly, thus marriage, virginity and widowhood are not fruits, nor virtues, nor good works; but three stations or states in life created and ordained by God, and are not creatures of our power. They are divine works and creations like all other creatures. For if it should be valid to interpret a station or state in life as good fruit, one would have to say the state of a lord, a servant, a man, a child and of officers was only fruit of the Gospel; in this way there would be no fruit at all left for the Gospel, since such states or callings are found everywhere regardless of the Gospel. But the chastity of virgins is paraded thus for the sake of a show, to the great danger and injury of immortal souls; just as if no virtue adorns a Christian but virginity.

14. I will say further, that chastity is a different and a far higher thing than virginity, and is nothing more than that a woman has never been under any obligation to a man. Besides, however, it is possible that a virgin has not only a desire and a passion for man, in harmony with the character and nature of her female body; but she must also be full of blood and life in order to bear children and multiply the race, for which God created her, and that creation is not her work but God’s alone. Therefore that woman may not hinder God’s work, nature as created by God must take its course, whether children be born or not. But chastity must indeed be a state of a woman’s mind that has no or little desire for man, and has in her body also little or no seed to bear fruit or children.

15. Now it is generally the case that a married woman does not so often experience such desire and lust, such a flow of love or life; for she will be relieved of the same by or through her husband; and besides, where a virgin has only passion in the thoughts of her heart and in the seed of her body, a married woman has much displeasure mingled with the pleasure of her husband, so that to speak in common terms, the high and best chastity is in the married state, because in it is the least lust and passion, while the least chastity is in the state of virgins, because in it there is much more lust and passion. Therefore chastity is a virtue far above virginity; for we call a bride still a virgin, although she is indeed full of desire, passion and love for her bridegroom. Chastity waves high over all three states, over marriage, over widowhood and over virginity. But when God does not work wonders it sinks low and exists most in the married state and least in the state of virgins, and there are not three kinds of chastity, but three states of chastity.

16. True, when we consider virginity according to its outward appearance, it seems great that a woman restrains herself and never satisfies her desires with a man. But what does it help if persons restrain their passions longer without a man or a woman and then satisfy them more than with a man or woman? Is there not more unchastity where there is greater lust, love, lewdness and sensation than where there is less? Therefore to calculate according to the amount of lust and sensation, as unchastity should be considered, virginity is more unchaste than the state of marriage. This is very apparent among prostitutes, who are virgins and yet are very forward and obscene, and cherish greater thoughts of the sin than the sin itself is. In short, I wonder if there is a virgin twenty years of age, who has a healthy, perfect female body.

17. This is enough concerning chastity, that we know how the fruits of the Word must be understood differently and in a wider sense than pertaining to chastity, and be applied especially to the fruits, by which many are converted and come to the knowledge of the truth. For although works are also called fruits, yet Christ speaks here especially of the fruits the seed of the Word brings forth in hearts that become enlightened, believing, happy and wise in Christ, as St. Paul says in Romans 1:13: “That I might have some fruit in you also, even as in the rest of the Gentiles;” and Colossians 1:6: “Even as the Gospel is also in all the world bearing fruit and increasing, as it doth in you also;” that is, many will be made alive through the Gospel, delivered from their sins and be saved; for it is the characteristic work of the Gospel, as the Word of life, grace and salvation to release from sin, death and Satan. In harmony with this fruit follow the fruits of the Spirit, the good works of patience, love, faithfulness, etc.

18. Now that some seed brings forth thirty, some sixty, and some a hundred fold, means that more people will be converted in some places than in others, and one apostle and minister may preach farther and more than another; for the people are not everywhere alike numerous and do not report the same number of Christians, and one minister may not preach as many sermons or cover as great a territory as another, which God foresaw and ordained. To the words of St. Paul, who preached the farthest and the most, we may indeed ascribe the hundredfold of fruit; although he was not a virgin.

IV. WHY CHRIST CALLS THE DOCTRINE CONCERNING THE DISCIPLES AND THE FRUITS OF THE WORD A MYSTERY.

19. But what does it mean when he says: “Unto you it is given to know the mysteries of the kingdom of Gad”, etc.? What are the mysteries? Shall one not know them, why then are .they preached? A “mystery” is a hidden secret, that is not known: and the “mysteries of the kingdom of God” are the things in the kingdom of God, as for example Christ with all his grace, which he manifests to us, as Paul describes him; for he who knows Christ aright understands what God’s kingdom is and what is in it. And it is called a mystery because it is spiritual and secret, and indeed it remains so, where the spirit does not reveal it. For although there are many who see and hear it, yet they do not understand it. Just as there are many who preach and hear Christ, how he offered himself for us; but all that is only upon their tongue and not in their heart; for they themselves do not believe it, they do not experience it, as Paul in 1 Corinthians 2:14 says: “The natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God.” Therefore Christ says here: “Unto you it is given”, the Spirit gives it to you that you not only hear and see it, but acknowledge and believe it with your heart. Therefore it is now no longer a mystery to you. But to the others who hear it as well as you, and have no faith in their heart, they see and understand it not; to them it is a mystery and it will continue unknown to them, and all that they hear is only like one hearing a parable or a dark saying. This is also proved by the fanatics of our day, who know so much to preach about Christ; but as they themselves do not experience it in their heart, they rush ahead and pass by the true foundation of the mystery and tramp around with questions and rare foundlings, and when it comes to the test they do not know the least thing about trusting in God and finding in Christ the forgiveness of their sins.

20. But Mark says, Mark 4:33, Christ spake therefore to the people with parables, that they might understand, each according to his ability.

How does that agree with what Matthew says, Matthew 13:13-14: He spake therefore unto them in parables, because they did not understand? It must surely be that Mark wishes to say that parables serve to the end that they may get a hold of coarse, rough people, although they do not indeed understand them, yet later, they may be taught and then they know: for parables are naturally pleasing to the common people, and they easily remember them since they are taken from common every day affairs, in the midst of which the people live. But Matthew means to say that these parables are of the nature that no one can understand them, they may grasp and hear them as often as they will, unless the Spirit makes them known and reveals them. Not that they should preach that we shall not understand them; but it naturally follows that wherever the Spirit does not reveal them, no one understands them. However, Christ took these words from Isaiah 6:9-10, where the high meaning of the divine foreknowledge is referred to, that God conceals and reveals to whom he will and whom he had in mind from eternity.

Seventh Lesson - Understanding Pilgrim's Progress



SEVENTH LESSON

Great-Heart

After many lessons at the Interpreter’s House, and being washed (baptism), Great-Heart went with them, as protection. P. 233
GREAT-HEART. With all my heart; but first I must premise, that He of whom we are now about to speak is one that has not His fellow. He has two natures in one Person, plain to be distinguished, impossible to be divided. Unto each of these natures a righteousness belongeth, and each righteousness is essential to that nature; so that one may as easily cause the nature to be extinct, as to separate its justice or righteousness from it. P. 234
Later, at Beautiful Palace, Great-Heart went back to the Interpreter’s House. Prudence asked the sons of Christiana basic catechism questions – James, Samuel, and Matthew.

The Two Valleys

They left to enter the Valley of Humiliation and the Valley of the Shadow of Death.
GREAT-HEART. It is true, said their guide, I have gone through this Valley many a time, and never was better than when here. I have also been a conductor to several pilgrims, and they have confessed the same. ‘To this man will I look (saith the King), even to him that is poor and of a contrite spirit, and trembleth at My Word’ (Isa. 66:2). P. 269
In the second valley, they were pursued by a lion –
The lion also came on apace, and Mr. Great-heart addressed himself to give him battle. But when he saw that it was determined that resistance should be made, he also drew back, and came no further (1 Peter 5:8, 9). P. 271
Honest Blessed the Four Sons and Mercy
HONEST. I have heard much of your husband, and of his travels and wars, which he underwent in his days. Be it spoken to your comfort, the name of your husband rings over all these parts of the world: his faith, his courage, his enduring, and his sincerity under all, has made his name famous. Then he turned him to the boys, and asked them of their names, which they told him. And then said he unto them: Matthew, be thou like Matthew the publican, not in vice, but in virtue (Matt. 10:3). Samuel, said he, be thou like Samuel the Prophet, a man of faith and prayer (Psa. 99:6). Joseph, said he, be thou like Joseph in Potiphar’s house, chaste, and one that flees from temptation (Gen. 39). And James, be thou like James the Just, and like James the brother of our Lord (Acts 1:13, 14). Then they told him of Mercy, and how she had left her town and her kindred to come along with Christiana and with her sons. At that the old honest man said, Mercy is thy name; by Mercy shalt thou be sustained, and carried through all those difficulties that shall assault thee in thy way, till thou shalt come thither, where thou shalt look the Fountain of Mercy in the face with comfort. P. 279

Later, Mercy Married Matthew, Phoebe Married James

Then Samuel whispered to Christiana, his mother, and said, Mother, this is a very good man’s house, let us stay here a good while, and let my brother Matthew be married here to Mercy, before we go any further. The which Gaius the host overhearing, said, With a very good will, my child. So they staid there more than a month, and Mercy was given to Matthew to wife. P. 297
Now, about this time, Matthew and Mercy were married. Also Gaius gave his daughter Phoebe to James, Matthew’s brother, to wife; after which time they yet staid above ten days at Gaius’ house, spending their time, and the seasons, like as pilgrims used to do. P. 303

Two More Marriages, Mnason

Thus they sat talking and spending the time, until supper was set upon the table; unto which they went and refreshed their weary bodies; so they went to rest. Now they stayed in this fair a great while, at the house of this Mr. Mnason, who, in process of time, gave his daughter Grace unto Samuel, Christiana’s son, to wife, and his daughter Martha to Joseph. P. 310


Christiana Crossed the Dark River

Now the day drew on, that Christiana must be gone. So the road was full of people to see her take her journey. But, behold, all the banks beyond the river were full of horses and chariots, which were come down from above to accompany her to the city gate. So she came forth, and entered the river, with a beckon of farewell to those that followed her to the river side. The last words that she was heard to say here, were, I come, Lord, to be with Thee, and bless Thee. P. 342
So her children and friends returned to their place, for that those that waited for Christiana had carried her out of their sight. So she went and called, and entered in at the gate with all the ceremonies of joy that her husband Christian had done before her. At her departure her children wept. But Mr. Great-heart and Mr. Valiant played upon the well-tuned cymbal and harp for joy. So all departed to their respective places. P. 342

The Four Sons and Their Wives

As for Christian’s children, the four boys that Christiana brought with her, with their wives and children, I did not stay where I was till they were gone over. Also, since I came away, I heard one say that they were yet alive, and so would be for the increase of the CHURCH in that place where they were, for a time. Shall it be my lot to go that way again, I may give those that desire it an account of what I here am silent about. Meantime, I bid my reader Adieu.

Concluding Thoughts about The Pilgrim’s Progress

History has already decided that this book has had enormous impact on Western culture, with 2000+ editions, movies, cartoons, free Kindles, children’s editions, modern language editions, and translation. The used book market shows that other works are considered far more valuable, when issued by the same press in the same number – Limited Editions Book Club copies of The Pilgrim’s Progress are priced from $30 to $100. Copies of Moby Dick from the same source are $5,000 on eBay. Both titles were limited to 1500 numbered copies. Muck-raker would buy Moby Dick as an investment, sure to grow in value.
This book is entertaining, with a lot of wry comments about human failings, but also edifying, with its unusual concentration of Biblical material expressed visually with descriptive names of people and short stories about their challenges and losses. I know from German-speaking boys that dramatic stories and transparent names are easy to remember and repeat – Struwwelpeter is an example. Caspar-Suppe would not eat his soup, so he shriveled up. They laughed at the extreme stories. So The Pilgrim’s Progress has lions, giants, swords, and beheadings.
The Pilgrim’s Progress should be read a little at a time, because the lessons are not at the end but on every page. Bunyan’s favoring Luther’s Galatians over any other book except the Bible is clearly evidenced among those who love both works, but not by those who have read neither one.

The Pilgrim’s Progress Map

Pages from the Lutheran Library Print Edition


City of Destruction – Christian leaves;  Christiana and their children follow in Part 2
Slough of Despond - Pliable, Obstinate, Worldly Wiseman, Evangelist
Wicket Gate – Good Will
Interpreter’s House - Interpreter (Holy Spirit)
The Cross – Three Shining Ones
Difficulty Hill – Formalist, Hypocrisy
Palace Beautiful - Discretion, Prudence, Piety, and Charity
Valley of the Shadow of Death – Two Men, Demons, Pope and Pagan, Faithful met again
Vanity Fair – Talkative, Lord Hate-Good, Hopeful, By-Ends, Witnesses: Envy, Superstition, and Pickthank; Demas, Lot’s Wife
Doubting Castle - Giant Despair, his lovely wife Diffidence
Delectable Mountains -  Shepherds: Knowledge, Experience, Watchful, and Sincere



Friday, February 14, 2020

Significant Otter - For Valentine's Day

Responding to LutherQuackers Are Quaking Up




Hi Greg,

In your post this morning "LutherQuackers are Quacking Up." you quoted a Rev. Boisclair who said in part,

"What is mystifying to me is Jackson's love for Luther, who would never have stomached Jackson's Synergism."

Perhaps you could request that Bosclair provide proof of:

1. Your Synergism.  How does he define this in his words?

2. Luther's rejection of "Jackson's Synergism"

Without this, it's all emotion and fear without anything real to grab hold of.  You have written so much, it should be easy for him to provide quotes of "Jackson's Synergism", whatever that is.

This would let us all have a real discussion - or at least understand from both sides where the theological divide occurs. 

If "Jackson's Synergism", whatever that is, is condemned anywhere in the Book of Concord, let's see it. 

The National Weather Service has issued a Hot Air Alert for the LutherQuackers websty.

Enjoying the Hissy Fits from LutherQuackers




A few observations are enough to send the noisy LutherQueasies into fits of rage. They illustrate the shallow ignorance of Lutheran leaders today.

The essential beginning is the Word of God. The Objective Justification extremists hijacked Romans 4 to impose their dogma on the Missouri Synod, using the non-Scriptural Brief Statement of 1932. For some reason that was elevated above the Book of Concord and the Bible.

If anyone wants to discuss Justification in the LCMS-WELS-ELS-CLC (sic), the Brief Statement is not only the starting point - but also the template for the entire canon. Every atonement passage is kidnapped for Objective Justification. Anything following the absurd OJ obsession is nonsense.

Sorry boys, but I read and listened to modern theology for years, and OJ is modern, rationalistic, mainline, apostate theology. As one LCA leader snarled on a Word and Witness tape, "They have no grace." What does that mean? He was denouncing all the Evangelical ministers because they taught faith in Christ. Here is the syllogism:

  1. God's grace cannot be linked to faith, a contingency.
  2. They (the evil ones) speak about faith in Christ.
  3. Therefore, they never teach grace.
 Listen up! Faith-ians. See below.

That is why Walther, Pieper, and their lick-spittles always run away from Scriptural exegesis. One must start with the Watherian thesis, borrowed from Stephan, nicked from Halle, press-ganged from Calvin. The OJists respond from the Waltherian sermon barrel - 
  1. Calvinist! 
  2. Arminian! 
  3. Synergist! 
  4. OJ-denier! 
  5. Election without Faith denier!
  6. You make faith a work of man!
  7. You think salvation is incomplete so you must do one thing more - believe!
  8. You are not a Christ-ian. You are a Faith-ian. Your faith is in faith, not in Christ!
 Luther was a faith-alone-ist.

As Shakespeare (Oxford) said, "A little pot is soon hot."

To maintain this level of Scriptural stupidity, each OJ expert must ignore the plain meaning of God's Word, starting with Genesis 15:6 - continuing throughout the Old and New Testaments. 


Thursday, February 13, 2020

LutherQuackers Are Quacking Up.

 "Come for a blessing, child. You seem stressed, worried, and befuddled."



Rev. David R. Boisclair (Drboisclair)
Advanced Member
Username: Drboisclair

Post Number: 703
Registered: 1-2002
Posted on Wednesday, February 12, 2020 - 7:47 pm:    Edit Post Delete Post Print Post
"The lady doth protest too much methinks"--Shakespeare, Hamlet, act III, scene ii

Jackson covers his own logical fallacies by accusing others of committing them. He is the unmatched king of the fallacy of ad hominem argumentation. His website is a monument to that lamentable FALLACY.

His Achilles's heel is his total embrace of the Synergism of the Iowa and Ohio Synod's F.A. Schmidt and F.W. Stellhorn, who claimed that faith precedes God's gracious election to salvation. He has even firmed this up by his advocacy of the "later Melanchthon," who was Synergist par excellence. This dovetails nicely with his synergistic doctrine of justification.

Pope Jackson thinks that Martin Chemnitz supports his heterodoxy, but Martin Chemnitz taught that God's gracious election COMES BEFORE faith not after it as Jackson and his minions opine. Oops, no electio intuitu fidei finalis.

What is mystifying to me is Jackson's love for Luther, who would never have stomached Jackson's Synergism.


Rev. David R. Boisclair (Drboisclair)
Advanced Member
Username: Drboisclair

Post Number: 704
Registered: 1-2002
Posted on Wednesday, February 12, 2020 - 8:40 pm:    Edit Post Delete Post Print Post
Oh, and Pope Jackson is guilty of an historical error. John Bunyan (1628-1688), whom he is showcasing now with his study of The Pilgrim's Progress, fought on the side of Cromwell and the Long Parliament, not King Charles I. Sorry. His holiness Jackson said that Bunyan was on the side of the king and the Cavaliers.

Also, The Pilgrim's Progress is Calvinistic in its theology, see the Interpreter's exposition of the chicken and her chicks in the second part. John Bunyan was a Calvinist.

Here endeth the LutherQuack, anothe quack without Scripture or Luther.]

***
GJ - Bunyan was not concerned with leaving his life history, so his side in the war is debated, not confirmed. There is certainly evidence that he fought for the royalists and helped put Charles II on the throne.

There is a Jackson family story that an ancestor loaned Charles II money and sued to have the loan paid. The King put him in prison and ruined him, so the Jacksons have mixed feelings about Charles II, as Bunyan probably did. Charles bankrupted our ancestor, but that got one part of our family to America. The Huguenots were another branch, persecuted by France and lucky to only be exiled. We thrive under duress, so keep quacking, Luther Quackers.

David neglected the fact that Luther's Galatians was Bunyan's most read book after the Bible, an odd oversight since we are always listening to David's excited quacking about what a good Lutheran he is. I do not think I know any OJists who have a clue about the Galatians book.

But, like most nasty-grams from this dysfunctional cell, the posting misses the point. I am teaching the class and writing Understanding Pilgrim's Progress because it is a worthwhile Christian book to read. The people who defy Luther and condemn Justification by Faith might start with a careful reading of the Book of Concord and Melanchthon.

We belong to the Church of the Augsburg Confession. I consider myself a theologian of the Augsburg Confession, a term found in the Formula of Concord.

Perhaps David is so prone to find Calvinism where it is not because he is stuck on that dogma, inherited like Stephan's STD, passed on by Walther and his lick-spittles.

 This is next, followed by a book on Luther's Galatians, then CFW Walther: The American Calvin.
---

A Reader Responded -

Hi Greg,

In your post this morning "LutherQuackers are Quacking up." you quoted a Rev. Boisclair who said in part,

"What is mystifying to me is Jackson's love for Luther, who would never have stomached Jackson's Synergism."

Perhaps you could request that Bosclair provide proof of:

1. Your Synergism.  How does he define this in his words?

2. Luther's rejection of "Jackson's Synergism"

Without this, it's all emotion and fear without anything real to grab hold of.  You have written so much, it should be easy for him to provide quotes of "Jackson's Synergism", whatever that is.

This would let us all have a real discussion - or at least understand from both sides where the theological divide occurs.

If "Jackson's Synergism", whatever that is, is condemned anywhere in the Book of Concord, let's see it.

Abusive Cult Behavior in Politics and in Synods


Abusive cult behavior in religious groups is well known. One WELS pastor sent me a book on this and asked what I thought. I wrote, "It fits WELS, every bit of it."



I just finished an article from a woman describing the Left-wing social activism among knitters.

  1. This is her article. 
  2. The previous link was blocked! Here is one that works.

The Objective Justification cult has taken over two synods - WELS and LCMS - that originally taught Justification by Faith. Missouri was behind WELS in its revolution. WELS was first to get rid of Gausewitz and substitute an OJ catechism, Kuske's. They proved with the Kokomo debacle that they could deceive everyone and attack the Kokomo Statements as "a parody" when those statements from their own dear JP Meyer were used to excommunicate people.

Unlike cub editor Phil Hale, I went to Kokomo and talked to the two men who were kicked out by WELS, with their families. And those men gave me the letters stating their alleged crime (which Armin Panning also approved) - the sin of rejecting the Kokomo Statements - which were written out in the letters.

The OJ cult in WELS and LCMS used their dogma to unite around Church Growth and to kick out anyone who questioned their Calvinism.



Valleskey is very clear about love, love, loving OJ and Church Growth.



Wednesday, February 12, 2020

Calvinist News Tries To Review Treasures from Luther's House Postils, Fails.
Jesus' Blind Man Parable Comes To Mind

 The wrong illustration was used by the editor. He could have emailed me for the correct one.

Review: Treasures From Luther’s House Postils, by Gregory L. Jackson, February 17, 2020 Issue, CN

Introduction by OJist Phil Hale, cub editor of CN. Alleged review by Pastor Jonathan Reprecht, WELS pastor, certified OJ advocate.

From Hale - lots of laughs -

"More attention should be given to Luther’s sermons. They at one time had a place in most Lutherans’ houses. But to have 37 pages, including strange advertising, out of multiple volumes of Luther’s sermons, cannot give but a taste.

Every serious Lutheran should read Luther’s postils. Many seem to be available online for free, since the recent Baker published version is partially based on the Lenker edited edition of Luther’s works (The Precious and Sacred Writings of Martin Luther), which is now in the public domain. The newest volumes of Luther’s Works (CPH) is (sic) also re-translating many of Luther’s sermons. [GJ - Please translate this glossolalia!]

Since the real thing is available at no cost, there is no need to settle for a select bite, edited by someone who denies what Luther taught on justification and thinks he is virtually the only orthodox Lutheran in American (sic) today. Rather than just promoting Luther’s teaching, he cannot help but promoting himself. –ed."

[Here endeth the Hale storm.]

GJ - We have provided the House Postils at a bargain cost in the printed version, especially when ordered at the author's price. We have also provided them at 99 cents on Kindle, and free as a merged set of all three plus the Treasures - PDF.

The purpose of the set was to make them more available, portable as Kindles and as free PDFs, and non-profit. 

The Treasures volume is a low cost way of introducing the set when they have been largely overlooked. 



People appreciated the Gems volume of the Lenker Luther Sermons (8 volumes) so I decided to create one for the House Postils.

Hale has no argument for Justification without Faith, so he indulges himself in personal attacks, at the level of a middle school remedial English student. Even then he would get a D for not matching the subject to the verb and failing to follow through on parallel constructions.


Lazy Ruprecht - Typical WELS Hot Air Merchant

Ruprecht seems as unsettled - dealing with Luther's words - as Hale is. The first part is a hilarious, uncited, unsourced monologue on exactly who wrote the House Postils. Using sharp research skills, perhaps from the Dummies Guide to Luther, Ruprecht has thrown doubt upon the historical postils simply by wondering which words Luther really wrote. Too bad the age of synoptic Gospel comparisons is over. He could have attained tenure at Mordor or even the Little Schoolhouse on the Prairie. (Are you related to Gaylin Schmeling? Sorry, can't hire you.)

The same logic could be applied to Law and Gospel, by another Calvinist, CFW Walther. He lectured and someone took notes. Also, Luther's final version of Galatians - he lectured from an outline, and notes were taken. But Luther agreed to what they took down, so no one says, "He never really wrote them, though scholars are still divided."

Ruprecht - 
"The supplementary information mentioned above takes up 10 of the book’s 37 pages. It is all interesting yet sometimes a bit frustrating due to the lack of details to satisfy the curiosity that is stimulated. Pastor Gregory Jackson is the editor, and he compiled his vignettes from the work of one of his members, Alec Satin, who published Luther’s complete House Postils in three volumes. But others have also published this three-volume compilation, and all seem to agree that it is very difficult to do so without extensive research in the notes of the original German Weimar Ausgabe of Luther’s works. Even Concordia Publishing House reportedly refrained from publishing this work due to the accuracy questions."
[Here endeth Ruprecht.]

I have the House Postils (three volumes) edited by Eugene Klug, who is far more credible than Ruprecht. CPH despises Luther and Justification by Faith, and their treatment of the 500th Anniversary is a shame.

Lazy Ruprecht could have asked for details by email or phone, since he is so interested in playing the role of the wise professor. This was a joint project between Alec Satin, Norma A. Boeckler, and me. 

By lowering prices and making everything free, our participants expect to see these works carried over into the next generation, not buried by neglect as so many books were before. 

Some Lutheran individuals have reprinted old classics, but they are scattered. We are trying to gather them into several distribution points, where they can be used in America and for world missions.


Sixth Lesson Tonight - Pilgrim's Progress - 7 PM


SIXTH LESSON

The Gate Beyond the Dark River

After many discussions between the believers and fellow travelers like Atheist and Ignorance, Pilgrim and Hopeful discovered they could not reach the Celestial City until they crossed the Dark River, which had no bridge. P. 171
They entered the Dark River with fearfulness and difficulties, but they were helped in cross from life into eternal life.
Then I saw in my dream, that Christian was as in a muse a while. To whom also Hopeful added this word, Be of good cheer, Jesus Christ maketh thee whole; and with that Christian brake out with a loud voice, Oh, I see him again! and he tells me, “When thou passest through the waters, I will be with thee, and through the rivers, they shall not overflow thee.” [Isa. 43:2] Then they both took courage, and the enemy was after that as still as a stone, until they were gone over. Christian therefore presently found ground to stand upon, and so it followed that the rest of the river was but shallow. Thus they got over. Now, upon the bank of the river, on the other side, they saw the two shining men again, who there waited for them; wherefore, being come out of the river, they saluted them, saying, We are ministering spirits, sent forth to minister for those that shall be heirs of salvation. Thus they went along towards the gate. P. 173
The descriptions of Heaven which follow are full of glorious citations from  the Scriptures. Here is one passage –
Now while they were thus drawing towards the gate, behold a company of the heavenly host came out to meet them; to whom it was said, by the other two Shining Ones, These are the men that have loved our Lord when they were in the world, and that have left all for his holy name; and he hath sent us to fetch them, and we have brought them thus far on their desired journey, that they may go in and look their Redeemer in the face with joy. Then the heavenly host gave a great shout, saying, “Blessed are they which are called unto the marriage supper of the Lamb.” [Rev. 19:9] There came out also at this time to meet them, several of the King’s trumpeters, clothed in white and shining raiment, who, with melodious noises, and loud, made even the heavens to echo with their sound. These trumpeters saluted Christian and his fellow with ten thousand welcomes from the world; and this they did with shouting, and sound of trumpet. P. 177

Ignorant Removed – Wedding Feast Garment Lacking

Ignorance did not have his certificate, so he was not greeted and not allowed into Heaven. Instead he was carried out and placed into a shute that led to Perdition, illustrating the wedding feast parable where one guess came without a proper garment and was thrown out to Hell, where there was weeping and gnashing of teeth.
Now while I was gazing upon all these things, I turned my head to look back, and saw Ignorance come up to the river side; but he soon got over, and that without half that difficulty which the other two men met with. For it happened that there was then in that place, one Vain-hope, a ferryman, that with his boat helped him over; so he, as the other I saw, did ascend the hill, to come up to the gate, only he came alone; neither did any man meet him with the least encouragement. P. 179
So they told the King, but he would not come down to see him, but commanded the two Shining Ones that conducted Christian and Hopeful to the City, to go out and take Ignorance, and bind him hand and foot, and have him away. Then they took him up, and carried him through the air to the door that I saw in the side of the hill, and put him in there. Then I saw that there was a way to hell, even from the gates of heaven, as well as from the City of Destruction. Matthew 22:1-14
What of my dross thou findest there, be bold
To throw away, but yet preserve the gold;
What if my gold be wrapped up in ore?—
None throws away the apple for the core.
But if thou shalt cast all away as vain,
I know not but ’twill make me dream again.


Part Two Christiana’s Story

After the overwhelming success of The Pilgrim’s Progress, with a phenomenal number of books sold for that time – 100,000 – Bunyan wrote Part Two, Christiana’s Story, not as a second book, but as a continuation of the original. However, many editions only include the first part, which make those works more portable, but leave the readers to imagine the family enduring the sorrows of the City of Destruction. The Lutheran Librarian’s printed and online versions contain both parts. The third part did not come from Bunyan, but from someone who hitched a ride on his fame, like the publisher who wrote a Lutheran blog filled with verbatim (but uncited) biographies from The Catholic Encyclopedia – and even linked them shamelessly on LutherQuest.
Part Two has a lengthy opening in poetry, compared to the first part getting involved in the urgency of leaving the City of Destruction and trying to include Christian’s wife. The narrative in this part starts with Christiana realizing she should have gone with her husband, repenting of that error, and telling their four sons about the need to take the same pilgrimage.
The family passed through the Slough of Despond and entered through the Wicket Gate.

Interpreter’s House, P. 220


Christiana was shown new lessons at the Interpreter’s House. After the muck-rake is the spider.

INTERPRETER. That prayer, Said the Interpreter, has lain by till it is almost rusty. ‘Give me not riches,’ is scarce the prayer of one of ten thousand (Prov. 30:8). Straws, and sticks, and dust, with most, are the great things now looked after. With that Mercy and Christiana wept, and said, It is, alas! too true. When the Interpreter had shown them this, He has them into the very best room in the house; a very brave room it was. So He bid them look round about, and see if they could find anything profitable there. Then they looked round and round; for there was nothing there to be seen but a very great spider on the wall: and that they overlooked.
MERCY. Then said Mercy, Sir, I see nothing; but Christiana held her peace.
INTERPRETER. But, said the Interpreter, look again, and she therefore looked again, and said, Here is not anything but an ugly spider, who hangs by her hands upon the wall. Then said He, Is there but one spider in all this spacious room? Then the water stood in Christiana’s eyes, for she was a woman quick of apprehension; and she said, Yea, Lord, there is here more than one. Yea, and spiders whose venom is far more destructive than that which is in her. The Interpreter then looked pleasantly upon her, and said, Thou hast said the truth. This made Mercy blush, and the boys to cover their faces, for they all began now to understand the riddle. Then said the Interpreter again, ‘The spider taketh hold with their hands (as you see), and is in kings’ palaces’ (Prov. 30:28). And wherefore is this recorded, but to show you, that how full of the venom of sin soever you be, yet you may, by the hand of faith, lay hold of, and dwell in the best room that belongs to the King’s house above!
CHRISTIANA. I thought, said Christiana, of something of this; but I could not imagine it all. I thought that we were like spiders, and that we looked like ugly creatures, in what fine room soever we were; but that by this spider, this venomous and ill-favored creature, we were to learn how to act faith, that came not into my mind. And yet she has taken hold with her hands, as I see, and dwells in the best room in the house. God has made nothing in vain. Then they seemed all to be glad; but the water stood in their eyes; yet they looked one upon another, and also bowed before the Interpreter.