ICHABOD, THE GLORY HAS DEPARTED - explores the Age of Apostasy, predicted in 2 Thessalonians 2:3, to attack Objective Faithless Justification, Church Growth Clowns, and their ringmasters. The antidote to these poisons is trusting the efficacious Word in the Means of Grace. John 16:8. Isaiah 55:8ff. Romans 10. Most readers are WELS, LCMS, ELS, or ELCA. This blog also covers the Roman Catholic Church, Eastern Orthodoxy, and the Left-wing, National Council of Churches denominations.
Martin Luther Sermons
Bethany Lutheran Hymnal Blog
Bethany Lutheran Church Springdale AR 72762 Reformation Seminary Lectures USA, Canada, Australia, Philippines 10 AM Central - Sunday Service
We use The Lutheran Hymnal and the King James Version
Luther's Sermons: Lenker Edition
Click here for the latest YouTube Videos
Friday, May 20, 2011
Hove - God Speaks to Us Through the Means of Grace,
Acts Upon Us
"In the Word of God there is not only a speaking about God, but in and through His Word God Himself speaks to us, deals with us, acts upon us. Therefore the Word of God is also an efficacious means of grace through which God regenerates, converts, and sanctifies man. This efficacy the Word of God possesses always; it is always united with the Word, never separated from it."
E. Hove, Christian Doctrine, Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1930, p. 27.
Labels:
Hove,
Means of Grace
Luther - The Church Is Recognized by the Word and Sacraments
"The church is recognized, not by external peace but by the Word and the Sacraments. For wherever you see a small group that has the true Word and the Sacraments, there the church is if only the pulpit and the baptismal font are pure. The church does not stand on the holiness of any one person but solely on the holiness and righteousness of the Lord Christ, for He has sanctified her by Word and Sacrament."
What Luther Says, An Anthology, 3 vols., ed., Ewald Plass, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959, I, p. 263. Matthew 24:4-7.
KJV Matthew 24:4 And Jesus answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man deceive you. 5 For many shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many. 6 And ye shall hear of wars and rumours of wars: see that ye be not troubled: for all these things must come to pass, but the end is not yet. 7 For nation shall rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom: and there shall be famines, and pestilences, and earthquakes, in divers laces.
Labels:
Luther,
Means of Grace
Katy Perry Has Probably Added a New Clause in the Contract:
No More Poses with Slobbering Fans
bored has left a new comment on your post "Tim Glende Did Not Transform This Narcissist":
I didn't see a line in the rider about banning the backstage area to pathetic Lutheran (sic) pastors.
Obviously the rider you found was outdated--pre Glende/Ski.
Labels:
Katy Perry,
MLC; Ski; MLS;Tim Glende;
Tim Glende Did Not Transform This Narcissist
The Smoking Gun
MAY 19--As she prepares to embark next month on the U.S. leg of her 2011 world tour, Katy Perry will be carrying a 45-page concert rider that outlaws carnations, details very specific furniture requirements, and outlines a 23-point “principle driver policy” for chauffeurs in towns the 26-year-old singer visits.

According to Perry’s rider, excerpted here, the performer’s dressing room (which has to be draped in cream or soft pink) needs to be outfitted with two cream-colored egg chairs, one of which should have a footstool. It is unclear whether Perry requires original Arne Jacobsens or cheap knockoffs. A coffee table needs to be “perspex modern style.” A pair of floor lamps should be in “French ornate style.” And the singer’s refrigerator must come with a glass door.
As for the dressing room’s flower arrangement, Perry wants “White and purple hydrangeas, pink & white roses and peonies.” If those flowers are not available, Perry will settle for a “selection of seasonal white flowers to include white orchids.” However, promoters are advised, “ABSOLUTELY NO CARNATIONS.” That warning is, of course, underlined.
In a commendable effort to curb the environmental impact of plastic bottles, Perry’s rider notes that water dispensers must be provided in all dressing rooms and production offices, and that tour personnel will be supplied with “SIGG drinking bottles.”
When it comes to hotel provisions, Perry requires a “1 bedroom presidential suite” in a “5 star property.” And free Internet service and a complimentary breakfast must be provided to the performer and her touring party.

The rider also alerts promoters that they may be required to hold back tickets for concerts so that Perry & Co. can provide the ducats to “resellers” for “distribution to the public” on the “secondary market.” In other words, Perry reserves the right to pocket some of the proceeds from the sale of tickets--not made available at face price to her fans--scalped at inflated prices by these brokers.
The quantity and location of tickets earmarked for these secondary markets will be determined by Perry’s “Personal Manager,” according to the rider, which was provided to TSG by our pal Jester. (6 pages)
Labels:
Katy Perry,
WELS
Another Example of WELS Abuse of Pastors
I cannot say more at this time. Some laws were broken, nothing new for WELS leaders.
Bored Scours the Popcornites And The Incensed
bored has left a new comment on your post "Lito Cruz, PhD - On Smells and Bells Lutherans":
I think the Smells and Bells contingent is just as motivated by Agenda as the Popcornites. Agendizing Christianity, regardless of what agenda, is the problem.
No one would mind real reverence, but when practices invented in the 8th century are thrust upon us, and we are told this is the only way to be reverent, then I ask "what's your agenda?"
Singing the Latin words of the Liturgy while everyone else sings English does not make you Holier. It makes you annoying.
You walk back to your seat after communion with closed eyes and bowed head, with your folded hands at arms length. You get an A for effort, but I think your holy-ometer was permanently damaged that time you bashed your knee into the radiator and nearly fell over.
***
GJ - I used to see Roman Catholic tabloid ads about worshiping with the Fourth Century Syrians. Buy the package! I would hear nuns at Notre Dame say, "Did you go to the 9:45 AM Mass? Wasn't that great?"
Performance.
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS
Luther - We May Not Surrender an Iota of Doctrine
"In philosophy an error that is small at the beginning becomes very great in the end. So a small error in theology overturns the whole body of doctrine...That is why we may not surrender or change even an iota (apiculum) of doctrine." What Luther Says, An Anthology, 3 vols., ed., Ewald Plass, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959, III, p. 1365. Galatians 5:9.
KJV Galatians 5:9 A little leaven leaveneth the whole lump.
---
AC V has left a new comment on your post "Lito Cruz, PhD - On Smells and Bells Lutherans":
GJ and LPC,
Comparatively speaking, liturgy-emphasizing confessional Lutherans turning to Rome is (sic) far less a problem than Church Growth pietist Lutherans taking an entire synod to Fuller.
***
GJ - One sentence is so packed with logical potholes that I will not try to unravel it.
I favor the formal, high church style of worship, but I do not think one fad is less dangerous than another. I pay attention to what people emphasize. When they make their actions more important than their doctrine, the first is a smokescreen for the second.
For instance, the Shrinkers hate the liturgy and insist on getting rid of Lutheran hymns, the Ecumenical Creeds, and Lutheran Biblical sermons. What the Shrinkers really believe is reflected in the messages they plagiarize - salvation by works in the absence of the Means of Grace. WELS, the Little Sect, and the CLC (sic) are completely captive to these oafs, and they cannot even acknowledge its existence - let alone its dominance.
The Romanizing crowd includes such posturing peacocks as Paul McCain, MDiv, whose peritus is Jack Kilcrease!; David Scaer, seminary doctorate; and Fenton, who left the bosom of Missouri UOJ for Eastern Orthodoxy. McCain and Scaer are as goofy about UOJ as the worst in WELS.
The problem is not the incense but the nebulous doctrine. The issue is not "extremes of worship" but foul doctrine. A Lutheran minister should be content to preach in a garage in a black robe with the incense shipment lost in recent floods, trusting in the efficacy of the Word.
A Lutheran minister will not hide the Sacraments, but he will not offer canonical law on the only possible way anyone could worship. I recall a worship professor at LSTC leading people down that path. When he was kicked out of teaching for liturgical fundamentalism, he took a parish call and became a leader in gay activism, having one of the first Reconciled in Christ congregations.
The pastors bewitched by such people as David Scaer should recognize that the LCA led the way in the same trends, following Rome. They should ask themselves why they all feel compelled to obey instructions from Rome on the three-year lectionary, liturgical observations, and even liturgical colors. Is this really the time to identify with the Antichrist and present such slavery as a better way to worship?
Suet Thief Wakes Us Up at 2 AM
I was asleep when all three dogs began carrying on. I heard odd noises around the window, where the birds feed and suet hangs. I just put new suet in the baskets. A third basket disappeared on the front side of the house, so I suspected a raccoon. Last year they put an end to the large bags of suet being hung outside, since each one lasted a day.
I keep a flashlight on the window sill, but I could not find the culprit at first. I waited until the burgling sounds started again. I shone the light at the window. The shameless raccoon faced into the light, a symbol of thievery and greed, his masked face limned with hunger. With my flashlight beam illuminating him, he reached up and effortless unhooked the basket holding the suet. It fell to the ground and he went down to finish it off.
We live in the woods, above a ravine, not too far from a creek. We enjoy seeing God's Creation at work around us.
Sign Him Up for Church Growth
Threats, Etc.
May 19, 2011
Patrick Edouard, 41, a former pastor at the Covenant Reformed Church in Pella was arrested March 23 and charged with three counts of sexual abuse 3rd degree, two counts of sexual exploitation and one count of sexual exploitation by a counselor.
Court records indicate that Edouard, pictured, forced sexual contact on at least three women while serving as the minister from 2003-10. Each sexual abuse complaint included statements that Edouard told the women that if they reported the abuse, no one would believe them. In one case, he told the woman that her husband would not forgive her.
In a written statement acquired by the Journal-Express, The Consistory at Covenant Reformed Church stated, "The congregation of Covenant Reformed Church has undergone a severe trial. We request all Christians be in prayer for us. There will be no further comment."
May 19, 2011
Edouard submits written not guilty plea
Steve Woodhouse Journal-Express
Pella — Accused former Pella Pastor Patrick Edouard has submitted a written plea of not guilty and waived his right to a speedy trial.Patrick Edouard, 41, a former pastor at the Covenant Reformed Church in Pella was arrested March 23 and charged with three counts of sexual abuse 3rd degree, two counts of sexual exploitation and one count of sexual exploitation by a counselor.
Court records indicate that Edouard, pictured, forced sexual contact on at least three women while serving as the minister from 2003-10. Each sexual abuse complaint included statements that Edouard told the women that if they reported the abuse, no one would believe them. In one case, he told the woman that her husband would not forgive her.
In a written statement acquired by the Journal-Express, The Consistory at Covenant Reformed Church stated, "The congregation of Covenant Reformed Church has undergone a severe trial. We request all Christians be in prayer for us. There will be no further comment."
Bruce Church on Extreme Makeovers and Takeovers
bruce-church (http://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Luther - The Word of God Brings Eternal Life - Not...":
LCMS DPs engineering closures or takeovers of churches that resist CG methods. A few weeks ago we learned about the Minnesota U chapel being sold, and now a DP takes over a church called Gloria Dei and gives it to a congregation called New Vision. Hmm:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/reclaimnews/message/241
***
GJ - Isn't that how Latte
Luther - The Word of God Brings Eternal Life - Not Love
"Therefore, do not speak to me of love or friendship when anything is to be detracted from the Word or the faith; for we are told that not love but the Word brings eternal life, God's grace, and all heavenly treasures." What Luther Says, An Anthology, 3 vols., ed., Ewald Plass, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959, III, p. 1411f. Ephesians 6:10-17.
Chemnitz - Quoting Origen on Doctrine
my dissertation advisor, put on the doctoral hood. Both have passed away and gone to their reward.
"Let him therefore who is concerned about his life not be taken in by the friendliness of heretics to agree with their doctrine. Neither let him be offended at my faults, who am a teacher, but let him consider the doctrine itself." Origen, Homily 7, on Ezekiel. Quoted by Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, trans., Fred Kramer, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1971, I, p. 154.
Lito Cruz, PhD - On Smells and Bells Lutherans
LPC has left a new comment on your post "Good Point about the Divinity of Mary":
They also want to show that a "real" Lutheran is RC friendly and anti-Prot.
This makes it easier, it lowers down the conscious resistance.
This is the effect of UOJ. Since in UOJ everyone is already saved before they even believed, life gets very stale and boring.
To preoccupy themselves with things that bring some novelty; they get into being busy about smells and bells, vestments, Momma Mary and even the rosary and yes, even the titles.
LPC
Labels:
Church of Rome
Kent Hunter, DMin Fuller - On Sound Doctrine
Kent Hunter: "Correct doctrine is essential. But it is never to be a priority at the expense of the mission. In fact, when the quest for proper doctrine intensifies to the point of neglecting mission and ministry, then it is no longer proper doctrine." Foundations for Church Growth, New Haven: Leader Publishing, 1983, pp. 152-3. Cited by Rev. Curtis Peterson, former WELS World Mission Board, "A Second and Third Look at Church Growth Principles," Metro South Pastors Conference Mishicot, Wisconsin, February 3, 1993 p. 21.
Curtis A. Peterson holds a B.A. from Concordia Senior College, Ft. Wayne, Indiana, and a M.Div and STM (l966 and l983 respectively) from Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, Missouri.
In almost 30 years in the ministry in both the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods, he was an activist with many published articles supporting the orthodox Lutheran cause in the "Battle for the Bible" in the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod, and author of several articles in the Wisconsin Synod between l987 and l995. He also delivered several essays at pastoral conferences during those years.
He served congregations in Burlington, N.C., Rock Falls, Ill., Garland, Tex. and Gretna, La., in the LCMS and in Milwaukee, Wis. in the WELS.
A Foundation member, he is now retired, resides in Wisconsin and calls himself a humanist and a freethinker.
Freedom From Religion Foundation
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS; CLC (sic)
Thursday, May 19, 2011
LSTC Prez Resigns
LSTC News Release
James Kenneth Echols resigns as LSTC president
Posted May 18, 2011
“President Echols has provided visionary leadership for LSTC and among the ELCA seminaries,” said the Rev. Dr. Philip Hougen, chair of the board of directors. “Under his leadership, LSTC successfully completed an ambitious $56 million comprehensive campaign, built the Augustana Chapel and created the Cornelsen Director of Spiritual Formation position. Dr. Echols also helped create A Center of Christian-Muslim Engagement for Peace and Justice, making LSTC one of the top 20 seminaries in the U.S. in interfaith studies. Over the last several years he has initiated efforts to get the ELCA seminaries to collaborate more closely to better serve the church.”
After the ELCA entered into a full communion agreement with the Presbyterian Church U.S.A., Dr. Echols led LSTC in a decade-long closer collaboration with McCormick Theological Seminary (PCUSA). He has been a leader in the ELCA and in the wider community, serving on the board of the ELCA Division for Ministry, the executive committee of the Association of Theological Schools in the United States and Canada, and the steering committee of the USA Section of the Council of International Black Lutherans. He is the editor of I Have a Dream: Martin Luther King Jr. and the Future of Multicultural America (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2004).
Echols was elected president of LSTC in May 1997. He served as academic dean at the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia (LTSP) from 1991-1997. He joined the LTSP faculty in 1982, teaching American Church History. Since 2005 he has team taught, with Dr. Albert “Pete” Pero, The Theology of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. course at LSTC.
A native of Philadelphia, Echols received the bachelor of arts degree from Temple University and the master of divinity degree from the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia. He continued his studies at Yale University, where he received the degrees of master of arts, master of philosophy, and doctor of philosophy in the history of Christianity.
The LSTC board of directors has appointed the Rev. Dr. Philip Hougen to serve as acting president while it prepares for a presidential search. Ms. Sarah Stegemoeller was elected as chairperson of the board at its May 15-17 meeting in Chicago.
Y'all Have To Remember That Every Lutheran Is Confessional, No Matter What They Profess
As a confessional church, the Lutheran community affirms the normative authority of Scripture and tradition. Lutherans also insist that Christ and the gospel are the hermeneutical key for interpreting both Scripture and tradition. The gospel, which always points us to Christ, is, therefore, the interpretative lens in light of which the biblical and theological heritage of the church must be understood, evaluated and affirmed.
As a Lutheran community, part of the body of Christ, we also share with you our experience of Christ’s refreshing spirit in our seminary community. Here at LSTC, we have been blessed by lively and faithful conversations with lesbian, gay, bi-sexual and transgender students and pastors in our midst about matters of sexuality, gender identity, and committed relationships to human partners and God. We see firsthand the hope, the pain, and the joy in these conversations. While we do not always agree with each other, we discover Christ’s spirit in this fellowship. Deeply committed to our unity in Christ, we once were emboldened to ordain free and former slaves, whites together with peoples of color, women and men alike, to serve as pastors of the church. We must now broaden that circle to include a yet more full company of God’s children who confess the gospel and the lordship of Christ Jesus.
The undersigned members of the LSTC faculty:
Klaus-Peter Adam
Terrence Baeder
Kathleen D. Billman
Kurt Hendel
Esther Menn
Raymond Pickett
José D. Rodriguez
Craig Satterlee
Lea Schweitz
Michael Shelley
Benjamin Stewart
Rosanne Swanson
Linda E. Thomas
Barbara Rossing
David Rhoads
Peter Vethanayagamony
Christine Wenderoth
VÃtor Westhelle
We also refer to the ‘Appropriate Next Steps for the ELCA’ that can be found under http://prophetess.lstc.edu/~rklein/
Lutheran School of Theology Faculty Statement, 2009 |
***
GJ - I spotted this, trying to find out why the LSTC president resigned. It was not directly because of this, but I do imagine that funding has dropped like a stone since 2009. LSTC was a sucker's bet from the beginning, Conrad Bergendoff's dream of having his denomination sharing space with his alma mater, the U. of Chicago.
I used to go there and use the seminary library for research on my dissertation.
JBS Speakers Bureau Includes a Bishop
John Birch Society Speakers Bureau Rt. Rev. James Heiser | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Wednesday, 04 June 2008 08:07 |
![]() In 1995, Heiser earned his M. Div. from Concordia Theological Seminary (Fort Wayne, Indiana). He served as a Graduate Assistant for Systematic Theology at Concordia (1995–6), and as an Assistant Professor at Luther Bible College in Rockford, IL (1996–1998), during part of which time he also served as the ordained Deacon of Our Redeemer Lutheran Church (Forsyth, IL). Since 1998, Heiser has served as Pastor of Salem Lutheran Church in Malone, Texas, while maintaining his responsibilities as publisher of Repristination Press, which he established in 1993 to publish academic and popular theological books to serve the Lutheran Church. In addition to his service at Salem Lutheran Church, Heiser has also served since 2005 as the Dean of Missions for The Augustana Ministerium and in 2006 was called to serve as Bishop of the Evangelical Lutheran Diocese of North America (ELDoNA). An advocate of manned space exploration, Heiser serves on the Steering Committee of the Mars Society. His publications include two books; The Office of the Ministry in N. Hunnius' Epitome Credendorum (1996) and A Shining City on a Higher Hill: Christianity and the Next New World (2006), as well as dozens of journal articles and book reviews. He resides in Hillsboro, Texas with his wife and children. |
Labels:
ELDONA; Eastern Orthodox
Testimony from Taiwan:
Recommends Liberalism To His 4,000 FB Friends
Kevin Shen is first-generation American. His father is a doctor who returned to Taiwan with his wife, to head a clinic there. We met Kevin in St. Louis, about 20 years ago. We took him to church each week.
Since I had mentioned about this book in my last posting's comments thread about Liberalism creeping into and poisoning once Bible-Believing Churches, I would like to share this book that is about this Liberalism seeping into Churches, written by Pastor Gregory L. Jackson. Pastor Jackson had first led me to a saving knowledge of Jesus Christ and is a good friend of mine whom I have known for many years.

www.amazon.com
Liberalism: Its Cause and Cure : The Poisoning of American Christianity and the Antidote
***
GJ - Kevin thought it was quite funny that I had to buy a copy of my own book to produce a new edition. Most of my books still float around the used market.
Everything is available as a free PDF download here. The print copies can be ordered there too.
A friend from my family's Disciples of Christ church asked for doctrinal books, so I am sending two copies of Catholic, Lutheran, Protestant.
Brett Meyer gave away 50 copies of Luther versus the UOJ Pietists: Justification by Faith at the Emmaus conference.
Kevin wondered if the free PDF could be shared with others. I said, "If I tried to get money for the PDF download, some people would not pay, for many reasons, from lack of money to not have a plastic card to pay for it. This way, someone in India or Ghana can have all the books they want to download. The difference between getting all I can and giving a lot away is not that much anyway."
Kevin was impressed that a 20 year-old book, which he dug out recently, was so accurate in predicting what would happen today in the mainline churches. I have found that being 20-25 years ahead of church leaders is no guarantee for popularity in the visible church.
Mrs. Ichabod talked to him too. They discussed laying up treasures in heaven. He was given no hope for living after a horrific traffic accident four years ago. Now he realizes how fleeting are the treasures on earth. Kevin knows cars. He said I would need to spend $100,000 to get as roomy a car as my ancient Lincoln, if I bought a new Mercedes limo. Needless to say, we are both Going Galt.
Most of the time, publishing means getting plenty of negative feedback. In fact, the day I got my first copies of Liberalism, the Shrinker faction pounced at the council meeting. That book really made the leadership of WELS angry. The final chapter threw Kovaciny, Oelhafen, and Adrian into loud tantrums, when it was delivered as conference paper. The Cure chapter is about the Holy Spirit working through the Word and contains actual criticism of Fuller Seminary and Church Growth. The conference refused to "approve" the paper, which says a lot about WELS and the Means of Grace. If I had questioned clergy adultery, they would have executed me on the spot.
Worst of all, the book became an immediate best-seller for NPH when they expected little interest in doctrinal books.
Liberalism was also the only book not reprinted in the latest version. But they gave me the rights to it, and they have been generous in sending me books to review. NPH was great about promoting Catholic, Lutheran, Protestant.
Labels:
Martin Chemnitz Press
Portrait of the Parson as a Young Heretic
Barth and Fuller Seminary
I have to start with Karl Barth of Switzerland. As readers know, he was a Communist, an adulterer, an intellectual fraud, and an apostate. His mistress wrote most of his Dogmatics and hardly anything was written after Charlotte Kirschbaum died. His students must have known, because she lived in his home with Karl, wife Nellie, and his children.
Barth's carnal adultery damaged his own soul and harmed his entire family. His spiritual adultery cast a long shadow over all of modern theology, because he is the most influential of all Protestant theologians of the 20th century.
My Notre Dame advisor, John Howard Yoder, was his student, and doubtless got some his peculiar ideas from Barth. Yoder, as detailed in Hannah's Child, was disciplined by his Mennonite congregation and conference for having a number of Mennonite women become intimate with him.
Two leaders of Fuller Seminary were students of Barth, taking his neo-apostasy back with them and changing the entire mission of the school. Instead of being a conservative Evangelical school, Fuller became a feminist anything-goes ecumenical mainline school, openly opposed to inerrancy and scornful of those who labored under such delusions. The conservative staff quit and Donald McGavran, sociologist, entered with his Church Growth concepts, with a Barthian foundation. One WELS graduate of Fuller confirmed in a letter that Barth was Fuller's official theologian.
The Barth effect could also be seen in the School of Psychology being named after a sex offender so notorious that they had to remove his name from it once the facts came out.
St. Paul, German Village, Columbus
The LCMS kicked Floyd Luther Stolzenburg out of the ministry "for cause." The better term might be "for many, many causes." His wife divorced him and she gained custody of their children. The husband of his mistress sued Floyd, the staff of Salem in Blackjack (St. Louis) and other LCMS entities.
Floyd came back to Columbus, following his ex-wife and shopped for a job. The public school system would not hire him. Various denominations would not hire him when they checked up on his exit from Salem, Black Jack. Floyd visited St. Paul, German Village, which was loosely affiliated with WELS, on its own terms.
The story is that Floyd got funded because his father was a business pal of The Donor. He started Luther Parish Resources as a Church Growth agency, but the new board refused to hire him. The Donor doubled the ante, so LPR hired Roger Zehms (divorced WELS pastor, St. Louis) and then Floyd. Both men worked out of The Donor's real estate office.
LPR
LPR consisted of two divorced ex-pastors acting like the supervisors of the Columbus WELS congregations. The whole concept, as Wally Oelhafen admitted, was to get Floyd a WELS parish after a decent interval, and DP Robert Mueller and VP Paul Kuske recommended him for colloquy.
Mueller and Kuske gave the ex-pastors years to promote Church Growth and cause trouble in the local congregations. I thought the LCA was bad, but I have never seen such evil in one group of congregations. Good was bad, and bad was good, according to WELS.
Stolzenburg was never a member of WELS and said he would never join. St. Paul, German Village, was handy for playing the chameleon. Nevertheless, Kuske and Bob Schumann both wrote letters of recommendation for Floyd, and Floyd got hired at the sister church of St. Paul, Emmanuel (also independent and Masonic). The Masons wanted Floyd, who pledged in a letter to commune them.
Poor Little Tim Glende
Glende had the misfortune of growing up in a circuit of delusions. The circuit pastor did not hold circuit meetings until I raised the issue. Floyd had no business even being a lay leader, let alone a fake pastor, but that was supported 100% by his own pastor, VP Kuske, and DP Mueller. In fact, no one in the entire Michigan District objected - except for me.
Floyd taught Church Growth at St. Paul, German Village. He promoted CG in Columbus and wherever WELS could trick people into listening to him. He became a leader of the Ohio WELS women's group, too, with his second wife. Floyd was famous for his work with the LCMS women's groups. I will leave the details out, but SP Jack Preus told me that Floyd was famous all over North St. Louis.
Bullying and Fears
People objected to Floyd's obnoxious behavior, but his guard dogs were always there to snarl at anyone who dared to object. When some pastors objected to Floyd giving a paper at the Ohio Conference, the objection was made to look like a crime.
Kuske is still remembered for being the dean of boys at Michigan Lutheran Seminary. The students called it The Reign of Terror. I suspect he was called to Grove City to spare future generations his methods. Sparky Brenner followed, and Kuske was visibly jealous of his replacement.
When Floyd got his job at Emmanuel, one member was terrified of being known for objecting to him. That person did the research that WELS lied about. Copies of the lawsuit floated about, but nothing came of it.
ELS, Thoughts of Faith, More Lies
Thanks to Roger Kovaciny, WELS, and Jay Webber, ELS - Floyd's Masonic congregation became a donor to Thoughts of Faith in the Ukraine. St. Marvin of Schwan gave most of the loot, which disappeared faster than a cheese factory on its way over.
Floyd's Emmanuel newsletters, which I received from a friend, bragged about their association with Thoughts of Faith. His website also boasted about it and published photos.
Somehow Emmanuel got a matching grant from Schwan to send money to TOF for a chapel. That means WELS/ELS got behind this project, because they had Marvin in their pocket. He was making regular down-payments on his indulgence, where the two sects and Missouri erased the Sixth Commandment. Or maybe they omitted the not, as the printers did in the Sinner's Bible.
Once Floyd and Schumann (another Shrinker) had Columbus to themselves, the whole situation at St. Paul, German Village blew up. Schumann was forced to resign for false doctrine, which had been quite blatant. He is now a loud atheist, like another WELS Shrinker, Curtis Peterson. Nitz left for Arizona. St. Paul is a fraction of what it once was, after decades of Church GROWTH.
The Evil Continues
I was the only WELS pastor who objected to Church Growth and kept at it. Some voiced some objections and were shut down in various ways. I remember two of them who told a mutual friend, "We are going silent so we can get the calls we want." They got their calls as a reward.
Jay Webber told me that I should publish this and that. He never did, of course. He wanted to go to the Ukraine and did. I thought Webber and Kovaciny in the Ukraine together was the ultimate punishment for both of them.
WELS/ELS bullying methods do not stop with the person who dissents. They bully the entire family. Nothing is too low for them. Thus WELS and the Little Sect reproduce bullying and enforced brain-dead conformity.
The Church Growth Movement should really be called the Copy and Paste Movement, because the only thing LPR, Stolzenburg, Zehms, Kelm, WELS, and the ELS did was copy what the Enthusiasts promoted in the worst of their parishes.
Thus Glende is only doing what he was taught at his home congregation in German Village, his WELS schools, and in the officially supported WELS Church and Change sorority. The drama queens of Church and Change scream and sob like someone's baby sister whenever they are caught in their skullduggery. But they have no remorse about what they do to the laity and to those they choose to exclude.
Unfortunately, many in WELS think that is the only reality. A good number have grown up in towns where they never spoke to a non-WELS member. Like old-fashioned Mennonites, they are quick to shun and have deep emotional problems from being shunned.
The secrecy and lying are quite impressive in WELS. The Columbus pastors never told the truth about Stolzenburg and Zehms...or anything else. They even denied LPR was started to promote Church Growth. They said that the idiot vicar who wrote the paper about LPR did not know what he was talking about. That idiot vicar, David Peters, was later a doctoral student at Marquette, and his vicar's office was packed full of CG books when he left. He must have seen the light, because he became part of Issues in WELS, aka That Union Grove Bunch.
Deceit is the primary management method of WELS. Wayne Mueller denied CG in WELS while running all the CG programs. One of The Love Shack honchos came down to Columbus and suggested that Floyd was the best person to run the "Precious Is the Child" evangelism flop. Floyd smiled broadly. It was CG speaking to CG and showing that the leadership of WELS was behind him 100%, just as they were behind Al Just and William Tabor.
The laity and pastors are ordered to address the most grievous problems in one particular way, which is always wrong. Therefore, all questions end up being the reasons for getting rid of someone. Write a letter! - but the reply TOP SECRET EYES ONLY. So the leaders have rope for the hanging but their response, if revealed, is even more rope for the hanging. Neat system. Their Father Below doubtless looks up in awe at them.
They have no problem with brutalizing people, so their astonishing level of adultery and alcoholism are just symptoms of the deeper problem.
WELS is loveless because they have no Gospel. They teach 10,000 man-made laws replacing the 10 Commandments. They have no Gospel because everyone is born forgiven. The only things they really care about are utterly false - UOJ and Church Growth plagiarism.
Tim Glende is so clueless that he blogs to show how little he comprehends about being a pastor:
- He does not give his name, but he did slow down and tone down once I identified him as the author.
- He condemns Lutheran authors although he routinely plagiarizes Methodist-Babtists.
- He has nothing to offer but condemnation. There is no Gospel on his blog, no edifying quotations, no inspirational pictures. His idea of humor is to show people I know (named, no less) eating fecal matter from a toilet.
- Although DP Englebrecht seems as spineless and inept as the rest of the WE:S DPs, he is just as thuggish as Glende, because he endorses and encourages this behavior.
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS; CLC (sic)
Millions for the Colleges, Hardly a Dime for the LCMS Seminaries
Bruce Church has left a new comment on your post "Lutheran Seminary Fraud: Students Are Bankrupting ...":
When former President Kieschnick said that the ten Concordia U's were the "crown jewels" of the Missouri Synod's higher educational system, he put the synod's money where his mouth was. While Missouri HQ only gives $150,000 to each seminary each year, it turns out that the synod has assumed debt for the Concordia U system, and subsidizes them to the tune of $20 million each year! That means of undesignated funds coming from offerings to the synod, $2 million goes toward each CU campus yearly on average! So Kieschnick wasn't kidding about the Concordia U's being the crown jewels, while the seminaries must be the footstools.
Then after President Kieschnick has a hand in signing over all that synod money to the Concordia U's, he gets a job raising money for CTX (Concordia U-Texas). That reminds me the revolving employment door between corporate lobbyists, industry regulators, and the industry they regulate, whether that be coil, oil, natural gas, etc. It also reminds me of how Germany Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder had Germany do big business with the Russian state business Gazprom, and as soon as he was out of office, he got a job with Gazprom.
I think the synods need a full disclosure statement when their leaders recommend their schools, similar to statements news programs have, for example, if PBS Newshour does a story on Shell Oil, they come out and say BTW Shell is an underwriter for the Newshour. I mean, how much stock would one put in the praise of a synodical official for an education institution if after he said it he disclosed that there's a revolving door of employment between synod leaders and the Concordia U's? Or that the synod took on so much CU debt that it takes nearly $20 million per year just to service it? Or that if students didn't attend CU's in sufficient numbers, the synod would have to subsidize the CU's even more and lay off synodical staff to do it?--just as President Harrison had to do lately when funds ran short. He paid the CU bill first while laying off 50 synodical workers.
----------
A Pastoral Letter to Pastors of The Lutheran Church--Missouri Synod
From President Jerry Kieschnick, Apr 2010:
http://www.trinitymenasha.com/Portals/trinitymenasha/docs/Newsletters/April%202010.pdf
Our system of higher education is a crown jewel of our Synod,
and I thank God for all 12 of these institutions and the service they render to God and our Synod.
--
President Harrison May 2011 Lutheran Witness:
http://classic.lcms.org/pages/wPagex.asp?ContentID=1012&IssueID=55
Some 26 percent of the unrestricted dollars received go to service the $20 million in historic debt of the Concordia University System, including interest and to subsidize educational operations.
Kieschnick's new job:
http://steadfastlutherans.org/?p=14012
In his new role, Kieschnick will nurture and expand existing relationships with congregations, organizations, foundations and individuals to support Concordia in its mission of developing Christian leaders...
Gerhard Schröder's Gazprom scandal:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerhard_Schröder#Gazprom
Wednesday, May 18, 2011
One More for the Icha-peekers.*
Mary Lou College Students Should Not Waste Their Time Reading This.
I posted the doctrinal graphic, below, on Facebook, for my 1300 friends.
A Roman Catholic friend copied the graphic and posted it for all her friends. I have also noticed Lutheran friends quoting from the graphics too.
This illustrates what Luther said about a stone thrown into a pond. The influence of the Gospel moves outward, pressing on, even when halted or persecuted.
* - An Icha-peeker is someone who goes to the computer to look for the last post of the day, in case there is a new one. The wives who wait for them are called Icha-widows, since they often feel a need to send a comment for the new post. Mrs. Ichabod considers herself the first Icha-widow.
Attaching the blog name to family members began early in the blogger revolution. Since then, other terms have been added by Icha-readers.
Good Point about the Divinity of Mary
bored has left a new comment on your post "The Book of Concord Does Not Support the Divinity ...":
This is a good point to make. I've seen many of the "genuflection-guild" unsurreptiously cross themselves whenever Mary's name is mentioned. Accompanied by it is the quick look around to notice who noticed how holy they are.
***
GJ - That was a good litotes, Bored. I might have said "overtly," but your double negative yielding a positive (litotes - for the Mequon grads) is right on target.
I find this trend alarming and dishonest. Many Lutheran clergy are adopting a high church style to show how confessional they are, but the real agenda is to ease into Romanism and take people with them.
The late Richard John Neuhaus did this with great success. Avery Dulles, SJ--nicknamed A Very Dull SJ--converted him, and Neuhaus took a number of Lutheran clergy into the papacy with him.
David Scaer appreciated this quality in Neuhaus, so he invited Father Neuhaus (formerly LCMS, then AELC, then LCA, finally Church of Rome) to lecture the innocents at Ft. Wayne. A witness said that about half the audience nodded in agreement with Neuhaus as he beat the drums for Rome in his propaganda speech - "How I Became the Catholic I Always Was."
That is why I call Ft. Wayne The Surrendered Fort.
That is why Scaer invited the apostate Jack Kilcrease to speak there.
The best way to tell if a layman or pastor is poping is to listen to him talk about the Virgin Mary. Veneration of Mary is the surest sign of popery. The Church of Rome is devoted to teaching works-salvation and the mercy of Mary.
Mary is the Queen of Purgatory, according to Rome. She visits the souls suffering for thousands of years in Purgatory, because the Atonement of Christ was not enough to pay for all their sins. The works they did on earth were not enough to earn their salvation. The money given and prayers offered after their deaths are inadequate to redeem them from the debtors' prison, but some relief is possible.
The souls in Purgatory will return to earth and do special favors for Catholics and the Eastern Orthodox. These ghosts will help them get jobs and protect them from harm.
Labels:
Church of Rome
Luther - The Word of God Is the Light
In a Dark and Gloomy Place
"Thus this text also strongly opposes all human doctrine; for since the Word of God is the light in a dark and gloomy place, the conclusion follows that all besides it is darkness. For if there were another light besides the Word, Peter would not have spoken as he did. Therefore look not to how gifted with reason they are who teach any other doctrine--however grandly they set it forth. If you cannot trace God's Word in it, then doubt not that it is mere darkness. And let it not disturb you at all that they say they have the Holy Spirit. How can they have God's Spirit if they do not have His Word? Wherefore they do nothing else but call darkness light and make the light darkness, as the prophet Isaiah says, in Isaiah 5:20."
Martin Luther, Commentary on Peter and Jude, ed. John N. Lenker, Grand Rapids: Kregel Publications, 1990, p. 248. 2 Peter 1:19.
We have also a more sure word of prophecy; whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the day star arise in your hearts: Knowing this first, that no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation. 2 Peter 1:19-20, KJV.
Andreae, Who Initiated the Book of Concord,
Taught Justification by Faith
"Concerning the article on the justification of the poor sinner in God's sight, we believe, teach, and confess on the basis of God's Word and the position of our Christian Augsburg Confession that the poor, sinful person is justified in God's sight--that is, he is pronounced free and absolved of his sins and receives forgiveness for them--only through faith, because of the innocent, complete, and unique obedience and the bitter sufferings and death of our Lord Jesus Christ, not because of the indwelling, essential righteousness of God or because of his own good works, which either precede or result from faith. We reject all doctrines contrary to this belief and confession."
Jacob Andreae, Confession and Brief Explanation of Certain Disputed Articles, Robert Kolb, Andreae and the Formula of Concord, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1977, p. 58.
Essay on Andreae
Labels:
Andreae,
Book of Concord
Luther - Through the Bible, And No Other Book,
Heaven Is Opened, Satan Locked Up
"For him who believes and keeps Christ's Word heaven stands open and hell is locked. The devil is also taken captive, sin is forgiven, and the believer is a child of life eternal. This is taught by this Book, Holy Scripture, and by no other book on earth. For this reason let him who would live forever study in it diligently. He who does not do so and does not want to do so is and remains in death eternal."
What Luther Says, An Anthology, 3 vols., ed. Ewald Plass, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959, I, p. p. 82. John 8:51.
KJV John 8:51 Verily, verily, I say unto you, If a man keep my saying, he shall never see death.
Lenski - On Sugarcoating the Gospel.
Clown Ministry Is a Gift from WELS Church and Change,
Mark and Avoid Jeske.
"Paul offers no excuse for preachers who desire to eliminate certain teachings of the gospel on the plea that they can thus reach and attract more people than if they insisted also on these teachings. Paul intends to omit, even in his own mind, any addition to the gospel, any admixture, any sugar-coating of it by human, worldly wisdom." R. C. H. Lenski, The Interpretation of St. Paul's First and Second Epistle to the Corinthians, Columbus: Wartburg Press, 1946, p. 89. 1 Corinthians 2:2.
KJV 1 Corinthians 2:2 For I determined not to know any thing among you, save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.
Krauth - An Age of Darkness Is a Creedless Age
"An age of darkness is a creedless age; corruption in doctrine works best when it is unfettered by an explicit statement of that doctrine." Charles P. Krauth, The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology, Philadelphia: The United Lutheran Publication House, 1871, p. 215.
Hebrews on the Word of God
KJV Hebrews 4:12 For the Word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart. 13 Neither is there any creature that is not manifest in His sight: but all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of Him with whom we have to do.
Let My People Go
Brookfield Church To Break Away from ELCA
By The WTMJ News Team
BROOKFIELD - Calvary Lutheran Church in Brookfield has chosen to break away from the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.In 2009, the ELCA voted to allow gay and lesbian clergy.
Calvary council member Larry Bonier says sexuality has little to do with them breaking away.
"There is also a move by the ELCA to water down the teachings of the Bible, and that's a problem that our congregation had," said Bonier.
Bonier says mebers also feel the ELCA is too controlling and doesn't give individual congregations enough power.
A second area church is also considering breaking away.
Philosophy Determines the Conclusion
I read Hauerwas' memoirs earlier and posted some thoughts. Recently I have re-read most the book, realizing how useful the narrative is for people wondering about modern theology.
Philosophy and theology are closely related, especially since the Christian Church began in the Roman Empire and used classical culture to express the Faith. Philosophy determines the conclusion of argumentation, because philosophy is the net that holds the facts.
For example, the Grand Canyon is a fact, a colorful ditch 10 miles across. I grew up being taught "The Colorado River slowly carved the canyon out of rock over millions of years." The philosophy behind this conclusion is evolution, natural causes, no Creator please, we are scientific now. The Genesis Flood cannot be included in the argument because the Bible is considered a charming bundle of myths, even though we have a modern example of a rush of water creating an impressive (but smaller) canyon overnight. Add a patio cleaning attachment to your garden hose and watch a mini-demo, as rocks blow away from the water stream like popcorn.
Modern theology is grounded in modern philosophy. I remember the panic induced when I was studying for the doctoral exams - three full days of writing. I had to pass those exams to move onto the dissertation phase. I tried to study Kant and modern philosophy, because Kant was basic to modern theology.
Briefly, modern philosophy is completely detached from the Biblical concept of the efficacy of God's Word.
Also, no one deals with the fact that Tillich was pathologically immoral, that Barth was a Communist fraud who let his mistress do all his writing for him, after he sketched the outline (the big print in the Dogmatics).
When Barth's mistress, Charlotte Kirschbaum, died, his publishing came to a halt. He finally dedicated a volume to his long-suffering wife, Nellie. Anyone can see the early dedication to Kirschbaum and the final one to Nellie in the books published today.
But these matters are inconsequential to modern theologians, because their philosophy excludes the Word of God from their thought, except to cite when convenient. To be bound to the Word as the revelation of God is too constricting.
I have noticed the impossibility of dealing with "conservative" Lutheran clergy and leaders, because they begin with the rationalistic philosophy of Pietism. As anyone can see from the doctrinal graphics I have posted, the Book of Concord and the great Lutheran theologians teach justification by faith.
But when the current leaders see those passages, which they rarely contemplate, they see their double-justification from the Pietist theologian, Georg Christian Knapp (still in print today, after 180 years.)
Moreover, the same leaders embrace the 10,000 rules of Pietism while excluding the 10 Commandments (except the 8th, which does not apply to them...ever). This neo-Pietistic philosophy is useful in ignoring all false doctrine and condemning those few who point it out.
Pietism is excellent at sanctimony while excusing amoral behavior - "We have never been good at sanctification," an old WELS excuse for clergy hedonism. Tim Glende's anonymous blog is typical for his holier-than-thou condemnation of Lenski and other authors he is too dense to understand.
His uncle John Brug's magnum opus, The Ministry of the Word, is a Pietistic disaster.
Pietism is a form of Enthusiasm, separating the Holy Spirit from the Word of God. If an author has no use for the efficacious Word working through the Means of Grace, he is not a Lutheran and will undoubtedly distrust any genuine Lutheran author.
How many Lutherans have heard that "this exciting new program
The reason Missouri, WELS, and the Little Sect have engaged in marketing, cutesy-wutesy songs on Sunday, and clever tricks is their reliance on Pietism.
Where is the proof? The outcome, Halle's UOJ Pietism, points to the philosophical foundation of the new-Synodical Conference, the "separated brethren" who actually work closely together with each other and with ELCA. Like Jack Kilcrease, they can move from WELS to ELCA to Romanism without breaking into a sweat, because UOJ Pietism means never having to say you're sorry.
I was trying to make sense out of Hauerwas' book when I ran into a passage that explained everything. Robert Wilken (LCMS, Seminex, ELCA, Roman Catholic now) explained this or that to him about Lutheran doctrine. Wilken is an apostate who believes nothing, like many church historians. Claiming to understand Lutheran doctrine via a conversation with Wilken is an easy way to escape Luther.
The Reformer had a philosophy, the Scriptures. He subordinated all books to the Bible. That is the great divide. Either one adopts this approach or rejects it.
That explains why Lutheran laity cannot have a real conversation with the clergy about doctrine. The Syn Conference clergy filter everything through their Pietistic training.
Rick Tecklin: "You should not be plagiarizing Craig Groeschel."
Tim Glende: "My uncle is John Brug." (The children of faculty are never held accountable for their folly. Ask Marc Schroeder and his second wife.)
Rick: "Groeschel is a false teacher."
Glende: "I graduated from WLS." (Poor students, if they have the right relatives, are never wrong. Good students, lacking the right DNA, are always wrong.)
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS; CLC (sic)
Lito Cruz, PhD - On Australian Private Schools
LPC has left a new comment on your post "Lutheran Is Not a Holy Word":
Bruce,
In Australia, there are not enough students to support an Evangelical school. So consequently they have to open up their student population to the secularist families. The Evangelical community is so small to pay for the bills.
What happens next is that the secular students out number the Evangelical students. The majority becomes the lobby group.
Thankfully in here, the word Lutheran is blazoned in the billboards and compared to the Evangelical schools (I choke to say Evangelical since it is a Lutheran word originally) they have a higher academic standard. Even Evangelical families are sending their kids to Lutheran schools.
I am sure they could have simply renamed the school to generic Christian brand and they would get more success, but thankfully, the Lutheran brand name has not been despised yet.
LPC
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS; CLC (sic)
The Promise Cannot Be Received Unless By Faith -
Apology of the Augsburg Confession
"Now, that faith signifies, not only a knowledge of the history, but such faith as assents to the promise, Paul plainly testifies when he says, Romans 4:16: 'Therefore it is of faith, to the end the promise might be sure.' For he judges that the promise cannot be received unless by faith. Wherefore he puts them together as things that belong to one another, and connects promise and faith." Apology of the Augsburg Confession, Article IV, 50. Justification, Concordia Triglotta, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1921, p. 135. Tappert, p. 114. Heiser, p. 36. Romans 4:16.
Labels:
Book of Concord
Melanchthon - Justification by Faith
"But since we receive remission of sins and the Holy Ghost by faith alone, faith alone justifies, because those reconciled are accounted righteous and children of God, not on account of their own purity, but through mercy for Christ's sake, provided only they by faith apprehend this mercy." Apology of the Augsburg Confession, IV. #86. Of Justification, Concordia Triglotta, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1921, p. 147. Tappert, p. 119. Heiser, p. 39.
The Book of Concord Does Not Support the Divinity of Mary
"Granting that the blessed Mary prays for the Church, does she receive souls in death, [the example of her faith and her humility]. But the subject itself declares that in public opinion the blessed Virgin has succeeded altogether to the place of Christ. Men have invoked her, have trusted in her mercy, through her have desired to appease Christ, as though He were not a Propitiator, but only a dreadful judge and avenger." Apology Augsburg Confession, XXI. #27. Saints. Concordia Triglotta, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1921, p. 349f. Tappert, p. 232f. Heiser, p. 106.
Labels:
Book of Concord
Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Lutheran Is Not a Holy Word
LutherRocks has left a new comment on your post "Holy Word (sic) Changes the Name of Their School":
The decision...and I kid you not...was based on the observation of the school principal being at various education fairs. He noticed that even though he had a well designed display booth from WELS, the booths that had way more 'traffic' were the ones who had 'christian' in their name. Didn't you know the most effective scientific conclusions are based on a feeling? What's the matter with you? Did you forget to take your diaprax today?
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS; CLC (sic)
Another Step Downward
AC V has left a new comment on your post "Why All the "Christian Academies" Popping Up in WE...":
This is what happens when LESs and LHSs become "outreach" oriented. True story: Because area LCMS high school has enrollment of 40% non-denom students, the High School Association of LCMS congregations is considering admitting to the Ass. the non-denom church with greatest number of students enrolled in said LCMS-HS in order to give policy voting rights.
'nother factoid: Students required to attend religion classes. So as not to offend non-denom students, test questions are worded thus-ly:
"Agree or Disagree: Re the Lord's Supper, the Lutheran tradition teaches the Real Presence." (There is a conscious effort to avoid saying "The Bible teaches...." so as not to put sacrament-denying, non-denom tuition-paying students on the spot.)
***
GJ - With UOJ, none of this matters, and that is why it has happened.
Floyd Luther Stolzenburg had the WELS laity calling this "Christian-bashing." Yes, any talk about false doctrine or heterodoxy was Christian-bashing.
Bruce Church Defends Hypocrisy in the Missouri Synod
LutherRocks has left a new comment on your post "Bruce Church Defends Hypocrisy in the Missouri Syn...":
I prefer the pensive photo earlier in the post than the photoshop...it is more contrived...
bruce-church (http://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Lutheran Seminary Fraud: Students Are Bankrupting ...":
Grumpy, I can make an educated guess as to what's happening. If a MLC graduate doesn't make the cut for a call right out of college, he or she can prove his or her dedication to the WELS by taking an overseas call, but that might be (often is) just teaching ESL for a year. At least that maintains a person's spot in the call pool. If he or she didn't do that, or find another teaching job, their position in the call pool would erode, and eventually they'd be out of the pool altogether. Then they'd have to take a few classes as refresher to get back in the pool, I suspect.
I know in the Missouri synod seminary students can't opt to take off a year or two after graduation and expect to come back and receive a call. A person can only receive CRM status after being in the ministry for a while--how long I don't know. Maybe it at the discretion of the DP. They even do that for sem students too--no breaks in seminary schooling or can't get back into the system. Unfortunately, they encourage a student to come to seminary even though he might want to put it off a year or two or three until he's really ready. THEN, once he's in they tell him he can't leave and expect to get back in! It's insane. If he knew that going in, he would have chosen to wait to start until his situation was optimal and he built up his motivation.
About the CRM status. To keep on it one must preach now and then or he drops off the clergy roster altogether. Ironically, Dr. Jackson gets on Paul McCain's case for wearing a collar and calling himself Rev. However, I think that pastors who work as professors, execs, speakers, editors or writers at Synod HQ, CPH or the LLL (Lutheran Laymen League) or LHF (Lutheran Heritage Foundation, e.g., Good News Journal), or Issues Etc, and such, must preach and administer sacraments now and then at a church or churches or else they lose their CRM or clergy status and the Rev. title to boot. So McCain isn't doing anything out of the ordinary, and he's doing what's expected of him.
McCain, Paul, Rev.
Position: Synod Executive Staff
http://www.lcms.org/page.aspx?pid=1081
***
GJ - Bruce, thanks for mentioning one of Lutherdom's most obnoxious promoters of Universalism, in the name of UOJ - Paul McCain, MDiv. I find it amusing that McCain's theological support comes from Jack Kilcrease, who was born in a WELS parsonage, went to Luther (ELCA) Seminary, and teaches at a Roman Catholic school. That roughly parallels McCain's diverse and polychrome doctrinal opinions.
Missouri claims that the congregation is the only form of the church, so church executives pretend to be parish pastors. Seminary professors pretend to take parish calls. McCain has served a parish for only three (3) years, and that was a platform so he could campaign for Al Barry becoming Synod President.
McCain could wear papal robes if he taught justification by faith properly, but he does not.
Why All the "Christian Academies" Popping Up in WELS?
AC V has left a new comment on your post "Holy Word (sic) Changes the Name of Their School":
"They deny however that this is in any way marketing."
Then why? Tell me! Why? Give me the surveys, statistics, and expert opinion that "Christian Academy" is an improvement over "Lutheran School."
What's the agenda? Give it to me in plain English.
***
GJ - John Lawrenz, a Church and Changer, must have touched the Blarney Stone, because he has the gift of blarney. He said in 1987 that Missouri had degenerated to recruiting anyone for their schools, while WELS could keep their own as parochial schools.
The Christian Academy idea comes from the WELS consultants. They demand thousands of dollars from the parish to advise the congregation to adopt Fuller marketing methods. The idea, AC V, is to open up the school to everyone, to make it a generic private school, with a sentimental attachment to the Christian faith, so no one is offended by Lutheran doctrine.
"Rev. Figwhistle, if I enroll Buffy and Sparky in your school, will you force them to learn Lutheran doctrine?"
Obviously, the Lutheran name is a terrible burden, truly a cross to bear.
School is a bit annoying, too, implying lessons to be learned. Academy is more like Plato's Academy and has a nice ring to it.
The LCA had very few parochial schools. In fact, I never knew of one, and I was in many of their congregations. The ALC had some parochial schools. Missouri was known for its school system.
Long ago, every WELS congregation seemed to have a school attached, from the start. It may have been tiny, but it was there. The church sign said, "Salem Lutheran Church and School. WELS," the only variation being the name of the church.
Robert Schuller advocated dropping the denominational label on churches. His Garden Grove Community Church is bankrupt.
Paul Kuske, Roger Zehms, and Floyd Luther Stolzenburg started Pilgrim Community Church in Grove City, Ohio. Attendance was three (3) on one Sunday, and the folly collapsed to the sound of laughter all over the Michigan District. Paul, Roger, and Floyd were the experts in Church Growth in the district.
---
Scott E. Jungen has left a new comment on your post "Holy Word (sic) Changes the Name of Their School":
My experience says that "Christian Academy" means taking in anybody from anywhere also long as their tuition checks don't bounce. Usually it's done because "if we didn't do it we couldn't keep the school open". So much for Lutheran education.
Scott E. Jungen
Labels:
ELCA; ELS; LCMS; WELS
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)