Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Head of Luther Seminary in St. Paul resigns amid financial woes | StarTribune.com



Head of Luther Seminary in St. Paul resigns amid financial woes | StarTribune.com:


Head of Luther Seminary in St. Paul resigns amid financial woes

  • Article by: ROSE FRENCH , Star Tribune 
  • Updated: December 11, 2012 - 9:42 PM
School announces search for new president after losing nearly $4 million last school year.
The president of Luther Seminary in St. Paul has resigned amid rising maintenance costs and declining enrollment.
Considered the country's largest Evangelical Lutheran Church of America (ELCA) seminary, the school wants to "take a fresh look going forward" after losing nearly $4 million last school year, Luther's board chairman Jim Lindus said Tuesday.
The seminary announced Monday that Richard Bliese stepped down from the job he's held since 2005. Officials plan to name an interim president by January and launch a national search for a successor.
Enrollment is down from 822 nearly five years ago to 764 students this year.
"We kind of had a perfect storm here of financial challenges in the last year or two," Lindus said. "Rising maintenance costs; our buildings are older and so we've had more deferred maintenance.
"We had a lower investment performance than we were expecting, and education costs in general are going up. And we're trying to figure out how do we adjust to that in a church that ... has become smaller."
The school's annual report for 2012 showed a total income of $23 million while expenses were $27.1 million. The total market value of its endowment has also taken a hit in the down economy. As of June, it was $65.4 million compared to the same time last year when it was $76.8 million.
Lots of seminaries struggle
Other ELCA seminaries nationwide are also dealing with "very challenging times," Lindus said. "They're all facing the same problems. The scale is different because we're much larger than the rest of them."
Minnesota has the largest number of ELCA members of any state, with close to 800,000. The ELCA is the nation's largest Lutheran denomination, with nearly 4.2 million members.
The ELCA has seen at least 600 of its congregations leave since its controversial policy change in 2009 allowing for openly gay and lesbian clergy in committed relationships to serve as pastors.
Other mainline Protestant denominations have also seen their numbers dwindle in the past several decades, according to religious scholars. "There are seminaries that are growing," said Charles Foster, professor emeritus of religion and education at Candler School of Theology at Emory University in Atlanta.
But in general, he said, "There has not been a strong support for youth ministry in the churches for some time ... so that there has not been a kind of trajectory of people moving from high school to college campus ministry programs to seminary. That doesn't exist like it used to in the mainline Protestant denominations. There is some movement in evangelical [Protestant] circles."
Enrollment decline is tied to church attendance, said Eliza Brown, a communications director for the Association of Theological Schools. The association has seen overall enrollment across its nearly 270 member schools in the United States and Canada fall between 1.4 percent and 3.3 percent a year since 2006.
"It's all related -- and that both limits the number of people who are launched from their congregations to pursue a vocation in ministry and it also means there are limited positions waiting for those people when they come out," Brown said.
Only about half of the students last year who earned master of divinity degrees had job offers once they graduated, she said.
"And yet the debt they've incurred as students has gone up and up. So they're coming out with higher levels of debt and fewer prospects for ever being able to service that debt," she said.
Creativity required
At Luther Seminary, tuition is nearly $15,000 per year, although the actual cost of attending is closer to $32,000 with room and board and other costs.
Theological schools will need to be more "creative in responding to the market and to the interest of students and the realities of how those students can actually play out their calling to ministry," Brown said. "And they can do that in so many different venues beyond traditional congregational ministry. ... They're looking at chaplaincies, social work, a variety of venues.
"And hopefully, there will continue to be a need for congregational ministers."
Staff writer Patrick Kennedy contributed to this report. Rose French • 612-673-4352


'via 

Blog this'

bruce-church (https://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Head of Luther Seminary in St. Paul resigns amid f...": 



Concordia Lutheran seminaries skyhigh tuition scandal (look in the comments section for plenty of related links):

http://ichabodthegloryhasdeparted.blogspot.com/2011/09/lcms-seminary-cost-scandal-fabulous.html

Ash Wednesday - 7 PM Central - February 13, 2013



Ash Wednesday, 2013


Pastor Gregory L. Jackson



The Hymn #552                Abide with Me            2.11
The Order of Vespers                                                p. 41
The Psalmody               Psalm 1                        p. 123
The Lection                              Joel 2:12-19
Matthew 6:16-2

The Sermon Hymn # 17            O Worship the King     2.44

The Sermon – Repentance and Faith

The Prayers
The Lord’s Prayer
The Collect for Grace                                       p. 45

The Hymn # 429      Lord, Thee I Love                  2.54


KJV Joel 2:12 Therefore also now, saith the LORD, turn ye even to me with all your heart, and with fasting, and with weeping, and with mourning: 13 And rend your heart, and not your garments, and turn unto the LORD your God: for he is gracious and merciful, slow to anger, and of great kindness, and repenteth him of the evil. 14 Who knoweth if he will return and repent, and leave a blessing behind him; even a meat offering and a drink offering unto the LORD your God? 15 Blow the trumpet in Zion, sanctify a fast, call a solemn assembly: 16 Gather the people, sanctify the congregation, assemble the elders, gather the children, and those that suck the breasts: let the bridegroom go forth of his chamber, and the bride out of her closet. 17 Let the priests, the ministers of the LORD, weep between the porch and the altar, and let them say, Spare thy people, O LORD, and give not thine heritage to reproach, that the heathen should rule over them: wherefore should they say among the people, Where is their God? 18 Then will the LORD be jealous for his land, and pity his people. 19 Yea, the LORD will answer and say unto his people, Behold, I will send you corn, and wine, and oil, and ye shall be satisfied therewith: and I will no more make you a reproach among the heathen:

KJV Matthew 6:16 Moreover when ye fast, be not, as the hypocrites, of a sad countenance: for they disfigure their faces, that they may appear unto men to fast. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward. 17 But thou, when thou fastest, anoint thine head, and wash thy face; 18 That thou appear not unto men to fast, but unto thy Father which is in secret: and thy Father, which seeth in secret, shall reward thee openly. 19 Lay not up for yourselves treasures upon earth, where moth and rust doth corrupt, and where thieves break through and steal: 20 But lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust doth corrupt, and where thieves do not break through nor steal: 21 For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.



Collect
Lord God, heavenly Father, who didst manifest Thyself, with the Holy Ghost, in the fullness of grace at the baptism of Thy dear Son, and with Thy voice didst direct us to Him who hath borne our sins, that we might receive grace and the remission of sins: Keep us, we beseech Thee, in the true faith; and inasmuch as we have been baptized in accordance with Thy command, and the example of Thy dear Son, we pray Thee to strengthen our faith by Thy Holy Spirit, and lead us to everlasting life and salvation, through Thy beloved Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, who liveth and reigneth with Thee and the Holy Ghost, one true God, world without end. Amen,

Repentance and Faith


Mankind has done so much to pay for sins, from endowing masses for eternity to building great cathedrals and institutions. Pagans have many forms of man-centered repentance, and Christianity gets corrupted by imitating them. Self-inflicted pain is a demonstration, not genuine contrition.

Strangely, the rationalism of man has enabled people to ignore the clear teaching of the Bible and turn to invented notions, man-made tradition, and novel ideas.

The most novel, coming from nominal Christians, is that faith does not matter, and yet trust in the Word is the constant emphasis of the Scriptures.

There is the reality of God’s wisdom uniquely revealed in the Word of God. That wisdom is so different from man’s knowledge, that Paul refers to it as the “mysteries of God.” These are not mystery stories and certainly not anything borrowed from pagans. The mysteries are those things known to us only through the work of the Holy Spirit in the Word.

Therefore, faith itself is not something man can conjure in his own mind, through intense thinking or an act of the will. God has shown that repeatedly – that faith comes by hearing the preached Word of God.

In the  preaching of the Gospel Word, the Holy Spirit enters the heart and man begins to trust in this way – “Yes, this is true. I believe this to be true of me.” As Luther often said, if we only think it applies to others, there is no faith. It is true for us as individuals. That happens to newborns, who also trust their parents, their mothers especially.

After months of hearing the parental voice, the baby sees that one face – or two faces – and smiles very early. The baby hears the voices and identifies with all those familiar things once masked by his warm, interior home.

Parents see that with siblings too. If they want the baby to smile, they have the older brother or sister do something. Big smiles – a special bond.

So when a baby is baptized and hears the Gospel Promises, the blessings of God are embraced and believed. That is why infant faith is the purest, because a baby does not measure and weigh what the great and wise might say, but has an uncomplicated trust, often spoken.

We see that in Christmas pageants and the way in which children understand the story of Christ. I debate with adults who question whether Jesus could consecrate His Body and His Blood. Children, when asked how, say, “He is God. God can do anything.”

That is such a simple confession of faith, yet many learned adults trip over and it becomes the stone of stumbling, the tripwire of their faith. From one doubt springs another until all the articles of faith are missing. They are left with “man is good. Man is ethical. I am good because I am ethical.” And yet the history of man says otherwise.

Repentance is always connected with faith, because the believing heart knows that there is a vast gulf between our pretensions and reality.

The first inkling of repentance is connected with faith, because someone must realize he cannot make himself good by his own efforts. Trusting that the God is gracious to us sinners is that beginning of repentance – not making a show of things, but realizing what the Gospel means.
"For the Word of God is the sanctuary above all sanctuaries, yea, the only one which we Christians know and have. For though we had the bones of all the saints or all holy and consecrated garments upon a heap, still that would help us nothing; for all that is a dead thing which can sanctify nobody. But God's Word is the treasure which sanctifies everything, and by which even all the saints themselves were sanctified. At whatever hour, then, God's Word is taught, preached, heard, read or meditated upon, there the person, day, and work are sanctified thereby, not because of the external work, but because of the Word, which makes saints of us all. Therefore I constantly say that all our life and work must be ordered according to God's Word, if it is to be God-pleasing or holy. Where this is done, this commandment is in force and being fulfilled."             Large Catechism, Preface, #91, Third Commandment, Concordia Triglotta, 1921, p. 607. Tappert, p. 377. 
God’s Word makes us into saints, because His Word alone makes us holy. Luther liked to say this because he grew up among people made holy by their robes, haircuts, vows, and solemn masses. His visit to Rome showed him how all the holiness was just a farce. The city of saints was especially corrupt and immoral, not a center of holiness.
The problem comes from making man’s institutions the heart of all holiness, when it is the Word of God that makes us holy. The Gospel moves the heart to believe anew and to realize the depth of forgiveness offered to each and every one of us.
So the center of repentance is faith in these Promises rather than in emotions, sorrows, and outward expressions.
And where is our treasure? We laugh about this among our friends and church members. Early in life we think about things we want to have, to acquire. Soon we learn that whatever we own, owns us. And later in life we think of presents as someone stopping by and taking something away.
When earthly treasures become more transitory to us, we see the value of the Gospel Treasure – a common term in the Book of Concord and in Luther. The treasure is forgiveness. This treasure is distributed to people by Holy Spirit, using the Means of Grace.
Isn’t that simple? The cross – or the atonement – is the treasure. God’s beloved Son has died for all of your sins. This forgiveness, called justification by faith, is the distribution of the treasure through Holy Baptism and Holy Communion, through teaching and preaching, through absolution and the “mutual consolation of the brothers.”
The last should be our common language. “I am sorry,” which leads to “That’s OK. Forget it. I have forgotten.” Mutual forgiveness is the necessary companion of love and friendship.
Those who believe the Gospel pass along the treasure each and every day. It begins with a forgiven and forgiving heart. That makes us patient with the errors and shortcomings of others, because we realize our own in the light of God’s grace. We are easily moved to be forgiving as life’s conflicts move through our lives from day to day, from the annoying customer service person to big crisis looming at the moment.
So that Gospel treasure makes everything better in two ways. It takes the away the burden from our hearts and also from others. It constantly moves back and forth between people, a blessing for all parties concerned.
Today someone mentioned the Hatfields and McCoys – their long-running warfare in West Virginia. I know one of them. She said the dispute went on so long and cost so many lives that they stopped counting who was wrong and had a peace meeting. Now they have joint reunions because the families are inter-married anyway.
Man could not settle the problem with guns, so forgiveness ended the warfare.


Quotations

"For the Word of God is the sanctuary above all sanctuaries, yea, the only one which we Christians know and have. For though we had the bones of all the saints or all holy and consecrated garments upon a heap, still that would help us nothing; for all that is a dead thing which can sanctify nobody. But God's Word is the treasure which sanctifies everything, and by which even all the saints themselves were sanctified. At whatever hour, then, God's Word is taught, preached, heard, read or meditated upon, there the person, day, and work are sanctified thereby, not because of the external work, but because of the Word, which makes saints of us all. Therefore I constantly say that all our life and work must be ordered according to God's Word, if it is to be God-pleasing or holy. Where this is done, this commandment is in force and being fulfilled."
            Large Catechism, Preface, #91, Third Commandment, Concordia Triglotta, 1921, p. 607. Tappert, p. 377. 



"For neither you nor I could ever know anything of Christ, or believe on Him, and obtain Him for our Lord, unless it were offered to us and granted to our hearts by the Holy Ghost through the preaching of the Gospel. The work is done and accomplished; for Christ has acquired and gained the treasure for us by His suffering, death, resurrection, etc. But if the work remained concealed so that no one knew of it, then it would be in vain and lost. That this treasure, therefore, might not lie buried, but be appropriated and enjoyed, God has caused the Word to go forth and be proclaimed, in which He gives the Holy Ghost to bring this treasure home and appropriate it to us. Therefore sanctifying is nothing else than bringing us to Christ to receive this good, to which could not attain ourselves."
            The Large Catechism, The Creed, Article III, #38, Concordia Triglotta, 1921, p. 689. Tappert, p. 415.      

Luther: "True, the enthusiasts confess that Christ died on the cross and saved us; but they repudiate that by which we obtain Him; that is, the means, the way, the bridge, the approach to Him they destroy...They lock up the treasure which they should place before us and lead me a fool's chase; they refuse to admit me to it; they refuse to transmit it; they deny me its possession and use." (III, 1692)
            The. Engelder, et al., Popular Symbolics, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1934, p. 5.                    
"These treasures are offered us by the Holy Ghost in the promise of the holy Gospel; and faith alone is the only means by which we lay hold upon, accept, and apply, and appropriate them to ourselves. This faith is a gift of God, by which we truly learn to know Christ, our Redeemer, in the Word of the Gospel, and trust in Him, that for the sake of His obedience alone we have the forgiveness of sins by grace, are regarded as godly and righteous by God the Father, and are eternally saved."     Formula of Concord, Thorough Declaration, III 10 Righteousness, Concordia Triglotta, 1921, p. 919.                 
"Early in the morning it rises, sits upon a twig and sings a song it has learned, while it knows not where to obtain its food, and yet it is not worried as to where to get its breakfast. Later, when it is hungry, it flies away and seeks a grain of corn, where God stored one away for it, of which it never thought while singing, when it had cause enough to be anxious about its food. Ay, shame on you now, that the little birds are more pious and believing than you; they are happy and sing with joy and know not whether they have anything to eat."
            Sermons of Martin Luther, 8 vols., ed. John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983, V, p. 114. 

"These means are the true treasure of the church through which salvation in Christ is offered. They are the objective proclamation of faith which alone makes man's subjective faith possible (Augsburg Confession, Article V). The Formula of Concord (Solid Declaration, Article XI, 76) states expressly that God alone draws man to Christ and that he does this only through the means of grace."
Walter G. Tillmanns, "Means of Grace: Use of," The Encyclopedia of the Lutheran Church, 3 vols., Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1965, II, p. 1505.           
     
"It is a faithful saying that Christ has accomplished everything, has removed sin and overcome every enemy, so that through Him we are lords over all things. But the treasure lies yet in one pile; it is not yet distributed nor invested. Consequently, if we are to possess it, the Holy Spirit must come and teach our hearts to believe and say: I, too, am one of those who are to have this treasure. When we feel that God has thus helped us and given the treasure to us, everything goes well, and it cannot be otherwise than that man's heart rejoices in God and lifts itself up, saying: Dear Father, if it is Thy will to show toward me such great love and faithfulness, which I cannot fully fathom, then will I also love Thee with all my heart and be joyful, and cheerfully do what pleases Thee. Thus, the heart does not now look at God with evil eyes, does not imagine He will cast us into hell, as it did before the HS came...."
Sermons of Martin Luther, 8 vols., ed., John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983, III, p. 279.

"Thus we see what a very splendid thing Baptism is. It snatches us from the jaws of the devil, makes us God's own, restrains and removes sin, and then daily strengthens the new man within us. It is and remains ever efficacious until we pass from this state of misery to eternal glory. For this reason everyone should consider his Baptism as his daily dress, to be worn constantly. Every day he should be found in the faith and its fruits, suppressing the old man, and growing up in the new; for if we want to be Christians, we must practice the work whereby we are Christians. But if anyone falls from baptismal grace, let him return to it. For as Christ, the Mercy Seat, does not withdraw from us or forbid us to come to Him again even though we sin, so all His treasures and gifts also remain with us."  
What Luther Says, An Anthology, 3 vols., ed., Ewald Plass, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959, I, p. 61.      
"(3) Hollazius (ib.): 'The Word of God, as such, cannot be conceived of without the divine virtue, or the Holy Spirit, who is inseparable from His Word. For if the Holy Spirit could be separated from the Word of God, it would not be the Word of God or of the Spirit, but a word of man. Nor is there any other Word of God, which is in God, or with which the men of God have been inspired, than that which is given in the Scriptures or is preached or is treasured up in the human mind. But, as it cannot be denied that that is the divine will, counsel, mind, and the wisdom of God, so it cannot be destitute of the divine virtue or efficacy.'"
Heinrich Schmid, Doctrinal Theology of the Evangelical Lutheran Church, trans., Charles A. Hay and Henry E. Jacobs, Philadelphia: United Lutheran Publication House, 1899, p. 505.

Roman Catholic Indulgences
"Indulgences are, in the Church, a true spiritual treasure laid open to all the faithful; all are permitted to draw therefrom, to pay their own debts and those of others."
            Rev. F. X. Schouppe, S.J., Purgatory, Illustrated by the Lives and Legends of the Saints, Rockford: Tan Books and Publishers, 1973 (1893), p. 195.


UOJ Rolls Downhill from Zion on the Mequon Heights

Richard Jungkuntz was worried that WELS would lose its UOJ.
He took it into Missouri and then Seminex,
chaired the first gay Lutheran seminary,
and joined The ALC.


rlschultz has left a new comment on your post "You Have To Be Carefully Taught To Hate the Gospel...":

"They moved the UOJ down to the lowest levels."


We know what rolls downhill. In this case, it has taken the form of UOJ. If one were to undertake a careful study of church history, you would notice that false doctrine is rarely a grass roots movement. Betrayal by the leaders is the norm. 



Ichabod Predicts - Third World Pontiff.
Pope resigns: Peter Turkson reveals vision for the Church and 'alternative lifestyles' - Telegraph

Pope resigns: Peter Turkson reveals vision for the Church and 'alternative lifestyles' - Telegraph:


Ghanian Cardinal Peter Kodwo Appiah Turkson
Ghanian Cardinal Peter Kodwo Appiah Turkson  Photo: AP
Cardinal Peter Turkson, a 64-year-old Ghanaian prelate, is the bookmaker's early favourite to succeed Pope Benedict XVI.
He told The Daily Telegraph Tuesday that his biggest challenge, should he be elected, would be to maintain an orthodox Catholic doctrine while "at the same time knowing how to apply it so that you do not become irrelevant in a world that has continuous changes".
Cardinal Turkson, who holds one of the most important jobs in the Roman Curia and has been repeatedly promoted by Pope Benedict, was quick to take a conservative line on gay marriage and other "alternative lifestyles".
"We need to find ways of dealing with the challenges coming up from society and culture," he said, adding that the Church needed to "evangelise", or convert, those who had embraced "alternative lifestyles, trends or gender issues". He added: "We cannot fail in our task of providing guidance."
Cardinal Turkson has caused controversy in the past both by screening a video claiming that Europe faced being overrun by Muslims and by insisting that condoms were not the solution to preventing HIV.
The African prelate said he had reflected on the enormous personal burden of becoming the leader of the Catholic Church. "It would certainly mean a lot if I had to be a pope," he said. "If I was elected pope it would signal a lot of [personal] change. Very big change in a lot of regards. I have been an archbishop, which involved a certain amount of leadership and now having to do this on a world level, the dimensions expand almost infinitely.
"It is going to be a life-changing experience and I think that is what it has been for Benedict and those who have gone before us. The challenge will also be with the individual to want to make his mark, not trying to fit into anybody's shoes but finding his own shoes to wear."
Cardinal Turkson also said the Vatican needs to "restore and repair" an image that has been "badly compromised by recent scandals".
Pope Benedict's eight-year papacy saw controversies over paedophile priests, a tense relationship with the Muslim world, and the conviction of his butler for stealing documents that revealed corruption at the top of the Vatican.
"[We need] to relevantly address issues and the credibility of our own ministry and leadership," said Cardinal Turkson. "The Church, if you adopt the imagery of a boat, is going through quite a bit of a storm and it does not appear to be over yet," he said.
"In Europe, churches are getting empty, the population appears not to relate much to the Church and to religion and all of that –that is an issue to deal with. In the new churches, Latin America, Africa and Asia, where the Church appears to be growing there is also the challenge of being able to maintain membership. Whoever succeeds Benedict will not lack challenges and they are an invitation to creativity and innovation."
He acknowledged that he will be in the running when 118 cardinals enter into a conclave in the Sistine Chapel next month to select their next leader.
"It is a possibility [that there will be an African pope]," he said. "Already at the last conclave there was a move to have a candidate from the southern half of the globe," he said. But he pointed out that there is constant speculation over the idea of an African pope.
"Before I got here there was a young African cardinal called Arinze from Nigeria. And at every conclave everybody was talking about him as an emerging candidate. Arinze is now 80 and actually there is no way he can participate in the conclave. So after Arinze another African shows up in the Vatican, now there are actually two of us, there is a cardinal from Guinea. So again there is speculation."

***
GJ - I was ready to predict a Third World pope coming out of this conclave, even before I saw this article. I thought so last time, when Benedict was elected, after making a deal to appoint a liberal to replace him in the Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Roman and Universal Inquisition (original title).
They toned it down to Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF).
Third World Christian congregations are growing fast, but the decadent West is declining. In addition, there is a gulf between the two. The Ethiopians just broke with ELCA over the gay issue, something ELCA cannot understand.
African Episcopalians are incensed over the US Episcopal election of gay  bishops, soon to happen in England. Sure, they had them before, but they are emptying the closets now.


'via Blog this'

Ecclesia Augustana Is a Good Read

This stained glass window honors the Augsburg Confession -
Confessio Augustana

Emperor Charles V, with his jutting Hapsburg jaw,
called the Imperial Diet of Augsburg.
Muslim troubles kept him from destroying nascent Lutheran doctrine.
Some younger men started the Ecclesia Augustana blog. They have not linked my humble URL, but I can forgive them.

They produce good posts, time after time.

The Augsburg Confession is an eloquent expression of Biblical doctrine, and the Apology of the Augsburg Confession contains a wonderful expansion on justification by faith.

No one should enter the debate without a thorough knowledge of both, since Luther and the Concordists considered themselves "theologians of the Augsburg Confession."

As I understand it, the men writing the blog have not entered seminary, but they have more to say than the pompous DPs of the SynCons. Apparently the SynCon seminaries have a corrosive effect on the brain, worsened by years of luxury and revenge in the DP's office.




"But I thought the Chief Article was UOJ!
Eight years of WELs education down the drain."

Ecclesia Augustana: Revisiting "Faith is a Cause" and the "Four Components of Justification"




  Ecclesia Augustana: Revisiting "Faith is a Cause" and the "Four Components of Justification":


Revisiting "Faith is a Cause" and the "Four Components of Justification"

Whether by happenstance or design, Ecclesia Augustana’s contributors typically refrain from publicly exposing individuals, preferring instead to focus on their errant paradigms. Exceptions have been made where the severity and public nature of the abuse warrants it. In this instance, I’m going to address an individual who is misrepresenting this blog in a separate venue.

Recently, Dr. Jack Kilcrease visited this blog and left a comment.  Because the blogger system records referring sites, we realized that a number of users were accessing Ecclesia Augustanathrough his blog, Theologia Crucis. After visiting the blog, we discovered that he wrote an article about Ecclesia Augustana. I briefly hoped that it might result in an opportunity for meaningful dialogue.  But before finishing the first sentence of Dr. Kilcrease’s post, I realized that the article was going to be little more than an attempt to demonstrate his own intellectual prowess at the expense of attacking Ecclesia and the competence of its authors.

He begins with the insinuation that this blog is little more than fanatics “fixated on the anti-objective justification heresy.” While I certainly do not deny the “heresy” of justification by faith alone, the fact is that justification has only been the topic of a mere seven posts on this blog. That’s barely 20% of our total posts, which discuss such varied themes as the necessity and ubiquity of Holy Baptism, the non-adiaphoric nature of the Divine Liturgy, the dangers of sectarian practices, the Church's perspective on contraception, the importance and meaning of the Hypostatic Union, and the paramount importance of the Blessed Means of Grace and their impact on Christian living and theology - among many other topics. In reality, justification has not been a topic of our posts more than twice per month in the four short months that this blog has been extant.  I guess for that we ought to apologize to our readers. If justification is truly the chief doctrine of the Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church, upon which its very existence stands or falls, it should occupy our thought more than a mere 20% of the time. Especially in a time when the very integrity of the doctrine is being assaulted on every hand.

Regardless, the assertion that we speak on the topic ad nauseam doesn’t speak very well of Dr. Kilcrease’s investigative abilities, at the very least; it might even indicate that he himself is suffering from some sort of fixation on the universal justification heresy.  In fact, every post he made this month over at Theologia Crucis has been dedicated to the heresy of universal justification. What's more, he makes a habit of going around the internet promoting the Huberian paradigm (I can attest to having discussed the topic with him a number of times on Facebook - albeit that he seems to have blocked me on account of it!). I will let the reader decide who is “fixated.”

All of that, of course, is tangential, though I find the context somewhat useful in demonstrating the character of the parties involved. The actual thrust of Dr. Kilcreae’s post is dedicated to examining one of the blurbs I wrote last month, “Faith is a Cause.” My post was written primarily to direct the reader to some of Pastor Paul Rydecki’s excellent translations of the Fathers of Lutheran Orthodoxy. Dr. Kilcrease summarizes my post as follows:

“The gist of what is said here is as follows: Polycarp Leyser states that faith is the ‘instrumental cause’ of justification. The theologians of the old Synodical Conference said that it was God's Word and the merit of Christ that was the cause of justification, and not faith in and of itself. Hence, they are out of step with orthodox Lutheran theology and wrong.”

Dr. Kilcrease seems to be saying that my article implies God’s Word and the merit of Christ are not causes of justification. I certainly am not making that implication. In fact, in an even earlier article I wrote entitled the “Four Components of Justification,” where I actually treat this topic in greater depth than the passing reference I give to it in the article Dr. Kilcrease is addressing, I demonstrate that the grace of God and the promise of the Gospel are integral parts of justification.

After this misleading summary, the doctor goes into a long diatribe about Aristotlean metaphysics and its influence on medieval scholastic theology.  By virtue of our manifesto, as an Ecclesia Augustana contributor I admit to being less than the esteemed theologian and learned academic that Dr. Kilcrease imagines himself to be (as he puts it, most of the contributors here atEcclesia are just “college kids”). So I will defer to his explanations of the categories of cause for our purposes here. Using his classifications, the scheme of four causes can be understood in terms of the following example:

“For example, a hammer is the instrumental cause of a table. It is used by the efficient cause (the acting agent, the carpenter). It isn't the idea what what a table is (formal cause) or the wood the table is made out of (material cause). Neither is it an acting agent (the efficient cause). Rather it is merely the passive means through which the material receives its shape based on the idea of the mind of the builder.”

In the form of a list, we have:

Causes of a Table
1. The formal cause (“the idea what what [sic] a table is”)
2. The material cause (“the wood the table is made out of”)
3. The efficient cause (“an acting agent”)
4. The instrumental cause (“a hammer”)

When it comes to Justification, one could put it like this:

Causes of Justification
1. The formal cause (the grace of God)
2. The material cause (the merits of Christ)
3. The efficient cause (the Holy Spirit in the promises of the Gospel)
4. The instrumental cause (faith)

Well what do you know, this list looks strangely similar to the one that I drew up in the “Four Components" article. So let’s take faith out of the justification equation. The grace of God is still there. The merits of Christ are still there. The promises of the Holy Gospel are still there. But just as wood, the Carpeter, and His plan exist objectively, without that “hammer” by which the Holy Spirit puts it all together, there is no “table.”

Now I freely admit that the “scheme of causes” analogy isn’t perfect and I’d rather stick to the way I put it in the "Four Components" article, which is none other than the words of the Solid Declaration itself. Still, per Dr. Kilcrease’s own formula, I don’t see how he can claim that justification is an “existing reality.” Does the table exist before the hammer puts it together? It can surely be the desire of the Carpenter, but until that hammer is available, it’s just a desire. It isn’t a reality. 

So too, it is most certainly true: God has decreed that all should be justified (FC:SD:XI:14-15); He alone provides the means of that justification. But unless one actually has that faith - as Dr. Kilcrease would put it, without that “hammer” - there is no justification. Thus, all who have not received the gift of faith from God the Holy Spirit stand condemned from eternity for not believing on the Name of God’s one and only Son. They are not justified from eternity. They are condemned (St. John 3:18).

Dr. Kilcrease wants us to be familiar with the terminology he ostensibly learned after studying medieval scholastics. That is all well and good, and I freely admit that understanding the context of a given text is immensely helpful in reading it. But perhaps instead of directing us to the schematic formulas of Aristotle, Dr. Kilcrease could take some time to examine the plain words of Holy Writ, which clearly say that the reprobate are “condemned already,” not justified, and with the Confessions in saying that the unbeliving and unconverted person “is not reconciled to God” (FC:SD:IV:8).


2 comments:

  1. I only started reading Jack's posts since October. I think..the one where he noted Rydecki's removal was the first. I made an unfortunate comment on that post that I fell on the opposite side of the controversy at the time. It was a bad week. I had just read the Marquardt paper and was almost shaken by it. Plus I was not ready to come out of the JBFA closet.

    With that unfortunate moment of weakness behind me...I have noted some of the posts Jack has made. I would comment that for a guy in his position, he is a bit of an intellectual hack. Most of his posts sound like the acedemic equivalent of writing an Executive Summary in the business world. (e.g "..with the goal to empower our partners in the globization of opportunities while maintaining a vision of mission critical virtualization...). The point being there are a lot of trendy $5 words that in reality say nothing.

    I would expect someone in his position to be somewhat proficent in exegetical study but I don't think he could function if all he was handed was a Bible and a BoC.

    Perhaps I'll expound one day on my theories about people with Phd's.
    Reply
  2. Dr. Jack Kilcrease made this statement back in 2010 in a post titled A Discussion On UOJ:

    Dr. Kilcrease
    "But if a sin is paid for, why is not forgiven? I would suggest that it is. I mean, if you deny that payment=forgiveness, what sort of ontological status does the payment have? To clarify: If a sin is "washed away" then how can it still be around? Did Jesus only potentially make a sacrifice for the sins of the whole world, which we then activate via the means of grace? I think not."
    JUNE 9, 2010 3:31 AM

    Jack has since deleted the entire post and 64 of the 66 comments.

    Jack is a rationalist. He once chided me for simply quoting Scripture against UOJ without revealing what the concept was that the words were attempting to communicate.

    UOJ is the perfect storm for rationalists. It establishes a religion that declares and assures the unbeliever of God's forgiveness and righteousness without faith because the faith they have is not in Christ but in a false declaration that never occurred. Rationalists war against the faith of the Holy Spirit which brings the peace and comfort that passes all understanding because they do not have it. They claim a higher assurance of sins forgiven because their forgiveness comes without faith. The catch is that they do not have the comfort of the Holy Spirit's faith and therefore easily rage against Scripture, the Lutheran Confessions and anyone who does not condone their rational man-made doctrine.

    In these last days Satan has achieved the acceptance of a lie - the Lutheran Synods in harmony with the church of the Antichrist - the Roman Catholic Church - announce anathema upon one Justification solely by Faith in Christ Alone.


'via Blog this'

McLaren is the guru of Emerging Churches,
like The CORE in Fox Valley, CrossWalk in Phoenix.
Jeff Gunn should evangelize his atheist son, eh?
---

narrow-minded has left a new comment on your post "Ecclesia Augustana: Revisiting "Faith is a Cause" ...":

Jack-He must increase, but I must-Kilcrease seems to be very impressed with his "credentials." Did he actually earn his doctorate, or was it an honorary freebie? He should consider a career in politics, where saying a bunch, while saying absolutely nothing, is rewarded.

Apparently we uneducated peons don't see the light of UOJ. Thank God! I now see it as a blessing that going to Fort Wayne didn't work out for me.