Thursday, October 27, 2011

Looking for Authority Instead of Studying the Word of God



LPC has left a new comment on your post "Jack Kilcrease Butters Up David Scaer for Another ...":

Jack is an example of what happens when you become a Waltherian. When you become a UOJer, you become dependent on an authority. You have to look for someone 'great'.

In LC-MS, there are plenty of professors specialising in historical and systematic theology, they have no one (after Walther Maier) that can be considered a specialist in exegetical theology.

The weakness in exegesis leads to dependence on an authority of what the Scripture means ( according to so and so etc).

Only the synodical conference Lutherans interpret Romans 4:25 like they do, the declaration of the whole world irrespective of faith to be justified.

Lenski does not believe this interpretation, neither does Walther Maier agree with that interpretation.

This is where the Synodical Conference people are unique and on their own because they are the only ones that interpret Romans 4:25 the way they do.

LPC

Wauwatosa theologian.

Luther Rocks: TLH - Still Relevant for the Times.
James Tiefel's CGM Hymnal - Not



Luther Rocks: TLH - Still Relevant for the Times:

'via Blog this'


TLH - Still Relevant for the Times



From Wikipedia: The Lutheran Hymnal (TLH) is one of the official hymnals of the Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod. Published in 1941 by Concordia Publishing House in St. Louis, Missouri, it was the LCMS' second official English-language hymnal, succeeding the 1912 Evangelical Lutheran Hymn-Book. Development of TLH began in 1929 as a collaborative effort of the churches of the Evangelical Lutheran Synodical Conference of North America and became the common hymnal for both the LCMS and theWisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS). Containing 668 chorales, hymns, carols, and chants, plus the liturgy for the Common Service, Matins, Vespers, the propers, collects and prayers, the suffrages, canticles, psalms, and miscellaneous tables, TLH became an extremely popular and beloved worship resource in theLutheran church in North America, and attempts to succeed it in more recent years have often met with strong resistance.

The first attempt to replace TLH began in 1965, when the LCMS began work on the Lutheran Book of Worship and invited other Lutheran denominations in North America to participate in its creation. As a result of disagreement and compromise with the other churches involved in LBW's production, the LCMS objected to some of its content, and Lutheran Book of Worship was published in 1978 without the endorsement of the very church body that initiated its production. An LCMS revision ofLBW was quickly published in 1982 under the title Lutheran Worship. Lutheran Worship (LW) was intended to replace TLH as the official hymnal of the LCMS; however, many congregations were still unsatisfied with the final product, leading them to continue using TLH. According to a 1999 survey by the LCMS' Commission on Worship, approximately 36% of the synod's congregations were still using TLH as their main hymnal, and even more were continuing to use it in combination with LW and/or other hymnals and hymnal supplements. An even newer hymnal, Lutheran Service Book (2006), has restored many of the former hymnal's features in the hope that more widespread use can be achieved. In the WELS, TLH was effectively replaced by Christian Worship: A Lutheran Hymnal in 1993, and few congregations continue to use it on a regular basis.

The Lutheran Hymnal is commonly referred to by many to as the "Red hymnal," in contrast with LW, the "Blue hymnal". However, the "Red hymnal" moniker is somewhat misleading. The initial editions of TLH were in fact bound in blue, and the hymnal has been simultaneously available in both red and blue cover versions for much of its history. Although the red cover version is now more common, many congregations' pew racks are filled with blue-covered copies of the "red" hymnal. Generally, members of these congregations refer to TLH simply as "the old hymnal". The widespread use of Lutheran Service Book (LSB) [1] has begun the process of resolving the LCMS' hymnal controversy, as initial reviews have been generally quite favorable. Concordia Publishing House has announced that all TLH-related supplemental materials, including specialized accompaniment editions and the agenda, will go out of print when current supplies are depleted, but plans to continue to produce the pew edition for the foreseeable future. TLH remains an officially sanctioned hymnal of the synod, and it is unlikely that the synod will ever formally decommission it as an official hymnal.

Jack Kilcrease Butters Up David Scaer for Another
Concordia Seminary,Ft. Wayne Gig

Jack Kilcrease nominates North America's greatest Lutheran theologian,
earning our favorite Catholic lecturer another free trip to Ft. Wayne,
where they routinely turn out Catholic and Eastern Orthodox priests.


Dr. Jack Kilcrease has left a new comment on your post "Infamous Huberists: From the New Gallery at The Sm...":

Though I am certainly flattered to be chosen for your hall of fame - don't you think Dr. Scaer would be more fitting than I? I mean, I'm small potatoes. I think he's probably the greatest living Lutheran theologian in North America at this point (Oswald Bayer would be the greatest in Germany). Just saying.

***

GJ - The facts show Walther to have been a brittle, tyrannical, and fanatical usurper. Tom Hardt is a UOJ fanatic, so he did a fine job of connecting Walther with Huber. Hardt's praise of Walther  mercifully exposes the Kidnapper's alarming opinions.

The following quotations are from Hardt's essay - Justification and Easter, A Study in Subjective and Objective Justification in Lutheran Theology.

Hardt - "As a first observation it should be said that Walther’s homiletic treatment of the relationship between Easter and justification shows no sign of a gradual development. Our material covers the period 1840-1886, and all the sermons seem to possess the same degree of dogmatic clarity."

Walther - “As we were co-punished in Christ’s death, we are again co-absolved from our sins in His resurrection.“48

GJ - Walther's statement above is bizarre and profoundly wrong.

Hardt - "In 1844  we see an expression coined that was to become well known: 'That the resurrection of Christ is the fully valid justification of all men.'”51

GJ - The early use of Easter absolution suggests learning this fallacy from Stephan, Pietistic circles, or even the rationalists of Berlin where Walther was trained.

Walther - “Yet, my beloved, the resurrection of Jesus Christ is not only the highest and final consolation of all men, because not until then is the consolation of the cross and death of Christ revealed and are both of them made consoling, but because it contains a consolation in itself which is not to be found in any other work of the redemption, not even in the passion and death of Christ. Consider only the following and you will soon agree with me. Whereas the passion and death properly speaking were acts of Christ, His resurrection was, on the contrary, properly speaking the act of His heavenly Father... This is, however, of the highest and most consolatory importance... Whereas the passion and death of Jesus Christ was the penitence and confession of the Son of God for the entire apostate humanity, His resurrection was, on the contrary, the heavenly Father’s absolution, subsequently solemnly and factually delivered in Christ to all men, publicly before heaven and earth.”57

Hardt - "Easter as an act toward the world in general is thus continued, repeated, in the means of grace, the Gospel in all its forms, which effectively convey the gift of Easter to individuals."

GJ - Hardt does not recognize that he and Walther are using Easter as the Means of Grace for the entire world, without the Word, without faith. This opinion is blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, who works only through the Word and Sacraments. The Scriptures do not teach that  the Holy Spirit works again to create a second justification that validates the first one. Hardt is consistent with Olde Synodical Conference false doctrine - no wonder he is admired by Ft. Wayne, the ELS, and Jay Webber. High church Enthusiasts are still Enthusiasts, as witnessed in the Church of Rome and Eastern Orthodoxy.

Missouri Proceedings, 1860, Walther presiding -  "During the discussions a reference was made to the fact that within the Missouri Synod it had always been preached that: “Through the resurrection from the dead God has absolved all the world, i.e., set it free from sin; if now the world already is absolved and set free from sin, what is then the absolution or preaching of the Gospel in the church? Is it, too, a setting free, or merely a proclamation of the setting free that has already occurred? Answer: … precisely through the Gospel occurs the conveying of what is in God’s heart... a proclamation that really brings and gives the forgiveness… The absolution in the Gospel is nothing else than a repetition of the factual absolution which has already happened through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead.”63

GJ - WELS, Missouri, and the ELS do not teach the Biblical Means of Grace, but twist its meaning to say that the Gospel in Word and Sacrament simply states what is already true - they are already forgiven, whether they believe it or not. They were born forgiven, but they have to decide that they are forgiven, just like everyone else in the world. Walther is the hero who brought the false doctrine of Samuel Huber to the new world, later clothed in the double-justification language of Knapp (Woods' translation).

Hardt - "Another expression of considerable repute connected with Walther’s theology on Easter and justification is “objective justification” versus “subjective justification.” It has been investigated as to when this terminology was first used by Walther or men like him.68 It seems, as far as the investigations for this article permit us to see, that the terms were made known to Walther through an article in a theological paper in Germany, printed in 1867. Walther reprinted it in his Lehre und Wehre in the same year, and it can be said to throw clarity on the original meaning of the words."69

GJ - The article was printed in Germany in 1867, but the OJ/SJ language in English had been in use in the Knapp two-volume set (English translation) since 1831. Woods (Calvinist) was a super-star among mainline Protestant leaders in America, and Knapp was in print throughout the 19th century. Therefore one might expect that the OJ/SJ terms drifted across the ocean in English and drifted back in German. Walther was every bit as original as Paul Calvin Kelm, copying his false doctrine and gasping "Oh - this is so creative."

Note well - Walther introduced OJ/SJ terms originally from a Calvinist American used to explain the doctrine of a Halle Pietist.

Dr. Lito Cruz is correct in labeling all this a product of the Calvinists, smuggled into the Olde Synodical Conference by  Walther - the American Luther or the American Crypto-Calvinist?

Hardt - "The essential differences between Walther’s doctrine and Huber’s concerning universal justification can be summarized in the following way: First of all, we do not meet the slightest hint in Walther’s theology about God as being forced by His own essence to know of no contradictory tension between Law and Gospel. Walther at no place suggests that the unbeliever is no more under the wrath of God or that a second judgment is necessary to deprive the unbeliever of his first, universal justification. As early as 1846 Walther says in a sermon: “For that is indeed true: here everything depends on faith. He who does not apply to himself the victory of Christ in His resurrection through faith, upon him Law, sin, death and hell still have power. He experiences no power, no joy from this victory. For him Christ is still in His tomb.”72 So Walther upholds the truth of John 3:36: “The wrath of God abideth on him.” Within this frame all Walther’s statements on Easter and justification must be understood."


GJ - The first difference is not important for this discussion. The second one shows Hardt's inability to grasp basic Biblical, Lutheran doctrine. "Apply to himself" is synergistic at best, drifting toward Pelagianism, where man perfects himself.  This is not upholding the truth of John 3:36. The Synodical Conference is blind to the efficacy of the Word alone in the Means of Grace. We do not decide to believe in the universal absolution, a truly ham-fisted blend of universalism and decision theology. The Gospel Word creates and sustains faith in us by the work of the Holy Spirit. God declares us justified through faith in His Son's death and resurrection.


Hardt's Conclusion - "Not unimportant is the fact that Walther was well aware of Huber’s theology and its dangers. In his edition of Baier’s Compendium Theologiae Positivae, Walther inserted a page with very pertinent material concerning the Huberian controversy, dealing with the impossibility of saying that all mankind has received the remission of sins, pointing to John 3:36: “The wrath of God abideth on him.” As a professor of dogmatics Walther thus has seriously warned his students against Huberian aberrations.75  In his ministry as a preacher of the Word he has certainly led his parishioners on equally safe paths. Also for coming generations his presentation of the relationship between justification and Easter has a lasting value."


GJ - Just as Joe Kron feared, Easter absolution (UOJ) had its place in the LCMS from the very beginning. However, the written evidence shows that Missouri was perfectly able to express justification by faith in Biblical, Confessional language - in its 1905 Catechism, in other statements before the 1932 Brief Statement (now canonized by the Enthusiasts). Concordia Publishing House prints a KJV catechism with no mention of OJ/SJ and once sold the WELS Gausewitz Catechism, which also managed to discuss the Chief Article without repeating Walther's fetish about Easter absolution.






Narrow-minded Lutheran has left a new comment on your post "Jack Kilcrease Butters Up David Scaer for Another ...":

"GJ - WELS, Missouri, and the ELS do not teach the Biblical Means of Grace, but twist its meaning to say that the Gospel in Word and Sacrament simply states what is already true - they are already forgiven, whether they believe it or not."

You nailed this one, Pastor Jackson. When arguing for weekly Communion, one reply I heard was, "I know I'm already forgiven, so why cut into fellowship time EVERY week and make those who can't Commune with us feel unwelcome EVERY week?"

Following this rationale, perhaps C&A should only be utilized on the non-Communion weeks, because I know I'm already forgiven. Besides, that "poor, miserable sinner" stuff is offensive to visitors.

Paul McCain Visits the Shrine of C. F. W. Walther:
The Bicentenniel's Most Ironic Home Movie



Have you wondered why most Internet discussions about Lutheranism are about electing the next president and fussing about the most trivial details of official synodical history?

I do not wonder at all. Those in charge in the synods loathe Martin Luther's doctrine and spare no effort to eliminate all traces of it. They cannot deal with the facts of their own history and doctrine, so they dance around the edges. The leaders love to watch pastors bickering over trivia, because they derive their power from alienating people and manipulating the naive.

American Lutheran church history consists of telling the biggest lies and hiding the most facts possible. The Concordia Historical Institute has plenty of evidence about the criminal and unethical actions of C. F. W. Walther. The youngest of pastors who pledged themselves to their syphilitic, adulterous bishop--CFW -was schocked, schocked to find out about Stephan's errant ways. Sure. The bishop's family was booked for passage to America, but he only took his son and his long-standing mistress, Louise Guenther. His mistress was not a secret because Stephan was under house arrest for his affair with her and other wome, up to the moment he left for America. I think the court thought, "Good riddance." They took extensive testimony about Louise and others, so the matter was public, published in court documents. When a man takes his mistress but not his wife to a new location, he has broadcast his infidelity to the world. Those who pay attention to him should be jailed as his enablers. The cover-ups continue to this day, but synodical wrath is reserved for those who tell the truth.



Walther was the man who stole back the 40 acres given by the Society to the bishop. Fraudulently changing court documents is a crime. That would never happen today - except Jerry Kieschnick changed the will of an elderly woman and still became SP. No one seemed to mind. Christian News worried more about whether the conservative candidate du jour was Waltherian enough. Perhaps some grand theft larceny would have helped the other man seem more like CFW.

The LCMS could tell the truth about Walther, instead of having him hover six feet above the ground, more immaculate than the Blessed Virgin Mother. One of the Ft. Wayne heroes was actually in prison in Europe. The synod admits that much. They should brag that Walther ran from the police so fast that the cops never got to serve the arrest warrants for kidnapping his niece and nephew. Pastor Otten is a runner and a biker - he would appreciate that fact. Missouri hstorians rejoice that another pastor and 50 others drowned in the journey to America, sparing their beloved and irrereplacable leader, who would have been on the ship - if he had obeyed the law.

Walther involved his in-laws in the kidnapping, so his future mother-in-law was arrested for her role in Europe. He involved his lawyers in hiding the kids from his own father (a pastor) and the authorities. He also involved his future in-laws in the mob action against Stephan, although he never confronted Stephan about the adultery. Remember that when reading Walther's Pastoral Theology and Law and Gospel. Wonder no more why Missouri treats clergy so badly - Walther established the pattern.

Worst of all, Walther was a crack-pot theologian. I will explore that in the post above, giving people a chance to wipe their brows and get another cup of coffee.

Martin Stephan was investigated for many years. He installed a young
girl in his attic and lived with Louise Guenther at the spa, where he was treated for
syphilitic rashes. Three daughters were deaf, a symptom of congenital syphilis.
He was trained at Halle University, where Knapp taught double-justification.
Thus Stephan founded the Church Growth Movement in the Syn Conferance:
crypto-universalism combined with clergy adultery.

WELS' Doctrine Is Upside-Down:
False Teachers Like Paul Kelm Are Rewarded.
Sound Doctrine Is Banished.



AC V has left a new comment on your post "Infamous Huberists: From the New Gallery at The Sm...":

The ultimate irony is that today in WELS' brand of Lutheranism those who hold to UOJ terminology claim to be holding to the "old and universal method of teaching" and the one who holds to the "new phraseology and new modes of explaining doctrines" such as "Justification is by faith alone" is "compelled to relinquish his office, and go into exile."

***

GJ - The WELS posture of teaching sound doctrine and avoiding false teachers can no longer be maintained without loud guffaws and knee-slapping.  Above is one false teacher congratulating his cell group for promoting the false doctrine of Fuller Seminary and their Father Below, crowing that a new version of their odious newsletter will be published to promote the same bilge.

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Infamous Huberists:
From the New Gallery at The Smoking Gun

Pope John the Malefactor
Easter absolution sermon:
plagiarized from Huber.


AC V has left a new comment on your post "Since We Have So Few Lutherans Left, Let Us Celebr...":

More on Huber and UOJ terminology:

"Learned men are at this day agreed that Huber swerved from the Lutheran doctrines, in words rather than meaning; for what the Lutherans maintain respecting the love of God as embracing the whole human race, and excluding no one absolutely from eternal salvation, this he would explain in a new manner and in new phraseology. But this age having learned from numerous examples, that new phraseology and new modes of explaining doctrines produced as lasting and as pernicious disturbance as new errors, urged Huber to adopt the old and universal method of teaching, in preference to his own. And when he declared that he could not do so, and his patrons here and there threatened to produce disturbance, he was compelled to relinquish his office, and go into exile." - Murdock's Mosheim, Cen. xvi. sec. iii. Part ii. chap. L

The modern history of Universalism, from the era of the Reformation to the present time (Volume v.1) (page 21 of 36)

http://www.ebooksread.com/authors-eng/thomas-whittemore/the-modern-history-of-universalism-from-the-era-of-the-reformation-to-the-prese-tih/page-21-the-modern-history-of-universalism-from-the-era-of-the-reformation-to-the-prese-tih.shtml

Jack Kilcrease, Roman Catholic college instructor.

Jack Cascione, President of the Jack Cascione Synod.

Tim Glende, Tyrant.

Jay Webber, Huber Professor of Universal Forgiveness,
Little Sect on the Prairie.

Stevie Kurtzahn, tireless opponent
of Shrove Tuesday pancakes.


Gurgle and Ski, who help me
spell-check this blog.

Richard Jungkuntz, godfather of radicalism, Seminex,
the first Lutheran seminary to train homosexual and lesbian candidates.
Paul McCain, salesman for the
Calvinist ESV.


Walther Conference Cancelled at Our Lady of Sorrows, St. Louis.
Isn't the Cancellation Automatic Now?



bruce-church (https://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Quote of the Day: Luther and Paul":

The Walther Conference at Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, has been cancelled, the second time this has occurred. It was cancelled after Herman Otten sent an outline of his speech to the synod hierarchy detailing what he thought Walther would have done if he were in leadership today. It was too much for them to bear, apparently.

Several years ago, SP Kieschnick had the Walther conference cancelled at St. Louis seminary specifically because many of the participants and attendees had sued the LCMS and Kieschnick over his election fraud. This occurred despite the out-of-court settlement that Kieschnick signed saying he would not retaliate against the whistle blowers. Then subsequently he violated the agreement again when he approved 114 or so delegate exceptions mostly from the liberal east coast portion of the LCMS, thereby securing his re-election, just as he had done three years before, the very action that brought on the lawsuit. After Kieschnick got away with that scot-free both times, the lawyer Doggert, or whatever his name was, resigned from the Lutheran Foundation, since Kieschnick showed he could act with impunity despite any legal process mounted against him:

Walther 2011 Conference Canceled:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/reclaimnews/message/255

http://christiannewsmo.blogspot.com/2011/10/walther-200-years-after-his-birth-what.html

***

GJ - Sure, Paul McCain was going to let Cascione and Otten occupy Our Lady of Sorrows Seminary in Clayton and get the Bronzies all pumped up. That will happen right after  McCain outgrows his gun fetish.

I remember Bishop Sauer dealing with a group of German ethnic pastors. The "interest group" - as it was called - was entitled to meet and have their officers. They arranged a meeting when Ken Sauer was the LCA bishop in Ohio. He said he could not find the meeting place. That is even better than "I forgot" or Doug Englebrecht ducking a meeting and leaving a letter. How can someone say, "But you did know how to get there."

The Germans were pretty upset and mailed out a letter about it. Perhaps five people read it.

One reader was correct. Almost no one cares about Walther. The vast majority will never read anything about him, so the mythological lies will continue. His methods of grabbing power and bullying others will continue to be emulated by his descendants.

Three people kidnapped, mob rule, massive theft, land fraud -
let's build a shrine to our hero.

The Walther shrine, complete with BVM Walther statue.
Buy mini-statues from Christian News.

Quote of the Day:
Luther and Paul



AC V has left a new comment on your post "Two Birthdays To Note: Martin Luther and Martin Ch...":

Quote of the day:

Martin Luther held that it was "not at all in conformity with the New Testament to write books about Christian doctrine." He noted that before the Apostles wrote books, they "previously preached to and converted the people with the physical voice, which was also their real apostolic and New Testament work."[4] To Luther, it was necessary to write books to counter all the false teachers and errors of the present day, but writing books on Christian teaching came at a price. "But since it became necessary to write books, there is already a great loss, and there is uncertainty as to what is meant."[5] Martin Luther taught preaching and lectured upon the books of the Bible in an exegetical manner. To Luther, St. Paul was the greatest of all systematic theologians, and his Epistle to the Romans was the greatest dogmatics textbook of all time.[1]

from Wikipedia: "Lutheran scholasticism"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lutheran_scholasticism 

Luther Rocks: John 3:16 is Over Rated

Luther Rocks: John 3:16 is Over Rated:

'via Blog this'

Grace In Action CrossTrain Coaching.
Don Patterson and Jeff Gunn Using WELS To Make Profits, Not Prophets

Grace In Action CrossTrain Coaching:

'via Blog this'


CrossTrain Ministries Coaching Network Conference
October 5th - 8th
Daytona Beach, FL
(Fly into Orlando International MCO)

Effective Strategies for Developing Leaders in Your Ministry
(Pastor Don Patterson)

  • Positive communications explaining what you do and why you do it
  • Enlist their services to enjoy opportunities to handle the Word
  • Give them opportunities to see the Word work.
  • Develop strong relationships that allow you to know individual's strengths and weaknesses and apply God's Word to both
  • Integrate the Word as part of every interaction with them.
  • Value the relationship with your leaders by being grace filled and forgiving
  • Live your expectations of others by being a servant
  • Live in the shadow of the cross instead of our success and failures



    Small Group Leadership
    (Pastor Jeff Gunn)

    The means of grace are the key to people growing in their faith. One way to deliver the means of grace to the people of our congregation is via a groups system. "Growth groups" are gatherings of 12-15 people in homes of the congregation for the purpose of sharing the word of God with one another, praying and worshipping with one another, enjoying fellowship, serving in the congregation and community, and reaching out with the gospel.

    PS - Don't forget the rice, Jeff.
    ---


    LutherRocks has left a new comment on your post "Grace In Action CrossTrain Coaching. Don Patterson...":

    The cost of ministry is rising...1200$ per year last May...up 100$ in October. Better sign up while you can! 

Two Birthdays To Note:
Martin Luther and Martin Chemnitz



raklatt (http://raklatt.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Walther's 200th Birthday - October 25, 2011: Mytho...":

We Lutherans look forward to celebrating two birthdays a few days into November. The 9th and the 10th.

Martin Chemnitz and Martin Luther.




Gordon and Norma Yeager — a model of matrimonial harmony « Churchmouse Campanologist




Gordon and Norma Yeager — a model of matrimonial harmony « Churchmouse Campanologist:

'via Blog this'

Since We Have So Few Lutherans Left,
Let Us Celebrate Huberism



LPC has left a new comment on your post "Digging Up an Obscure Theologian: AC V Has a Busy ...":

It is interesting that Huber used to be Reformed. He was in utter wacko mind when he thought that justification was the same as the atonement. This indeed is the paradigm of Calvinism.

Based on that quote that Dr. Greg provided, clearly Huber was a UOJer.

He was also greatly mistaken to believe that a person who claims only believers are saved is a Calvinist. He missed JBFA. Since he missed JBFA he could not then detect universalism in himself. One is a corollary to the other.

LPC

---

AC V has left a new comment on your post "Delicious Quotation from Hardt: UOJ and Huberism":

Huberanism:

http://www.studiumexcitare.com/content/6 

---

LPC has left a new comment on your post "Huber and Walther":

Bruce,

Plagiarize is the word. Thanks for that.

The way he did it was clever, he denounced Huber but at the same time adopted Huber's paradigm. Neat.

The side effect of this? Well he sounded original or insightful and even orthodox.

If a person can be dishonest in his relationship with people (kidnapping etc), does this not trickle down to being dishonest in theology?

Look at Issues Etc., they have now featured Walther's life twice and probably more to come. What is more is that they do it with much adoration.


LPC

---
LPC has left a new comment on your post "Calov, Gerhard, and Quenstedt: Are These Men Addre...":

Agree that UOJ is Huberism as well as Waltherianism.

LPC

---

GreyGoose:


The Huber posts are very interesting.  To understand that the controversy was heated in Chemnitz' time could indicate that the Zwingli/Calvin influence remained in sway with a certain ambivalence and continued at one level or another until the Knapp/Woods definitions tended to solidified things. 
All of the UOJ arguments are of the "well, but..." trait.  Even the Walther quotes are as two-sided as Huber's.
A fascinating look at the historical progressions. 

---

AC V has left a new comment on your post "Who Is Polycarp Leyser? The Founder of a Dynasty o...":

References to the Huber controversy:

He was opposed by Polycarp Lyser and  Hunnius (1593), whom he in his turn charged with Calvinism. For the particulars of the controversy, and the explanations of Huber, see Schröckh, iv. p. 601, and Andr. Schmidii Dissert, de Sam. Hnberi Vita, Fatis et Doctrina, Heimst., 1708, 4. Jul. Niggers, Beiträge zur Lcbensgesch Sam. Hubens, in Illgen's Zeitschrift, 1844. Trechsel, in the Berner Taschenbuch, 1844. Schweizer, Centraidogmen, i. 501 sq.

http://books.google.com/books?pg=PA279&lpg=PA277&dq=Dr.%20Samuel%20Huber%20Lutheran%20theologian%20universalism&sig=r64RhJR00M-X2owTQbWbAQKHayk&ei=yh2oTqOAO4OLsQKIk4jADw&ct=result&id=24QXAAAAYAAJ&ots=2AYNdMwoLj&output=text  


GJ - Someone wondered what happened to Huberism after he was repudiated. The Calvinists began to gain among the Lutherans again. Not long after, Spener took advantage of the Arndt book to publish his new program of unionism, doctrinal indifference, and cell groups - Pious Wishes - the beginning of Pietism.

A recent book by NPH noted that Calvinism is no longer crypto among the Lutherans.

---

bruce-church (https://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Since We Have So Few Lutherans Left, Let Us Celebr...":

One can see why Walther liked the BoC so much. All his errors came to the scene after the BoC was written, and thus they were not proscribed by the BoC. Meanwhile, Walther could charge that his opponents' beliefs violated the BoC.

Walther's 200th Birthday - October 25, 2011:
Mythological Origins of the LCMS.
WELS, ELS, LCMS Filled with Huberism and Enthusiasm


The LCMS continues to promote a mythological view of C. F. W. Walther. Contrary information has been stored at the Concordia Historical Institute, where Paul McCain once sought refuge, but no one wants to admit the truth.

When Walther was born in 1811, Germany was divided between Pietists and rationalists. Orthodox Lutherans were scarcer than hen's teeth. Walther's education was rationalistic but he fell in with a group of extreme Pietists. He was starving himself to death when he found comfort in the less strict cell group circles of Martin Stephan. His new leader was trained in Halle Pietism and took great pride in the success of his cell group congregation in Dresden. Walther gave Stephan credit for saving his life.

When hagiographers write about Walther's health, readers should remember that their hero was emotionally disturbed and starving himself to death with acts of contrition. Doubtless he read plenty of Luther when sick, but that did not make Walther a Lutheran.

Stephan, like many cell group leaders, had profound hold on many of his followers. Although it is true that he had religious opponents, Stephan also made enemies with his early dalliances with various women. Like many cell group or Church Growth leaders, Stephan imagined he had a right to have sex with the women and girls in his congregation.

Unfortunately for his long-suffering wife, Stephan contracted syphilis from his adulteries. This fact is also known among insiders although it might have escaped the notice of his closest followers at the time. Syphillis begins with a sore but may seem to go away without treatment. Various symptoms may appear from time to time, but the ignorant sufferer may think, "I was only imagining that I had the French disease. I have to stop worrying so much." During this stage Stephan passed the disease to his wife. The son was healthy, but three of their daughters were deaf and sickly, symptoms of the congenital syphilis. Stephan and his wife were also plagued with various symptoms.

Stephan had rashes, a sign of syphilis, and his #1 mistress, Louise, lived with him at the spa when he was being treated. Stephan's wife visited the spa to help, but she was sent home. Stephan also installed a young woman in his attic, never explaining why. His wife kicked the girl out and locked the attic. Stephan had the lock broken and brought the girl back. He insisted he was "master of the house." Bullying adulterers and their passive wives are a common feature of the Church Growth Movement today.

Stephan's behavior led to police investigations and various accusations of improprieties with women. He was famous for late-night walks with women. Stephan was under house arrest just before he was allowed to leave for America. His wife gave clear testimony about the extent of his adultery, so the mythologists of today can hardly claim ignorance.

Therefore, the claim that the Stephanites "suddenly" found out about his adultery proves how anxious Walther and his descendants were to hide their prior knowledge of the randy bishop's immorality. Multiple appearances of syphilis among the women in America may have spread panic among the pastors, who knew they would soon be ridiculed again in the newspapers - this time for following a syphilitic impostor.

The Walther gang faced the possibility that they would be arrested with Bishop Stephan, or strung up for bringing a diseased phony to America as their bishop. Those fears explain the frantic and secretive stealing of the bishop's land (given to him by the society) and the mob action. Walther and his mob descended like a pack of wolves on the fold. Walther already prepped his future in-laws and others in Perryville about the bishop, but avoided Stephan.

The Truth about Walther's Mob Action 
Walther had no qualms about breaking the law. He and his brother kidnapped their niece and nephew from their father's parsonage, bringing them to America, where the children died. The police issued arrest warrants for Walther, which is why he left Europe on a different ship. His ship sank in a storm, leading the hagiographers to rejoice that God spared the life of their hero, whose personality and doctrine left an indelible (bad) impression on the LCMS.

Walther led the mob of 300 from St. Louis to Perryville on May 29th. He left the bishop's supporters at home. According to Stephan himself:
  • Pastors Loeber and Keyl told Stephan he was no longer bishop. Stephan was denied food from that time on.
  • Vehse and Marbach, attorneys who helped Walther kidnap the children, helped lead the mob.
  • Vehse forced Stephan to undress, so they could look for more money to steal from him.
  • Two men guarded Stephan - forcible detention. The mob surrounded the house, lit fires, and hit the house with whips. In effect, they threatened the life of Stephan and forced him to surrender all his personal possessions, money, and books, leaving him bankrupt. All this happened without a trial or even a hearing.
  • The mob stole 4000 gold coins.
  • They also took 1500 books, a valuable library even today, but far more precious in the days of the letter-press.
  • They stole his clothing and bedding.
  • Contrary to the lies being spread today in Perry County by Walther's idolaters, Stephan was not given a choice over the courts, a return to Europe, or exile in Illinois. He was taken at gunpoint on a steamer the next day, with nothing left. This was the third kidnapping arranged by Walther, yet the Purple Palace historians hail him as the American Luther.
  • The felons dumped Stephan in a ramshackle hut with a spade and an axe to "earn his living."
  • Not content with what they had already done, the Society spread stories about Stephan, such as his conversion to Roman Catholicism. They accused him of being an embezzler, although he had no access to the funds.
  • Louis Guenther, his #1 mistress, came over to help Stephan and live with him. She had previously lived with him at the spa. Stephan was quite ill at this point, doubtless a response to his stress and exposure, being forced to camp on the ground the night he was driven out of his house.
  • Walther fraudulently tricked Stephan's son into giving up the title to the 80 acres that the bishop bought with his own money. The son had no right to change ownership and later felt used and abused by Walther. Nevertheless, the Stephan family has had a long and impressive history in the LCMS. One was a speaker for the Lutheran Hour.
  • Stephan eventually took his case to court and won back a token amount from the Society. The mob kept two valuable chalices they stole from him, which are still a point of contention. One was used for Holy Communion at Walther's church in St. Louis. Ain't that sweet?


I have no use for adulterous pastors. Their marital infidelity is but a clue of their unfaithfulness to the Word of God. Stephan was a disease-ridden false teacher, but Walther's gang were his enablers. They participated in his Pietism, his blend of Lutheran and Calvinistic doctrine. They ignored Stephan's numerous and obvious examples of immorality. They were like many city folks who came to America and found the wilderness to be far less than they imagined.

The Saxon Immigration Society reminds me of the Columbus WELS pastors, who knowingly followed a man kicked out of the LCMS ministerium and sued by the husband of one mistress. All their subsequent troubles can be traced to their willingness to spread false doctrine while overlooking the obvious. Unwilling to let WELS enjoy all the toxins and pathogens, the Little Sect on the Prairie adopted the same adulterer and worked with him through Thoughts of Faith (sic). Impressario Jay Webber, a true Waltherian, said he was helpless to do anything about it.

Walther's methods have created the template for Synodical Conference behavior. He had to be top dog. Any deception was fine, as long as it advanced his personal cause. Anyone who differed with Walther was driven away. All the Lutheran groups were supposed to bow to Walther. If they wavered, he denounced them as false teachers.

In Pursuit of Religious Freedom is essential reading to get behind the lies told by Paul McCain, Steadfast Lutherans (sic), SP Harrison, Christian News, and the rest.

The Stephan website is also worth studying.

Yes, we know Stephan was really a cad, but nothing justifies the behavior of the Walther mob.

The Stephan website is managed by a lesbian descendant of Stephan, but that does not change the facts. McCain's knee-jerk personal attacks are right from the Walther playbook.



---

rlschultz has left a new comment on your post "Walther's 200th Birthday - October 25, 2011: Mytho...":

Two hundred years later in this country, Orthodox Lutherans are still scarcer than hen's teeth.