Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Intrepid Lutherans: C.F.W. Walther: Filching from sectarian worship resources equals "soul murder"



Intrepid Lutherans: C.F.W. Walther: Filching from sectarian worship resources equals "soul murder"


WEDNESDAY, MARCH 23, 2011


C.F.W. Walther: Filching from sectarian worship resources equals "soul murder"


In October of 1998, Professor Mark DeGarmeaux (Bethany Lutheran College, ELS) delivered a paper to the Evangelical Lutheran Confessional Forum of the ELS and WELS in Milwaukee, WI. The title of this paper was Sacramental Worship, Sacramental Preaching: Treasures of our Lutheran Church -- a terrific little essay that explores and extols the unique liturgical treasure we Lutherans have inherited, concluding:
    The Lutheran church has been truly blessed by God with a rich treasury of liturgy, hymnody, preaching, and praying. We are not a sect, but we understand and recognize ourselves as part of the Church catholic, the one Holy Christian and Apostolic Church. At the same time we realize that there is a difference between our theology and that of other denominations in many ways. Our treasures are in the understanding of sacramental and sacrificial elements in the Divine Service, in understanding the Word and Sacraments as powerful and efficacious means of grace, and in the proper distinction between Law and Gospel. And we look forward to the marriage feast of heaven when the Bride will be joined to Christ Himself and will enjoy the great sacramentum of the marriage feast of the Lamb.
This treasure has been kept and valued by generations of Lutheran confessors as a practice which carries a body of worshipers through the Divine Service, focusing them on Christ and His gifts, in a way that not only represents and reinforces our body of pure doctrine, but our distinction and separation from the heterodox. So how would a Lutheran, imbued with genuine confessional ardor, react to the notion of importing sectarian worship forms into Lutheran practice? Using C.F.W. Walther as a benchmark of confessional ardor, DeGarmeaux demonstrates the answer to this question by including as an Appendix to his essay the following letter from Walther, which was written to a man who asked about the use of Methodist worship resources in Lutheran churches:
    Carl Ferdinand Wilhelm WaltherHonored Sir, This morning I received your worthy letter, written on the 19th of the month. In your letter you ask for my opinion on whether it is advisable to introduce the singing of Methodist songs in a Lutheran Sunday School. May what follows serve as a helpful reply to your questions: No, this is not advisable, rather very incorrect and pernicious.
    1. Our church is so rich in hymns that you could justifiably state that if one were to introduce Methodist hymns in a Lutheran school this would be like carrying coals to Newcastle. The singing of such hymns would make the rich Lutheran Church into a beggar which is forced to beg from a miserable sect. Thirty or forty years ago a Lutheran preacher might well have been forgiven this. For at that time the Lutheran Church in our country was as poor as a beggar when it comes to song books for Lutheran children. A preacher scarcely knew where he might obtain such little hymn books. Now, however, since our church itself has everything it needs, it is unpardonable when a preacher of our church causes little ones to suffer the shame of eating a foreign bread.
    2. A preacher of our church also has the holy duty to give souls entrusted to his care pure spiritual food, indeed, the very best which he can possibly obtain. In Methodist songs there is much which is false, and which contains spiritual poison for the soul.Therefore, it is soul-murder to set before children such poisonous food. If the preacher claims, that he allows only "correct" hymns to be sung, this does not excuse him. For, first of all, the true Lutheran spirit is found in none of them; second, our hymns are more powerful, more substantive, and more prosaic; third, those hymns which deal with the Holy Sacraments are completely in error; fourth, when these little sectarian hymnbooks come into the hands of our children, they openly read and sing false hymns.
    3. A preacher who introduces Methodist hymns, let alone Methodist hymnals, raises the suspicion that he is no true Lutheran at heart, and that he believes one religion is as good as the other, and that he thus a unionistic-man, a mingler of religion and churches.
    4. Through the introduction of Methodist hymn singing he also makes those children entrusted to his care of unionistic sentiment, and he himself leads them to leave the Lutheran Church and join the Methodists.
    5. By the purchase of Methodist hymn books he subsidizes the false church and strengthens the Methodist fanatics in their horrible errors. For the Methodists will think, and quite correctly so, that if the Lutheran preachers did not regard our religion as good as, or indeed, even better than their own, they would not introduce Methodist hymn books in their Sunday schools, but rather would use Lutheran hymn books.
    6. By introducing Methodist hymn books, the entire Lutheran congregation is given great offense, and the members of the same are lead to think that Methodists, the Albright people, and all such people have a better faith than we do.
    This may be a sufficient answer regarding this dismal matter. May God keep you in the true and genuine Lutheran faith, and help you not to be misled from the same, either to the right or to the left. Your unfamiliar, yet known friend, in the Lord Jesus Christ, C. F. W. Walther St. Louis, Missouri January 23, 1883
Notice that there are at least two factors involved in Walther's blistering criticism of sectarian worship resources. First, the introduction of false teaching to the congregation (a) by the false content of the sectarian worship, (b) by the true teaching which is absent from it, and (c) by the manner in which the Methodist practice itself entices the congregation away from the Lutheran confession, is inexcusable and alone grounds for rejecting material from such sources. Second, the fellowship implications involved with endorsing such materials, and subsidizing their sources, not only impacts other Lutherans, who have every right to question the allegiances of those responsible for introducing such materials, but impacts the sectarians from whom we remain separate, who consequently have every right to suspect (based on the practice of using sectarian sources, itself!) that those Lutherans using their materials are, in fact, admitting deficiency in their own confession.

If we grant that Walther is a suitable benchmark of confessional ardor, how would we categorize those who are indifferent to the usage of sectarian and heterodox worship materials? According to Walther, above, it seems that a pastor who engages in practice which raises suspicions regarding his confession is himself guilty of offense against the whole congregation, not the observer who is led to suspicion on the basis of that pastor's public practice. Is this an accurate assessment of the above statements? If so, is this consistent with more contemporary teaching regarding how one ought to interpret public practice? Based on what Walther seems to say above, should a Lutheran pastor so conduct himself in his public practice as to raise no suspicions regarding his fidelity to the Lutheran confession, or is such fidelity strictly a matter of internal motivations, making public practice not much of a big deal at all?

***

GJ - Message understood, Intrepids. Why should Lutherans borrow double-justification from that Halle Pietist Georg Christian Knapp? Knapp's UOJ was in print before Ferdy landed on the docks of the Big Easy.

Knapp's UOJ is still in print today.

Knapp's formulation became the mainline denominations' Universalism as the 19th century progressed (or regressed). UOJ is the Universalism of Missouri, WELS, and the Little Sect today.

I ask again - why borrow from false teachers when Luther and the Concordists are so clear?

Rob Bell and Universalism - From Church Mouse

Rob Bell, Fuller Seminary grad - just like Larry Olson, the Harmless Heretic, and many others in WELS and Missouri.
The Little Sect, too, but they do not count.



Rob Bell and Christian Universalism — your kids (may) love it « Churchmouse Campanologist


As I’ve explained in the previous two posts (here and here), Christian Universalism is deeply seductive to the enquiring mind.
I’m not sure what advice to give to parents out there except to get your children started early on the Bible so that they are well grounded in it by the time they reach secondary school.  After that, it may be too late … for a number of years, anyway.  What I noted from my own experience growing up was that the kids who knew the Bible could refute Christian Universalism — or Universal Reconciliation — straightaway, explaining why.


***
GJ
Rob Bell went to Fuller? I thought that was such a conservative seminary! All the WELS and LCMS leaders went there: world missions, American missions, evangelism, snake handling. 


Mid-Week Lenten Service


By Norma Boeckler, Word and Sacrament




Mid-Week Lenten Vespers


Pastor Gregory L. Jackson

http://www.ustream.tv/channel/bethany-lutheran-worship

Bethany Lutheran Worship, 7 PM Central Time

The Hymn # 142 A Lamb 1:21
The Order of Vespers p. 41
The Psalmody Psalm 3 p. 123
The Lection The Passion History

The Sermon Hymn #5 Open Thou My Heart 1:93

The Sermon – The Way, the Truth, the Life

The Prayers
The Lord’s Prayer
The Collect for Grace p. 45

The Hymn # 46 On What Has Now 1:62

KJV John 14:1 Let not your heart be troubled: ye believe in God, believe also in me. 2 In my Father's house are many mansions: if it were not so, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you. 3 And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you unto myself; that where I am, there ye may be also. 4 And whither I go ye know, and the way ye know. 5 Thomas saith unto him, Lord, we know not whither thou goest; and how can we know the way? 6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me. 7 If ye had known me, ye should have known my Father also: and from henceforth ye know him, and have seen him. 8 Philip saith unto him, Lord, shew us the Father, and it sufficeth us. 9 Jesus saith unto him, Have I been so long time with you, and yet hast thou not known me, Philip? he that hath seen me hath seen the Father; and how sayest thou then, Shew us the Father? 10 Believest thou not that I am in the Father, and the Father in me? the words that I speak unto you I speak not of myself: but the Father that dwelleth in me, he doeth the works.

This passage from John is an excellent example of how much teaching can be found in one paragraph of that Gospel, yet the thoughts are expressed in the simplest words possible.

I noticed when attending another service that many passages in the Bible fall into poetical cadences, short phrases, easy to remember and understand. In this particular case, it was this part of the birth story for Christmas:

KJV Luke 2:1 And it came to pass in those days,
that there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus,
that all the world should be taxed.
2 (And this taxing was first made when Cyrenius was governor of Syria.)
3 And all went to be taxed,
every one into his own city.
4 And Joseph also went up from Galilee,
out of the city of Nazareth, into Judaea, unto the city of David,
which is called Bethlehem;
(because he was of the house and lineage of David:)
5 To be taxed with Mary his espoused wife,
being great with child.
6 And so it was, that, while they were there,
the days were accomplished that she should be delivered.
7 And she brought forth her firstborn son,
and wrapped him in swaddling clothes,
and laid him in a manger;
because there was no room for them in the inn.

We can easily imagine the angelic message being memorized and passed on as poetry or as a hymn:

10 And the angel said unto them,
Fear not:
for, behold, I bring you good tidings of great joy,
which shall be to all people.
11 For unto you is born this day
in the city of David
a Saviour,
which is Christ the Lord.
12 And this shall be a sign unto you;
Ye shall find the babe
wrapped in swaddling clothes,
lying in a manger.

I noticed the poetic structure because the minister ran everything together as prose.

John’s Gospel is considered the most poetic, because all of Jesus’ sermons fall into the short, simple repetitive phrases of poetry. That is one reason why they are remembered so well. Try reading them that way.

There are two main messages in this paragraph from John. One is the relationship between the Father and the Son. That is constantly emphasized in the Fourth Gospel but also found elsewhere:

KJV Matthew 11:27 All things are delivered unto me of my Father: and no man knoweth the Son, but the Father; neither knoweth any man the Father, save the Son, and he to whomsoever the Son will reveal him.

That is also in poetic phrases.

The point in this passage is illustrated by the foolish statement of Philip, “Show us the Father and it will be enough.”

The response dispels the notion that the Father and Son are entirely separate, although they are distinct persons of the Trinity. Hearing the Son means hearing the Father. Seeing the Son means seeing the Father.

Everything Christ does is from the Father. Thus, anyone who tries to make three gods out of the Trinity is wrong. The Gospel of John teaches the Three-ness of the One God and the Unity of the Three Persons.

Some might ask, “If so much is said about the Father-Son relationship, is the Holy Spirit neglected?”

John’s Gospel also includes one of the most extensive sermons on the Holy Spirit, one so significant that every pastor should memorize it as much as possible.

Notice that John’s Gospel does not have Chapter 1 – The Father, Chapter 2 – The Son, Chapter 3 – the Holy Spirit. The revealed Word is not at all like a Confession of Faith (by man) or a theology textbook. But from the Word of God we can put together what God teaches.

John 14:5 Thomas saith unto him, Lord, we know not whither thou goest; and how can we know the way? 6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.

This is a word play, which we also use in English. The way is literally the road, often used or abused in the term synod (walking together, although flash mobs are more organized and better disciplined).

There is a transition from “Where are you going?” to the great I AM statement:

I am The Way, The Truth, and The Life.

This completely repudiates those opinions which treat Jesus as one more great religious teacher. This era is no different from the pagan era, where people were glad to welcome Jesus as another religious leader, as long as they could buy His magic (they imagined) or associate Him with others.

This sentence alone cannot be confessed while also stating that there are other paths or roads to salvation. While that sounds tolerant and open-minded, to equate Jesus with Buddha and tree gods, it is just the opposite. Those who compromise the faith to allow pagan religion are soul-murderers. They are more dangerous than pagans because they blend a tiny bit of truth with a dominant supply of error.

The second part of the statement leaves no doubt with its litotes, or double negative to illustrate a positive in unmistakable terms. No one (negative) except (negative).

That does not permit any special cases, for no one can possibly know the Father except through knowing the Son.

This gives us the greatest confidence that in John’s Gospel we have the true revelation of the grace of the Father in giving His beloved Son to die for our sins.

The Bible judges all books. If someone comes up with a theory or a great work of bogus scholarship to set John’s Gospel aside, we know better. No book judges the Fourth Gospel, but John’s Gospel judges all attempts to interpret it.

If someone is looking for sermon books, get Luther’s sermons on the Gospel of John. He gave those sermons reluctantly when he said he would rather be working in the garden, retired.

There is more truth in one page of Luther’s correct interpretation of John than in all the “practical” books of the moderns.

John’s Gospel is a constant source of God’s grace, a way to build up one’s confidence in the Word, and a great comfort and guide. The Fourth Gospel is Jesus speaking to us in His simple, yet profound sermons.

More on the Bloat



bruce-church (https://bruce-church.myopenid.com/) has left a new comment on your post "Bloated Hours, Bloated Costs at Lutheran Seminarie...":

Wow! I guess everyone is so stunned by the situation with the LCMS seminaries that they can't even comment--including even President Harrison. One seminary president is calling it quits after this year, too. I wonder why.

***

GJ - Readership is staying near 2,000 page-reads per day. I get an idea who is reading it by some of the emails I get.

One ELS pastor said, "Everyone reads Ichabod." Traffic was very high during the last WELS convention.

Synodical officials make sure they know what is being said about their territory, so assume, Rev. Church, that every post about them is read and discussed.

I see things evaporate right after being quoted here. That is why I kelm them into the post instead of just posting.

And readers - Rev. Church has provided a vast amount of information about the cost of seminaries. Fairly soon I will post my 25 year predictions. Remember, I was 25 years early in writing about ELCA.

If you do not read this blog for the opinions, read it for the facts and the quotations.

Those who like anonymous, malicious gossip have Tim Glende's quarterly effort to entertain them.

Denominational Abuse Continues


I am not ready to defend the Church of Rome for anything, but they finally started doing something about their abusive church workers. The criminal conspiracies to cover up began 24 years ago. There was widespread reporting and an institutional effort to clamp down - on those trying to reform Rome. They finally lost so many lawsuits and so much respect that the new pope had to take action.

WELS, Missouri, and the ELS should take note. They have used the same criminal cover-up tactics. What earthly courts will not handle will finally be addressed in the ultimate Supreme Court. It's fun to dine on Daddy Warbucks' dime, but our mortal days are short, nothing in comparison with eternity. Meanwhile, many are harmed - not only the targeted victims, but also many surrounding them. The corruption caused by the cover-up adds to the crime. Clergy and laity learn to look the other way, lest they be accused of evil. Soon they can overlook everything, and they do in the good ol' boy network. How else does one become a Doctrinal Pussycat?

Someone contacted me today. All the details I will offer is this - decades of suffering have followed her experience.

The ELCA had to pay out $40 million for one case, where a known homosexual predator was ordained. Their news service published the story. It was not hidden. I am no fan of ELCA, but that is a good start, to publish the truth.

Rome got rid of Wisconsin Lutheran College's famous lecturer, Archbishop Weakland. They forced him into retirement. His lurid life was exposed and his embezzlement of church funds publicized. Still, many stuck by him.
Long before "Party in the MLC," there was Weakland, lecturing at Willowcreek's Little College.

New Graphics Folder for Frequent Writers

WELS Church Lady.


I am developing graphics for people who write often. They are intended to be complimentary. I appreciate the extra research done and the insights offered.

Bloated Hours, Bloated Costs at Lutheran Seminaries,
Revealed by Bruce Church



Bruce Church has left a new comment on your post "Essay Backs Bruce Church's Arguments about Seminar...":

Seminary professor Frederick Schmidt says that many M. Div. programs are "bloated," no doubt so seminaries could rake in more federal student loan dollars per degree. He says that the accrediting agency only requires 72 credit hours for a M. Div., but is aghast that some seminaries require as much as 106 credit hours. He'd probably have seizures if he heard how many credit hours the LCMS seminaries get away with requiring, namely 137 and 139 (see links below). You'd have to look at the US defense department to find "cost overruns" as big as the cost overrun for getting a LCMS M. Div. For that many credit hours, you'd think a guy could walk away with a M. Div and a D. Min, or at least be well on his way toward receiving a Doctor of Theology.

So if 106 credit hours is "bloated and expensive," and the most expensive Methodist seminary out of their dozen or so seminaries is the 29th most expensive seminary in N America, then what adjectives are left to describe the LCMS's M. Div. programs, which are 9th and 11th most expensive programs in N America, and require nearly twice as many credit hours to graduate than is required by ATS!:

Seminary costs compared:
http://www.scribd.com/bruce_church
----
Concordia St. Louis M. Div.
http://www.csl.edu/admissions/academics/mdiv/curriculum/
Credit Hours/Area
27 Exegetical Theology
26 Systematic Theology
18 Historical Theology
30 Practical Theology
18 Free Electives
18 Vicarage
137 Total
----
Concordia Ft. Wayne M. Div.
http://www.ctsfw.edu/Page.aspx?pid=392
Credit Hours/Area
40 Exegetical Theology
18 Historical Theology
43 Pastoral Ministry and Missions
29 Systematic Theology
3 Field Education and Vicarage
6 Electives
139 Total
----
http://www.patheos.com/Resources/Additional-Resources/Is-It-Time-to-Write-the-Eulogy-Frederick-Schmidt-03-21-2011?offset=1&max=1

In spite of the fact that there is room for so many extras, the degree itself is bloated and expensive. The Association of Theological Schools require at least 72 hours of course work, but some seminaries require as much as 106 hours; and the inside joke among most seminarians is that they will be fortunate to crowd three years into four . . . or five.

Flow of Funds to Seminaries
http://ichabodthegloryhasdeparted.blogspot.com/2011/02/flow-of-funds-to-seminaries.html

***

GJ - Add to that, an MDiv is a useless degree. Try to market it for a job, even in teaching. In higher education, a lawyer gets doctoral level pay. An MDiv will not get hired to teach anything.

One seminary veteran used his skills in ancient languages to learn computer languages, taking courses at a top computer science school. He gets wahoo pay and benefits now, plus bonus awards and incentives. He also uses his training to help at his local church.

The Lutheran seminaries deceive men into thinking there is a shortage, even though congregations are folding and merging (a polite way to fold). The seminaries are used as a convenient place to put a Flounder into a job because he has the same last name as an earlier professor, his father or uncle or in-law.

Meanwhile, the same synods are filling the gaps with non-traditional training, which erases even more slots.

If the synods got rid of abusive teachers and pastors, not to mention the alcoholics, there would be a critical shortage and higher standards. The only one now is a blood test.

"Oh? Fifth generation and related to four professors, three DPs, and one Daddy Warbucks? You can do no wrong, buddy. We need more just like you. Ignore the legalists. They do not appreciate the awesomeness of you."

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

ELCA Presiding Bishop Promises:
"It Gets Better"

"Please, Brett. No jokes about the title."


ELCA NEWS SERVICE
March 21, 2011
'It Gets Better' Book Features ELCA Presiding Bishop
11-035-JB
[Click for larger image] ELCA Presiding Bishop Mark S. Hanson recorded a video for the 'It Gets Better' project in October 2010.     CHICAGO (ELCA) -- An essay written by the presiding bishop of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) is featured in a new book, It Gets Better: Coming Out, Overcoming Bullying, and Creating a Life Worth Living. The Rev. Mark S. Hanson's essay is a transcript of his "It Gets Better" video, which was posted on the project's YouTube channel in October 2010.
     Hanson's essay was selected for inclusion by Dan Savage and Terry Miller, the founders of the project and the editors of the book. The two men launched the "It Gets Better" project when they created a YouTube video that reached out to lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender youth facing harassment and bullying.
     What followed was a worldwide phenomenon. According to the book's notes, more than 6,000 "It Gets Better" videos with messages of hope and encouragement have been posted to date, with more than 20 million views the first three months.
     In his essay, Hanson offers reassurance to young people who are gay, lesbian, bisexual or transgender, saying, "You are a beloved child of God."
     "Your life carries the dignity and beauty of God's creation," Hanson said. "God has called you by name and claimed you forever. There is a place for you in this world and in this church." 
     Hanson, the father of six children and four grandchildren, writes that words have the power to both harm and heal people. "Sometimes the words of my Christian brothers and sisters have hurt you, and I also know that our silence causes you pain," he wrote.
     Hanson adds that as a Christian, he trusts God is working in the world for justice and peace "through you and through me. It gets better," he said.
     Among the many writers whose essays are featured in the book are President Barack Obama; the Rev. V. Gene Robinson, bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of New Hampshire; Ellen Degeneres, entertainer; U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton; U.S. Sen. Al Franken of Minnesota; U.S. Rep. Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco; and Suze Orman, author and financial adviser.

"Brett, stop enabling Jackson!"

Are the Young Too Stressed?



grumpy has left a new comment on your post "Another Stab At Michigan Lutheran Seminary":

I have noticed that the younger generation of pastors often complain about being overworked and overstressed, unable to balance work and family, etc., etc., etc.....

It is interesting that an "oldster" like Prof. Zeiger would need to take over from a "youngun" like Pastor Frey....

The future does not look rosy if this trend is widespread. Unfortunately, I have seen this myself among some of the youngsters out there....

Grumpy "Hey kid, stay off my lawn" Lutheran...

Essay Backs Bruce Church's Arguments about Seminary Education




Is It Time To Write the Eulogy?


A large number of the mainline seminaries are selling their buildings and property, cutting faculty, and eliminating degree programs. Those that are not, are competing for a shrinking pool of prospective students and rely on scholarships and lower academic standards to attract the students that they do have...


Denominations have left seminarians to pay for their educations, saddling them with debt that they cannot comfortably repay because beginning salaries for clergy are often below the poverty level. And, at the same time, they have offered alternative routes to ordination bypassing seminary entirely, leaving those who do go to wonder why they worked so hard to accomplish the same goal. What we will never know is how many prospective clergy are lost because they conclude that if the ministry is something you can do without preparation it isn't really worthy of their attention....

In some cases a seminarian can wait five to seven years before learning if she will be ordained, and in the meantime he is forced to run a gauntlet of committees and requirements that is more akin to hazing for membership in a fraternity, than it is serious preparation for ministry.

Synod President Biographies Are Full of Holes


WELS SP Mark Schroeder


Three Synod Trifecta

May 5-6, 2011
Lecturer: The Reverend President Mark G. Schroeder, Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod. President Mark Schroeder graduated from Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary in 1981. He served in the parish as the Pastor of Faith Evangelical Lutheran Church in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin. He then served as president both of Northwestern Preparatory School in Watertown, Wisconsin and of the newly formed Luther Preparatory School on the Watertown campus and guided the amalgamation of two synodical preparatory schools into the new Luther Preparatory School. In July, 2007, he was elected president of the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod. President Schroeder married his high school sweetheart Andrea (Kuester) in 1977 and they have been blessed with four children.

***

GJ 

- He was assigned to Fond du Lac in 1981.
- He accepted a call to Maitland, FL in 1987. Oops. Left out of the bio.
- He accepted Call to Northwestern Prep in 1990.
- He accepted Presidency of new “Luther Prep School” in 1996.
- He was elected Synod President in 2007.

I have noticed this before. No one would ever know that Joel Gerlach left WELS. That was erased from his bio. When I mentioned that, based on local narratives, someone wrote, "I found that in the conference notes." He came back, of course, to make the synod safe for Church Growth. That is ironic, since Gerlach apparently left over a doctrinal issue.

During the Al Barry supremacy, the denizens of LQ made a big deal over my synod membeships. Someone born and bred LCMS was de facto superior (as long as everyone forgot about Cascione, who was rejected by the ELS and founded the Cascione Synod). I brought up Al Barry's extensive synodical history, which included the church basement seminary plus Bethany (ELS) plus a WELS vicarage and finally Missouri. That could not be found in the Concordia Historical Institute bio. Perhaps McCain photoshopped the bio during his brief tenure at the CHI.

Jack and Robert Preus belongws to three synods.

Why the Gap with Schroeder?
One person offered this opinion - a short call would not be listed by WELS pastors, according to custom.

The funny thing is, I remember the call to Florida. At the time, my WELS friends told me that anyone who got too critical of Church Growth was given a call out of Florida. Florida was Radloff's baby. He graduated with Valleskey, so the two of them would be good sources about how CG started in WELS.

I was starting to publish in Christian News about Church Growth. I got a letter from Pastor Mark Schroeder in Florida. He asked me for resources about Church Growth because he was assigned a paper about it for his conference. I sent a packet to Florida. In a few weeks I saw that he was called to be the president of the Watertown prep.

He has been Synod President for almost four years now. He has not acknowledged in public that Church Growth doctrine exists in WELS. Sweeping changes include:
  1. The CG VP Wayne Mueller was replaced with Fuller grad VP Jim Huebner.
  2. Church and Change has done everything it wanted, and still has a website active, with so many nodes growing that the original cancer site no longer matters.
  3. Church and Change founder Steve Witte (DMin, Gordon Conwell) was promoted to the Asian board first, then promoted to seminary president there.
  4. Church and Change founder John Parlow has gone with various groups to such events as the Babtist Drive conferences hosted by Andy Stanley.
  5. Church and Change leader Don Patterson (a district vp, woo-hoo) has led a group of suckers to Exponential, a pan-demon conference in Orlando each year.
  6. Shrinker leaders like Aderman, Patterson, and Bivens write for FICL, dominate FICL.
  7. Major domo Mark Jeske does whatever he wants, in whatever synod he wants.

Call me over-speculative, but I believe the Florida exile represents the unmentionable in WELS, Missouri, and the ELS today - Enthusiasm, Church Growth and worse, denying the Efficacy of the Word, UOJ.

One man put this in his office: "The unspoken is often the most significant thing."

That must be true, because there have many efforts to silence me. All I do is post or publish what is easily obtained from the libraries and the Net. I mention the unmentionable.

Their Shrinkers can give R-rate sermons, so bad that children are warned to stay away. But the truth is treated as pornography.

My Definition of Irony - Intrepids Lindee and Webber Praising Krauth!

Tuesday, March 22, 2011


C.P. Krauth explains how orthodox Lutheran Synods descend into heterodoxy

Charles Porterfield KrauthThe name Charles Porterfield Krauth (d. 1883) may be unfamiliar to most WELS Lutherans. Perhaps this is because he was not WELS. Regardless of the reason, this unfamiliarity is most unfortunate, for Krauth was, in fact, a leading figure of the confessional Lutheran movement in 19th Century America, and his contributions to confessionalism remain vitally important. He was a Lutheran of the early Eastern synods and a student of Samuel Schmucker (d. 1873) – who taught that the Augsburg Confession was rife with error, envisioned a future for American Lutheranism which espoused union with Reformed and Methodist Christians, advocated a theological formula for doing so, and even founded an organization to advance these ideas. Krauth grew to oppose Schmucker, his former teacher, eventually retiring from parish ministry to combat unionism full-time and to work toward establishing confessional unity among Lutherans in America under the Unaltered Augsburg Confession. To this end, and under Krauth's leadership, the General Council was formed in 1867, serving as a significant and positive force for the advancement of Lutheran confessionalism. That work still being "relevant", portions of the General Council's output has even appeared on Intrepid Lutherans in the past – the Explanation of the Common Service being published on this blog last July (which is now available in book form from Emmanuel Press, should the reader desire a personal copy). Regarding Krauth and his significance, Rev. David Jay Webber (Little Sect on the Prairie), in his fine essay Charles Porterfield Krauth: The American Chemnitz, quotes a figure who should be familiar to WELS Lutherans – C.F.W. Walther:

***

GJ - There is just one little problem with Lindee and Webber gushing about Krauth. Both of them teach against justification by faith, unlike Krauth.

The General Council theologians recognized and emphasized the efficacy of the Word in the Means of Grace. I believe Knapp's peculiar notion of double-justification was unknown in the General Council, although it was a fetish of Walther and Pieper.

Krauth taught in harmony with Luther because he was trained in an anti-confessional atmosphere, knowing far more about the union spirit than anyone.

In contrast, Walther became a Christian through Pietism, came from Pietistic circles, and arrived in America with a Pietist bishop-for-life, Stephan. Walther's struggle was over leadership rather than doctrine, and he quickly became the new bishop-for-life. He also picked his successor, F. Pieper.

Spener and Halle were both such halle-wed names in the 19th century that no one could question anyone or any idea from there. Nor did people like to admit that Pietism turned to pure rationalism so quickly.

Walther and Pieper were good examples of the 19th century American ideal, a union of the Reformed and Lutheran ideals. All Lutheran-Reformed unions ended up Reformed, with the ones more influenced by Lutheran doctrine lasting longer. Krauth wrote about that as an example from church history.

The Walther sect grew so rationalistic that it took a major revolution to install a synod president with intellectual ties to Lutheran Orthodoxy (Jack Preus).

If that were not bad enough, WELS and Missouri sent all their leaders through Fuller Seminary and rewarded anyone with a Fuller degree. This happened because everyone was fussing over the canon law of Pietism rather than teaching the Means of Grace. May I pray with my maiden aunt on her deathbed if she is ALC but really orthodox? "Yes!" "No!" "Well, it depends. Are you sure she will die?"

Lindee is correct in pointing out the three stages of error, which first came from Augustine. He and Webber are good examples of UOJ Enthusism being the third stage of error in the Synodical Conference. UOJ is the only "doctrine" taught by the Synodical Conference now, and they all agree about it. They might as well merge so they can circle the drain together.

Church and Change's websty and programs are intact. But don't let me catch you talking about justification by faith.


---

"The Holy Spirit works through the Word and the Sacraments, which only,
in the proper sense, are means of grace. Both the Word and the Sacraments bring
a positive grace, which is offered to all who receive them outwardly, and which
is actually imparted to all who have faith to embrace it."
Charles P. Krauth, The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology, Philadelphia: The United Lutheran Publication House, 1871, p. 127.

Krauth's statement is incompatible with Lindee and Webber claiming that grace comes to people without and before the Word.

The Blessing of the Compost, Reprise


Iggy Antiochus wanted a photo of the Blessing of the Compost at the Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago (ELCA).

Another Stab At Michigan Lutheran Seminary

Voss called as next MLS president


On March 14, the Michigan Lutheran Seminary Governing Board called Rev. David Voss from Memorial, Williamston, Mich., to serve as president of Michigan Lutheran Seminary (MLS), one of two preparatory schools operated by the synod.

A 1983 graduate of Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary, Voss has also served at Faith, River Falls, Wis.
Rev. Paul Prange, administrator of WELS Board for Ministerial Education, notes that Voss has experience in educational administration at his current congregation, which would serve him well as president of MLS.

Rev. Jonathan Schroeder from Faith, Sharpsburg, Ga., returned the call as MLS president last week. The position has been vacant since Sept. 17, 2010, when Rev. Aaron Frey resigned the position. Dr. William Zeiger, vice president of MLS, is serving as president during the vacancy.


***
GJ - Did you wonder why Anonymous Blogger Tim Glende went Medieval about my truthful description of Aaron Frey resigning? I did too. They graduated the same year at The Sausage Factory, where the claim of infallibility is backed by "I drank a lot of beer with him!" That is how Rich Krause defended the Harmless Heretic Larry Olson. Krause neglected to mention that Olson picked up a quickie DMin from Fuller, which qualified the Very Rev. Dr. Olson to supervise Krause for a similar drive-by DMin. Notice that all the WELS Shrinker DMins call themselves "Dr." all the time. Hahahaha.

Glende still has an alleged statement from Aaron Frey on his blog. The trouble is - there is no proof that statement was ever made. It did not appear on Frey's FB page or blog when I saw it. Keep on making stuff up, Tim, as much as your conscience allows.

I am looking for the new WELS call report, to settle some factual matters with Anonymouse, above. For some reason it is not posted yet.


WELS Discipline - Never at Rest - Always Searching Out and Destroying...Lutheran Faith

Jesus is his rice!



Brett Meyer has left a new comment on your post "Two events designed for lay members | Wisconsin Ev...":

CrossTrain Ministries Coaching Network

This ministry is being partially funded by Grace in Action (GIA) and WELS Kingdom Workers.

Small Group Leadership
(Pastor Jeff Gunn)

The means of grace are the key to people growing in their faith. One way to deliver the means of grace to the people of our congregation is via a groups system. "Growth groups" are gatherings of 12-15 people in homes of the congregation for the purpose of sharing the word of God with one another, praying and worshipping with one another, enjoying fellowship, serving in the congregation and community, and reaching out with the gospel. In this portion of our coaching network we will discuss the groups system: why it is beneficial, how it operates, how to set a groups system up and get it rolling, what the challenges to running a groups system are, how to deal with problems with groups, and how to continue to expand groups to meet the various needs and character of the congregation.

BIO

Jeff Gunn is pastor of Crosswalk Lutheran Ministries in Phoenix, Arizona. A teenage convert to Christ, Jeff was brought into the WELS fellowship through a neighboring family, an experience that God used to develop a life-long passion for outreach with the gospel. He graduated from Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary in 1982 and subsequently served for 14 years in the Central Africa country of Zambia. Six of those years were spent living in the bush, pastoring multiple village congregations. In the next eight years, Jeff continued to serve congregations as a pastor, but also served as WELS field coordinator for the Zambia Mission, and as a professor at the Lutheran Bible Institute and Seminary in Lusaka. Jeff's 14 years serving in Zambia have given him a unique perspective on the management of the ministry of the gospel. Since returning to the U.S. in 1996, Jeff has served as religion instructor and assistant principal at Arizona Lutheran Academy for five years. In 2001, he became Director of Native American Missions for the WELS. Finally, in 2004, Jeff received the call to launch CrossWalk Church on the campus of Arizona Lutheran Academy. Starting with about 30 people in 2004, God has blessed this ministry so that today there are two services and 500 people worshipping each Sunday at CrossWalk. CrossWalk uses a contextualized approach to worship, weekly growth groups, and ministry teams as key components to its approach to gospel ministry in a church that describes itself as a "church for unchurched people."

http://www.nextdisciple.com/giaprojects/crosstraincoaching.html

Watch This Video on Full Screen.
WELS Members May Not Watch or Hum Along,
Due To LCMS High Churchiness



Truly, the glory has departed.

Two events designed for lay members | Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS)

Two events designed for lay members | Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS)

Another Church and Change episode sponsored by WELS,
promoted by SP Mark Schroeder.



The theme of the 12th Biennial WELS Kingdom Workers Convention is "Equip to Serve." As Mr. Bill Meier, national executive director of WKW, explains, "We have all been called to serve our Lord, Jesus, no matter what our station in life." He adds, "We are inviting all WELS members to join us as we celebrate the opportunities the Lord gives us to serve and explore which opportunities best fit each of us." In addition to workshops to better equip attendees to personally do mission work, WELS home and world mission workers will give presentations on their mission experiences.
WKW is a parasynodical organization whose purpose is to engage Christians in outreach ministry and assist WELS missions in their task of making disciples of all nations. Last year, 3,000 WELS members were engaged in WKW ministries.

***

GJ - Kingdom Workers is another lobbying group, cloned from Church and Change, doing the work of Church and Change, promoted by the Synod President.

Rich Krause is another Shrinker with a drive-by DMin supervised by Larry Olson, of all people.

Etc. Etc.

‘The De-Confessionalization of Lutheranism?

‘The De-Confessionalization of Lutheranism?

Intrepid Lutherans: Dr. Martin Luther on the Christian's obligation to evaluate doctrine

Intrepid Lutherans: Dr. Martin Luther on the Christian's obligation to evaluate doctrine


MONDAY, MARCH 21, 2011


Dr. Martin Luther on the Christian's obligation to evaluate doctrine


Dear Readers,

Now that we have attempted to clarify what is and is not adiaphora – mostly what it’s not – we need to address the following questions:
  1. Who is to decide which teaching and practices are true and correct and which are not?
  2. Who has the right to judge doctrine?
  3. Is this something that only seminary professors and district praesidia may do?
Early in the Reformation Luther was faced with similar questions. In the following treatise he very clearly emphasizes that it is not church leaders especially, but rather everyone and all Christians equally – the sheep of Christ! – who have the power and right to judge doctrine.

This treatise was published in May of 1523, of which we publish the first half, below. The translation is from Luther’s Works, Vol.39, page 305 and following. Some sections have been highlighted for emphasis, and headings have been added for clarification.

Pastor Spencer

If Rob Bell is right, then God, Jesus and the Bible are wrong « Churchmouse Campanologist

If Rob Bell is right, then God, Jesus and the Bible are wrong « Churchmouse Campanologist


As my American readers will know, Rob Bell, Fuller Theological Seminary alumnus, has a new book out called Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived.
The book has created a firestorm because of Bell’s apparent universalism, which he has denied.  Bell ispastor of the Mars Hill Bible Church in Grandville, Michigan. (His church is not to be confused with Mark Driscoll’s Mars Hill Church in Seattle, Washington.)  He is prominent in the emergent church movement — which, incidentally, the Archbishop of Canterbury endorses — and has written books about his theology.  As such, Bell is directly or indirectly responsible for thousands of souls around the world and, in some sense, for their salvation or condemnation.

Monday, March 21, 2011

ELCA Exit Percentages

Does this outfit make me look ELCA?


ALPB Online

Of the 609 congregations I am aware of that have taken votes to leave the ELCA, whether successful or unsuccessful, this is the breakdown by Predecessor Church Body:

  • AELC, 3 congregations,  0.5% of the total leaving. [GJ - The AELC sponsored Seminex, which was also the official seminary of the gay Metropolitan Community Church. The AELC also dominated the ELCA merger decisions, which led to gay quotas and voting on whether to use Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in the constitution. The Trinity won that one by only three votes.]
  • ELCA, 17 congregations, 2.8% of the total leaving. [GJ - ELCA lost some of its own brood!]
  • LCA, 215 congregations, 35.3% of the total leaving. [GJ - The liberal tradition is fed up too.]
  • ALC, 374 congregations, 61.4% of the total leaving ELCA. [GJ - The ALC started Lutherans Concerned for Lesbians and Gays, so they cut their own throats.]
  • Grand Total, 609  congregations.

I would like to find the overall ratio of Predecessor Church Bodies within the ELCA to determine how these figures compare to the overall membership of the ELCA. I recall some speculation that the former ALC congregations might have been more open to joining the LCMC, while former LCA congregations might have bided their time until the NALC got started. Time will tell if those ratios change.

Church and Changers, Their Allies in Various Sects,
And Their DP Enablers


One of the wickedest offenses possible to commit against the Church is the stirring up of doctrinal discord and division, a thing the devil encourages to the utmost. This sin usually arises in certain haughty, conceited, self-seeking leaders who desire peculiar distinction for themselves and strive for personal honor and glory. They will give honor to no one, even when they recognize the superiority of his gifts over their own. In their envy and vengefulness they seek occasion to create factions and to draw people to themselves. Many are deceived and immediately respond to the new doctrine presented in specious words by presumptuous leaders thirsting for fame. Many weak but well-meaning ones fall to doubting; many become reckless pleasure lovers, disregarding all religion and ignoring the Word of God. Even they who are called Christians come to have hard feelings against one another, their love grows cold and faith is extinguished. Christians, then, should be careful to give no occasion for division and discord. They must strive against them, submitting to all suffering and performing all demands to prevent, so far as possible, any disturbance of the unity of doctrine, of faith and of Spirit.

Devotional Readings from Luther’s Works for Every Day of the Year, Augustana Book Concern, Rock Island, IL, 1915, p.376 – October 25th Reading on Ephesians 4:3 Endeavoring to keep unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. John Sander. Contributed by Grey Goose.

Exeunt Omnes - Stage Right

We have added popcorn and soda to the worship experience,
based on the results from our marketing survey.



ALPB

I promised to report on my progress in getting information about possible new start-ups in the ELCA and about congregations whose votes to leave did not net a 2/3rds majority either the first or second time. I was given a name to contact at the ELCA, and sent her an e-mail on the 10th of March. I have not received any response. I haven't even gotten a statement that the information isn't available, just silence.

But, from other sources I learned:

Waters of Grace, Frazee, MN is a New ELCA Start

  1. Evangelical Lutheran Church, Gallupville, NY, Left ELCA and joined the NALC
  2. Hegland Lutheran Church, Hawley, MN, Left the ECLCA (sic), and joined the LCMC
  3. St Mark Lutheran Church, Middleburgh, NY, Left the ELCA and joined the NALC
  4. North Immanuel Lutheran Church, Pelican Rapids, MN, Left the ELCA and joined the LCMC

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Reminiscere - The Second Sunday in Lent

The Last Supper, sepia, by Norma Boeckler.




Reminiscere Sunday, The Second Sunday in Lent, 2011


Pastor Gregory L. Jackson

http://www.ustream.tv/channel/bethany-lutheran-worship

Bethany Lutheran Church, 10 AM Central Time


The Hymn #652 I Lay My Sins on Jesus 1:24
The Confession of Sins
The Absolution
The Introit p. 16
The Gloria Patri
The Kyrie p. 17
The Gloria in Excelsis
The Salutation and Collect p. 19
The Epistle and Gradual
The Gospel
Glory be to Thee, O Lord!
Praise be to Thee, O Christ!
The Nicene Creed p. 22
The Sermon Hymn # 454 Prayer Is the Soul's Sincere Desire 1:41


Dividing Line

The Hymn # 281 The Savior Calls 1:29
The Preface p. 24
The Sanctus p. 26
The Lord's Prayer p. 27
The Words of Institution
The Agnus Dei p. 28
The Nunc Dimittis p. 29
The Benediction p. 31
The Hymn # 374 Grace Tis a Charming Sound 1:91

KJV 1 Thessalonians 4:1 Furthermore then we beseech you, brethren, and exhort you by the Lord Jesus, that as ye have received of us how ye ought to walk and to please God, so ye would abound more and more. 2 For ye know what commandments we gave you by the Lord Jesus. 3 For this is the will of God, even your sanctification, that ye should abstain from fornication: 4 That every one of you should know how to possess his vessel in sanctification and honour; 5 Not in the lust of concupiscence, even as the Gentiles which know not God: 6 That no man go beyond and defraud his brother in any matter: because that the Lord is the avenger of all such, as we also have forewarned you and testified. 7 For God hath not called us unto uncleanness, but unto holiness.

KJV Matthew 15:21 Then Jesus went thence, and departed into the coasts of Tyre and Sidon. 22 And, behold, a woman of Canaan came out of the same coasts, and cried unto him, saying, Have mercy on me, O Lord, thou Son of David; my daughter is grievously vexed with a devil. 23 But he answered her not a word. And his disciples came and besought him, saying, Send her away; for she crieth after us. 24 But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel. 25 Then came she and worshipped him, saying, Lord, help me. 26 But he answered and said, It is not meet to take the children's bread, and to cast it to dogs. 27 And she said, Truth, Lord: yet the dogs eat of the crumbs which fall from their masters' table. 28 Then Jesus answered and said unto her, O woman, great is thy faith: be it unto thee even as thou wilt. And her daughter was made whole from that very hour.

Second Sunday In Lent
Lord God, heavenly Father, grant us, we beseech Thee, by Thy Holy Spirit, that He may strengthen our hearts and confirm our faith and hope in Thy grace and mercy, so that, although we have reason to fear because of our conscience, our sin, and our unworthiness, we may nevertheless, with the woman of Canaan, hold fast to Thy grace, and in every trial and temptation find Thee a very present help and refuge, through Thy beloved Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, who liveth and reigneth with Thee and the Holy Ghost, one true God, world without end. Amen.

Dividing Line

[Note – many extras are included in this sermon and others, so people can do additional research and reading. These sermons really sermons plus resources – unless I run out of time. Then they are sketches. If Lenski offends Mequonites looking for something wrong – good. It may be the only time you ever opened Lenski.]

Lenski:
Matthew 15:22) And lo, a Canaanite woman, having come out from those borders, cried out, saying: Show me mercy, Lord, son of David! My daughter is badly demon-possessed. “Lo” pictures the case as being remarkable. Even here in this distant section Jesus and his miraculous power are known (4:24). Writing for readers of Jewish descent, Matthew uses “Canaanite,” recalling the Old Testament account that the Jews had not completely exterminated the Canaanites as God had commanded. This woman was a descendant of that old pagan race. Mark (7:26), writing for Gentile Christians, calls her a Greek in the sense of a Gentile, to mark her religion; and a Syrophoenician by race, using the more modern term for her nationality. Before Jesus could enter her country, she “came out from those borders” to find Jesus at the edge of Galilee. Mark 7:31 makes it certain that Jesus afterward went through Sidon, but this woman took no chances—he might turn back from the border and so get beyond her reach. Jesus wanted no man to know of his presence, but word got out, nevertheless. When Mark tells us that he was in a house, this means only that he was in retirement and doing no work among the people. It does not place the following scene in the house, for v. 23 transpires in the open.
Jesus and his disciples had probably just dined in the house, which would make the reference to “the children’s bread” in v. 26 the more suggestive. As he leaves the house to go on, the woman is there, having, perhaps, anxiously waited for him. With the aorist imperative she begs for an act of mercy, and ἔλεος always means pity for the suffering, for the sad and painful consequences resulting from sin and our sinful state; while χάρις always refers to the guilt of sin. She begs the act of mercy for herself, but her sad state is due to the terrible state of her little daughter who is demon-possessed. The mere verb is enough—there is no need to add the particular havoc the demon wrought. On the actuality of demoniacal possession see the notes on 4:24.
When the woman combines “Lord” with “son of David,” she understands “Lord” in the higher sense as being in fact the Messianic title. She plainly reveals that she has knowledge of the Messianic hopes of Israel and had heard that they were being connected with Jesus as the promised great descendant of King David. It is not necessary to regard her as a Jewish proselyte, and it is quite enough to believe that knowledge had come to her from the reports that had been carried into her heathen land. She surely had tried the remedies offered in her neighborhood for her daughter’s recovery, all of which had proved ineffective. Then she heard of Jesus and how he with a mere word had expelled demons from poor sufferers like her daughter. These reports found fertile soil in her heart. How she had longed to reach this mighty Helper! Now he had come to this far corner of Galilee, and here she finds him with her fervent prayer.
23) But he did not answer her a word. This apparently strange silence on the part of Jesus must not be separated from what follows. And his disciples, having come forward, kept requesting him, saying, Dismiss her, for she is yelling from behind us. The picture presents Jesus walking on in silence, the woman following him with her frantic cries. The imperfect ἠρώτων is descriptive, and the verb denotes respectful asking. One after another of the disciples comes up to Jesus and joins in this request. The verb “dismiss her” is neutral in force and leaves to the discretion of Jesus whether he will dismiss her by granting or by denying her request. Yet the disciples had never seen Jesus deny anyone pleading for help, although at times he had delayed a little while (John 4:47, etc.; Matt. 8:5, etc.), namely whenever some question had first to be settled. It is fair, therefore, to conclude that the disciples think of a dismissal by granting the woman’s prayer. They indicate, however, that they are not moved entirely by pity for her distress. Jesus did not want his presence to become known, but the outcries of this woman were bound to attract public attention. It was quite a scene for thirteen men to walk along with a woman shouting ὄπισθεν, not “behind them,” but with the greater precision of the Greek, “from behind them,” R. 645. The thing may also have appeared unseemly to the disciples.
24) The motives that prompt the action of Jesus are by far more profound. He, however, answering said, I was not commissioned save to the sheep that have been lost of Israel’s house. Since Jesus is about to cross the boundary of the Holy Land and to go into Gentile territory for a brief time, all those present must know that this in no way implies a transfer of his ministry from the Jews to the Gentiles or even an inclusion of the Gentiles into his Messianic ministry. The working of this miracle was not to be understood as ushering in the performance of a great number of additional miracles among the Gentiles of this territory. The divine plan, according to which Jesus “was commissioned,” was to work out redemption in the Jewish nation and not elsewhere; as soon as it had been worked out, it would be carried to all the world. Moreover, this would begin in less than a year, following the next Passover. With this divine plan Jesus was in fullest accord, and his great work was already hastening to its climax. These mighty facts must be thoroughly understood. That is why Jesus delays and explains them in advance in the most impressive way and does not postpone the explanation until after the woman has gone.
Lenski, R. C. H.: The Interpretation of St. Matthew's Gospel. Minneapolis, MN. : Augsburg Publishing House, 1961, S. 593

There are many approaches to this miracle of healing, but it remains one of the difficult ones. Everyone has questions about this healing and what Jesus said. Perhaps it is best to start at the ending, which explains the entire story.

Matthew 15 28 Then Jesus answered and said unto her, O woman, great is thy faith: be it unto thee even as thou wilt. And her daughter was made whole from that very hour.

Lenski:
The greatness of this woman’s faith, here openly praised by Jesus, lies not in its strength and its intensity which overcome obstacles set up by Jesus and grow greater as these obstacles were increased. The greatness lay in submissively accepting and in rightly understanding what Jesus said about his Messianic mission. Her great distress did not dull her ears or darken her mind to Jesus’ word. The view that she overcame the reluctance of Jesus to help her attributes to Jesus what was foreign to him and gives a wrong turn to the narrative.
Lenski, R. C. H.: The Interpretation of St. Matthew's Gospel. Minneapolis, MN. : Augsburg Publishing House, 1961, S. 600.

I see a theme which is carried out many times in John’s Gospel, where it is clearer. Jesus always speaks at His level, as the Son of God with divine authority. He speaks at this level while the answers from His disciples and the followers are always at another level, sometimes picking up on words and phrases but missing the point.

For the Woman at the Well, John 4, Jesus spoke of providing water so that the woman would never thirst again. This is clearly a metaphor, but the woman responded about the labor of hauling water from the well each day.

During the washing of the feet of His disciples, Jesus corrected Peter about washing the feet of the first pope (according to Rome). Once this is explained, Peter asks for his hands and his head to be washed, too.

KJV John 13:5 After that he poureth water into a bason, and began to wash the disciples' feet, and to wipe them with the towel wherewith he was girded. 6 Then cometh he to Simon Peter: and Peter saith unto him, Lord, dost thou wash my feet? 7 Jesus answered and said unto him, What I do thou knowest not now; but thou shalt know hereafter. 8 Peter saith unto him, Thou shalt never wash my feet. Jesus answered him, If I wash thee not, thou hast no part with me. 9 Simon Peter saith unto him, Lord, not my feet only, but also my hands and my head. 10 Jesus saith to him, He that is washed needeth not save to wash his feet, but is clean every whit: and ye are clean, but not all. 11 For he knew who should betray him; therefore said he, Ye are not all clean. 12 So after he had washed their feet, and had taken his garments, and was set down again, he said unto them, Know ye what I have done to you? 13 Ye call me Master and Lord: and ye say well; for so I am. 14 If I then, your Lord and Master, have washed your feet; ye also ought to wash one another's feet. 15 For I have given you an example, that ye should do as I have done to you.

I see the main explanation for this healing miracle to be in Jesus’ own words of commendation, praising the woman for her faith.

This is truly the dividing line in the entire Bible, the difference between believers and unbelievers. Everyone is flawed and sinful. We are all equals in that respect.

But relatively few believe the Word of God and trust only in the wisdom of God. This miracle teaches that complete trust and shows how faith motivates people in spite of all evidence to the contrary.

So, let’s look at this miracle as one which shows us how this woman’s complete trust in the mercy of Christ moves every action and word.

Matthew 15:22 And, behold, a woman of Canaan came out of the same coasts, and cried unto him, saying, Have mercy on me, O Lord, thou Son of David; my daughter is grievously vexed with a devil.

How do we know she has faith? She offers her confession in her request or prayer – O Lord, Son of David. In the Greek speaking lands, Lord is used for the ultimate leader. No doubt the New NIV or future ones will make it mean “Sir, or Mr.” Lord can be used for lower level leaders, but it is often used for God. Revelation clears up any doubt by using “Lord of Lords, King of Kings,” a beautiful expression about Christ as the Savior and Creating Word.

Here the woman, though not a Jew, acknowledges that Jesus is the promised Messiah (Son of David).

Her trust means that she believes Jesus would hear her and grant her prayer for her daughter – possessed and thrown about with a devil. Some like to come up with a modern medical diagnosis. Such things keep publishing houses busy. But we should take it for what it is – demonic possession, which is far more dangerous and frightening than a seizure disorder, which can be modified with painkillers or alcohol. This also means the mother is certain Jesus has power over the demons, which is true.

23 But he answered her not a word. And his disciples came and besought him, saying, Send her away; for she crieth after us.

Anyone can claim that he knows why Jesus did not answer a word. These are very bright people. Without ever meeting me, they know my motivations better than I do, and they are happy to explain them, as long as they remain anonymous.

Jesus did not respond. It does not say, “He refused to answer.” It does not say, “He pretended not to hear.” It does not say, “He was forcing her to say more.” We only know that He was silent at this point while the disciples pleaded for Him to dismiss her for all the asking and crying out.

The disciples provide a useful contrast, which shows us how much this woman was pleading to Jesus. They did not want to hear another word – she was persistent.

We should always ask ourselves why a particular story was provided for us through the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. The world is not big enough to hold all that Jesus said and did, as John wrote in his Gospel.

So why is this difficult miracle given when others would be more soothing? The phrase “said not a word” is significant.

Many believers pray earnestly for a particular need, especially when parents and grandparents pray for children. There seems to be no answer, which is a severe trial. I have met parents whose child went through surgeries and treatments for 20 years and more. I have known parents of children with incurable ailments, where many treatments are tried and offer only partial help.

Some fall into the temptation of unbelief. But this woman is an example of constant motivation by faith in Jesus. A child-like faith keeps asking. Most of us have had experiences of children asking again and again, always smiling and trusting and loving. As Luther said, “They only expect good things.” They are certain that a few dozen more requests will do the job.

24 But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel.

Jesus responded to the disciples with this statement, above. This is a simple statement, so we should not look for motivation behind it. That is only guesswork. As I tell my Biblical students all the time, when turning them from the theories to the text itself, “The text is what we know for sure. Everything else is theory.” They are in awe of textbooks which claim this or that. I want them to be in awe of the Word of God rather than the opinions of man.

Jesus was sent to the Jews first, then to the Gentiles, as Paul said about his own work. This did not keep Paul from being an apostle to the Gentiles, nor did it impede his work with the Jews. The Word brought success in both groups, so much that Paul was hated and persecuted.

25 Then came she and worshipped him, saying, Lord, help me.

The worshiping should not be overlooked. This showed her complete trust in Him, even before she had any definitive answer. Her prayer was simple. She knew Jesus heard her words before. She said, “Lord, help me.”

26 But he answered and said, It is not meet to take the children's bread, and to cast it to [the little pet] dogs.

The term Jesus used here is not the same as “dogs.” This is the diminutive version of the word, suggesting indoor, pet dogs, allowed to have scraps. They are not the same as the outdoor, feral dogs, which would never be allowed in the house.

If we read it just as “dogs,” Jesus does seem insulting. But this is just a common observation, which anyone can observe today. We have a begging table, made of glass. Our three dogs gather under it and look upward as we eat, adopting the “starving puppy” look or the “loving, happy pet” look, both good as coaxing extra food. The do not sulk or get angry at being neglected and ignored. They have complete trust that they will get their portion and then some.

Therefore the woman’s response is in perfect keeping with the term used by Jesus. Notice that this explanation assumes they are speaking Greek to each other, not Aramaic. I doubt where the subtlety is there in Aramaic, and it would make no sense for Jesus or the woman to use a limited dialect as opposed to a world language. (Thanks to Yoel for this insight.)

27 And she said, Truth, Lord: yet the [little] dogs eat of the crumbs which fall from their masters' table.

She used the same term as Jesus, showing her faith in what He was teaching. His mission was to gather believers among His own people, and that was first in the limited time He had.

Yet so vast was His ministry of grace, that the scraps from that would please her and satisfy her.

28 Then Jesus answered and said unto her, O woman, great is thy faith: be it unto thee even as thou wilt. And her daughter was made whole from that very hour.

Jesus granted her prayer, and her daughter was healed at that moment, showing the power of His Word, since the daughter was not there on the journey.

Application
We can see how significant this is for all believers at this time. This is really a miracle story to help believers.

I know about many of the trials and difficulties facing our audience. Some are indicated in the prayers. Others are communicated privately.

More than that, it seems as if God is silent about the apostasy around us. If we watch religious TV, we can see an outright phony teaching blatant false doctrine in the name of (and with the financial support of) two “conservative” Lutheran synods. And he is the only media voice of those two synods combined. How can this continue?

This miracle shows us that the scraps are more than enough. God’s grace is so abundant in His Means of Grace that He will accomplish His will through His Word. If most choose to abandon and abuse it, they will get their reward from juggling with the Word, a dangerous project.

Those who utterly trust in Christ will never be separated from Him by all the trials and misfortunes of this life. God promises to make the Word more abundant through those crosses and to strengthen our faith in spite of them – because of them.

Our faith is not in us, because trials show us how weak we really are – impatient, angry, doubtful. Our faith is in God, and strengthened by His Word.

Quotations

"But see in this example how Christ like a hunter exercises and chases faith in His followers in order that it may become strong and firm."
Sermons of Martin Luther, ed., John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983 II, p. 149. Matthew 15:21﷓28.

"In like manner Moses must precede and teach people to feel their sins in order that grace may be sweet and welcome to them. Therefore all is in vain, however friendly and lovely Christ may be pictured, if man is not first humbled by a knowledge of himself and he possesses no longing for Christ, as Mary's Song says, 'The hungry he hath filled with good things; and the rich he hath sent
empty away,' Luke 1:53."
Sermons of Martin Luther, II, p. 149.

"All this is spoken and written for the comfort of the distressed, the poor, the needy, the sinful, the despised, so that they may know in all times of need to whom to flee and where to seek comfort and help."
Sermons of Martin Luther, II, p. 149.
"Now what does the poor woman do? She turns her eyes from all this unfriendly treatment of Christ; all this does not lead her astray, neither does she take it to heart, but she continues immediately and firmly to cling in her confidence to the good news she had heard and embraced concerning Him, and never gives up. We must also do the same and learn firmly to cling to the Word, even though God with all His creatures appears different than His Word teaches. But, oh, how painful it is to nature and reason, that this woman should strip herself of self and forsake all that she experienced, and cling along to God's bare Word, until she experienced the contrary. May God help us in time of need and of death to possess courage and faith!"
Sermons of Martin Luther, II, p. 150.
WHAT WE LEARN
"As for example when we feel in our conscience that God rebukes us as sinners and judges us unworthy of the kingdom of heaven, then we experience hell, and we think we are lost forever. Now whoever understands here the actions of this poor woman and catches God in His own judgment, and says, Lord, it is true, I am a sinner and not worthy of Thy grace; but still Thou hast promised sinners forgiveness, and Thou art come not to call the righteous, but, as St. Paul says in 1 Timothy 1:15, 'to save sinners.' Behold, then must God according to His own judgment have mercy upon us."
Sermons of Martin Luther, ed., John Nicholas Lenker, Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1983 II, p. 153. Matthew 15:21﷓28; 1 Timothy 1:15