|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ICHABOD, THE GLORY HAS DEPARTED - explores the Age of Apostasy, predicted in 2 Thessalonians 2:3, to attack Objective Faithless Justification, Church Growth Clowns, and their ringmasters. The antidote is trusting the efficacious Word in the Means of Grace. John 16:8. Isaiah 55:8ff. Romans 10. Most readers are WELS, LCMS, ELS, or ELCA. This blog also covers the Roman Catholic Church, Eastern Orthodoxy, and the National Council of Churches.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
| The chasm developed over 100 years ago. Schodde and Lenski participated in writing this classic. |
“Such is the contrast between the Bible of the old and the Bible of the new theologies. That there are compromise systems between the two—or at any rate attempts at a compromise — is certainly true; but it is impossible to effect a compromise between systems fundamentally and essentially at variance. This is a case of either — or, Delitzsch was right when he maintained that a “deep chasm” existed between the old and the new theology, and this chasm exists because there is a chasm between the Bible of the old and the Bible of the new theologies. In one word, the Scriptures of the one is the Bible without God; the Scriptures of the other is the Bible of and with God.”
“The Bible Of The Old And The Bible Of The New Theology.” By Rev. Professor George H. Schodde, Ph. D., Columbus, O. in Loy, ed. The Columbus Theological Magazine. Vol. 18, 1898. LutheranLibrary.org. Schodde earned his PhD at Leipzig and was a parish pastor (Canal Winchester) before teaching at Capital U. in Columbus, Ohio.
Harold Lindsell's The Battle for the Bible was itself a farce, exposing the more radical apostasy at Fuller Seminary. The school began with compromised inerrancy and later, during its Church Growth fever, abandoned inerrancy in a huff.
The first stage of abandoning inerrancy came from the academic pirouette that dazzles the mind - "The Bible is inerrant in doctrine, but not in history or geography." That was the original Fuller Seminary claim when it began about 1947. The slogan conveys the rationalistic idea that God was good on doctrine, but faulty on the history and geography in the Bible. However, in contrast to the mainline seminaries, Fuller was an oasis - or really, a mirage - in the desert of radicals like Bultmann, Tillich, and Barth/Kirschbaum.
In a series of moves, Fuller hired David Hubbard to push the independent seminary to the Left. Next, in 1965, Hubbard hired Donald McGavran to be the Church Growth guru. The partial inerrancy group (Lindsell, etc.) left, and the sincere crackpots took over. Hubbard said they did not have the time or energy to deal with the inerrancy issue.
![]() |
| Fuller has a gimmick for our dying denominations. Whee! Get a quickie DMin and get promoted. Wooo Pig Souie! |
![]() |
| Fuller Seminary invited the world mission executives for brain-washing, and the executives got the American missions on the payoff list. |
![]() |
Paul Kelm is one of many dunder-heads who fell for this Calvinistic clap-trap and influenced others. He is the Fort Knox of Church Growth Fool's Gold. |
![]() |
| A galaxy of failing stars - Paul Kelm! - Ron Roth! - Robert Hartman! |
![]() |
| Olson denied his Fuller status three times, and the Doc crowed. And Wayne Mueller published his famous claim - "There is no Church Growth in WELS." |
![]() |
| Tis funny how DMin sounds like demon! |
![]() |
| All you need is an endowment for robes and incense. |
![]() |
| Not every Roman Catholic parish is an example of high church worship. |
Amidst all these varying and opposing lists, this contradiction and confusion worse confounded, how utterly baseless must be those pretensions, whether made by the papists of Rome, or the semi-papists of Oxford, which are founded upon a supposed ascertained, and unbroken descent from the apostles?
The arguments to sustain them are lighter than air. Hence we are not surprised to hear that bright luminary of the British establishment, Archbishop Whately, declare his solemn conviction, that “There is not a minister in all Christendom, who is able to trace up, with any approach to certainty, his own spiritual pedigree. The ultimate consequence must be,” remarks the same excellent prelate, “that anyone who sincerely believes that his claim to the benefits of the gospel covenant depends on his own minister’s claim to the supposed sacramental virtue of true ordination, and this again on apostolical succession, must be involved, in proportion as he reads, and inquires, and reflects, and reasons on the subject, in the most distressing doubt and perplexity.
It is no wonder, therefore, that the advocates of this theory studiously disparage reasoning, deprecate all exercise of the mind in reflection, decry appeals to evidence, and lament that even the power of reading should be imparted to the people. It is not without cause that they dread and lament ‘an age of too much light,’ and wish to involve religion in a ‘solemn and awful gloom.’ It is not without cause that, having removed the Christian’s confidence from a rock, to base it on sand, they forbid all prying curiosity to examine their foundation.”
(Whately on the Kingdom of Christ, Essay ii. § 30.)
***
GJ - Lord Jim Heiser does not have the Apostolic Succession. His minions are copies of him, just as he copied Bishop DeJaynes in the office of fakery.
Doubtless it has bothered the faux-bishop Heiser that I was ordained by an Augustana Synod pastor - and later bishop - who was ordained by a Swedish prelate. The Augustana Synod was high church and enjoyed a continuing relationship with the Church of Sweden. Therefore, they are part of the Apostolic Succession.
Members kid me about the prohibitive cost of a fish-hat and the massive price-tags of Almy costumes.
The true apostolic succession rests on faithfulness to the Word of God, which the ELDONUTs continue to reject. They were fanatical in favor of Objective Justification, as Heiser was. Now they accept his imitation of papal infallibility: he is the ultimate authority. False doctrine never improves itself and usually scrapes the bottom of the dogma pile soon enough.
![]() |
| Wikipedia says that some of DeJaynes' followers joined up with Eastern Orthodoxy. Heiser began the bishop game with DeJaynes. CFW Walther was wanted for the felony kidnapping of his niece and nephew and signed the document making Martin Stephan his bishop. As my friend says, "A bishop and a pope stepped off the boat in America." |
![]() |
| Grape hyacinths are easy to plant and enjoy a sweet fragrance. They multiply over time and come in blue, blue/white, white, and pink. |
Tomorrow promises 100% rain, once started. The leaves are coming down quickly, and the serious cold will start on November 11th.
The bulbs are planted, with a few daffodils hiding in one of many cardboard boxes. My favorite way of finding things is not looking for them. Then they show up in surprising and mysterious places.
The new grape hyacinths just sent their leaves above ground. Every bulb starts its roots, once planted. The greens will feed the hidden flower, but I doubt the flower will show up before spring.
My next trick is remembering where all the bulbs have been buried. It is easy to say, "But they will be blooming all over the gardens. Take notes, make a map, photograph them."
Creation does not allow all bulbs to have the benefits of the others. Because we have such early and late warmth, the hardy (or autumn) bulbs do not fare well - except for daffodils and grape hyacinths. I have tried tulips and other beautiful bulbs, but they come up looking sick and not very hardy.
On the other hand, I can keep cannas and glads in the ground and not dig them up. They are tender or spring bulbs, but they will stay in the ground over winter and come back again.
![]() |
| I have seen spectacular cannas in the neighborhood. Their roots spread and tolerate our cool weather. |
![]() |
| WELS spies were sent to the Southern Babtists - and were dismayed by the convention banning the NIV from all their bookstores. And you wonder why WELS and Missouri are fading as fast as ELCA? |
In 1914 John Alexander Smith, Professor of Moral Philosophy at Oxford University, told his new class of undergraduates:
“Gentlemen, you are now about to embark on a course of studies which will occupy you for two years. Together, they form a noble adventure. But I would like to remind you of an important point. Nothing that you will learn in the course of your studies will be of the slightest possible use to you in after life, save only this, that if you work hard and intelligently you should be able to detect when a man is talking rot, and that, in my view, is the main, if not the sole, purpose of education.”
![]() |
| Editor of the worst hymnal ever, until WELS cranked out another one, even worse. |
![]() |
| Why no apologies? |
![]() |
| Kathryn Kleinhans, dean of Trinity |
Committed to womanist theology, Trinity Lutheran Seminary and the ELCA’s Quality of Call Initiative for Women in Ministry have appointed Denise Rector as the seminary’s first joint doctoral scholar-in-residence (DSIR).
Womanist theology is an understanding of God and the world that centers on the experiences and insights of Black women. Trinity, part of Capital University in Columbus, Ohio, has made increasing efforts to give voice to historical and contemporary exploration of Christian faith based on the unique experiences and contributions of women of African descent.
![]() |
| ELCA leaders |
![]() |
| Does anyone guess where Eaton, a mere bishop, stood after the 2009 vote? |
The DSIR is awarded to ELCA women of color who are completing their dissertations in theology, biblical studies or religion. The position supports the practical and professional requirements of doctoral candidates as they complete their dissertations in fields that serve the ongoing reformation of the church.
![]() |
| Nadia |
Rector is completing her doctorate through the Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago. Her dissertation explores the feedback loop between historiography (how we imagine and write history) and epistemology (how we know) in the construction of African American racial identities throughout U.S. history and in the church.
“I became interested in the study of womanist theology when I realized that I wasn’t seeing myself—a Black woman—or the history of Black women represented in the teachings of some of the theology classes I was taking,” Rector said. She finds that womanist theology “recognizes the importance of including people … whose rich, cultural understandings of the divinity of God may not always show up in church on Sunday morning.”
Rector said it was essential to explore these issues faithfully and theologically and to understand their effect on how church history and American history are incorporated into the teachings of God’s creation. “For a long time, there has been an Americanist religion that doesn’t always reflect the racial and ethical variety of creation.”
Womanist theology “recognizes the importance of including people … whose rich, cultural understandings of the divinity of God may not always show up in church on Sunday morning.”
Kathryn Kleinhans, dean of Trinity, said the seminary is committed to looking at American history “through marginalized groups and telling their stories of history, theology and ethics that we haven’t told yet.”
In 2021, both ELCA Gender Justice and Women’s Empowerment and the anonymous-donor-funded ELCA Quality of Call Initiative supported Trinity’s activities related to the ELCA Womanist Theology Initiative. The project allows students at all ELCA seminaries to take classes focused on womanist theology, regardless of which seminary offers the course.
The appointment of Rector also builds on the success of “Hush No More: Perspectives From Womanist Theologians,” a series of seminars hosted by Trinity in fall 2021 on the development of womanist interpretation of Scripture and womanist perspectives on pastoral care.
Mary J. Streufert, ELCA director for the Quality of Call Initiative and for Gender Justice and Women’s Empowerment, said the doctoral scholar-in-residence is an investment in women.
“Supporting women of color working in fields such as womanist theology is also an investment in ministerial imagination and formation in the ELCA,” Streufert said. “I cannot wait to see the Holy Spirit continue to work.”
Rector, who expects to finish her dissertation in 2024, said Black women seminary professors are rare.
“Being here at Trinity Lutheran Seminary has been like landing in the best-feathered nest for someone starting a teaching career,” she said. “Dean Kleinhans wants to bring in professors of color to be part of the diversity of academia so students have exposure to theology taught with a culturally rich, expansive and inclusive view.”
![]() |
| Recent bishop photo above, the pioneers below. |