Friday, February 9, 2018

"Great Writing Comes from Great Research" - A Quote from Scrabblebeard, Notorious Blogger

 David Valleskey advocated "spoiling the Egyptians," using the precious gold and jewels from Fuller Seminary, where he did or did not study, like his pal Frosty Bivens, who did or did not study there.

Timid Tim Buelow was always filling me in on the standard propaganda of WELS. One deception was - "Brug and Brenner were added to the seminary faculty to balance Mequon with more confessional Lutherans."

I said, "Just by claiming that, you admitted Mequon is a union seminary with two different doctrines."

He conceded that was so.

But of course, Brug and Brenner were picked for their willingness to slither along with the rest of the false teachers while feigning some kind of difference with the general decline of the faculty, which was never that great.

Unfortunately, because WELS was so nasty and stupid during the Protest'ant conflict, the fools-gold standard for faculty has been ever since - mediocrities who will not rock the boat. They like  smooth criminals like Valleskey who will smile and play one role (cautious about Church Growth) and then another role (gonzo for Church Growth) - depending on the audience. I have that description from a WELS pastor, who added, "I don't think he is being deceptive." Really? Chameleons are not deceptive - they are just trying to blend in - it's their nature.


As I wrote more than once before, Valleskey got frightened and denied going to Fuller when I asked him. But he bragged about it to Dave Koenig (CLC Church Growther, pal of Paul Tiefel, CGer).
And then Valleskey was angry with Koenig for telling me the truth, and Koenig was angry with me for posting the truth.

Some posts may seem unusually dense and packed with far too many details and links, but they are provided so people can start to do their own research. My only goal is to have people study the Scriptures, Luther, and the Confessions.

On the recent Gems list from Luther, Volume 7 - Our two kinds of armor against the devil are the following.

Two Kinds of Armor Against the Devil

4. These are the two kinds of armor, two weapons of defense, whereby the devil is vanquished and of which he is afraid: First, diligence in hearing, learning and practicing the Word of God, that instruction, comfort and strength may be received; second, sincere petitioning upon the authority of that Word, a crying and calling to God for help when temptations and conflicts arise. One or the other of these weapons of defense must continually be in active exercise, effecting perpetual intercourse between God and man — either God speaking to us while we quietly listen, or God hearing our utterances to him and our petitions concerning our needs. Whichever the weapon we wield, it is unendurable to the devil; he cannot abide it. Christians need both equipment’s, that their hearts may ever turn to God, cleave to his Word, and continually, with ceaseless longing, pray a perpetual Lord’s Prayer. Truly, the Christian should learn from the temptations and straits wherewith the devil, the world and the flesh constantly oppress him, to be ever on his guard, watching for the enemy’s point of attack; for the enemy sleeps not nor rests a single moment.

Exaudi, Volume 7




John Sparky Brenner Exposes His Bias in Jars of Clay -
Not a History But a Cover-Up

 Why do WELS clergy and laity ignore this example of JP Meyer's Scriptural wisdom while embracing his anti-Christian dogma of UOJ?

For all the bluster about WELS being Scriptural, in contrast to LCMS dogmatic statements, both sects are the same. They owned the German language and had all the sources at their disposal, but both synods fostered and promoted the anti-Christian cancer of Universal Objective Justification. Meanwhile, they fussed over trivia and staged great debates about adiaphora, avoiding the Chief Article - Justification by Faith.

Note - here is Pastor Vernon Harley's Justification by Faith essay. My wife and I met him and his wife before he died.

John Sparky Brenner is not an analytical historian like Thucydides but a tall tale teller like Herodotus. Here is a good example from his PR book, Jars of Clay.

Pastor John P. Meyer served as president of the WELS seminary,1937-1957. His teaching career spanned many decades. He began at Northwestern College in Watertown in 1902. His dogmatics notes were still be used in the 1980s, proving his post-humus influence.

JP Meyer is known for his commentary on II Corinthians, Ministers of Christ. Brenner wrote:
The commentary is a masterpiece offering, among other things, practical advice on Christian stewardship and insight into the precious doctrine of objective justification. Jars, p. 184.

He also wrote Studies in the Augsburg Confession. Really? His three Kokomo Statements are idiotic and contradict the Augsburg Confess - not to mention the entire Bible, Augustine, Luther, and the Book of Concord.



 Three of the four Kokomo Statements are from this book and remain unchanged, even though edited by Armin Panning, former seminary president and New Testament Greek professor!

Where were all the Biblical scholars? the studious laity? the parochial teachers?

WELS plays a game of GA double-talk. They pretend to back away from the Kokomo UOJ Statements but they seethe and hurl anathemas at anyone teaching Justification by Faith. I question whether John Sparky Brenner can even say those three words - Justification by Faith - and explain them from the Scriptures and the Book of Concord.

If UOJ is a precious doctrine, then Justification by Faith must be darkness and corruption. Imagine how distorted the brains of the Mordor students must be upon graduation and ordination in WELS!

---

From

http://ichabodthegloryhasdeparted.blogspot.com/2017/05/more-silliness-this-year-at-emmaus.html

 Supper at Emmaus - by M. Caravaggio
Luke 24:30 - 
30 When he was at the table with them, he took bread, gave thanks, broke it and began to give it to them. 31 Then their eyes were opened and they recognized him, and he disappeared from their sight.


Brenner - "Hoenecke, who was a Wisconsin Synod spokesman at a few of the free conferences, explained that doctrine must be drawn from those passages that teach that doctrine. We draw the doctrine of election from those passages that teach the doctrine of election, not from passages that teach justification by faith. Koehler summarizes Hoenecke’s comments from the free conference in Milwaukee in 1903." Emmaus paper.

GJ - Zounds. Hoenecke had no sense of the unified witness of the Scriptures, but chose to follow the thetical approach of Walther. That is - the thesis is solemnly pronounced first, then Scriptures are cited or mismatched to the dogmatic statement.




The Tenth Annual Emmaus Conference

The 10th Annual Emmaus Conference is Friday, April 28th, 2017, with a banquet the evening prior on Thursday, April 27th. The topic for the 2017 Emmaus Conference will be: “The Unsuspecting American Luthers”. The backgrounds, challenges, and impact of several Lutheran theologians in the 20th Century will be explored and discussed.
From Dan the Dense on Walther - "Walther believed in objective justification (John 1:29; Romans 5:18; 2 Corinthians 5:15 & 19). His 14th thesis reads: “In the tenth place, the Word of God is not rightly divided when faith is required as a condition of justification and salvation, as if a person were righteous in the sight of God and saved, not only by faith, but also on account of his faith, for the sake of his faith, and in view of his faith.”13

GJ - Daniel, have you read Justification and Rome? How about Romans 4? Romans 5:1-2? The Gospel of John?

---

Wherever two or three LCMS leaders are gathered together, CFW Walther worship begins. This Emmaus debacle was held in late April, but the papers are not posted yet. In this day of instant publishing, the papers could have been linked on the website. I recall Mirthless Mark Schroeder did not want his shared, years ago, not that he said anything worth publishing. Here is the non-archive archive.

The May 8th Christian News must be the archive, because they posted some promotional bits and photos about the event...afterwards. Oh dear, I missed the conference altogether. David Becker found the event disappointing, albeit without being there. Compared to WELS Luther Days, where Jay Webber spoke to one (1) person - and Natalie Pratt disappeared with the money - Emmaus 2017 was probably a smash hit.

We all know that Preus descendants are the Agent Orange of Justification by Faith. Whenever they suspect that Luther's doctrine is being taught somewhere, they spray their toxic dogma from Halle Rationalists all over, until nothing is left living: no faith, no Gospel, no fruits of the Gospel.

Does anyone wonder why the ELS is almost gone and WELS is corrupt beyond measure? To those who are kicked out of WELS, I always say, "Good for you. They did you a great favor." Alcoholism and adultery are not problems among WELS clergy and teachers - they are resume enhancers, if someone has the right friends and the wrong doctrine.

The strength of the LCMS is its mix of Pentecostal, ELCA wannabees, Walther worshipers, and Lutherans. The Missouri Synod is such a rainbow coalition that the bureaucrats do not have the power or urge to crack down on the Chief Article of the Christian Faith. Anyway, they have Otten to do their work for them. And Logorrhea - and their Fuller/Rome seminaries.

 You were born forgiven kids,
now don't ask any probing questions about this.


How bad is WELS? At Mordor Seminary in Mequon, Wendland is the salesman-in-charge of the New NIV. Valleskey was the previous president, based on years of gushing about Church Growth and studying at Fuller with his pal Bivens (also on the faculty). When I was there in 1987, I did not hear Church Growth promoted in the classroom. But once everyone was "finished," they were also required to attend the post MDiv training, which was all Church Growth. Besides that, when I accepted the call to Shepherd of Peace in Columbus, Ohio, the congregation had me attend Paul Kelm's Church Growth "evangelism seminar," which lasted a week. That event was stocked with such CG kahunas as Valleskey, Hartman, Kelm, Larry Olson, and such like.

Thursday, February 8, 2018

"But We Wanted a Male Pastor!" Bingo.
Feb 11 | Renaming Ceremony: Pastor transitions from female to male | Hoboken, NJ Patch. LCMS-WELS-ELS Joyfully Work with ELCA

Pastor Rose Beeson, New Jersey


Feb 11 | Renaming Ceremony: ECLA Pastor transitions from female to male | Hoboken, NJ Patch:

Bishop Tracie Bartholomew
Read this to discover the powerful, organized, well funded people behind Extraordinary Lutheran Ministries.





Barbara Lundblad preached for the installation of the current president of the failing ELCA seminary in Chicago - LSTC.


 ELM Board of Directors. Back, L-R: Jeff Johnson, Elise Brown, Margaret Moreland, Mike Wilker, Nicole Johnson, Emily Ewing, Barbara Lundblad. Front, L-R: Rose Beeson, Charlie Horn, Emily Ann Garcia, Brad Froslee, Gordon Straw. Photo credit: Emily Ann Garcia




"HOBOKEN, NJ - The congregation of St. Matthew Trinity Lutheran Church is celebrating Pastor Rose Beeson as she transitions from female to male and takes on the name Peter in a renaming ceremony on February 11 at 10:30 a.m.

The Rev. Tracie Bartholomew, bishop of the New Jersey Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), will be the featured preacher during the worship service that affirms transgender individuals who take on a new name and remember their baptism."


ELCA Pastor Charles Austin had lots to say
about this ceremony on the ALPB forum.

'via Blog this'

 "Trust the process."

Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Answered Questions - Lenker versus Lloyd Dougland: Both from Hamma Divinity

Lloyd C. Douglas became one of the best known writers of his era, starting as a Lutheran pastor and becoming a Congregationalist minister. He graduated from Hamma in 1903.

My latest research began with a question - How could tiny Hamma Divinity School (ULCA, LCA) turn out John N. Lenker and Lloyd C. Douglas? Lenker produced the enormously useful Sermons of Martin Luther. Douglas left the Lutheran Church, became a Congregationalist, and wrote best-sellers in his spare time, four of them turning into Hollywood movies.

I puzzled over this because my PhD dissertation actually began at Hamma Divinity's library, when the librarian gave me a box of books and a lead for a topic.

I always had a fondness for Lenker's Luther Sermons, as readers might have guessed. His ability to gather translators - including Lenski - was quite impressive. In those days, Lutheran academics could be united around Luther's preaching. Today they are united by scolding Luther or ignoring him altogether. They are only united in teaching against Justification by Faith.

Both men got involved in publishing. Lenker started his own publishing house - Lutherans in All Lands - was quite accomplished as a parish pastor. He taught at the Danish American seminary.

I ordered the Douglas autobiography and the second part, which his daughters wrote, about his adult career. Douglas received a call to Luther Place Memorial in Washington DC - considered a plum in those days. He a crisis of faith, which was never entirely explained, and resigned abruptly, taking a campus job, more of a social director for the YMCA. Later he got the itch to serve a parish again and became a Congregationalist minister.

Douglas was quite successful in Ann Arbor and in Akron, Ohio. However, in California, his liberal ways did not go over well with an elderly congregation. In those days, Congregationalists were not pan-religionists and social justice warriors as they are today in the merged United Church of Christ.

He gave away his lack of Confessional Lutheran loyalty when he paid for school playing the organ at Masonic Hall services (Wittenberg College and Hamma) and also in another location to boost his income. They paid "very well."

The two books about Douglas are a fascinating glimpse at the past,

 John Nicholas Lenker also graduated from Hamma in 1880 - and studied at Leipzig.





Even More Gems from Volume 7 - The Sermons of Martin Luther

 Graphic by Norma A. Boeckler



Defective Doctrine Destroys All Good

8. But tender mercy is to be shown only to Christians and only among Christians. With the rejecters and persecutors of the Gospel we must deal differently. It is not right that my charity be liberal enough to tolerate unsound doctrine. In the case of false faith and doctrine there is neither love nor patience. Against these it is my duty earnestly to contend and not to yield a hair’s breadth. Otherwise — when faith is not imperiled — I must be unfailingly kind and merciful to all notwithstanding the infirmities of their lives. I may not censure, oppress nor drive; I must persuade, entreat and tolerate. A defective life does not destroy Christianity; it exercises it. But defective doctrine — false belief — destroys all good. So, then, toleration and mercy are not permissible in the case of unsound doctrine; only anger, opposition and death are in order, yet always in accordance with the Word of God.
Fifth Sunday after Epiphany

Love Is Not Extended to False Doctrine

11. But the liberality of kindness is not to be extended to false doctrine.
Only relative to conduct and works is it to be exercised. As oft before stated, love with all its works and fruits has no place in the matter of unsound doctrine. I must love my neighbor and show him kindness whatever the imperfections of his life. But if he refuses to believe or to teach sound doctrine, I cannot, I dare not, love him or show him kindness. According to Paul (Galatians 1:8-9), I must hold him excommunicated and accursed, even though he be an angel from heaven. Thus remarkably do faith and love differ and are distinct. Love will be, must be, kind even to the bitterest enemy so long as he assails not faith and doctrine. But it will not, it cannot, tolerate the individual who does, be it father, mother or dearest friend. Deuteronomy 13:6-8. Love, then, must be exercised, not in relation to the doctrine and faith of our neighbor, but relative to his life and works. Faith, on the contrary, has to do, not with his works and life, but with his doctrine and belief.
Fifth Sunday after Epiphany

Jewels of Spiritual Beauty

20. From longsuffering and meekness the apostle distinguishes love and other jewels of spiritual beauty whereof we have already heard, though all are comprehended in love. As faith is the chief element of Christian character, so love is chief of the fruits of the Spirit, the jewel of surpassing beauty. Therefore Paul says, “Above all these things put on love.” Love transcends mercy, kindness, meekness and humility. Paul calls it “the bond of perfectness” because it unites human hearts; not a partial unity, based on similarity or close relationship, but a complete unity among all men and in all relations. It makes us of one mind, one heart, one desire. It permits no one to originate a peculiar order of doctrine or faith. All who love are of the same belief.
Fifth Sunday after Epiphany

When the Goal Is Falsified

3. The goal is removed when the Word of God is falsified and creations of the human mind are preached under the name of God’s Word. And these things readily come about when we are not careful to keep the unity of the Spirit, when each follows his own ideas and yields to no other, because he prefers his own conceit.
Such must be the course of events where love is lacking. The strong and the learned desire to be looked upon as peculiarly commendable, while the weak in the faith are despised. Thus the devil has abundant opportunity to sow tares.
Septuagesima

So Christ Is a Truly Insignificant Object in the World

21. Christ has been typified by various signs and objects in the Old Testament, and the rock is one of them. Note first, the material rock spoken of had place independently of man’s labor and far from man’s domain, in the wilderness, in desolate solitude. So Christ is a truly insignificant object in the world, disregarded, unnoticed; nor is he indebted to human labor.
Septuagesima

Vainglory in the Minister

4. The main point of this lesson is that in a preacher or a teacher no vice is more injurious and venomous than vainglory. It is true, however, that avarice also is an evil characteristic of false teachers, being found hand in hand with vainglory. For the sake of profit, for the purpose of gain, the false teachers aspire to prominence, to honor and position. With them, nothing but current coin will pass, and what does not pay dividend is unprofitable. Any other vice is more endurable in a preacher than these two, though none is compatible with goodness, blamelessness and perfection being required in the ministry according to Paul, Titus 1:7. This is not surprising, for the two vices under consideration are essentially and directly opposed to the nature of the ministry. The ministry is ordained to have as its aim the glory of God and its promotion.
Sexagesima

Avarice in the Minister

5. Avarice, too, is, according to its very nature, opposed to the interests of the ministry. Just as the ministry is to be devoted to God’s honor at the expense of our own, so is it to be devoted to the interests of our neighbor and not to our own. Otherwise it is an injury rather than a benefit. With the false teacher seeking only his own good, it is impossible for him to preach the truth. He is compelled to speak what is pleasing to men in order to gratify his appetites.
Sexagesima

The Character of False Teachers

9. Note the master hand wherewith Paul portrays the character of false teachers, showing how they betray their avarice and ambition. First, they permit true teachers to lay the foundation and perform the labor; then they come and desire to do the work over, to reap the honors and the benefits. They bring about that the name and the work of the true teachers receive no regard and credit; what they themselves have brought — that is the thing. They make the poor, simple-minded people to stare open-mouthed while they win them with flowery words and seduce them with fair speeches, as mentioned in Romans 16:18. These are the idle drones that consume the honey they will not and cannot make. That this was the condition of affairs at Corinth is very clear from this epistle — indeed, from both epistles. Paul continually refers to others having followed him and built upon the foundation he has laid. Messengers of the devil, he terms them.
Sexagesima. Note the following paragraphs - through 15  - false teachers.

Weak and Strong

28. It is a strange sort of strength which is weak and by its weakness grows stronger. Who ever heard of weak strength? or more absurd still, that strength is increased by weakness? Paul would here make a distinction between human strength and divine. Human strength increases with enhancement and decreases with enfeeblement. But God’s power — his Word in us — rises in proportion to the pressure it receives. It is characteristic of God the Creator that he creates all things from naught, and again reduces to naught all created things. Human power cannot do this. The power of God is the true palm-wood which buoys itself in proportion as it is burdened and weighted.
Sexagesima

Strength in Affliction

29. Note here, “weakness” is not to be understood in a spiritual sense, as on a previous occasion, but externally; as not illness alone, but every sort of evil, misfortune, suffering and persecution calculated to buffet and humble the body. The power of Christ, in connection with which spiritual weakness cannot exist, is invoked against this weakness likewise. He says, “Most gladly will I glory in my weaknesses, that the power of Christ may rest upon me.” And his weaknesses he immediately explains as infirmities, injuries, necessities, persecutions and distresses. The thought, then, is: Christ is not mighty within us, his word and his faith are not strong in us, unless our bodies suffer affliction. The false apostles, however, take excellent care to escape suffering.
Sexagesima

Justification Precedes Love

13. The false reasoning of the sophists will not stand when they maliciously deduct from this text the theory that the Christian faith is not effectual to blot out sin and to justify. They say that before faith can justify it must be garnished with love; but justification and its distinctive qualities as well are beyond their ken. Justification of necessity precedes love. One does not love until he has become godly and righteous. Love does not make us godly, but when one has become godly, love is the result. Faith, the Spirit and justification have love as effect and fruitage, and not as mere ornament and supplement. We maintain that faith alone justifies and saves. But that we may not deceive ourselves and put our trust in a false faith, God requires love from us as the evidence of our faith, so that we may be sure of our faith being real faith.
Quinquagesima

Preachers and the Word

2. He calls the Corinthians co-workers, as in 1 Corinthians 3:9, where he puts it: “We are God’s fellow workers; ye are God’s husbandry, God’s building.” That is, we labor upon you with the external Word — teaching and admonishing; but God, working inwardly through the Spirit, gives the blessing and the success. He permits not our labor with the outward Word to be in vain. Therefore, God is the true Master, performing inwardly the supreme work, while we aid outwardly, serving him through the ministry. The apostle’s purpose in praising his co-laborers is to prevent them from despising the external Word as something inessential to them, or well enough known. For though God is able to effect everything without the instrumentality of the outward Word, working inwardly by his Spirit, this is by no means his purpose. He uses preachers as fellow workers, or co-laborers, to accomplish his purpose through the Word when and where he pleases. Now, since preachers have the office, name and honor of fellow workers with God, no one may be considered learned enough or holy enough to ignore or despise the most inferior preaching; especially since he knows not when the hour may come wherein God will, through preachers, perform his work in him.
Invocavit

His Grace Is Not Intended To Cloak Our Shame

6. True, they who sin through infirmity, who, conscious of their transgressions, suffer themselves to be reproved, repenting at once — for these the kingdom of Christ has ready pity and forbearance, commending them to acceptance and toleration (Romans 15; Galatians 6:1; Corinthians 13:7); but that such vices be regarded generally lawful and normal — this will not do! Paul declares, “This is the will of God, even your sanctification.” And he speaks of “how ye ought to... please God.” His thought is: Some consider these sins a matter of little moment, treat them as if the wind blew them away and God rather had pleasure in them as trivial affairs. But this is not true. While God really bears with the fallen sinner, he would have us perceive our errors and strive to mend our lives and to abound more and more in righteousness. His grace is not intended to cloak our shame, nor should the licentious abuse the kingdom of Christ as a shield for their knavery. Paul commands (Galatians 5:13), “Use not your freedom for an occasion to the flesh”; and Peter (1 Peter 2:16), “As free, and not using your freedom for a cloak of wickedness, but as bondservants of God.”
Reminiscere

A Contest, A Battle

7. Likewise with covetousness: we are to understand that it is not to be named of Christians. That is, should one be covetous, should one defraud another or contend with him about temporal advantage, as evidently was true of the Corinthians (1 Corinthians 6:1), the offense must not be suffered to go unreproved and uncorrected. The Gospel must be carefully upheld and preserved among the multitude, “that our ministration be not blamed.” 2 Corinthians 6:3. I make this point for the sake of those who, so soon as they observe that all Christians are not perfectly holy, but will occasionally stumble and fall, imagine there is no such thing as a Christian and the Gospel is impotent and fruitless. Just as if to be a Christian meant the mountain already climbed and complete, triumphant victory over sin! The fact is, it is rather a contest, a battle. Wherever there is a contest, or a battle, some of the combatants will flee, some will be wounded, some will fall and some even be slain. For warfare is not unaccompanied by disaster if it be real warfare.
Oculi

Wrath Follows Apostasy

19. But we have additional light upon this subject, showing that because of such practices the wrath of God comes upon the unbelieving. In Corinthians 10:18 are cited numerous examples of punishment for the sin of fornication. See also Numbers 25. Again, because of wantonness, covetousness and unchastity, the entire world was destroyed by the flood. This is a severe utterance but true and indubitable. “For because of these things cometh the wrath of God upon the sons of disobedience.” “Sons of disobedience” — in other words, they who have fallen from the faith. Thus we see that he who does not show his faith by his deeds, is accounted practically an infidel. In fact, he is worse than an infidel; he is an apostate Christian, or an apostate from the faith. Therefore comes the wrath of God upon such, even here on earth. This is why we Germans must suffer so much famine, pestilence, war and bloodshed to come upon us.
Oculi

The Innocence of Christ

22. To further emphasize and make effectual in us the example of Christ’s patience, Peter proceeds to analyze it, to show it in its true colors, to mention the details and make plain how it differs from any other example of suffering. He has told us before that Christ did no sin, neither was guile found in his mouth. Why, then, did the Jews persecute and crucify him — put him to death? Inquire into his entire life history and you will find that no one could justly impeach, nor could convict, him for any sin. He himself appealed to his enemies to prove ought of sin in him. No one could show an injury he had ever done to anyone, or a wrong he had ever taught or practiced. On the contrary, he had gone about to bring to the Jewish nation the grace and salvation of God. He had revealed God’s Word, opened the eyes of the blind, healed the sick, cast out devils, fed great multitudes when hungry and lacking food. In short, in all his life, there was nothing in word or act but truth, goodness, beneficence and a disposition to aid. In return for the good he wrought, he was compelled to receive the ungrateful reward of man’s hatred and condemnation.
Palm Sunday

Purging the Old Leaven

10. Warrant is given here likewise for censuring and restraining the rash individuals who assert that men should not be terrified by the Law, nor surrendered to Satan. No! It is our duty to teach men to purge out the old leaven; we must tell them they are not Christians, but devoid of the faith, when they yield to the wantonness of the flesh and willfully persevere in sin against the warning of conscience. We should teach that such sins are so much the more vicious and damnable when practiced under the name of the Gospel, under cover of Christian liberty; for that is despising and blaspheming the name of Christ and the Gospel: and therefore such conduct must be positively renounced and purged out, as irreconcilable with faith and a good conscience.
Easter Sunday

Saints – Believers – Conscious of Their Sins
20. The sins remaining in saints after conversion are various evil inclinations, lusts and desires natural to man and contrary to the Law of God. The saints, as well as others, are conscious of these sins, but with this difference: they do not permit themselves to be overcome thereby so as to obey the sins, allowing them free course; they do not yield to, but resist, such sins, and, as Paul expresses it here, incessantly purge themselves therefrom. The sins of the saints, according to him, are the very ones which they purge out. Those who obey their lusts, however, do not do this, but give rein to the flesh, and sin against the protest of their own consciences. They who resist their sinful lusts retain faith and a good conscience, a thing impossible with those who fail to resist sin and thus violate their conscience and overthrow their faith. If you persist in that which is evil regardless of the voice of conscience, you cannot say, nor believe, that you have God’s favor. So then, the Christian necessarily must not yield to sinful lusts.
Easter Sunday

Faith Receives the Preaching of the Gospel

16. Further, Peter, citing the testimony of the prophets, indicates the nature of Christ’s kingdom as not external power; not temporal dominion like that of earthly lords, kings, and emperors; not dominion over countries or control of people, property and temporal concerns; but a spiritual, eternal kingdom, a kingdom in the hearts of men, an authority over, and power opposed to, sin, everlasting death and hell, a power able to redeem us from those things and bestow upon us salvation. Salvation is ours, Peter teaches, through the preaching of the Gospel, and is received by faith. Faith is the obedience every man must render unto the Lord. By faith he makes himself subject to Christ and partaker of his grace and blessings. Paul also (Romans 1:5) uses the term “unto obedience of faith.”
Easter Monday

Strive After What Is Above

7. In other words: Seek and strive after what is above — the things divine, heavenly and eternal; not the terrestrial, perishable, worldly. Make manifest the fact that you are now spiritually raised and by the same power will later be raised bodily.
Easter Wednesday

A Christian Is Born of God

13. It requires something more than mere human wisdom and skill, more than human power, to withstand and overcome an enemy so formidable as the devil. As said before, the Christian must be fortified with the knowledge of how to guard against his wiles and deceptions and how to withstand him. Hence a Christian is called a person who is born of God. He must be different from an intelligent heathen and a skillful worldling to rightly understand God’s Word and apprehend Christ through faith, and must use such knowledge as weapons of offense and defense in the conflict.
Quasimodo

Baptized into Suffering – The Cross

6. Paul would say: “What will you do, beloved Christians? Will you live in the world and not encounter any persecution because of your good deeds? Will you rage at the wickedness of the world, and in your rage become wicked yourself and commit evil? Understand, you are called to suffer persecutions; they are a consequence of your baptism, your Christianity. For these you renounced the devil and professed Christ. You are baptized unto the suffering of every sort of misfortune, unto the enduring of the world and the devil.” You cannot escape the smoke when compelled to live in the inn where the devil is host and the whole house is filled with it. Again, if you would have fire, you must have smoke as a consequence; if you would be a Christian and a child of God, you must endure the resultant evils that befall you.

7. In short, the Christian, because he is a Christian, is subjected to the holy and precious cross. He must suffer at the hands of men and of the devil, who plague and provoke him; outwardly with misery, persecution, poverty and illness, or inwardly — in heart — with their poisonous darts. The cross is the Christian’s sign and watchword in his holy, precious, noble and happy calling unto eternal life. To such a calling must we render full dues and regard as good whatever it brings.
Misericordias

He Sustains Us through the Word and Sacraments

48. Now, Christ our Lord is that faithful Guardian, that true Bishop, who above all others is entitled to the name (with him office and name are identical), and who bears it with due honor, to our eternal happiness. For, standing at the right hand of God and showing his wounds, he unceasingly intercedes for us before the Father; and moreover, on earth he rules, sustains, nourishes and protects, through his Word, his sacraments and the efficacy of the Holy Spirit, the little flock that believe in him. Were he not present with and watching over us here, the devil would long ago have overthrown and destroyed us, and also the Word of God and the name of Christ. And such is the case when God in wrath turns away his eyes from the world to punish its ingratitude. Then immediately everything falls into the devil’s power. Therefore, pure doctrine, faith, confession and the use of the sacraments are dependent for their perpetuity solely upon the vigilant guardianship of our beloved Shepherd and Bishop.
Misericordias

Two Kinds of Armor Against the Devil

4. These are the two kinds of armor, two weapons of defense, whereby the devil is vanquished and of which he is afraid: First, diligence in hearing, learning and practicing the Word of God, that instruction, comfort and strength may be received; second, sincere petitioning upon the authority of that Word, a crying and calling to God for help when temptations and conflicts arise. One or the other of these weapons of defense must continually be in active exercise, effecting perpetual intercourse between God and man — either God speaking to us while we quietly listen, or God hearing our utterances to him and our petitions concerning our needs. Whichever the weapon we wield, it is unendurable to the devil; he cannot abide it. Christians need both equipment’s, that their hearts may ever turn to God, cleave to his Word, and continually, with ceaseless longing, pray a perpetual Lord’s Prayer. Truly, the Christian should learn from the temptations and straits wherewith the devil, the world and the flesh constantly oppress him, to be ever on his guard, watching for the enemy’s point of attack; for the enemy sleeps not nor rests a single moment.
Exaudi

Intemperance – Living Like Swine

7. Now, God having in his infinite goodness so richly shed upon us Germans in these latter times the Gospel light, we ought, in honor and gratitude to him, to try to reform ourselves in the matter of intemperance. We should fear lest through this evil besides committing other sins we draw upon us the wrath and punishment of God. For naught else can result from the pernicious life of intemperance but false security, and contempt of God. Individuals continually dead in drunkenness, buried in excesses, living like swine, cannot fear God, cannot be occupied with divine things.
Exaudi

Embrace the True Word of God Revealed from Heaven

51. In the first place, therefore, it is necessary that both preachers and hearers take heed to doctrine and have clear, unmistakable evidence that what they embrace is really the true Word of God revealed from heaven; the doctrine given to the holy and primitive fathers, prophets and apostles; the doctrine Christ himself confirmed and commanded to be taught. We are not permitted to employ the teaching dictated by any man’s pleasure or fancy. We may not adapt the Word to mere human knowledge and reason. We are not to trifle with the Scriptures, to juggle with the Word of God, as if it would admit of being explained to suit the people; of being twisted, distended and patched to effect peace and agreement among men. Otherwise, there would be no sure, permanent foundation whereon the conscience might rely.
Exaudi

Office of the Holy Spirit

7. Observe here, the Holy Spirit descends and fills the hearts of the disciples sitting in fear and sorrow. He renders their tongues fiery and cloven, and inflames them with love unto boldness in preaching Christ — unto free and fearless utterance. Plainly, then, it is not the office of the Spirit to write books or to institute laws. He writes in the hearts of men, creating a new heart, so that man may rejoice before God, filled with love for him and ready, in consequence, to serve his fellows gladly.

Pentecost

Tuesday, February 6, 2018

Another Insight from the History of Mordor - aka Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary

Sparky Brenner's Jars of Clay, The History of Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary.

Mordor faculty lounge: "He reviewed your book again?"
Sparky: "Who?"
Bivens: "Ichabod, the enemy of our gospel."
Sparky: "A complete review?"
Wendland: "No, I fear it's the death of a thousand cuts. One more tidbit."

Forget Q. I can read the minds of the unfaithful and predict their responses.




On display today is the logical fallacy of poisoning the well. WELS practices it 24/7, as the graphics show. The idea is to make the source so untrustworthy that anything from that source is automatically toxic. That also warns the clergy to stay away from that topic, that source, that blog.

As I mentioned before, Sparky Brenner is an Ichabod unawares. He has published information backing my intuition that the so-called Election conflict was really about (really against) Justification by Faith. Notice that Walther and his cronies chose to attack Pontopiddan rather than deal with the Scriptures. Slogans are so useful - "He teaches intuitu fidei! in view of faith." The Latin is so obscure that the Fox Valley Fools wrote it as inuitu fidei - which I imagine is pig Latin for the faith of Eskimo.

 Fox Valley raged against this insightful graphic.
I should not pick on them for their bad spelling and worse Latin, but they never stop bragging about their superior educational system. Evidence? Bueller? Bueller? Anyone?


The origin of the blacklisted phrase is - "in view of the merits of Christ apprehended by faith." How exactly is that bad? Nevermind, the UOJ Stormtroopers say. So a slogan was invented, in Latin no less, to flail Justification by Faith. That is poisoning the well. Since then, Synodical Conference discussions have resembled drunken bar fights more than efforts to clarify Scriptural doctrine.



Here Is the Passage
As those within and without WELS should know, all WELS stories concerning the LCMS illustrate the staggering superiority of WELS over Missouri, so this tale shows how Hoenecke helped out when Walther's poor choice of words alienated so many.

Walther argued that Election is without faith, because otherwise faith would be a work. CFW was heavily influenced by Pietism and by his rationalistic education. UOJ is full of rationalistic logic, such as - "If Christ became sin for us, the entire world is pronounced forgiven and saved." The trouble is, they have no Scriptural or Confessional basis for that. Nevermind.

Here is the poisoning of the well, as practiced by Sparky Brenner. When Schmidt disagreed with the Great Walther, it was a "personal struggle." That is a dog-whistle for those who know the old LCMS canard. Schmidt did not get the call (Walther made faces at the mention of Schmidt's name) but F. Pieper did, so the Election conflict was Schmidt's revenge for not getting the call. That makes SynCon ears perk up, even if no one else catches the hint. Brenner calls it a "personal struggle" between Walther and Schmidt in Jars, p. 83.

When someone argues that WELS is teaching false doctrine 24/7, one of the faithful apostates will snap, "You are judging hearts, and that is a sin." They may say, "You are shredding the Eighth Commandment" or "Have you ever read Matthew 18?"

Claiming that Schmidt disagreed with Walther because he did not get the call is poisoning the well. Somehow an enormous book came from those hurt feelings - The Error of Modern Missouri. Everyone fell in line because Schmidt did not get that call? That is a strange claim to make.

In truth, Walther manipulated the call to get F. Pieper placed as his personal choice. Pieper enlarged the UOJ bridgehead established by Stephan and Walther until that dogma became Chief Article of Missouri, WELS, and the Little Sect on the Prairie.

Note this from the Sparky dissertation -
"Schmidt addressed the relationship of universal justification and the individual’s appropriation of justification in several of his theses." p. 61

Oh no! Sparky almost said Justification by Faith, but his careful phrasing avoided those toxic words.

Friends, relatives, and WELS clergy - mark how easily the details reveal the script.

Sparky's dissertation really hammers Schmidt for no longer going with the Walther position -

Schmidt seems to have sought the call to become Missouri’s English professor of theology in 1878.296 He seems to have been hurt when he did not receive that call.297 On January 2, 1879, Schmidt notified Walther of his objections to his 1877 essay. He told Walther, “I can no longer go with you. . . I dare no longer keep silence.”298 Schmidt soon contacted President Schwan of the Missouri Synod to let him know that he was going to make his objections public unless circumstances changed.

The accusation is made in the main body of the dissertation, but refuted in the footnote -

Schmidt’s brother-in-law, Pastor Henry Allwardt, disputes this accusation. He claims to have spoken with Schmidt about Walther’s essay in March 1878, fully two months before the convention that failed to issue the call to Schmidt. Both he and Schmidt at that time were one in their concerns about Walther’s essay. Henry A. Allwardt, “Appendix to A Testimony against the False Doctrine of Predestination recently introduced by the Missouri Synod,” translated by R.C.H. Lenski and W.E. Tressel in The Error of Modern Missouri: Its Inception. Brenner, p. 79.




Another GJ nota bene - Lenski's family was kicked out over objecting to UOJ, so that is why WELS continues to rave that "Lenski is not good on justification." Haha - they poison that well with every class at Mordor.

For those who are unaware of Schmidt, he was quite talented, fluent in Norwegian. If not for Walther's dogmatic blundering, more Lutherans would have been united behind Justification by Faith. But this way, Walther made sure he was the Missouri Pope and later the Synodical Conference Pope.

To this day, all doctrinal matters are settled by Holy Father Walther, among the stalwart - and synod president elections (each one an election without faith) hinges on one's Waltherian fidelity, whether real or feigned. "But let's keep working with ELCA." That makes more sense than people realize - ELCA teaches the same UOJ from the same bosom of Pietism - Halle University.




The point of the Brenner story in Jars is to say that Hoenecke helped smooth out Walther's language and cement friendship between Missouri and the Wisconsin Sect. Walther needed Hoenecke's help and friendship.




Monday, February 5, 2018

Paul McCain's New Vocation - Gun Training Films and Disney War Films

McCain used to write fondly about his years at a Roman Catholic school.
This is my guess about the faculty there.




He identified himself as Paul McCain and calls his videos
VDMA Films, a little touch of irony in a humor-challenged Harrison aide. Given his reputation as an ex-blogger,
Xerox Films would have been more fitting.

I was reading Free Republic for the latest in news. They link stories from all kinds of sources. The website is conservative, pro-life, and very supportive of our military.

I was curious about Disney providing films or cartoons during WWII, but not surprised. VDMA Films surprised me.




I would not be offended if McCain sold off his books to buy his weapons. I have nothing against the Second Amendment. I am a member of the NRA, but I found the juxtaposition of Synd President campaign aide and tubby warrior rather odd.